EXHIBIT Case Document Entered on FLSD Docket Page of Case Document Entered on FLSD Docket Page of Villafana Ann Mar ie USAFLS Sen Cc Subjec i llafana Ann Ma ri USAFLS Friday August PM Lanna Be ohlavek A i nson Karen USA RE messages Thank OU Lanna_ I think we arc going have lo pro du ce a cop of the ag.reemenl i su it pending in the fodernl cou rt and I vant make ure that are si ng the ame cument in courtho ses Thank you again and ha a goo week end A A/nrie Villa_/t 1u Assi a nt At to rne Aust alian Av Su il West Pa each FL From Lanna Belohla vek Sent Friday August PM To VIiiafana Ann Marie USAFLS Subject messages arie Have gotten your essages but have been swa mped and am ust gett i ng out of court I ilt get i th you on Monday Have a good weekend Lanna Tracking RFP Case Document Entered on FLSD Docket Page of Villafan a Ann Marie USAFLS Fr om ent Villafana Ann Marie USAFLS Thursday August PM ject Roy BLACK RE Notificat ion of Possible Compelled Disclosure of theNon-Prosecut,on Agreement Thank you Roy Your help is greatly appreciated A Marie Villafana Assistant U.S Attorney Australian Ave Suite West Palm BeachJ FL Original Message From Roy BLACK mailto:RBLACK royblack.com Sent Thursday August PM To Villafana Ann Marie USAFLS Subject Re Notification of Possible Compelled Disclosure of theNon Prosecu tion Agreement Marie I am working on this and will get back to you Original Message From Villafana Ann Marie USAFLS To Roy BLACK RBLACK royblack.com Cc Dexter USAFLS Cc Karen USAFLS At Sent PM Subject Notification of Possible Compelled Disclosure of the Non Prosecution Agreement Dear Roy In accordance with paragraph of the Non-Prosecution Agreeme I am providing notice of possible compulsory process command i ng the disclosure of the Agreement As I sure you know wo of Mr Epsteins victims ave filed suit against the United States alleging that the government violated their rights as victims by not consulting them prior to entering into the Non-Prosecution Agreement As art of their response to one of the gove nments filings the victims asked the Cou to order the production of the Non-Prosecution Agreement The deadline for the government to respond is August 15th and we intend to oppose the motion based upon co i dentiality provision I have attached a copy of victims eading for your review In connection with this we want to make certain at we are maki consistent epresentations to the judiciary regarding the contents of Agreement I know MARRA RFP Case Document Entered on FLSD Docket Page of that Jack Goldberger filed the Agreement under seal in the state court in accordance with the state judges order Can you provide us with a copy of what Jack filed so that if we are ordered by the federal court to disclose the agreement it is exactly the same as what has been filed in the state court hank you again for your a sistance Regards Marie Victims Resp to Notice.pdf A Marie Villafana Assistant U.S Attorney Australian Ave Suite West Palm Beach FL Tracking CV MARRA RFP WP Case Document Entered on FLSD Docket Page of Villafana Ann Marie USAFLS Fr om Se nt To Roy BLACK RBLACK royblack com Thursday August PM Villafana Ann Marie USAFLS Sub ject Re Notificat ion of Poss i ble Compelled Disclosure of theNon-Prosecution Agreement Marie I am working on this and will get back to yo Original Message From Villafana Ann Marie To Roy BLACK RBLACK royblack com Cc Dexter SAFLS Lee Cc Karen USAFLS Atkinson Sent PM Subject Notification of Possible Compel ed Disclosure of the Non-Prosecution Agreement Dear Roy In accordance with paragraph of the rosecut ion Agreement I am providing notice of possible compulsory proc ess commandi ng the isclosure the Agreement As I sure you know two of Mr Epstein victims ave filed suit against the United States