X-2HIBI-3T Case Document Filed Page of Case Document Filed Page of ir i nia Giuffre Pl ai nt i rt Ghislaine Maxwe ll Dcfondanl United States District urt Southern District of New York Case No RWS I NOTICE OF SERVICE OF RULE SUBPOENA TO PRODUCE DOCUMENTS INFORMATION OR OBJECTS OR TO PERMIT INSPECTION OF PREMISES UPO JEAN LUC BRUNEL PLEASE TAKE NOTICE THAT pur sua ntt Rule of he Fe eral Ru les of Civil Procedure aintiff Virginia Giu ffre ereby prov ide No ice of Service of Subpoena to Produce Documenr I nformat io or Objects to Perm i Inspection of Premises upo ean Luc Brw1e A copy of he Subpoena is attacJ1ed to thi Not ice as Ex hi it A ated February Si gri lVfoCawley Sigrid 1v1cCawley Admitted Pro Hae Vic Boies Schiller Flexner LLP Las Olas Blvd Suit Ft Lauderda FT Da vi Boies Boie Schiller le xne LLP Mai St ree Armonk NY ll en Brockman Boies Schiller Fl ex ne LLP Lexington Ave New York New York Case Document Filed Page of CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE I HEREBY CERTIFY that on February I served the foregoing doc ume nt on the individuals iden ifi ed below via email Laura A Menninger Es HADDON MORGAN FOREMAN P.C I East I th A venue Denver Co orado Tel Fax Email lmenninger hmflaw.com Sigrid Mccawley Sigrid Mccawley Case Document Filed Page of ev Subp oc nn rodLJce il1 fu ma iq Objects ermi I nspec ion Pie i i a il A c1i To UNJTED STATES DISTRICT COURT Virginia Giuffre fa il uUf Ghislaine Maxwell tf endanl fo th So uthern is tri of New rk Ci il Action No SUBPOENA TO PRODUCE DOCUMENTS INFORMA TlON OR OBJECTS OR TO PERMIT INSPECTION OF PREMISES IN A CIVIL ACTION JEAN LUC BRUNEL Joe i tone South East 5th Street Pompano Beac Florida a ti pe fo wh hi subp na i di Pro duc ion YOL ARE CO MMANDED produc a the i me at all la se forth th fo ll wi ng doc11m n1 ctronica lly i nfor ati or obj ec a to rmit in ii ction cop in st in or a mpl i ng of mate ri al LEAS SEE ATTACHED EXH I BIT A Pl ac Boies Sch i ll er Flexner LLP xington Avenue New Yo NY a te a nd ime am 11spec 1i of remis YOU ARE COMMANDED pe rm it ntr nto he si gn at premi ses and th er propert po sses sed or ontr ol ed yo a ime a te an location set fcir low so hat th ues lin a rty a i cl a ur urv ey photograph es am pl the pr ty an des i nated bject or oper at ion on i Place I Date and hn lhe fi 1l win pro vis io of ed iv cJr a a ed Rul la in th pl a of mp ian Rul lating our ro te i a a son su bj c1 a po anti Rul and lating to you dut ond to this su po na and the pote tia onse ence of not doin so at OF OR ig noture o/C i or Deput rk The a me addr ess a i add ss a nd telephon umb th a 1o rn ey pre sent in name o.fpa ty Virginia Giuffre issues reque st thi ubpoen a a re Sig i Mccawley SF LLP Las Olas Blvd Ft aud erd a le FL ccawley sfllp Notice lhe person who i ss ue or requests this subpoena I thi ub poe na om and 1he prod ction nfdo u1 dron ic a lly sto i fo rm a ti an ible ings th in spe ctio of mi ses fore trial a tic a nd a opy th ubp ena must se rv ed ach ar ry in th i case fo re i i ser the so to hom it i dire ed Fe Civ a Case Document Filed Page of AO Rev ub po na Dornm ri forma1io11 Oh_1ccts to Per ii I ns pec i on of Premises in a i i Action age ivil Action No CV RWS PROOF OF SERVICE This section slzould be.flied with the court mies required by Fed Civ received this subpomia for a fi 11divid11a and title if an on daw I served the ubpoe na by del i vering a copy to the named person as fol ows on ate or I returnect the ubpoena uncxcc utc eca se Unless the subpoena was i ss ed on behalf of United St a te or one of it officers or agents I hav also tendered to the wit ess the fe es for one ays attenda nce a nd the mileage allowed by law in th amount My fees are fr trav el and for se vices fi..1r a ota of I declare under penal ty pe1j ry that is information i true