UNITED STA TES DISTRICT COURT I I I A JAN OE CA TD SE CV MA RR A/J OH NS ON Pl ain ti ff JEF FR EY EPS TEIN Defendant JANE DOE NO CASE NO TD 32-MARRA/JOHNSO Pl ain ti ff JEF FR EY EPS TEIN Defendant JAN OE CA TD SE CV MA RR A/J OH NS ON Pl ain ti ff JE FF RE EPS TEIN Defendant JAN OE CA TD SE CV MA RR A/J OH NS ON Pl ain ti ff Case Document Entered on FLSD Docket Page of JEF FR EY EPS TEIN Defendant JANE DOE NO CASE NO TD CIV-MARRA/JOHNSON Pl ain ti ff JEF FR EY EPS TEIN Defendant JAN OE CA TD SE CI MA RR A/J OH NS ON Pl ain ti ff JEF FR EY EPS TEIN Defendant A CA TD SE CI MA RR A/J OH NS ON Pl ain ti ff JEF FR EY EPS TEIN Defendant JAN OE CA TD SE CI MA RR A/J OH NS ON Pl ain ti ff JEF FR EY EPS TEIN et al Case Document Entered on FLSD Docket Page of Def end ant DO II CA TD SE CI MA RR A/J OH NS ON Pl ain ti ff JEF FR EY EPS TEIN et al Def end ant JAN OE CA TD SE CI MA RR A/J OH NS ON Pl ain ti ff JEF FR EY EPS TEIN Defendant JAN OE CA TD SE CI MA RR A/J OH NS ON Pl ain ti ff JEF FR EY EPS TEIN Defendant OM NI BU OR DE TH IS A US is before the our on th foll ow ing moti ons Pl ain ti ff MA oti on or Protect iv Order Re reatm ent Re cords D.E Plaint if Motio or Lea to File Case Document Entered on FLSD Docket Page of Aff ida it of Pl ain ti ff Pl ain ti ff MA Em rgency oti on for Pr otec ti Or der Reg a rd ing the Dep osi ti on of Ser Thy and Pl ain ti ff eq uest for Emer ency ear ing on lai nti ff oti on for Pr otec ti Or der av ing ev iew ed the lea din fil ed i nci dent to hese matter and bei ng othe rw is dul adv is ed i the pr emis es i i er eby OR DE RE A ND A DJU DG ED A OL LO WS Pl ain ti ff MA Moti on or Protec ti Or der Tre atment Rec or ds is STR IC KE A OOT i tha Pl ain ti ff has noti fied th our i her epl of her it hdr aw al of the moti on laintif Motion or Lea to File Af idavit of Plaintif D.E is GR A NT ED Pl ain ti ff MA Emer ency oti Protec ti Or der eg ar din the Depo sition of Serge Th D.E is DE NI ED By this Motion Pla intif seeks a pr otec ti or der to pr ev ent he depo si ti on of Ser Thy pr esent ly sc hedul ed for Aug ust from oin forw ar For the eason tated i udg ar ra Or der of August de aling ith the nea rly ident ical issue said otion as it relates to Dr Th is deni ed In th sam Motion at issue he re styl ed a a em ergency Plain tif so ught to prot ect a in Dr a it io wh ic wa le ll win a Aug ust As Dr Po pe eposi ti on as sc hedul ed to tak pl ace the ay after the iling of the Motio Jud ge Marr a ha ndle tha portion of th io an eme rg ency basis Plain tif asserted basis or rotect ing th de positio of Dr Pop is the sa me basis Pl ain ti ff a is es her to pr otec he depo si ti on of Thy namely Pl ain ti ff ondi ti onal Case Document Entered on FLSD Docket Page of Not11 ic12 of Inte9 nt Ex21 cl12 usi13 ely23 Rel15 on St10 atuto8.992 ry23 amag11 es Pr10 ov16 ide9 by20 ase and9 the psy11 chot10 her10 api9 pati12 ent ri15 il14 eg12 eit11 her10 of thes10 ar13 uments9 it10 hst9 and cr13 uti11 ny16 In hi15 ug12 ust9 er9 udg13 ar9 ra jected Pl9 ain9 ti10 co9 ntent8.992 ion9 that11 her noti12 ce of ti10 onal10 ntent9 co9 uld9 be used as a shi13 eld9 to pr9 ev16 ent the depos8.992 it10 ion9 of Pope from oin9 forw22 ar9 og12 entl12 noti15 ng12 that11 abs13 ent amended ple9 adin-10 or13 st11 ipu9 lat11 of the p9 ar9 ti10 es,9 Pl12 ain9 ti10 uni12 er9 al non-12 bin9 din9 noti15 ce of inte9 nt annot be us11 ed to9 pr12 ecl13 ude discovery13 in this case D.E In th-9 Order Jud-10 ge Marr10 a also reject-9 ed intif-14 2s cont10 enti12 on th9 at Pope d9 eposi15 ti10 on houl10 be pr9 otecte-16 on he bas12 is12 of the psychothe-12 rapist-pa-10 tient-10 priv14 ilege notin-9 tha-10 blan-4 ket asse-11 rtions the priv11 ilege the sort Pl9 ain9 ti10 ais13 ed er9 onst10 it10 ute mprop9 er9 iz22 ati11 ons of the p9 ri15 il14 eg12 nst9 ead Pl9 ain9 ti10 as ins13 tr11 uct9 ed to9 as9 ser14 any23 ps9 chot10 her10 api9 pati12 ent p9 riv10 ileg16 s9 he may19 hav20 dur14 ing19 the depos9 it10 ion9 on a ion9 b9 uest10 ion9 basis12 Id at he abov13 eason9 ing19 eq15 ual9 ly22 appl13 ies to he depo9 si12 ti10 on of Thy15 Li14 ke Pl9 ain9 ti10 as ins18 tr11 uct9 ed to9 do d9 ur9 ing19 the Dr15 pe depos9 it10 ion-11 int11 iff as9 ser14 any23 ps9 chot10 her10 api9 pati12 ent p9 il14 eg12 s9 he fair14 ly22 and re9 asona9 bly23 bel12 iev23 es she has dur10 ing19 the depos9 it10 ion9 of Thy15 on a uest10 ion9 b9 ion basi14 Acc12 or9 din9 ly22 ain9 ti10 MA10 Emerg13 ency22 Moti12 on for Pr10 ti10 Or15 der10 as9 ela9 tes9 to the eposi15 ti10 on of D9 d9 eni9 ed a9 nd ive Order D.E is DE9 NI10 ED The Cou9 rt11 sees no benef-10 to enter14 tai11 nin9 or12 al ar9 ument on the ss10 ue and ele9 cts13 to pr9 oceed8.992 ex16 cl12 usi13 ely23 upon the ple9 adi9 ng12 once the moti9 on has12 been fully23 br12 iefed Case Document Entered on FLSD Docket Page of DONE ND ORD9 ERED thi11 ug12 ust9 in Cha9 mbers18 at10 est9 Beac10 Fl13 or9 ida9 LIN11 NE9 A OH10 NS9 ON UN14 ITED STATES TRATE UD14 GE he Hon-11 orab-9 le Ken-10 net-10 A Marra All Counse-10 Record Case Document Entered on FLSD Docket Page of
5,063 characters