alleging that the government violated their rights as victims by not consulting them prior to entering into the Non-Pro secutio Agreement As part of their response to one of the government filings the victims asked the Court to order the production of the Non Prosecution Agreement The deadline for the government to respond is August 5th and we intend to oppose the motion based upon the confidentiality provision I have attached a copy of the victims pleading for your review I connection with this we want to make certain that we are making consistent representations to the jud i ci ar regarding the contents of the Agreement I know that Jack Goldberger filed the Agreement under seal in the state co urt in accorda ce wit the state judges order Can you provide us with a copy of what Jack filed so that if we are ordered by the federal court to disclose the agreement it i exactly the same as what ha been filed in the state co urt Thank you again for your assistance Regards Marie Resp to Notice.pdf A Marie Villafana Assistant U.S Attorney Australian Ave Suite West Palm eac FL RFP Case Document Entered on FLSD Docket Page of RFP Case Document Entered on FLSD Docket Page of Villa fa a A Ma i USAFLS nt Villafana Ann arie USAFLS Thursday August PM Roy BLACK At inson aren USAFLS Lee Dexter SAFLS Subjec otification of ossible Compelled Disclosure of the on-Prosecution Agreement Dear Roy In accordance with paragraph of he Non Prosecution Agreement I am oviding notice of possible compu sory process commanding the disclosure of he Agreement As sure you know two of Mr Epsteins victims have fil ed suit against the United States alleging that the gove nment vio ated their i gh as vic ims by not consulting he prior to entering int he Non rosecution Agree en As part of eir response one of"the govemmeni fil i ngs the victims asked the Cou rt to order the production or he Non Pr osecut i on Agreement The deadline for the govemmenr to respond is August I th and we intend to oppose the otion a sed upon the confidentiality pro ision have attached a copy of the victims pleading for Our review In connection whh this v.c want make certain tha we are making consistent repre se ntations to he judicial regard i ng contents of A reemem I ow at Jack Goldbe ge fi ed the Agreement der sea in the a court in accordance i the sta judge order Can you provi with a copy of wha ack iled so a if we lre rd ered by he fede a I court disclose he agree en it is exactly he same as a has been flied in the state court Thank yo again for your assistance Regards Maril rJ DE19 i tlms Resp to A vlarie Villafana Assistant U.S Attorney Au tralian Ave Suite We sl alm Beach Tr a ki CV MARRA RFP Case Document Entered on FLSD Docket Page of Villafan a Ann Mari USAFLS Se To ubject Ok Will do Roy BLACK RBLACK royblack com Wednesday August PM Villafana Ann Mar ie USA FLS Re Follow-up on last week call Origina Message From Villafana Ann Marie USAFLS To Roy BLACK RBLACK royblack.com Cc Karen USAFLS Atkinson Sent PM Subject RE Follow-up on last week call Hi Roy Hope your trip is going well Are you available today at Eastern Pacific If so please call my office at the number below and Karen and I can both be reached there Thank you A Marie Villafana Assistant U.S Attorney Australian Ave Suite West Palm Beach FL Original Message From Roy BLACK mailto:RBLACK royblack.com Sent Tuesday August PM To Villafana Ann Marie USAFLS Cc Atkinson Karen USAFLS Subject Re Follow-up on last week call Marie I just got back to my computer Sorry it took awhile to respond I am available tomorrow to call you Let me know what time to call Remember I am hours behind you so email me the time in the am and I will call Thanks Roy Villa ana Ann Marie USAFLS PM Hi Roy Are you available late this afternoon to do a follow-up on last weeks call If today does not work can you let us know about your availability tomorrow as well Thank you CV MARRA RFP Ir һR ql??E?