Date Se,-vei signn ture lrinte nam a nd 1irl Server address Add i tional information regarding att mpted se rv ice etc Case Document Filed Page of AO l!!m Rev S1 1h p,Jcn a Prnd cc Do ur lnf m1 or vti.1ccts rm lt ln p,cti Prcmi;:cs i a ilil A ct i Pa ic Federal Ruic of i vil Prncedurt cl and Effective lu ofCumpliancc Fl,r a lrial Hearing DepMiti1 A uhpoen:i ay c01n1t.l a pcr 1Cl a tend a tri a hear i ill ition unly i fo ows ith in I ile re lht id i i:mp c:J or rr nr tr ansacts in pe ur with i he Lu te whe re pCTso resides i rn pl,1 yc.d rc ul rl lnmsacts ss son i lt hc erson i i a my a ar fficer or ii i command a tt ml i I mid wo ul incu utiswnttal pe11 Fnr Oth e1 Di co1 225ery subp ma comm:rnd prod11e i ueumcnl dcd ro nicall ored informa i trnigibk th i ng i place ithin I UU mi es of ere th pcr on reside is em oyed or e_rm rl tr,m ac h1 in pe nn rB ect i C1n ofpr i cs at the plcmiscs be iri sp;:ctcd Protect ing a Person Subject to a Subpoena I A 225r1itli11g Undr,e rde11 or pen Sr1ctio11s vr l1l Lor re po ns ible i i rni ng en in 11bpm:m11J1us luk n:as rn1bk id i us ing un luc tr dcn or cxpc1m a per son h_1cc rlic ubpocrrn Th co tbe cli ct where cnmp ian ce i rcqui-rd enforce this dUI nd i pn a a pprnprint anc i hid1 in clude km ea min gs i hl a1 ey i p::i nr mtrnnc fail comp Comm1md ro Pm fu ce Material or lermit spectio11 A e1rmn ilol Reqwred A per sM c1 mrn:.1dcct pmdu ce docum nts cc cmic llv tored i11fom 1ti OJ a gi bl thi1,s or IV nn iL 1n pecti prt Jl i ilccd llCJ ll tUr i i JII ie pl it or pruJuc11011 or i unl es a so ccm 1mand cd app 1r ror a dcpos1lio.11 or ecrin11 per,on 1:nl ltcl to pr oduc doc ume or a11giblc h,ng or to re mil i ns pet:tion ay se nt ly or rney dcs cd Lli sl1bpo writt..:n ob ccl on to in pcc ling copymg es ti ng or plin any or rl hc mater ia or i cmisc,-:ir to pi durin ckc tr nicall torcd info ma ion in rhc form or rorm quc lt The nhj cc i on st be ser before em li of th i spccilie fr wmpliance or It 1ys afte tile bpoena i sen ed If Jil ob jtcli l1 i 1udt the folk1w i rnle ppl i At any time on nm ice co the co rnm:rn dc cls on he se ing pany ma ove he co11 1l iw the di trict where cn i li a i 11ir cd fr 1r i ord i mpe ling productivn or ins ec ion ii l1 t:s a ct 1a be rc4u i n:d on ire ed i th order 1d li unJ mu st pro1e i on who i ncitlicr pmiy no pa ol1kc1 from i gn ifi an pen ult ntt from comp li nc Q1rnslti11g or Mot!ij j-i Subpuem When Requ ired On timdy mo i the co1 th di st rict i re npli an t:c i require quash or modify a suhpoc nn th a i fail nllow reawnable tl1i1 con1ply ii eq uire a t!lSO ll Lo rnmp be yon Ille g.n 1p hica i i1i sp ecified i.n Ruk i quirc fsc:lnsu fp i il egC or other prnkc cr i i11v x.:c i or wai ver rpli es or i jeoc a pcrnm undu burden fihtn Permirred prn ed a pt 267son wlJjccl to i ntlecrerl ubp oe a til un li th i ic1 co1pl i ce i m:n mmion sh or odi ne nn i it requires i di osi a lrudc ern:l ur otht:r rn1u i 11li at c,et1 rd dt Clop1rn:nl or ornmcrci a i fo 1m ation ii i clo in unrctainQrl c-x ert opinion or in ro nna inn lhat doc nol ile,n pecif i OClt rreMc i i pute a11d result fro 1h xpe rt ud tl1 rcqw tl by pllf Spe i11g o11dit i1S lr er1u 1/iw ln he circurn,tuncc described in llulc 4S the ourt ma instead ot qua sh in od i fyir1g subpoena.o der i rp cara cc rn Juclio under spe c.i i co ndit i on if th erving pn1 i ws sl:ll tial ie fo1 th te st imon nr nmtc i-i I th ea nn ot otherwise cr i d1ou1 u11tl uc lnm.lsh i w1d ii su re t.ha lhc llbpoc11acd person will be c:i so ably compensated D1i in Rc pon i11g ton uhpol;un I Protl11ci11g Docuimmts or ectro ni Stored lflf rm11tio11 Thes proc dure a pl prnduci11g dnc ument nr el ec ronically smred i11fonnatit1 A Doc1m A p1 un rc:,p ntling I bpocn lt prod11w ducu1 ust prod11 ce a tl icy me pt i lhe ordin ry cour;,c or b11,incs us rgani