t??t r?a Ś/Y?o 7w?τ 2F SK??n Rw Ć?Q-n r??q?K ИS?OQ ؿ?E?F?l C?Փ sP0Ksq d?V oϖm 2y 涑?Y O0 h?n?z l?eu HE??ڬ Z1 L?X K?zF UT ܦF?V W?Oyk?rG ÌȌ kR 6lٳf 6lٳf 6lٳf 6lٳf 6lٳf 6lٳf 6l kc 0h V?wg ʨ?4pȊ _?W?뿘?槯?QB?j s랧?_?z Cc Jy QL/?V?O ɖBYT VA?O WR Ηu Me7 R?I ot??d?o?heR?G o1WGRU S9 ٮy J??t jן Imq uk Юf?Ԭ?F?hf յk nf?ԯf?F?i x?O2 r??_Aӟ oǕx?j z?X??z i Η?3k P?onm?H??VF?ꬵ a ot??d?o?heR?G o1WGRU S8 sS?5)aki FY BUM G??Z AR 0k?lS-?v?wy L?Ȳ,sH М?y ئ??uV U?dX??8We AR ט?S?s OK?w?ςr?N V?dd E?X QJ?U??ܜ Ǚ?W?jW?R?o 4j I 8u RH V?u?w ԯt?4K?V?Y??eb?Y Y흉f _Xk KJ?O 0?խi 罚Ka5 U?HE Jy QL/?W u?O ԥ?үf?fWh?HY dV U4 S?p??S kT?V?mIlo qy 敞Jsf?FbK?K?8??z OU?tH h?fXS?h?c o?F?se W?t?Û h??Iկ k?C mcE 3Mi?s پ??ZM jӼ?w?s?뚜 ea 1FC2?Z i xѮ??cH?.?k b?oA??GX 0?զCcg?뚝?5 k5?o F?C W?Isuus wv ĒMsjڵ W?Isuus wv ĒMp?6v B?i K?J?Ǚ vfj Vb?rs?l A jw k?о T?N W?Isuus wv ĒMp IbI h??s I gwbY??,I 6l?a a a OV b?k e?y uF?_?l d?Iq y?a?ҿ9 6lٳf OѾ cy?mB L?M?X Oi 6lٳf 6lٳf 6lٳf 6lٳf 6lٳf 6lٳf ϱ!?tO oe խl d?զ Rsr 7WxRN i??u N?yb??I QrPƦ gp?ג?f??早?I?I?m qp e0?k??ť?T?j?e럜?o 6lٳf 6lٳg I 0f 6lٳf 6lٳf 6lٳf 6lٳf 6lٳf 6lٳf 6lٳf 6lٳf 6lٳf 6lٳf 6lٳf 6lٳf 6lٳf 6lٳf 6lٳf 6lٳf 6lٳf 6lٳf 6lٳf 6lٳf 6lٳf 6lٳf 6lٳf 6lٳf 6lٳf 6lٳf 6lٳf 6lٳf 6lٳf 6lٳf 6lٳf 6lٳf 6lٳf 6lٳf 6lٳf 6lٳf 6lٳf 6lٳf 6lٳf 6lٳf 6lٳf 6lٳf 6lٳf 6lٳf 6lٳf 6lٳf 6lٳf 6lٳf 6lٳf 6lٳf 6lٳf 6lٳf 6lٳf 6lٳf 6lٳf 6lٳf 6lٳf 6lٳf 6lٳf 6lٳf o??j_?on _R A 6lٳf 6lٳf 6lٳf 6lٳf 6lٳf 6lٳf 6lٳf 6lٳf 6lٳf 6lٳf 6lٳf 6lٳf 6lٳf 6lٳf 6lٳf 6lٳf 6lٳf 6lٳf 6lٳf 6lٳf 6lٳf 6lٳf 6lٳf 6lٳf 6lٳf 6lٳf 6lٳf 6lٳf 6lٳf 6lٳf 6lٳf 6lٳf 6lٳf 6lٳf 6lٳf 6lٳf 6lٳf 6lٳf 6lٳf 6lٳf 6lٳf 6lٳf 6lٳf 6lٳf 6lٳf 6lٳf 6lٳf s_?ik 5V??H?Iw ޔq 6lٳf 6lٳf 6lٳf 6lٳf 6lٳf 6lٳf 6lٳf 6lٳf 6lٳf 6lٳf 6lٳf 6lٳf 6lٳf 6lٳf 6lٳf 2D e?n lٳf 6lٳf 6lٳf 6lٳf 6lٳf 6lٳf 6lٳf 6lٳf 6lٳf 6lٳf 6lٳf 6lٳf 6lٳf 6lٳf 6lٳf 6lٳf 6lٳf 6z xRG?6p7y d?j?W Qi Z?P?y L?l z?V?A bZ r/T Csv l??msS?W i??sI i S?e?Y?ҪH f?O?N o?ʯ Ӆ?W?3?yo q??e ZF?_?ڼVk ѹjCq?iP hL 6lٳd?S A?o gn h?X 7r ZJ 6l y?Ze s?,t?y.n Yۊ 3P q?q M6 Ew I Vh??lٳa?k m5 4v Ѵ?M4 gwb UA,H w?k?n?閺m?H??G??i Ee?8 U?Q?g?,??Hn?P?in BD ɨV6?B?ٳf 6l K?i4Xt sx o0 o?ğ i7?e Am?Z??a XQ 6l eg t?տ F?F pv?U?壘1 f??3C?tm?E nJ J?V??s?I Z?iV Ub h?rS?q c?x Gn chv ON H??G?oLu ŵ?K4?I Uf Kd 6l 2i f??K4?C?ˮi6wҴ1z?b?DX??D J?m d?n su g0 zR?W 뛙5 B?W I??