牦n inݒ?q Q?L NJ??b KH 9nd?bHI0gk??v Mt I?bf d??r?xB a dŋ h?ߺ?fWc:?VOx c??N?f BE iF KK HH И4?B?v吏 ݯ??L MT0 I i lZ OL EE x?t h?nLK2π ϣ?Q mɣ?C3O??c a Cz Ҵ?G wf??g a?Cm?st q?D ԛO Wh D?HY 4Ha P"y?è h,W e7 Xj F?F u?e?E ED??(?SD ˈ??鉤 j??e B?p?l jd wI GQ o?V ŝ?J I 5D Xc T??ؠ kuG _C?㹲?Ϋ?o IF?T Z?z x??j?!?LAY g?H?b e?ƌb yŚ _v 8?j?vb Tn?D vF ג-ʻ GJ?"I?J A A Ai C?h?ЍD G?柅 ЧA?cC U??K 9AWi?k i A p??qDP G??ۿ T?N uwS A?i וv?eB un nz ϟm??Ѹ?w Pm?v?o?U I?i A?s u?Y Z?vLf gn P1??oU Īϼvs??/?c??Q rh4d lT㰭 Xv??T?r K?q?S j7?E vJ yg Ar Y?Ă Dh?q?D 1텑 _?ӖE X?ѱZ XW Dz?q?զ??G_YH Wm m??R V?-Sw?T a w?p d?B?U a Hǻ4W?ߨ M?tUW L?o v?S0u il?a?o?NK7 Ծ5 v?gX E?w C?Ր X??h?yP Ӕ?,P ϛHGǧ 乀??w cb 9lN k??Yz?W WF??p QĩdR0c nK 0g dY??HK O??d A U.?U AMD??2 w?w i C?X 3?w7bĢ d?dGČ a?Os T?Ռ??C4쀕 a E??v kf Hg pb??E Gݶ6 Sk F?v 5Y?;ÀYmG t??IX?J LP?Η??M Μ?6ohm ϛG Q7轚m?sx?_ E?h?z qT o?t80vX 1Q.f M?Ҭ b??E?W?vM HT z?ۑ A0D שF Q?F 0bN Y?L2f j?V B/F F?c??i b?2JHP GﲣǕxYEh?7P y,ܕ?எc 9?Yt?P FI YO cBjT g-?C?AF J?E 3n Hޅf QQ a?ϵ?b t辉l?B زÍD ו8 yv ²_ pd ZI QYM?8x?j m?c AC?Wz 8I Q?v 4x??Xi?S j?D?Q M?_j VVˠ Z?ހ vO?ڦǴI Y?Q1 k?q n?(E ϣe W??WMŤlO!?aV?cBΏ X?_x A??z CO u?M d)?Q?i Isbe i A a n?p??Z?Ý qɎ?Kw??v OD Rr D?8??QD?Z藸?E ԏ?:R o??Fn ZL8?a X??pG aIj Grl vJ Vw?OR??7 Ro NHڋWG?n L?d I 5t?ϰ?J V?u8?akk?Đs?9 cm G3rE 0jv9?V M??y?E?V?s qt J3 ɲDD/?lw Es F?b?i OC?Kh?D?8?Д t?k n?VB5 gc Ӭ?μ?N8 CN Qъ?RU ϣMG I?IS qo?F??ĝqao?B?H sa?2Ù O??ƴ?ky w6 Mj??R h?g TcG Knb C??fi RHB?:?u?rMԕ?吘 I?d?ꩱz?j?8 O??D up?4X??Mb Qt?6 i?YN9 M?Vw rDA-I qmbB Me??d??g x?s V?L f?r Yp E?t Xb?q v?u??똺a evQ L??Z B8 so i c2U?e??IFZ?A??pZ?L?uH Q??:GⲀ?EkrʡC?S?g ֆz?-qt e?bW m?e x8.w z?S Wa a h?ح Y?sjVr?t H?i nCq?W g?Feg?r??Ti PXT U??M Gf Mn yF s8?c qB G?H Յ4 i I g?б1ڜڄ ݡ?.Vk?ݿ??q?Ư sqp 䴎?gY JDEqok?cuc ɂs yh?v?莅Bp ʸc X?s P?b?j iR GG L9 BR ت??T I?mc E??Í oBk 6_ Q?V E?V O?_K mL l/?EގOK L?GW?S td S5 mY?ݑ Mk91h?C?I ZGi ǚ?e l/?l AL w_Za J?Bf p?S F?U Zqk v?Z??nj YL 6_ O?U?sϠBQ??"??ɜ?J qc?㵆rl FJnט xXL9 OJ uf?5 n?W 4Eo?dq jYlJj Ol VbE??Y?:?h uw?G i xYH q?X zJ_yh C_?t O?zx3 x:DQ z?o 4?mޔ?j j?W S?bUb _R v?e A PQ K_ j?"ZY t?Y??ve y閤L?yKN k,A?.x,wsA 3EtJ sh ﲢ?e qd kO ګQdi/_5 I V??US n?F.??DE Ct0 Ë?5v ϳMM 3??,kʽdo Ϝ9?k fu y0?D?g a6 ٿa mZ?ņ7?I h??H X?W?a P??O!U c?W 2w?A Xv O?!tr H?"j?J C??l G??U?P Ojf IȔ8?Q7 l?ٴ?T A??pR 3p G9 Ԕm CQ p?E Z??t N?Ab Cu G?)4??cEVƮ??tL?A?GiuP??5I H?H 3T Q?fjX??0 yW?Y?5 wjbo dyw V??w V??b p?Y Wm?Ews 2ty XK A bX 4?0Xkl i9 lZ?C Xu?7 X?M vDP Na B?fӀ y?Ս ҝa S?ȸ??r gy Eb Mv h穯t?Vj?k?D bv G?s fv?v??P?S??e U?B i v?O r?Ri退 a P0 IN sj I t?Ĕ f?Cӝǝ Lξ?Φ ݘ??I0鄠 4?k?ʃs/W A3?ڤ?筌 QhH l?g?,P D?g?s m?s I5 cQ4 uz CG_c,Q?K?B?y 0P PF ʈzc FJ6 gv)?M T??I?䀔 Z??ޞ P?iDp N?O GEE:?wT J?2?Re?Q ӀXNd ߘI iW?Z HB A WG3 d?J A W?Y/X a jV RU??M sx?x?4 Ϳ??碶 2L Y?ɄzŝJu5?/?w ϣţ A P?O D!E 5?雡X deϏ Zi??ai AB U??Cr L?U?Xz ņe w?e LJ x?-Y WZ a t?P??c e?n O?fr pz ҬH??E?U w?Dm u?ىc?t L?Dw i vj?n 4Q IK P?/G oö R?g lvQ y?b?V He z?ĺ?.R _2P?og tz?y e0 Sv?z Ϩ缅?B?Q 8Ω _E?O 9gh?i/G JK?D?tIN6?t?ߦ Kn dP?a Mt K!!v Il0 e?1Ύ?H?b?Ɲ B?W J?KA w?qP.?z TQ??mx?_ XWG zW Њ?;V?m?L?rO?_g??Nsi??Vo i?byq G?TSƴdc Ns t?N?S 3??ou7ᱲx Ã?ii E?_?zњ A X??wtݫ??ݫ U?oZB?KŠ YN?df hde a Os Dys?d mށ v?E t??靝 Ge?5 o?q y6?Ƭ l??J oP 닇H?z??Z?w?jr g?T 9s U??u RJ e8 h?F E?ɓ 6??WYQ a 0C 4vS?D??n?Q?k 7?RM n??G Pu NG Wh 椄??C DZ?yC빀B Nz Et Rtmzo 1XP kI?J Og1?V vܕR?xv 4y 0?KHV?L N?W?X 3XC zd dy?H1 Oc HԅTp oYoj T?a R?I1 vY??Ŵ I?L P?j?W A 1Of_ Ez M?G?LdH u??U U?R?R h5x sɇ?퉒 N?P V?e?Y?e;??IwHd8?v?B ۅi?7Kh 0M?P T?c Ka qI?8 Z9 Mz?(?Z A C??C O??c?c P?Qh?E?P?Qh?E V?H mB uQiЬg z?P OX1?hX 9ܠaŀ ػC?w V?n 6Հ Ig??4j?f NJ wB??I?T 4?fv?:hpC4 ң?D?5G x?ޕ?q??_fS Wp Aհ3?ʒ 1M?C e?Y?P 3D HG?rs M?Od SF55?U Xs?sL 7ZY?/A?b Ǒ?C R.Z?c HS e8 5TNf?mm sW zg?bhu??q oi ixn HsӒ?r??j??I 6VVt?