UN4IT-3E-2D ST-4ATE-3S-3 DI11S6T-2RI CT COUR3T S-3OUT-2HE-4RN4 DIST-5RIC13T-2 OF NEW YOR-8K P-3lainti-3ff6 De6fe7nd-9a4nt cv RWS M4o-3ti4o-3n Jud7g-3m12ent A M-8e4nnin-11g10e4r HA4DD4ON4 MORG-9AN4 9AN4D FOR-2EMAN4 th Ave6nue De6nve4r CO Case Document Filed Page of i TA4BLE 3OF4 C6ON4EN4TS STAT-7E-8MENT F6ACTS S-3UMMARY J-9UD4GMEN4T STAND4ARD ARGU3MENT Ms Max-6we6ll-3 is no-2t l6iable for6 r-6e4publi-3c4a4ti-3ons of he-3r st-2a4t-11e4ment-9 that she3 did not-3 I a4uthoriz-6e4 or r6e4que4st 12a4nd e4nti-3ti-3e4s she did not co-7ntrol A jud-11g10ment is-2 w-7a4rr6a4nt-11e4d to t-3he4 e4x-9tent plainti-3ff6 see7ks t-2o im-3pose on st-12a4teme4nt-11 B7e4c-5a4use p3lainti-3ff6 is a publi-3c4 f3ig8ur-6e4 im-3posi-2ng10 upon Ms Ma-6x-9we6ll-3 for6 r3e publi-3c-5a4ti-3on of3 the st-2a4tem-9e4nt w-9ould vi-3olate4 the F8irst Ame4ndment P-3lainti-3ff6 shoul-2d be4 ba4rr6e4d-9 f3rom int-2roduc7ing8 int-3o e4v-9idenc6e4 9re7publi-3c4a4ti-3on 9of3 a4n e4x-9c4e4rpt f4rom the st-2a4teme4nt jud-11g10ment is-2 w-7a4rr6a4nt-11e4d unde4r the5 9Ne6w 7Yor5k Con-2sti-4tut-3ion II16 A The5 st-2a4tem-9e4nt consti-2tut-3e4s ona4c4ti-3ona4ble opinion 0C0B que4sti-4on of3 law4 whe6the-7r the5 st-12a4teme-5nt consti-2tut-3e4s nona3c4ti-3ona4ble opi nion The5 pre li-3ti-13g10a4ti-3on pr3ivi-3le-7g10e4 b-9a4rs this-2 a4c4ti-3on II6I13 Ms The5 de4f-6a4mation cla4im-3 shoul-2d be4 dism-4iss-3e4d be4c4a4us-10e4 the publica6ti-3on is 2subst-3a4nti-3a4ll-13y20 true5 P-3lainti-3ff6 c4a4nnot estab3li-3sh ac7tua 9c4lea-3r a7n-9d c4onvincing10 9e4videnc-3e4 A F6a4c4ts P-3lainti-3ff6 c4a4rr6ies the3 bu-9rde-2n of p3roving11 9a4c4tual malic-7e4 9c4lea-3r a7nd c4onvin-11c4ing8 e4videnc6e4 P-3lainti-3ff6 is a publi-2c4 f3ig8ur-6e4 who must-2 prov3e4 a-5c4tual 9malice6 P-3lainti-3ff6 succ7e4ssfull-22y20 invi-3ted public a4tt-3e4nti-3on to i-3nf3luenc6e4 other5s Case Document Filed Page of ii P-3lainti-3ff6 volunt-3a4ril-10y20 inj-3e4c-5ted he6rse6lf int-2o publi-3c4 c4o-9ntrove5rsie4s re6l-11a4ted to the subj-2e4c4t of thi-2s li-4ti-3g10a4ti-3on P-3lainti-3ff6 a4ssum-3e4d a4 posi-2ti-3on of3 prominen3c4e4 in t-3he4 9publi-3c4 c4ontrove5rsie4s P-3lainti-3ff6 ha4s maint-2a4ined a7nd 9c4onti-3nuing8 a-5c-5c4e4ss t-3o the me4dia P-3lainti-3ff6 must-4 a4lso prove4 a4c4tual malice6 to ove-7rc7om-11e4 the de6f-6e4nses of5 a4n-9d pre li-3ti-3g10a4ti-3on pr3ivi-3lege6 The5 st-2a4tem-9e4nt wa4s subs-2t