ﭴ k?J?h??mm?if?iX R7?δ Ϩ?D e?Uy??o dx?X_?M E?n?T?a v"?h oG Hb J?ȲC(?I KF 6lٳf 6lٳf 6lٳf 6lٳf 6lٳf 6lٳf 6lٳf 6lٳf bBR E.U B9?Wwb?ٳf 6lٳf 6lٳf 6lٳf 6lٳf 6l kSq E?4i Vg VH mE S?sL?쵏(h a R?O?M e?r E?J LY 6u kW sG ms VІ?i Ty qh Ѭ?ŭy?W O?l dF hiw?m i Z??O d?J?a еxm?ki H??y ph?J?t 2O Ьr pB??j1??CXmU N?,s kL?WԴ?R??յ I D??xZDV??F 0?L?w奎 a _kZ??m R?N??SE M1?Qi 3Q c?Y _h Vh??t?V?I H??ۿ?p 9T v?o ni ݣ?O r??x K?崯 NnQ?ʊѴA Ͼm Lm _Kj CmF T?P J?QCow l??1?FVDR?P 8W y??S ū?z?m r9?X FT qW ռ?m Ci;i?1?u eӛ?Q?XZhψ sL r?8?dv rGVO ſ:k?OP?!Լ WS MR I;q?E YYh?W?X?5 t?u_ R?Z I?R Ip cT 8sR p?v L?д Q?d KȮ FV dRS?m ᲆydfq Qgh ǚt Xy mo O?O4 zl t?:?L?H??ɮdfViO 9S WB?;?KO mDZ ڈek uM ȳ??TS4 2U tk tO v??C p??Iaiq"1B?Y S9 俛?y??SZ cf Zr??G zRM ɮE A I EuooVwv k2H?E a?oN m,?y?fXM yK?p a Ky s?xe _w i i?qme R9 2?UI 8g?t駟 e0??ee Yg?p??Ib??Zr 9t Uדu7 s?ˡCiq?i?qy3Ciw ͺN J??U?h?d?Uh?N ɛGm??8ޝ K??g 21Ex ɡj?m oo韬۴.??ȓE fT 7W Ɠ?h??y i m?x G?e z?qsͿ??Jy o?S?F ex?PIZ??RFI u?Ycg?6 Jԍ??ݺ?u ۉR9 y?G h??MKR 6U G?E l?e OJ??a r?ζ S?TC 3h ӥiw Z?C R(ey a pkξl?w?_ YJ m7 H?-d HeI Mjߘ??1 m7Y A O?ȱ zc?WE g?ᮓ?o KN i:x A w-f K?D ܮҩ IJ pw?G?r a4?j o?a??-ŭ奬 u?h H?L?v g?ח o?3F _y N??KU?n E?:F W?t?n?լ??U k?9u?Hd?x?Q a K"?nae i h?k iJ L?Ե6 wv?4 c?E?Q"UCȞ?B W?o3yKʚ?!?Z Hf?dxc??hy?ϝ i WW meq R?Kj gU?㢬e ll?m O?I??U?n V?q?x?Ic kw ŠhZ??Z?I Q??YL 2s I y?mjo 6z a QE qfT ZC Gd?L0 MB-at?m?A 2Q i?h I W0?hY i 3g y?ȗ TB Ah?d??G Kff?,?gTb?,?H?T i Ci L1?x c?H Kg o?ݔ?h k?o ki?MOY??y Xbh-?9 dsIa??N?pw?u ɿ?ٿ G,l?w j?j E?Y g??WTg g??厙?h uIo?S n?ݠd?ޘ r7?q v?X?3G d?z??vZ T?t e?ȏvV;??-?ІY?R yA廽.?I?ޓ 1X?F t?e?Khf w??Xư I 6lٳf 6lٳf 6lٳf 6lٳf 6lٳf 6lٳf 6lٳf 6lٳf 6lٳf 6lٳf 6lٳf 6lٳf 6lٳf 6l s?-O?ھ?u t5L M?KP ևFK Bg?K l??H t?I I-?ҚD??J U?lZ H?i?v?K6?.?P?ĔYR?Y la L??K?ƹ k7 0z 7?LA oTHP??ϯ?/?ȟʏ?O H?:G i Ֆ5kpn vX?Yc u??R??j?Z??Gqj?z wump?y?E YXz??P?p N?G m?_i E?I ג3 a 2V A ߗ?SI qЇ??ǡ"?n9z _Yh Case Document Filed Page of Maxwell has not made that showing She has not shown or attempted to show that the grand jury materials in her case are apt to reveal any deficiency in the proceedings leading to her indictment See Fed Crim ii And her convictions for conspiracy to transport minors with intent to engage in criminal sexual activity U.S.C transportation of a minor with intent to engage in