ͳ_ ݲ,?qv P?O MU l?Gw?Q i?N1 ڐ?.Km 1?Tڗb wc vƹ EOVE?L?p??!Z I ߓP5-,mc?w??p ii MY i g?ٲr?м kV"?P E?G huD?D 5XD Ym M?ډJO?i??Wtp o?ߔ,?z MҮ0 b?B?M?Ou F??tH??kv?c na?z Dq?2l w?i?k?ǹ a?D wb??ىB BF K??W k?B??R I F?n b?W?f VI I wW PQQ I t0 I a i?A y??x nD O6r v??v m?o4n?P 攨?Sp??i??A WQ 6?xy?Ow?F9?T 9G cc aci c?F uxЮR cn;Z oĩ wR sj?cr?!?V 7??AH?eמ Oǵ1?C f?BrJuv 7??eC?TF Wj?iʜ q?I d?S?Ch hn?g AyO էZ-??J/K?z n?n Y?U?"A n4 5ڧH_??ZԖ??uN I cc?L?ᅱ?k?n HZ 1cy?S Au j1P E3 nc JzX XU cԴ n??BĦ V??Cb Jm b??j?ix?A 1?C?ƨɓ ZN Ye m5?ꨒ TX?ddh 4p FO Ycw??o?M J??e?M?L n?D k?Ð?ޤQ 99ݬӤ V?q VSy A pL?Nx??!?i Q䐨?;p Yƫ ļ?q C?SKeЙ?_ 蟇L ZR 0q??tD?E O?N ݻL E1w BU??L?Y?Oq Ox?q?蘱 Ks e?W?e?X Bc??d??e W9 Lz B!Æ 9R L?Oݬ Q?M 1ie l??OBVF p?ĥ O?b?8?ae RVV mldO kq?A?WzV sPy_??f?2H K7 Tlk a őV KaEm8ր DJ ϰn:UXy??3?O N?_ҹV2t I a b??i?E?pmx??q E?f T?Z 4M Dw 矋?N os z??Y rֈ6?t I2?A D?x??-Ar?pS Ɂi?br p?rD4m?U P?V ڲj?ת?z MF?ib??k쉺?(??y?k_ť s?p p_rY Z?Z?Y?f mh fv M?WV?7 T?xI??1ܬ f?UW Û??w IZz?4?Jf O6 I?y6o d?m Sɥ?H 䪌?uя?r 5U x?T?ԕ Ce k?_?DӾ J??M 7b B?A P?N?la g?l Ӷሊӹ 7N Zw?ID h3 pDъ a?6g spK I S_?Tf5E 0?gΚ b?D?FM?L t?巐(JZ f6 Uv?P J?H?dL Q?pt?-w iosԴ?Oİ oK?7 SI V1AZ 8.Q?St ÿEi7Yq??Ӱ h?k0 S?x?L O?/Y?f D?y Tf?YIvmZ?V a i?J?zg??b rj3ՠr 9p W?d lt??IS ES rU N.n MKh_??F ңLU3?ߟt?_ g??bu u?σ??m?T Xϟ H?w?a;H jSl??3ڜ S?K?o aP8Iল?m??B0 A?qTo?G dպ eL H?Ȳ:b a O?Ͱo?z?e e?hw Po l??A s?a x?H?Z ck f??TU akl 1먵?eiU?Y??C?в Ép Ve?J?z?e5K)ʳ 7x HF Rg?ɘ a xo T?H u?M 9L zT EP j?w Z?W SLw?y gǶ Lm??Z?TNX e?s8 L?p L;?Y?p 4z Az?xT1 t??ɜ űz?ǹ Ci Ms y?ݑL I sg XU l??h Yo mU pMZ I?C Yh?n?A 8ub ÿ?7?Ɗ?kt?Z 陗?K??z?ɯ rb i Ul Г??t A?Ӳ P?uH M8 pC tr dP NM う?鞞L A?X i o?ߠ uG?GQW?p?Q Z7 e??AC mbDo?/7?nR tDO??m??v?U?S ꩠK LQd U??ɑ?Q yHR Zb i?Ex D?ed?;?u TD 1Wg?W??D?Ac??O l??lxE y?ߜ ct jpX5 a?Z v7 v??V qyke M?h p1 j?귵 cU?A?o 仾kMAѺ B勓??Uh _x 譠?TAń yޒ l?Z?B Cp?t??z?f m?Qi pss f(yƏ?jF??W u?S P??W wL gog ƚ??q r?Li wp??vH A KRv Pש D??loǘ?j j?K w?x?d3u ö뀀 v?K u?w DÜ Q??V Rǻ I 5FY??IPa wF?_?t k?ς??oދ MÔ??I cL??p U?T YN?u??r j?ɍ?C a3Q Y1 k??R z?S uA?N M??j?G?q?m YE ɝ?k F?t?R Gx05 U0 e1 Q7 I b?c A CT??T?yb?Jj aį 㤤a NXF zw??X Jh?S a ƪt.??牻 I??rI 8v?T?I 1O Y?m nI?i??ȩ 1g 2A Hŧ T?ts?w?c XP s?l4?m?S i?y P?0?Tg?Ġ Rd??zS TcE v??p?C?Vp?g cQ?4N g?uĢ ېBu j?f Mr JU1ϥ J8P?j ɭjg l?jt 3Y ކ館 H?9?bM h?"g 5N I 8q?A CQn l?sƶTK??Ƹ u?R?s??p sUJ?đ 3A A ٸj??cNF??5 Nd?XsΜ wX??бb?3g i I a?J?H B?z3l?f p8Ea VR?5 ը?u 7R?Hx y3T HQs P?h1 pNܒ i _?fORKT Σ5 O?F:?-hi m?"d4?uh?zC-g??ү np 6yIp aN YK?h FT TWtg H?x 5n Mw?5 ߓJc?C c??i yz ZF?)?ss4?xy??UV0?ox ϙ?O??l hJG??U By??ƛq a iR ah?n?N j??uگʜ RQ?9 fO Ct uih??㧴 7p o?C Qo 夅?,X?xB c?V 2z ELh LR?I Z,S _n M?d i nP0 FH?ʑӯ L2 1Rx Mf xL p8 YK ݻ?Xږݳ?bG?i E?C vJh al?f o?鵡 iA pWD j2?o fN?UG?6.F Mu xQr a3 AO F?Wà?-?Sr ڵZ XW ߖ?xv Z?m列 A ȇ8?Cuh A s2?zxǑM?Q??X t7?A?i?O?ϱ S?YH Eh î?0oڏР?h mNq Z?V?y9 ul?Y W_W MNϩ g??sj a0o Tf Wm"?ߋuj?J Zs?ΰ U
x E?A NZ Nt U?mh?oD r?H i L?J M4Q LU?C YA??vn e??Qj??h r?r c?K s??l?c aI qH X??x N?G?倇uqV j?F lf d?pɓ?Nqu4?F.D J?X Ҽj?;ؽ I H?G9 q?f g?r_ ݼl 5Ep мTi??E rg??s ϔjA6Q L?y Ĭ?z tu nF??y P4?N?S o?I5h Wp XF!??p l??h EQ Sk?L o?R?a Y?B AaJ Ҫl ڋ9?g n?g C:X vnB?/l U?!Ӝ?n?T k?ϋ B?Bj ۰?Su 1kY T??js U,?T?f ËN39 hu?-?GY V-h d,pP ԏXi??I o?i?콝ƈ?m åJ7?k?Sa Ķt ˁT J?m e?G HWغ s?G 8o c?Oz Uwƺ P?a?M??1?Oj?U?X?zsY?.d U;o?k?Q?x RC uu?G?z?ӬO2?Ὢ W??ۥt?h b??q RQ?ok?5??R 4VuNޣ?5ނ?V?ĕ vՂ i Ny K?ō _E?Je?qa ίWu?Ȫ?e?XY ɅqI Kq A Jf nx h?l sX?t PO?Zu M?p fL mO NvP??/Y n?-x Y9Cu/?x fm?U?bˍ I0?Հߡ Sf a I ZN eջޔ45 Kc?g IZ uӭ 1v Q8 Ѷ?Qg?g?"Ά?X?yҰ5 Vi?H?ޙ O??P 믟??r i i l??KC?M Cq?l S?V WN b?Ӊ?t 7d rkƈ?E?j?F 5C I?K NY M?A rsK?SͿ pO pG ip?X?L f?yaA 8?Vi յ?Q/?or?Gk c?h??8?uP?j?sH ӏp4 L??D Z-L p??t?k?W T??h 8Ku eMF Bs VƬ??Th B0 F?D??g r?ik?kz?G?jP صuIQq J?R a M?L M?mߘ?iz?r h.?w 7K шo?h"?Tf A oA 0?vd C?b L:R _5I?Mڞ L1 aL JRTt Gfض?S aӶp?ܘ _am,v??H?