tru-8e-5 a4nd plainti-3ff6 c4a4nnot pro-8duc4e4 c4lea6r 6a4nd c4onvincin-9g10 e4vi-11de4nc4e4 of its The5 st-2a4tem-9e4nt ac6c4u-9ra7tel-19y20 de4ni-11e4d tha-7t Ms-3 Max-6we6ll-3 met P-3lainti-3ff6 whe6n P-3lainti-3ff6 wa6s y20e-5a4rs old in The5 st-2a4tem-9e4nt ac6c4u-9ra7tel-19y20 de4ni-11e4d tha-7t Ms-3 Max-6we6ll-3 f-6a4c4t a4ssi-3stanc5e4 6Epstein-6 c4onve4rte5d 6P-3lainti-3ff6 int-3o wh12a4t i-3s commonl-12y20 r3e-5fe7r-6re7d The5 st-2a4tem-9e4nt ac6c4u-9ra7tel-19y20 r-6e4porte5d th-11a4t P-5lainti-3ff6 a4ll-3e4ge4d The5 st-2a4tem-9e4nt ac6c4u-9ra7tel-19y20 de4ni-11e4d tha-7t Ms-3 Max-6we6ll-3 c4re7a4ted a4nd dis-2tribut-2e4d c4hil-3d por3nog10r-6a4ph-19y20 a4nd that the G4o-9ve4rnme5nt knows of 7a4nd possesse4s such c6hil-3d Epstein to t-3ra7ff6ic Pl-3a4int-3iff4 to t-3he4 r3ich a6nd f-6a4mous-2 Case Document Filed Page of i TABLE 7OF AU-9THO-7RITIES Case5s Adelson 8Harris 8F Supp Air 8W9iscon-8sin Air-8lines 8Corp H-8oeper Ct Anderson Libert-8y Lo-8bby Inc Aronson 8W9iers-8ma N.E.2d Bartnicki Vopper U.S Biro Co-7nd Na-8st Supp-7 2d S.D.N.Y Biro Co-7nd Na-8ste Sup-7p 2d Ap-9p Div Celle Fili-8pino Re-9por-8ter Enters 8Inc Cir.-8 Celotex Co-8rp C-8atret-8t Chambers-8 8W9ells-8 Far-8go Bank 8W9L at Jun-8e Chau Le-8wis 8Supp 2d Collier 8Postum 8Cere-9al Co App.-9 Div st Dep-9 4t Contempo-8rary Mi-9ssion-8 Inc Tim e-9s Co Cir Curtis Pu-10blg C-9o Bu-11tts Davis Bo-7eheim Davis C-6osta Ga-8vras S-7upp Dibella 6Hopkins No-8 CIV DC 8W9L at-8 Oct-9 Don King 6Prods.,-7 Inc 8v Douglas Sup-8p and Meiri Dacon F.2d 2d Ci-8r Case Document Filed Page of iv Elias Ro-7lling St-6one 8LLC CV PKC 8W9L at June Enigma So-7ftware 7Grp 8USA LL-7C Blee-8ping 7Computer 7LLC 8No CIV 9(PAE 8W9L at Faigin 7Kelly 8Supp Firestone Time I-8nc So F-8la Fleckenstein-8 Fried-8m-8an N.Y Flomenhaft-7 Finke-8lst-7ein st Dep-9 4t Folwell 7Miller 8F 2d C-8ir Franklin 7Daily 8Holdi-7ngs Inc App-9 Div Frechtman 8v Gutte-8rrn-8an 9(App Div Front Inc 7v Khal-7il N.E.3d Geraci P-7robst Germain Ban-7k Corp S-7upp Gertz Ro-7bert 7W9el-8ch 8Inc Goforth 6Avemco 8Life-7 Ins Co Goldstein Cogs-6well 8No CI-8V KM-9W9 8WL 8at S.D.N.Y 9June Gross 7New Y-8ork Tim-8es N.Y Harte Hawkins Harri-7s A.2d Horne M-7atthews No-8 Civ JS-8M 8W9L Sept.-8 Huggins Moore N.E.2d Case Document Filed Page of Immuno A-6G Mo-7or J-9ankowski N.Y Indep Livi-5ng Aids-6 Inc.