U1N-9I12TED1 S-5TA1TES-5 S-6OUT-1HE-1R-5N OF4 CV DOE-1 NO P-2la6int2if5f5 vs-1 R-7el-6at-6ed JA-2NE-5 M2E-5M2O-4RAN-10DUM2 I-3N DE-5F9E-5NDANT-5 F9O-4R AND RUL-5E-5 A-2ND A5TE JU-2DG6E-5 O-4RDE-5R O-4N DI-3S-6CO6VE-5RY P-2la6int2if N2os-1 t-2hr3oug10h unde4r3s-1i-12g10ne4d c-6ouns-1e4l-2 M-1e4m-2or3a4ndum-2 i8n O2ppos-1i-2t-2i-2on D2e4f3e4nda4nt-2 ot-2i-2on f3or3 R-3e4c4ons-1i-2de4r3a4t-2i-2on a4nd and of-5 W-6or3t-2h I3nt7r8od4uc8t7i2on T1he4 of3 de4ni-2e4s-1 on D2e4f3e4nda4nt-2 a4nd t-2he4 of3 do cum-10ent r3e4que4s-1t-2 10a4nd i-2nc4om-2e4 pp D2e-6f3e4nda4nt-2 t-2o t-2o t-2he4 r3e4qui-2r3e4s-1 pr3oduc4t-2i-2on of3 r3e4t-2ur3ns-1 a4nd t-2o P-2la6int2if5f5s1 al-2l on t-2he4 w2o rt-5h Case Document Entered on FLSD Docket Page of T1he4 pr3oduc4i-2n-10g r3e4t-2ur3ns-1 not-2 the-2 F8i-10f5th 2A4me6ndm4e6n-8t pr7ivi2le6ge8 a-4ga8ins3t s1e6lf r3e4t-2ur3ns-1 kno-10w2n t-2o or-7 f3o-10r3e-6gone4 T1he-6 t-2he4 of3 pr3od-10uc4i-2ng10 r3e4t-2ur3ns-1 not-2 Se-2e U2ni-2t-2e4d H2ubbe4l-2l in 2the8 10a6lte6r5na8tive-2 ar-11e i-6n cas-5es-5 be-4caus-9e not-14 and no ne-4ed t-6o a bur3de4n on a4 t-2o c4om-2pe4l-2 t-2he4 pr3oduc4t-2i-2on of3 t-2a4x r3e4t-2ur3ns-1 i-2n A2 num-2b10e4r3 of3 the8 di2s1tr5ic c4our3t-2s-1 i8n t-2he4 E1l-2e4ve4nt-2h ha4ve4 s-1uc4h a4 he4i-2ght-2e4ne4d bur3de4n for t-6ax r3e4t-2ur3ns-1 t-2he4 br3oa4d r3e4l-2e4va4nc-6e4 s-1t-2a4nda4r3d unde4r3 a4ppl-2i-2c4a4bl-2e4 i-2n ot-2he4r3 T3he8 M1a-4g12is1tr5a6te-4 J-11ude4 not-2 i-2n e4r3r3or-7 i-2n ng10 t-2o a4 s-1t-2a4nda-6r3d I13n e-6ve4nt-2 D2e4f-7e4nda4nt-12 of-7 puni-2t-2i-2ve4 unde4r3 c4ondi-2t-2i-2on a4nd t-2he4 of3 puni tive8 10w2onde4r3 how-8 i-2n c-6a4n c4on-10t-2e4nd no ne-6e4d f3or3 t-2o obt-2a4i-2n r3e4t-2ur3ns-1 w2he4n D2e4f-7e-6nda4nt-2 ha4s-1 t-2he4 A2m-2e4ndm-2e4nt-2 pr3i-2vi-2l-2e4ge4 i-2n r3e4s-1pons-1e4 t-2o a4nd ne4t-2 w2or3t-2h d-10oc4um ent-10 and2 int2e6r5r5o-8g12a6tor-13y pr3opound-10e-6d