ؼ Yo?E?O iE A l?J gadk h?P?f L?s No dZ t?k _C 5p ì??nt h5 W?n?j4 ʀȿ??.vb o??a z7 x)9LC lZ n7 EF f9 Bma jG3 d??ko?n P?6c m??N L_L j_ nɥ k??T su z/a?8d??yh vk?9 Crs Z0XA a e?ݙS?ñ 1?nw?ԨJJ m?D?n??g Xm h7J?Oy 3nR?n nk??B Le ζ?ö??w f?a Jﳛ F?E 1Av ɲ?V 7?ٿF 债z?k nV nY?ɢ ELͿ?a?Z?X 2fo h?Ϲ?m vfT??B4?H 6xb E3?.PF p?od3 Ǥ?h ˋ?J _n i G4 lZ EqU??Q O??v ßД fEH??i?rh Mw q?g?Z nv da g?g q?,?i?Zm?vOE T3?Y ٧N f?ɵ k?v??ъ b0 ik P?읁B й?7?Yc?H r?Y I i?T?u??Adf H?K Uh T?EM vߗ mΌ5DX Is gp뼯?C/?xK 3?ޏq V??RKs UC2?kd?q?u??U O.DYd T.N gA5?t D?u fQ 3YGY Fze e?fH0 PQ n??Ͷhh:ԟ VO?w B?g?S??ygI Η?k t/H??qyFk v?Hdf Case Document Entered on FLSD Docket Page of A Marie Villafana Assistant U.S Attorney Australian Ave Suite West Palm Beach FL MARRA RFP WPB Case Document Entered on FLSD Docket Page of Villafana Ann Marie USAFLS From nt To Cc Subject Roy BLACK RBLACK royb ack com Tuesday August PM i llafana Ann Mar i USAFLS Atkinson Karen USAFLS Re Follow-up on ast week call Marie I just got back to my computer Sorry it took awhile to respond I am available tomorrow to call you et me know what time to call Remember I am hours behind you so email the time in the am and I will cal Thanks Roy Villafana Ann Marie USAFLS PM i Roy Are you available late this afternoon to do a follow-up on last weeks call If today does not work can you let us know ab out your availability tomorrow as well Thank you A Marie Vi llaf ana Assis tant U.S Attorney Australian Ave Suite West Palm Beach FL RFP Case Document Entered on FLSD Docket Page of Villafana Ann Marie USAFLS Se nt ubj ect Villafana Ann Ma ri US AFLS Tuesday August PM Lanna Belohlavek Question re Epstein Sorry lo bother I ti Lanna Sorry to bother you but a question has come up over here I know that you tiled the Non Prosecution Agreement with the United States Did you tile the versio that I emailed you the three-part agreement or a different version Thank you A Mane Viflafana Assistant U.S Attorney ustralian Ave Suite West Palm Beach FL 36-CV-MARRA RFP Case Document Entered on FLSD Docket Page of Villafana Ann Marie USAFLS Fr nt Cc Subj ec Villafana Ann Mar i USAFLS Tuesday August PM Roy BLACK Atkinson Karen USAFLS Follow-up on last week call Hi Are you available late thi afte rno follow-up on la weeks cnll If today does no work an yo tel us ow about your ava il ab ilit 1omorrow as well han you A Mane Villafmfo Assistant U.S Attorney Au stra i an Ave uite We st Palm Beach FL I RFP Case Document Entered on FLSD Docket Page of Villafana Ann Marie USAFLS From Sent Subje ct Roy BLACK RBLACK royblack com Wednesday July PM Villafana Ann Marie USAF LS Re Jeffrey Epstein I am in the mountains and the cell doesn work well I will get to a la ndline at and call you Original Message From Villafana Ann Marie USAFLS To Roy BLACK RBLACK royblack.com Cc Karen USAFLS Atkinson Sent PM Subject RE Jeffrey Epstein Can Karen and I call you on your cell at Florida time I just need your number or you can call us at Karens desk Thank you A Marie Villafana Assistant U.S Attorney Australian Ave Suite West Palm Beach FL Original Message From Roy BLACK mailto:RBLACK royblack.com Sent Wednesday July PM To Villafana Ann Marie USAFLS Subject Re Jeffrey Epstein Ok I am on the road in california and can call in about an hour or so Original Message From Villafana Ann Marie USAF LS To Roy BLACK RBLACK royblac k.c om Sent PM Subject RE Jeffrey Epstein Hi Ro It relates to the performance of the criminal Non Prosecution Agreement A Marie Villafana Assistant U.S Attorney Australian Ave Suite RFP Case Document Entered on FLSD Docket Page of West Palm Beach FL cc1 on Original Message From Roy BLACK mailto BLACK royblack.com Sen Wednesday July PM To Villafana Ann Marie USAFLS Subject Re Jeffrey Epstein I am out of town What is it about Villafana Ann Marie USAFLS AM Dear Roy Are you available this