criminal sexual activity U.S.C a and sex trafficking of a minor U.S.C a entered following a jury trial and the 240-month sentence imposed by Judge Nathan have been affi1med on appeal by the United States Court of Appeals for the Second Circuit United States Maxwell F.4th 2d Cir petition for cert filed U.S Apr No Her argument is instead that with the Government having recently moved to unseal the grand jury transcripts her review of them would assist her counsel in crafting a response and setting out our position to the Court Dkt at There is no compelling necessity for that The Court has ordered the Government to produce these transcripts for the Courts in camera review by Monday July The Court will review these transcripts expeditiously In the event the Court determines it would benefit from Maxwells commentary as to a discrete aspect of these transcripts the Court stands ready to make that excerpt or a synopsis thereof available to her counsel to facilitate counsels briefing But there is no justification for Maxwell to obtain the extraordinary relief of plenary access to the grand jury transcripts in her case See e.g In re for grand jury materials in connection with habeas petition where defendant failed to make requisite showing of a particularized need Bruno Coveny No Civ WL at E.D.N.YApr same Henareh United States No Civ WL at S.D.N.Y June same report and recommendation adopted No Cr WL S.D.N.Y July cf e.g United States Blondet No Cr WL at S.D.N.Y Nov denying defendants pre-trial motion for in camera review of grand jury minutes where he did not demonstrate compelling necessity United States Lopez No Cr WL at S.D.N.Y Jan similar Case Document Filed Page of Fed Grand Jury Procs F.2d 2d Cir Recognizing the importance of secrecy to the proper functioning of the grand jury system the Supreme Court has established a strict test of particularized need United States Sobotka F.2d 2d Cir The showing of need for grand jury materials must be made with particularity so that the secrecy of the proceedings may be lifted discretely and limitedly quoting Procter Gamble Co U.S at United States Laster Appx 2d Cir similar SO ORDERED PA i United States District Jud Dated July New York New York