ze lal cl th cOlres pc nd ro he 1t eg ie the lemand ll Prll/11 fi imtlucmg l:le 1rm11caih Sto red h1 nrmmio11 Nol Speti i a bpo nn ocs sp ci a form for p1nd11 i11g clec nicly cd i11fom i o1t lhs ng mu pmdu ci it in form m1 i which i i ordi nar i i inL i or in eas onabl us ib i fon or fo nn I mnfcal/v Srn ri Jrji rmo1in11 lr1duNd In he pe on ros nee not pro d11t th same clcclronica1 sto red i nfo rmmi on in mor an on form clf.1siblt1 Elo!Ctronica/lJ wr cd 11fi.Jllm11ion r,on cspu 1ding need not prvvick discovc ofdcctron ical ly to rcd infunrn11 i li sou rc t:s lu 1i he pe so identi lie a rea onabl accessible beca se of 1rh1e bur den or cost Or i on to om 1p i sco or fo pmrenivc 1lltler th pe rSc re po nci in must show tho thi in fo rma i on i ot rt 1m hly ac iblc b,:cau JnJ11 burden or o,I i-tliu sho ini is mHdc the court may non.othch:ss er discovery from uch so urc if th rc tin party mv ond on idcring the i 1ita inn ltJ uk 6/bJ The lOlffl i spec if collditiom tor the di ov limin rivilef lt otectio11 A fo rm aIio rir/1/Jeld A pc wit.hhn dinf uhpoe11 ed i nfo1rntion unrkr i 1h a i i p1 il ge ubj ec pro1 ee 1i us rri al prep,1rari ll erial 1ll il exp ly 11ml ih 1rn und ii dcs1:ribc th natur u1 1h wirhheld d,1c1m co mmunication or g,i blc lh i gs in 1,:inn that wirhrnn revea li ng infomrn i ri it i vileged or prntecte I will en::i bl th p::i ies a se!iS hr laim Prudu rd lfi11fo nn uLion pniJu..:t:d i cs pv11 a t1bpoc i ubjec to a cl a i privile or of pro ection 1r a prep,1ratin11 mare i 1he king the cl im ma notif an a lh:il i vr.tf he lo 1ion i lt da irn 1d th ba i for it Aire i ng i li ed a pa rt must promptl retu rn eque ster de sl oy the specitied i1 1a io tl m1y cupies iL ha rn11 sc or di lv th i nl nnution un il lhi la im rc so lYc nl t:ikc eas onable eps lo retrieve 1e im11:itio11 i th p:irty li doscd it hefrwe hcing ified a nd mny r,romptl resem th in for on under sc,tl he co for the is where c-ornplir1ce i required a Jdcm1im1liu vllhe c.h he who prvduc,t.:d ht inl imn uli ll mu prco rvc I ll i n;1lio Lm iJ he i 1in1 i resolve ontcmrt 1i CU li lI lb tfo kt wh i.:om im11 i uin:d md ul afln 11rnl i on i m:;E:1Tcd lhi s.-s uing 11rn ld in rnnlcmpt a son who nuving been cn wi withouLadcqt1:1tc c:,cusc to obey tbc ubpoe a or an onie rela rt i i Case Document Filed Page of TO JEA LUC BRGNEL EXHIBIT A DEFJNITIONS Wherever they hereafter appear lhe fol owing words and phrases have he following meanings I Agent shall mean any agent employee officer director attorney independent contractor or any other person acting or pu porting to ac at the discretion of or on beha of another Con-espondence or co mmunicat i on shall mean all vritten or verbal communications by any and all methods including without limita ion letters memoranda and or electronic mail by ich info1ation in v"11atever form is stored transmitted or recei ed and includes every manner or means of disclost transfer or exchange and every disclosure transfer or exchange i11formation whether oraily or by document or otherwise face-to-face by telephone telecopies e-mail text modem ransmission computer generated message mail perso al delivery or othe wise Defendant shall mean the defendant Ghislaine Maxwell and her emp oyees representatives or agenls Do ument shall mean all in a nd graphic matter however produced or reproduc and each and every thing from which info rmat ion can be processed ransc ibed transmitted restored recorded or memo ria LZed i any way by any means regan.lless of technology or fom Tt includes without limitation correspondence moranda notes notalions diaries papers books accounts newspaper and magazine articles advertisements pholographs videos notebooks ledgers letters telegrams cables telex messages facsim i les contracts offers agreements reports objects tangible i