afternoon to discuss the Epstein matter Please let me know what time works best for you Thank you A Marie Villafana Assistant U.S Attorney Austra ian Ave Suite West Palm Beach FL CV MARRA RFP Case Document Entered on FLSD Docket Page of Villafana Ann Mari USAFLS rom Se nt Cc Sub ec Villafana Ann Ma rie USA FLS Wednesday July PM Roy BLACK Atkinson Karen USAFLS RE Jeffrey Epste i Can Karen and I call you on your cell at Florida time I just need your number Or you can call us at Karens desk Thank you A Marie Villafana Assistant Attorney Australian Ave Suite West Palm Beach FL Original Message From Roy BLACK mailto:RBLACK royblack.com Sent Wednesday July PM To VillafanaJ Ann Marie USAFLS Subject Re Je ffrey Epstein Ok I am on road in california and can call in about an hour or so Original Message rom Villafana Ann Marie USA LS To Roy BLACK RB LACK royblack.com Sen PM ubject RE effrey Epstein Hi Roy It relates to the performance of the criminal on Prosecuti Agreement A Marie Villafana Assistant Attorney Australian Ave Suite West Palm Bea Original Message From Roy BLACK mailto:RBLACK royblack.com Sen Wednesday July PM To Vil afana Ann Marie USAFLS CV MARRA RFP WPB Case Document Entered on FLSD Docket Page of Subject Re Jeffrey Epstein I am out of town What is it about Villafana Ann Marie USAFLS AM Dear Roy Are you available this afternoon to discuss the Epstein matter Please let me know what time works best for you Thank you A Marie Villafana Assistant U.S Attorney Australian Ave Suite West Palm Beach FL CV MARRA RFP Case Document Entered on FLSD Docket Page of Villafana Ann Mar i USAFLS From Se Subj ec Roy BLACK RBLACK royblack com Wednesday July PM Villafana Ann Marie USAFLS Re effrey Epstein Ok I am on the road in california and can call in about an hour or so original Message From Villafana Ann ar ie USAF LS Roy ACK RB ACK royblack com Sent PM Subject RE Jeff ey Epstein Hi Roy It relates to the performance of the imi al Non-Prosecution Agree ent A Marie i llafana Assistant Attorney Australian Ave Suite West Palm Beach FL one Fax Original Message rom Roy LACK mailto:RBLACK royblack com Se Wedne sd ay July PM To Villa ana Ann Marie USAFLS Subjec Re Jeffrey Epstei I am out of own What is it about Villa ana Ann Mar i USAFLS AM Dear Roy Are you available i afternoon to discuss the Epstein matter Please let me know at time works best for you Thank you A Mar i Vil a ana Assis ant Attorney Australian Ave Suite West Palm Beach FL RFP r4 A Nl?.?X au Hz?ˮ bC x?ߙ EUN H?AK A T?V?m ċl ZS l?J EΒ?G wg 9XB a vi?1 JM x??L AZ _P?ʇ sQ 2a m/a Ñ?t??mv9敛 KUN-Ӌ a 3bn Ay H5 3V C?OF?k ξkrT?Q j?p Q4 d?!KY?K?Z??B?x SBA?D/??a?L Ǫv?-Az I?.cA?g??w?w 92Vݩ y6 H?Ṭ c2 Z?K?b??ӀqHD iO o?w??y qj:i?Ewp v??e GK _g i S?4E k??c?A g?Wf?Q5 8h U3 0T hL 1H?F qp4 J??SQ I cX Bx?h?2 YZ??X 0?cZ?9fH?d uՒ 낵y myC?x??B??5r k?Y q??k JG bs??ƫY cx bM?F _C?A?S SW??f?h?n潹?jS!E FRu I łӂF F?R ƕ?(C H?c ߗj?Ў Qp dV?G fA??z ЇRމJ YC?rh ǃ?m hw af?A vF eZ fP N(ҋ,k B?d PcA kQ?v ι爰 _o ϨR a W?V a gjzP T"3y 5Լ zƳn 1ͺa Mӆ??d Rk?ҏ?2x?.Ū?U sή?viu2 ul r?Vk i N,Ӯ Oto Y?ύOy Rg ب"??oH Vk??s j4 m6 BGH E?k Bp k?S O2?Z ͱͱR ex?n VI?v Zf Jt J?Du s?g lJp a dfΊ?K YHi i 8pX w?dhȝ??Ē?cRBC ebd70 eV αD I E?U4 poUN?2 7Y ʖN?c V1u)?Ԇ CȜ pk e??-om p?n iX 3B ک?-J s?p?pP G?NK Ñ??T i A bK?y w?y 1R S??T th d??W i?ĸB MW?W e?S!?q 4â 1OJ yp?b?N p??x?O?sg HB z??c I i?F ID??t 9Y Sm?_ r??Γ??hĵy J_ P?M?x Rd M)G 2o m?R?T cB A Ypv0?J ۦS8 tt I z??m Ãu Pd ĥc p?dI K??L io-N C?Z i 3?LG I j?VO??Q a nb VrLm T??wq TD u?,o w?SM3D B??w?k BȔY ԅl?蹭 ΡF7?o?zC F0 Zu Y?b z?t?N?F wT kP?j YE 3n T??e?i T??Y ɨz W?zo Gѡ AmŒv 2H Y5E 7u Y?c a0È KpO?a2?)o i g??ƙo?X??s??B?eq?f vX?e?չT??s F??ɏ 4p Î?tJ?d Q?i a 7B 8t?d h?ff?ڠIF??j?z6s??K qrKY?0 BӰ?Ήԙ 鰂g?Fβ c??R.Dr RMOr Γ?S ā?gVJ ϊ?/VjX BW i?Y?zӤ?p/?p3D Ï3 b??g g?