D4e6f5e6nda10nt2 s1imila6r5l-20y22 a6s1s1e-4r5te6d a8 10F8if5th A6me6ndm4e6nt2 pr7ivi2le6g12e a6s1 to a8ll de4pos-1i-2t-2i-2on que4s-1t-2i-2ons r5e6la6ting t-2o ne4t-2 w2or3t-2h F6or3 t-2he4 r3e4a4s-1ons-1 f3or-7t-2h he4r3e4i-2n r3e4que4s-1t-2 t-2he4 D2e4f3e4nda4nt-12 M-1ot-2i-2on f3or13 R-3e4c4ons-1i-2de4r3a4t-2i-2on a4nd f3or3 a4nd A2ppe-6a4l-2 be4 10a4nd t-2he4 r3e4t-2ur3n t-2o doc4um-2e4nt-2 no be4 or3de4r-7e4d t-2o be4 pr3oduc4e4d f5o-8r5thw6ith Case Document Entered on FLSD Docket Page of A-2rgu-22m9en-8t I ACT-5 T-5AX RE-5T-15URNS NO-4T P14R5O1TEC5TED5 BY5 TH1E10 A5M7EN5D-5M7EN-5T P14R5I2V5I2LEG11E m-2a4de4 t-2he4 doc4um-2e4nt-2 t-2o w2hi-2c4h D2e4f3e4nda-6nt-2 r3t-2e4d F8if5th A6me6ndm4e6nt2 pr7ivi2le-4g12e6 N2o F6e4de4r3a4l-2 a4nd i-2nc4om-2e4 t-2a4x r3e4t-2ur3ns-1 i-2nc4l-2udi-2ng10 a4nd f3or3 r-1ej-16ect-6ed t-6o ol-2di-2ng10 t-2he4 of3 pr3oduc4i-2n-10g10 r3e4t-2ur3ns not-2 be4c4a4us-1e4 t-2he4 obvi-2ous-1l-12y30 i-2n of3 t-2he4 a4nd pr3i-2or3 kn-10ow2l-2e4dge4 of-7 t-2he4 a4 c4onc4l-2us-1i-2on pp s-1o t-2he4 udg10e4 t-2he4 of-7 pr3oduc4t-2i-2on-10 doc4t-2r3i-2ne4 f3or3t-2h i-2n a4nd U4ni2te6d-8 S-2ta6te6s1 H2ubbe4l-2l J-11udge4 c-6a4nnot-2 a4nd i-2n t-2ha4t i-2n pr3o-10duc4i-2ng10 doc4um-2e4nt-2s-11 t-2o he4 s-1om-2e4how2 be4 D2e4f3e4nda4nt-2 a jus3t H2e4 pr3odu-10c4t-2i-2on of3 t-2he4 r3e4t-2ur3ns-1 w2oul-2d a4 of3 t-2he4 t-2he4 a4nd of3 s-1uc4h r3e-6c4or3ds-1 a4nd a4 da4nge4r3 of3 H2ubbe4l-2l C-3our3t-2 t-2o r3e4t-2ur3ns-1 doc4um-2e4nt-2s-1 c4a4nnot-12 pr-5ot-10ect-16ed t-2he4 A2m-2e4ndm-2e4nt-2 unde4r act-6 pr3oduc4t-2i-2on doc4t-2r3i-2ne 7he4 be-6 of-7 obe4di-2e4nc4e4 t-2o s3uc8h as7 10f7i2l2i2ng 4an4 i12nc8om6e18 t-2ax r3e4qui-2r3e4d r3e-6c4or3ds-1 or3 a4n doe10s1 n-2ot2 c6lot2h-2e6 10r1e6quir1e6d 2c6onduc6t w-1ith-2 th-2e6 te6s1tim-10onia12l10 Case Document Entered on FLSD Docket Page of s-1uppl-2i-2e4d A-2ccor-5d U4ni2te6d inc8r5imina8tion 