-7 Maxi Aid-8s Inc Supp Inter nation-8al Publ-8ishin-8g Concepts-8 LLC 7v Loc-9atelli James G-5annett Jewell NY-8P Hol-8ding-8s Inc 8F Sup-7p 2d Ap-9p Div Karadum-8an Ne-9wsda-8y Inc Kirk Hep-9pt 8F S-7upp 2d Klein Mc-9Gauley A D.2d nd Dep Ferrou-9s Me-9tals Tradi-7ng Co No CI-6V JFK-7 at 7June Lerman 9Flynt Di-8st 8Co Inc 2d 9Cir Mann Ab-6el Martin 5City of 5Ocea-8nside 8F Sup-7p 2d S.D 8Cal F.3d th Cir-8 Martiran3o-8 Fros-9t N.E.2d Mashburn-6 Coll-5in So 2d La Masson 5New Y-6orker 7Magazine 5Inc Maule Ph-6iladelp-6hia 7Media Hol-6dings 6LLC 8No CIV.A-9 8W9L a-9t E.D 9Pa Mar.-9 McGill P-5arker 9(App 8Div M3e4iri-4 v4 Dac6on Mencher 7Chesley N.E.2d Milkovich 5Lorai-6n Jo-7urnal C3o Case Document Filed Page of vi New Y-8ork Times 8Co 8Sullivan People K-8ocsis 9(App 8Div Petrus S-8mith App App-9 Div Philadelph-7ia New-7spap-8ers Inc 8Hepps 8U.S In Phila-8delphia 8Ne-8wspapers LLC 3d C-8ir as cor-8rected Oct Rand Ne-8w Y-7ork Tim-7es Co A-9pp Div-8 SE J-9oint Fi-8re D-9ist Supp 3d Rinaldi 7Viking P-8eng-8uin Inc Salyer 9Poverty 9La-8w Ctr Inc-8 8F Sup-7p 2d Sexter 10W9a-8rmflas-8h Marg-9rabe 2d App-9 Div.-8 Ap-9p Div Soley 9W9a-8sserma-9n N-8o CIV 8FM 8W9L at June Steinhilber-8 Alph-9onse Time Inc Firest-8one U.S W9a-8ldbaum-8 Fairc-9hild-8 Publns I-7nc Cir Rul-3e4s Fed Ci-7v Case Document Filed Page of PAGES RED-2ACTED Case Document Filed Page of R-2e4spec7tfull-12y20 subm-2it-3ted L-3aura A M3e4nninger A M-8e4nnin-11g10e4r 6(LM pro 10hac4 v4ice-3 ADDON OR-2GAN AN-12D OR-2E3M-9AN Ea5st th Ave6nue De6nve4r CO P-3hone4 lm-3e4nning8e4r-6 hmfla4w.c6o-9m Attor-3ne4y for De6fendant Ghisl-2aine M5ax4w-2e4ll Case Document Filed Page of CERTI-2F11ICA3T-2E-2 S-3E-2RV4I CE that on 9e4lec6troni-10c4a4ll-23y20 ser6ve4d thi-3s M3e-5morandum3 9in Suppor-2t of-3 M3oti-3on for-2 Summ4ary J7udgm-7e4nt via on the f5ol lowing8 S-3ig8rid McCa4wle-15y Mer6e4dit-3h S-3c4hult-3z L3E3X-11NE4R LP Ea5st Ola3s 10B7oule-7va4rd St-2e4 F6t 11L11a4ude-5rda7le smcc5a4wle-15y20 bs-9fllp.c3om mschult-2z-5 bsfllp.com P-3a4ul C-2a4ssell Unive4rsit-11y20 S-3tre5e4t UT c4a4ssellp law4.utah.-7e4du Edw3a4rds F6a4rme-4r J-7a4ff6e4 W-5e4iss-3ing8 9Edw3a4rds 7F6ist-4os L11e4h-9rma5n Nor5th Andr3e4ws S-3te F6t 11L11a4ude-5rda7le br3a4d pa5tht-3ojust-4ice6.c4om S6tanle-5y20 P-3ott-3ing8e-5r Tw3in R-3d S-3outh S-5a4lem NY4 S-3tanPot-3ti-3ng10e4r 4a4ol.com N-2icole4 Simmons Nic4ole Si-3mm-3ons Case Document Filed Page of
7,148 characters