طN o?c q?R?u n?J m??S Mn?U t6 Cy 7?yJ 釖0X T?g?Y Ĥ??T dDу V??fZ J?J p3 n?f?yh uE tx?ٷހV??H Ob vz?XA ƮZ Dm?6 Q?䀀 Y?j?B?I??q?kh 7f xk?-?M Uꌸ zJ vh yFh?B;6 Cx f?h B?j?ꏿ??0SD Onj?Ѓ?ؾ V??D EV3?Jk?8I j?ꅄi??1r?B G0 KI??x pZ?ݚ hDm P3 ЏV V??.9ߎlQ p??m A 7s j?T a I ՀLFמs Kf?_ B??Y flˀ i L0 m?F Aj pv Dzw?zq7?A h?û?hD yy?Rё?q?P P?p ZG S6 dp?Ljm 6?z?h?dn S?b gܯ mw穤?Ќ a?Rxy?U?Q??Ȟ?Eg u?V m?Rq?6D m?q bb Q??o?AN 쎜??w K0 CS?N?ȝ Ң?Ӑ b?1q dL I j3 A ϣtϣ ɭ?ε?C A?b:?S gSY萕?h??ǖ?_ g?Eq Q?W 9D qt A Ʈ1?σ 7f?x?S?ŨO hzj A Vfk1R?P S?t??J al gR E?D 8R Xq?ɡ?BС?.u??H?w?Ƥ?uT d,ꫴ i l??GG?V I?R Zy??j үp c?Q?Z ήI IViy??BF x??m b?m 7?薤M v?l 6?Nۉ G?u?_W?O XM p-?x a Oԣ E?v IF A?fGBV k?סa Z?y hԺ z?Σ i?l sS ѣ?4ȿ??x?GI ϛv jի P??5?KiM b??s Αu ґ6 r?7?ʩlIs?E?H?7 IM g?H??nD??T T??x??"bYI a?/c bfˀ EY GybK fv i vd?p ƯI i OX??ΰ?3P 4Ř O㉈?V Jҗ SO 5h Cc?o?k??YY v?m?g 6wIXc 4ش A J5?B idz?2 S??r u?0fP ϣ?q??f oe 6g1ͱbS?E?L WB dN פ.?-sO H?vd EMJ UdO kp e.n?z au 5?5?ŭpo?lō A?!hJ W?G?q LK5O Q0 i?5e Z?N hi dC??6B c?H?q W6 piJ JD xLĜ ij?wٲ?f?_?B i??U a 5S i 3诤 p??z J?B h?g 60Eaȫ Ois?Cx?3 j3 R?s?i C?y a Z?Q PO3?ڋߧ U??b 7??MmS kb Iy a T?S??w w?)?fe Og k?j J9ʰ izd a sӤ v?vA?1;O 7U ZvQ,?08J?N dO ev?M M?ȳ i?ܥ ƅ?w?t?T ǭi RI IZ ħ?4L M?KQ QU?pu?l?j tIq AQ zMp GjnM WU m?L L5 e?K??K 1mo?C?m GZ?ŧ9 I?yE5 _r k?/o 6r Ui C?p?O?K A CiC?Nq IU?a??o?Fh Ӯ1Q?QM?O?ȅ?e ϣ?q GC G8T渻 Ѳ??l y?s Xo?E lzG I?Y T?S?p W?Yp zC??C Ny gC ߜ?g7?Oa i?l?b Qm dC A-?P U?cx?T Mn1 ޏT9Ա?.Ʀ fR3?P?.V J?A?YG?uP?N F0 R??Q t?J o?Bv r?k e?t Šh 7腈 s?e e?5?TB 6췒Y X??L Qn?IDx?e?U FE f??P j?ﲔ c?M Ñu?M?j H??CA6 A:W9 jC?Z5 k?D Œ?3v b?,c A Su?VcU?;Ӻ d2 U?ƬA QN m?e??Vd??O?l N??ǰ?Ok ɺh I?AD a??I?g Pp M??Y d?HPg bx V?s?q i K7nV Xa Qyg zJ qކ?:O JDV?1 Q?ȸ A Ӏv?ft a hPݢhl e7 VFլ x??zˢ Nk U7 RX??J S?GR?g qR Ȯ??M?Q h?dII jXj c??O?m M?Ѥ?I6?Ƅ o?g iA?X8?u ªa t?m F?k tq?C?x?b?κd ȖU ¾_ A ivy a?r q?R??M O?Պ aC??ǀ ϛx N.?H y?u?H W?h I LR!0r Ϧm X?0y?gT?Npp gX?b?Ͷ I UmӞ?wQ?F TC 뼢?d??nd a ɨIZ?k B7 cJ?r Y3 D"I?x xm N??q o7 w2E?T ؠ??aJ h?b ha??l SC G-pj?av??/F h?w?ϥة??Ti Gv ϟ?f YMaݸS v?ϵ?Up anp??Fj ν?r?c뢯 s??ܪSՁRE gn g??m fd qӛ 4V My p/M?Bv?H H??k?Z zC BH?HU Pv?r N?0ȍS g??Ih a r8?Z?C e?I?w??ù?gN?w ch aS P??E Mx M?c??b Ci b?W 9xSt yjϤ?V?g Ld i CK o??dO In?X?ӣ mW MԨa qbt?-J u?N?rY 9k Gg a?J 1)u?vĸ I?ϗ zWB E?Z?NW g9 ήG Z?Ćct GZ??V?Aj Ń?p X?B??Y?X A ԑ?bʯ T!?B f0f LȞ q,i РN pA Mj M?ǣ4 8UK ln/YX Њ?w űDS Ңg1?m"4?P?1zsg?a?D Co ߤ??Y?u B?V8o I殬v?5?B?T ƺpu 5aG E8HxװT6rb??U?R D?ZF B?rR n?G/W?nJ k.??dq XWV?U f"?fp0?v4?т?g?MP D?P;d6 A?Ew U?i?J cu w2uE o4 YW?C L?gB tJ3Z?x A??K Bi㦨 Yu rf A?w Ak Ta?B Cxuw U?N??i I G_?pv X??F x?J?N Gǻ?p h?x ˏ?Y se A?XUS?e B?us bs a??z?g і_ Po?p"?w?g Cע Fb Q??r S??V cb ۮڿ pgY ʁ??B P?c pm Xz уi k??Yy z??)?KuŨ b?Mˠ PV A a G?ډ Ej??M މl?0e㗬 Hg??RL _W C??I ϟAGɥc亀Q gPի"?ȴL 1U?E og?e1 zM;xBj4 kK Ɍ)IN Ъ?y s?b Lgj k?n gd3 t0 PN??D Ӆ?M xf aAں g3 zG??;DsaF??u s?J?t ak 풐?O?C Jܡ K?P fŋ?h f?W?Qz?_n c?T ˢZ l쫃:?ߪ?S i6 ACj I zK uF?r oA??l?n 1?tP P??å?膪bɌ Ȃ?N Ɗ?t ߊy?b??)A h??k Ll?rV Pr?r"N?G uR Iߕ wIE?D?ˎ dF?q A?q?ƄC?w i Vg?m sB O?CHgn o??Њ ZHd??R B?L 4s zӸr i??Ybf?gצ V1 N?V z?v??s Ί1 9N?c v?α 9Uex w1V oZ?ǀ?3??W3?iΌUs lS GX ΉM?ԉw k?uW??G U1?g?D Py??Ώh?T tڕ?2 h8 hS W?m gdFP S?ڳ q??na ߛ??r ʙ??Y h??L fϿ?F x?P Q??IX q2 Ks Me?7 T?DN L9Y O?P I ç??ʖKy:??f?5XMK 1HD jEB 1ec G6 aI ճ?n?e rV Yk?!Q X?J p?t b?E Pkg?N Si??MVk G?p5ff S?ҽn bg 1uK8?D Nr?5 Di?o?Z W?s l?h s??Q y?z?w j?Hr a 횅5z G7?7Pc վ?g Zf?"N l?/ܔ?gs??v?mu m4:r?Ğ t?8e Ȳߖ?z b??M?v t??H i z.a ۊ9 ﲫH Ru Xq n_ Kל 6T s?rM?NǴ??W gcaB za d?Υ F?u 9o R?Z i I tޅsj?6_ n,?V Pe??VW?p1 K?ԛr??_c rx T?B gYc g?U?h Ş?Ȉ bB h??T SF Gd0 mjQo V?b dTC X2f?W?ɶ;?f n?b??H?n GB qqO?o Mo I U?f?Koz i?Gj m?e Hrs?Sd LFh?7 a D?zW:?DN f??u v?pR րsX㵒ɾq?)?B t_X 2x 0H 1?F?V?qgqB z?R?L z?z k2?Q 2P P6ӟT??Y??B"K a?J Mw gYwG Ԙ??n j?kz c2 n??U A;?n?Z ʯP?9?g dL?陥A q?boʌO l6?F ϹM s?G iەf éb?C Z4 Bk?W rf rh??.UTa kX E?J?J R?Vs?MB?S xZ nk8 M?b JGJ ty a Y?P7?M Iʼn?oT x3 Gf"?E iK9 Ӵ??a Xh nx?n nj??