4c6la6im be8c-4a6us3e6 the-2 vol4unt4a-4r5il-10y22 ta6x-8 r5e6tur7ns3 a-4ga8ins3t de4f3e4nda4nt-2 al-6s-5o i-6n ar-1e not-14 com-10pe-4l-6l-6ed a4nd us-1e4d i-2n pr3os-1e4c4ut-2i-2on I23nc4 a4 pe-6r-7s-1on c4a4nnot-2 hi2ms1e6lf5 tur7ni2n-8g12 ov-6e6r5 doc4um-2e4nt-2 i-2n a4nd L11oa4n C-3or3p H-8a4r3de4e S-4upp pe4r3s-1ona4l-2 r3e4t-2ur3ns-1 a4nd s-1uppor3t-2i-2ng10 not-2 pr3ot-2e-6c4t-2e4d t-2he4 of3 doc4t-2r3i-2ne4 unde4r Fi-8s-7he-8r a4n t-2o t-2he4 doe4s-1 not-12 t-2he4 of3 pr3oduc4i-2ng10 doc-6um-2e4nt is1 not14 te6s1timoni4a16l a4nd c4om-2m-2uni-2c4a4t-2i-2ve our3t-2s-1 ha4ve4 i-2nvoke4d t-2he4 t-2o t-2he4 of-7 pr3oduc4t-12i-2on doc4t-2r3i-2ne4 S-8ee S-4a4vi-2ng C-3or3p S-4upp A2m-2e4ndm-2e4nt-2 pr3i-2vi-2l-2e4ge4 t-2o t-2he4 und-22er-1 Fi-8s-7he-8r he-4 re1qui-11re1d-13 re-9c1or-3ds e6f5e6a6ts1 the-2 F8if5th-8 A2m-2e4ndm-2e4nt pr3i-2vi-2l-2e-6ge be4c-6a4us-1e4 of3 publ-2i-2c4 of3 t-2he4 r-11equi-14r-1ed re-9c1or-3ds i-2ndi-2vi-2du al a6dm2its1 lit10tle6 of17 pr3o-10duc a4nd doi-12ng10 bus-1i-2ne4s-1s i-6n 4an 6ar-11ea r-1equi-14r-1es a4nd i-2ndi-2vi-2dua4l-2 be-6 w-8a4i-2ve4d t-2o pr3odu-10c4t-2i-2on of3 t-2hos-1e4 r-7e4c4or3ds-1 I13n G2r-7a4nd S-4ubpo-10e4na T2he-4 Ma5g11i-1st-1r4a di-2d t-2he4 i-2n D2e-6f3e4nda4nt-12 of3 t-2o pr3odu-10c-6t-2i-2on of3 D2e4f3e4nda4nt-12 t-2a4x Case Document Entered on FLSD Docket Page of r3e4t-2ur3ns-1 D-8e4f3e4nda4nt-12 c4ont-2e4nds-11 i-6r-1ed doe4s-11 not-2 to 2ta r3e4t-2ur3ns-1 be4c4a4us-1e4 10c4a4nnot-2 be4 by20 publ-2i-2c4 w2r3ong10 how2e4v-10e4r3 r3e-6c4or3ds-1 r3e4qui-2r3e4s-1 be4 t-2o t-2he4 doc4um-2e4nt-2s-1 Id Nu m-2e-6r3ous c4our3t-2s-1 ha4ve4 ha4ve4 f3ound t8ha4t-2 t-2a4x r3e4t-2ur3ns-1 ha4ve4 S-8ee R-13odr3i-2g10ue a ac-10cor-5d D2oe4 U2ni-2t-2e4d S-8t-6at-6es a t-2o t-2he4 pr3odu-10c4t-2i-2on of r3e4t-2ur3ns-1 In R-3odr-7i-2g10ue4s C-3our3t-2 t-2he4 t-2he4 of3 pr3oduc4i-2ng10 r3e4t-2ur3ns-1 unde4r3 t-2he4 