ngs work pape transcripts minutes repo11s and recordings of telephone or other conversa ions or communi ca i ons or of interviews Case Document Filed Page of TO JEAN LUC BRUNEL EXHlB I A or conferences or of other meetings occurrences or transactions affidavits sta emen su mmarie opinions tests experiments analysi evaluat i ons journals balance sheets income statements sta ti stical records desk ca endars appoi tment boo ks ists tabu lations sound ecordings data prot:essing inpu or output microfilms film negat iv es film ides memory sticks checks statements receipts sumn1aries computer pr i ntouts computer programs t:.xt messages mai information kept in computer ard dr iv es other computer drives of any kind computer ta pe back up CD-ROM other comp uter disks of any in teletypes Lelecopies invoit:.es works eets rint ed matter of eve ry ind and description graphic and oral records and representations of any kind and electronic writ ing and 267recordi ngs as se forth in the Fedei-al es of Ev id ence in cluding but no li mited to or ig inals or cop i es where originals are not ava i able ny document i th any marks such as in itia comm nts or notat ions of an kind of not deemed to be i dentical ith without such marks and is oduced as a separate document Where there is any questi on about whe er a tangib it othe wise desc ibed in these equests fa ll within he definition of document such tangible item sha ll be produced mployee inclu de a past or present officer director agent or servan including any atto rney associate or partner or paralegal Including means including i thout imitat i Je ffrey Ep stein include effrey P.pste in and any entities owned or con ro led by effrey Epstein any employee agent atto rn ey cons ltant or represen ta tive of effrey Epstein islaine Maxwell incl ude hi la ine Maxwell and any entities m;vned or controlled by Ghislai Maxwell a crnp oycc agent attorney co nsu lta nt or eprese nt a ive of Ghislaine Maxwell Case Document Filed Page of TO JEAN LUC BRL NEL EXHIBIT A Person i ncludes na ural persons prop 1i ernrc;,hips governmental agenc ie corporations partnerships trusts joinl ventures gro ps associations organizations or any other legal or business entity You or Your ere inafler means Jean Luc Brunel and any employee agent attorney consultant related entities or other representative of Jean Luc Brnnel I NS TR CTIONS Production of documents and items requested herein sha ll be made at lhe offict.s ofBoie Schiller Flexner LLP Lexingto Avenue New York Jew York Unless indic ated otherwise he Relev ant Period for this Reque is from Lo the present A Document should be conside ed to be with i the relevant time frame i it rei or relates to co mmunications meetings or other events or documents that occurred or were created 267within that time frame regardles of he date of creation of the re ponsive Do umenl Th i Request calls for the production of all responsive Documents in your possess io custody or control withoul regard lo the physical locat ion of such documents lf any Docum ent quested was in your possession or control but is no longer in its possession or control slate what disposition was made of said Document he reason for s11ch is pos it ion an the date of such lisposi lion for the purposes or eading interpreting constru i ng the scope these req uests the terms used shall be given their most expansive and in cJ usive in terpretat ion This i ncludes without imita ion the fo lowing a Wherever appropriate herein he singular form of a word shall be interpreted as plural and vice versa And as well as or shall be construed either disjunct iv ely or conjunct ively a necessary to bring within the scope hereo any Case Document Filed Page of TO TRAN LUC BRUNEL EXHIBIT A informa ion as defined herein which i ght otherw ise be