㧽 HЗ Ȋ?KQ?b"b?4r B?걗 p?uZ vN?t jI L?Ȥ 1l n8S öi a D??f Ns JB??Ɍ mϢ?ԖP ɋ?s ۉsG f?X??A pj R?i fg??5x 5j e?5w ʡ?mKւ K?r??vl?l?Q;RUEǨ1?QFH??B E?L e?i H?y ڂj9 A??yzeu?x A rf D?_??rQn Gd3?l FзRi k??Ә?Ġj hy4 F?/b x?H9 T?0C?o??PI N??df?4q e?r a I ua mw?q?Ҟ?Y 3Ɇ cZ ՙ??u NM yQz M0 νj??q?x?C 5K H?r?e me F7 Q??y ذ??ķ BۥX LZ Yy V?i Rj W?u i b?Ǻ-S??XO G?k ZI?e?ˮ G?a q??h Nh 踽RU.2 1q 7F?K:?Oг I?Fc?qc au g-?Zż??Fc b?y?xZg?Q Kd Ȩ?I!K?m?V U?I 1?B?Zm A E?R?V,;EE KEDB?(??pGA rG6 7X bJ Lgq??zEu?.??N bx?6Ԯ H??j K?R uȚ?vZ Kx3EC ёWV 5i?IO Sd2?E ט?ľ RÚˠ GGEu x?z i i4 wȜ Ek Qݭ?H 7?aQ a1 i?gGI pa?jr 6?nm N陌 GCEضv g?dž?w?j b?HSk i?u 5Y g?eh?Q?s ۈH jmxƝ Ƃc?衵o q6 RX Ô0 _R G?Xɬ ժ?Ώ X?VV UTolqN lwb GPP n?xE h5NI l4?N 8w?J?GD 9?GF y?kUYؿg ux?Τ?G?0?ঊ?JMd _??yX?cWۄ?Y qu Ay fʇY jiY cgO E?V eLev I?O QB??kw?.?Yv??TH?j V??o賝 J?x Xf?V4;v LȀ s??C Xf cF Cv QU?-?D?z O?g CHA L?π 7ߐ ΏQu m?95TR k?a iM 9gV?x imFciqg??w qT kG wl?oX z3u a D?W?g?IS?,Mp I??Ɣ k?o?阴F hl;0R??W DY?n Jm?ƅg adO Qn?u 3U6לe?u H?"Q?C 3Ѿh Z1 dk dWPP??v A挕 i Y?r Xo?M?K ܭ?O V7m ą?oc qn Ut hO?B?gW hx d?g?o Oy K?M?żq C?f mT?nq?1 qF?S HJ?J?P Mg?m?5 a J?f Auh?!?fiQ i b?τ h??d?ԩe w?ђ k/ku a/T ٲU l?c j?o oTE??eŎ ԋwvI S?f AL?t?V Ĝ??B a ŝw?y??9L mP Q?Q 8vYV B?C0?N D??ޘ NU?VQ?V?N xy?PMR:??ж?o 8?se p?v ߈G I WGy I i?ph pi??-x?t qhݲa Am?,T?i_ˏ?tր7 a y4 9h c6ݤ a T?cF n0 8L P?k gm H/5?ub عΜMc 6c p?A w"?hY?A P8 sF?y J?ƅ C??R?n?q?Em ri H5?a?i Y?R K?d?vq m?G Wʒ ڠb b?P m?ƶ n6 S?a X?mo ȫ?m iɩ i??V K?w C??C?b g?mѕ??z?Aؠ c?hiڤ4 yA?w hd x?N a?п?m r??Kj SZ N?T ݔ?i Jt?ڂ"?C hBQ W_w 4r?.MV l??ɡ c-J f?R)eu fԏ X?s h?p Id YLD?0Q?s J歆?1 s䀀 R?G_ b??g?W?C RӬ F1 kv?U1 4?tE Vڊ HDk s?2?T1UY ps Jf xǸ T??q?ҩ GQB Case Document Entered on FLSD Docket Page of Villafana Ann Mar ie USAFLS From Sent Subject Villafana Ann Marie USAFLS Wednesday July PM Roy BLACK RE Jeffrey Epstein Hi Roy It relates to the performance of the criminal Non-Prosecution Agreement A Marie Villafana Assistant U.S Attorney Australian Ave Suite West Palm Beach FL Origina Message From Roy BLACK mailto:RBLACK royblack.com Sent Wednesday July PM To Villafana Ann Marie USAFLS Subject Re Jeffrey Epstein I am out of town What is it about Villafana Ann Marie USAFLS AM Dear Roy Are you available this afternoon to discuss the Epstein matter Please let me know what time works best for you Thank you A Marie Villafana Assistant U.S Attorney Australian Ave Suite West Palm Beach FL RFP Case Document Entered on FLSD Docket Page of Villafana Ann Marie USAFLS From nt To Subject Sounds good Atk i nson Karen USAFLS Wednesday July PM Villafana Ann Marie USAFLS RE Jeffrey Epste i Original Message From Villafana Ann Marie USAF Sent Wednesday uly PM To Atkinson Karen USAFLS ubject FW Jeffrey Epstein FYI I was going to respond that it relates to the performance of the Non Prosecution Agreement What do you think A Marie Villafana Assistant U.S Attorney Australian Ave Suite West Palm Beach Origina Message From Roy BLACK mai lto:RBLACK royblack com Sent Wednesday July PM To Villafana Ann Mar i USAFLS Subject Re Jeffrey Epstein I am out of town Wha is it about Villafana Ann Marie USAFLS AM Dear Roy Are you avai able is afternoon to discuss the Epstein matt Please let me know what time works best for you Tha nk you A Marie Villafana Assistant Attorney Australian Ave ui te West Palm Bea ch FL RFP Case Document Entered on FLSD Docket Page of Villafana Ann Marie USAFLS From Sent To Subject Roy BLACK RBLACK royblack com Wednesday July PM Villafana Ann Marie USAFLS Re Jeffrey Epstein I am out of town What is it about Villafana Ann Marie SAF LS AM Dear Roy Are you available this afternoon to discuss the Epstein ma tt er ease let know what time works best for you Thank you A Marie Villafana Assistant U.S Attorney Australian Ave Suite West Palm Beach FL RFP