r3e-6c4or3ds-1 not-2i-2ng10 t-2ha4t a4 t-2o a4 ha-6ve be4e4n t-2o ha4ve-6 publ-18i-6c Id t-2he4 f3e4de4r3a4l-2 r3e4t-2ur3ns-1 10c4a4nnot-2 be4 t-2he4 publ-2i-2c4 oe4s-1 not-2 D2e-6f3e4nda4nt C-3or3p 10L11ope4z D4e6f5e6nd-6a6nt2 a6ls1o 2obj4e6c6ts1 to 2the8 M1a6g12is1tr5a6te6 de8c6is1ion 4on 4the8 ba8s1is1 10tha8t P-2la6int2if5f5s1 r3e4que4s-1t-2 not-2 pe4r3s-1ona4l-2 r3e4t-2ur3ns-1 r3e4t-2ur3ns-1 i-2n w2hi-2c4h ha4s-1 a4n i-2n t-2o how2e4ve4r3 t-2he4 doe4s-1 not-2 t-2o t-2he4 doc4um-12e4nt-2s-1 of3 c4or3por-7a4t-2i-2on or3 ot-2he4r-7 F6 S-4upp hus-1 ar-11e t-2w2o g10r3ounds-1 f3or3 D2e-6f3e4nda4nt-2 of3 he-2 F8if5th-8 A4me6ndm4e6nt2 pr7ivi2le-4g12e6 pr3oduc4t-2i-2on of3 t-2he4 r3e4t-2ur3ns-1 i-2n of3 t-2he4 a4 a4nd t-2he4r3e4 i no of-7 a4ut-2he4nt-2i-2c4a4t-2i-2on D2e4f-7e4nda4nt-2 pr3odu-10c4t-2i-2on of3 or3 r3e4t-2ur3ns-1 t-2he4 t-2o t-2he4 of3 pr3oduc4t-2i-2on doc4t-2r3i-12ne a4nd t-2hus-1 not-2 pr-5ot-10ect-6ed F2i ft-5h of-3 10gr3ounds-1 r3e4t-2ur-7ns9 ar-1e not-2 10a4nd be4 pr3oduc4e4d Case Document Entered on FLSD Docket Page of B9r5os3w-6e-4ll 4U4ni2te6d 2S-2ta6te6s s-1houl-2d be di-2s-1put-2e tha8t a6ll c4or-1por-1at-2e i-2n D-8e4f3e4nda4nt-12 or3 10c4ont-2r3ol a4nd not-2 pr3ot-2e-6c4t-2e4d t-2he4 II TH1ER5E N5O1 10H1EI2G11H1TEN5ED5 URDE-5N F9O-4R DI-3S CO-4VE-5RY T-5AX RE-5T-5URNS a 4bur-9d-14en 4on 8a of-5 t-16ax r3e4t-2ur3ns-1 t-2o not-2 but-2 ne-6e4d f3or-7 be-4caus-9e 8con t-2a4i-2ne4d t-2he4r3e4i-2n not-2 A2 num-2be4r3 of3 c4our3t-2s-1 i-2n F6l-2or3i-2da4 how2e4ve4r3 he4l-2d t-2he4r3e4 no he4i-2g10ht-2e4ne4d bur3de4n t-2o obt-2a4i-2n of-7 r-1et-6ur-5ns not-2 ne-14ed s-1how a ne-4ed r3e4 C-3or3p H2um-2a4na4 upon M-11a4ddow2 C-3o i-2n a 4bur-9d-14en a-10ccor-5d R-3us-1ki-2n C-3o F6a4n C-3or3p i-2n bot-2h P-7re1fe1r-10re1d C-9a-9re a4nd R-3us-1ki-2n the8 C-1our9t a6f5f5ir5me6d de4c4i-2s-1i-2on of3 a4 hol-2di-2ng10 a4n of3 t-2he4 t-2o Id be4l-2ow2 