construed to be outside the scope of thi list:overy request Any shall be unders ood include and encompass all and vice versa Wherever appropriate here in tl1e masculine form of a word shall be interpreted as fem i nine and vice versa Including shall mean i ncluding wi thout Limitation If you are unable to answer or respond fully to any document request answer or respond to the extent possible and speci the reasons for yow i nabitity to answer or respond in folL If the recipient has no documents responsive to a particu lar Reque the recip ient shall so tale Unless inst1"ucted otherwise each Request shall be cons rncd ind ependentl and not by reference to any other Request for the purpose of li mitatio The words relate re lating relates or any other derivative ereof as used herein in cl udes concerning referring to responding to relating to pe11ai ning to connected with comprising memorializing vi lem:ing commenting on egardi ng discussing showing describing reflecting analyzing or const ituting Identify means with respect to any person or any reference to tbe ident jt of any erson to provide lhe name home address telephone number business name business address business telephone number and a description of each such persons eo1mection with tl1e events in question ldentify mca11s with respect to any document or any reference to stating the identification of any document prov i de the title and date of ead ich document the name and address of the party or par ties respons ib le for the preparation of each suc document the name and address of the pa rty who requested or requir the preparation and on whose behalf it Case Document Filed Page of TO JEAN LUC BRUNEL F.XITTBJT A was prepared the name and address the rec i ient or recipients lo each such doc..:umenl and lhe present location of any and a ll copies of each such docume nt an tl1e names and addresses of a ll persons who have custody or control of each suc document or copies thereof 1n producing Documents i the rig inal of an Docurnen cannot be localed a copy shall be produced i lieu thereof and shall be egible and bound or stapled in the same manner as the 01iginal Any copy of a Documen that is no identical shall be l.onsidered a separate docw11ent If any requ sted Documenl ca nno be produce ct in full produce the Document to the extent possi.bic specifying each reason for your inability to produce the emainde of the Document stat ing whateve i nformation know edge or be ief which you ha ve concerning the portio not produced If any Document requested was at any one time in existence but arc no onger in existence then so sta.te specifying for each Document a the type of document the types of infi mnalion contained th ereon th date upon which it ceased to exist the circumstances under wh ich it ceased to exist the identit of all person havin knowl edge of the circumstances under vhich i ceased to ex ist and the identity of all persons ha ving no wledge or ho had know ledge of the contents thereof and ea ch in dividuals address All Documents shall be produced in the same order as they are kept or mainta i ned by you in the rdi nary courst of busine ss You are requested to produce all drafts and note whether typed handwritten or otherwise made or prepared in connection with the equested Documents whether or not se Documents attached to each other shall not be separated Case Document Filed Page of TO JEAN LLC BRUNEL EXHIBIT A Documents shall be pro duced in su ch fash io as to identify the department branch or office in whose possession Lhey ere located and where applicahle the natural person in whose possession hey we found an business address of each Oocumenrs custodia lf any Document res ponsive lo the reque st i withheld in all or part based upon any clai of priv i leg or prolection 267whet