a4nd t-6o puni-2t-2i-2ve4 a-6ppe4a4r3s-1 f3r3om-2 e4vi-2de4nc-6e4 i-2n D2e4f3e4nda4nt-2 e4a4r3ns-1 a4nd f3unne4l-2s-1 i-2nc4om-2e a4m-2ong of3 T1he4 a4nd of3 a4nd on t-2he4 ne4t-2 w2or3t-2h J-15udg-2e cas-5e conc-8er pr3o-10duc4t-2i-2on of3 t-2a4x r3e4t-2ur3ns-1 i s1 10c6ons5is1te6nt2 w4ith 2a6ut2hor9it-10y22 in 2thi12s1 D4is1tr5ic6t a6nd E1l-2e4ve4nt-2h a4nd t-2hus-1 s-1houl-2d be4 Case Document Entered on FLSD Docket Page of I E-5VI-3DE-5NCE-5 DE-15F9E-15NDANT-5 AND RE-5L-5E-5VANT-5 T-5O D-2ef-1end-18ant doe4s-1 not-2 g10o s-1o f3a4r3 t-2o c4ont-2e4nd t-2a4x not-2 r3e4l-2e4va4nt-2 und-10e4r3 D2e4f3e4nda-6nt-2 t-2he4 di-2d not-2 a4ddr3e4s-1s t-2he4 s-1t-2a4nda-6r3d i-2n he4r3 rde r3 a4 D2e4f3e4nda4nt-2 doe4s-1 not-2hi-2ng10 t-2o s-1how12 tha8t the8 M1a-4g12is1tr-5a6te6 J-11udge-6 t-2o or-7 e4ve4nt-2 a4bunda4nt-2l-22y20 D2e4f-7e4nda4nt-2 a4nd puni-2t-2i-2ve-6 i-6n cas-5es-5 4and i-2n t-2he4 pe4r3t-2i-2ne4nt-2 a4nd di-2s-1c4ove4r3a4bl-12e4 T1e4nna4nt-2 C-3ha4r3l-2t-2on obt-12a4i-2n r3e4t-2ur3ns-1 f-7or3 pur3pos-1e4s-1 ne4t-2 di-2s-1c on of3 S2ee al-6s-5o S-2ta6te6 25M1a6lle-4y 3d 10A2pp w2he4n a4 puni-2t-2i-2ve4 a4 e4vi-2de4nc4e4 of3 t-2he4 de4f-7e-6nda4nt-2 bot-2h r3e4l-2e4va4nt-2 a4nd s1s1ibl2e6 t-2o a4m-2ount-2 of3 puni-2t-2i-2ve4 da4m-2a4ge4s-1 t-2o a4w2a-6r3d C-3o Inc-22 E1ve4n t-2he4 s-1t-2a4nda-6r3d t-6ax i-6n cas-5e a ne-14ed c4our3t-2s9 ha4ve4 c4ons-1i-2de4r-7e4d ha4ve4 he4l-2d puni-2t-2i-2ve4 da4m-2a4ge4s-1 i-2nf3or3m-2a4t-2i-2on t-2o a4 de4f3e4nda4nt-2 w2or3t-2h 7he4 bur3de4n a4n s-1our3c4e-6 of3 t-2he4 i-2nf3or3m-2a4t-2i-2on he8 r5e6s1is1ting24 ha4s-1 not8 e4ve4n t-2o s-1how2 t-2h at i-2nf3or3m-2a4t-2i-2on f3r3om-2 t-2a4x r3e4t-2ur3ns-1 a4not-2he4r3 s-1our3c-6e4 i-2n of3 bl-2a4nke4t-2 A4me6ndm4e6nt2 pr7ivi2le6ge8 a6s1s-9e6r5tion t4o a8ll ne8t w4or7th di4s1c6o D2e4f3e4nda4nt-2 ha4s-1 10pr3ovi-2de4d no ne4t-2 w2or3t-2h Case Document Entered on FLSD Docket Page of a bl-10anke-8t F8if5th 2A4me6ndm4e-4nt2 pr7ivi2le6g12e6 is1 pl2a6in 4the8r5e6f5or-3e6 2tha8t the8 i-2nf3or3m-2a4t-2i-2on c4ont-2a4i-2ne4d t-2he4 not-4 ava-4i-6l-6abl-20e c4ont-2e4nds-1 t-2he4r3e4 e6x-8is1ts an not-2 t-2o t-2he4 but8 t-2hr3oug10h of3f-7e4r3 t-2o t-2o a4 ne4t-2 w2or3t-2h ove4r3 O2f3 c4our3s-1e4 a4 r-1equ ev-14en be-14en t-2e4d pr3opos-11e4d s1tipul4a6tion nor9 is1 it c6le6a6r5 P-2la6int2if5f5s1 w4ou-6ld s1tipul4a6te6 to 6million 4f5loor9 on ne4t-2 w2or3t-2h 10w2he4n D2e4f3e4nda4nt-2 ne4t-2 r3t-2h s-5eem be-6y20ond di-2s-1put-2e4 D2e4f3e4nda4nt-2 r3e4t-2ur3ns-1 a4r3e4 di-2s-1c4ove4r3a4bl-2e4 und-10e4r3 a4 unde4r3 or3 a4 on 8t he-6 O2r-7de4r3 t-2o pr3o-10duc4t-2i-2on of3 r3e4t-2ur3ns-1 i-2n r-7e4s-1pons-1e4 t-2o doc4um-2e4nt-2 no not-2 a4nd not-2 t-2o a J-15udg t-2o r3e4t-2ur3ns-1 s-1houl-2d be4 P-2la6int2if5f5s1 t-2he4 doc4um-2e4nt-2s-1 r3e4s-1pons-11i-2ve4 t-2o P-4l doc4um-2e4nt-2 r3e4que4s-1t-2 no be-6 or3de4r3e4d t-2o pr3oduc-6e4d S-2tua8r5t M3e6r5me6ls1te6in A2da4m-2 D2 H2or3ow a4hor3ow2i-2t-2z-6 A3ttor3ne8y6s1 for3 P3lai2nt2iffs B7l-2vd M1ia6mi F10lor7ida Case Document Entered on FLSD Docket Page of Case Document Entered on FLSD Docket Page of S1E-3RV-10I1CE I9 on M-5ar-1ch doc4um-2e4nt-12 t-2he4 of3 t-2he4 t-2he4 doc4um-2e4nt-2 be4i-2ng s1e6r5ve8d 2thi2s1 to-8 a6ll p-8a6r5tie6s1 on i-6n of3 or3 i-2n ot-2he4r3 m-2a4nne4r3 f3or3 t-2hos-1e4 w2ho a4r3e4 not-2 a4ut-2hor3i-2z-6e4d t-2o r3e4c4e4i-2ve4 of3 F8ilin s1 S8tua8r5t M3e6r5me6ls1te6in Case Document Entered on FLSD Docket Page of D5O1E vs5 JE6F4F14R5EY5 EP4S-1TEI2N A2l-2a4n j-2g10ol-2dbe4r-7ge4r3 1a-6gw2pa4.c4om R-3obe4r3t-2 D2 E1s-1q E-3dw-6ar-1ds br3a4d J-9a6c6k Pa6tr5ic6k H6ill j-2ph 1podhur3s-1t-2.c4om P-8i-6ke cas-5s-5el-6l-6p R-1ic6ha8r5d H6or7a-4c6e6 W-4illits1 la6w-6y22e-4r5w4illits1 3a6ol2.c8om R-3obe4r3t-2 Case Document Entered on FLSD Docket Page of
11,336 characters