her based on statute or otherv.rise state separately for each Document i.n add ition to any other i nformation requ ested a he pecific reques which ca lls for the production he nature of the pr iv i lege claimed its date the name and ad dress of each author the name and address of each of the addresses and/or indi vi lual to whom the Document was distributed i any the title or position of its aut ho type of rnngible object e.g lette memorandum telegram chart re port recording disk etc its title and subje ct matt er withont reveal i ng the information as to vh ich the privilege is claimed i with sufficient specificity to permit the Court to make foll determina tion as to vhether the claim of privi lege is valid each and every fact or basis on which you claim such privilege and whether he document contained an attachment and to the extent you are claiming a privilege as to the att achme nt a separate og entry addressing hat privilege claim If any Document requested 11erein is v.rithheld in all or part based on a claim that such Document constitutes attorney work product provide all of Lhe i nfor ma ion desc.:ribed i_n Instruction No and al.so identify the Litigation in connection with which the Documen and the information it contains was ohtained and/or prepared Plaintiff does not seek and doc not require the production of multip le copies of iden ical Documents This Request is deemed to be continuing If after producing he se Documen ts yo obtain or become aware of any urther information Documents thi gs or informa io y?g oRz Bm C?ޢ??U NN O,??RH Wz hC?2?AH?JtY cE 4Z t?ò?f YZ ʣ??h?Ч C??v N?rV v?1Y?cR 8J?k?q W1s?H Ѝz 8?KC v?h?5)jW Z?E?ʊZG?ٸ 6T7i?E RО??3?QDj i?n??C kK/?j 7R s4 4QO K?G iL??e A i S?,S?t d??s ꛜ?ȴ g?iN V3 oVڰ?8?ѐ b?S?Ȇ lm ŭH R?v f?t ω?Z m?p v?b 篚??N PpPC 2G gV x??q?P I lu eC HJ??D?o 4L Gu sp?A A W?o0o KU;?y l3 LU e?B?נK??Lf??TE I kr ܗx _Xu Z?D hI?K cY TO??ʐ ĮΥܐ xz a ߌ?T?P;?r t?Y TI Wk CL 3?Xwb ʕH?3??"?fKqO sQ cP?w q2 x??vJ;?xD??kY R?yx yت?7 B?B b6?T h?Z I??OnF??F W?f!F Jf?!S a ŽgǤ??A ˋ?I?W??P 9ͻ z??N H?S?v?냥 m??iO wF n0 ˣ?l??B m??r ɋz Nu c8 E??M wc?r i _1 k:u?Hq?ê?A?I5h?У ҾD??u?M w?g?OW?B ji?y I)Yz?DC V?.P a nL m?ku ON?TH Z?r"U Ta??n F??oT ekB?P?MѮ?XQBa u?C LI O)IC Ρ?ޝ A?ܢ yJb??8?ޞ?q o6?o y?ڞjz?i 7?Sn i 7u?t q??t?P?k Ch?4 un?.?lLP ӄ1?O m?8v y?s d?ȅ f6?Q H?R XZy pX K?X?j õD Q?F?qD?tm Qw Ր?E H?N?Ӂ G??ʶ?Ǡ a5?g?r 2S mS?2R Z?Ŗy a Qi ir??O Sn Il wó?n ߤ9 N?D a NT??Kr 9Ľ k?j H?F r?b St wq?d?NI FC Hj c?2T W7?Ͱ)q d?f 8?uH 瓴7 tU ل?z XH QL??qY ebsAi?h?C eU ps??1?vZ A Case Document Filed Page of TO JEAN LUC BRUNEL EXHIBIT A resp sive to this Request you are requi e.d to so state by supplementing your responses and producing such addit i onal Documents lo Plaintiff DOCUJVENTS TO DE PRODUCED PURSUANT TO THlS SUBPOENA All video tapes audio rapes photographs includ i ng film negatives or film slides CDs or any otl1er print or electronic media taken hat relate to I Alan Dershowitz Virginia Robe1ts Alan ersho"vitz in lhe pre sence of Virginia Roberts and Alan Dershowitz in he presence of Jeffrey Eps tein am and any female agent or employee of Jeffrey Epstei All video tapes audio tapes hotographs including fi neg at ives or film slides CDs or any other print or electronic media taken lhat relate to I Ghis laine Maxwell Ghislaine Maxwell in the presence of Virginia Robe11s Ghislaine r-..faxwell i th presence of Jeffrey Epstein and and/or any female agent or employee of Jeffrey Eps tein and Ghislaine Maxwell in the presence of any female under the age of eighteen years old ll video tapes audio tapes photogr aphs including film negatives or fi lm slides CDs or any other print or electronic media taken hat relate to Jeffrey Epstein Je ffrey Epstei i the presence orVirginia Rober and Jeffrey Epstein in the rese nce of any female under the age of eig hteen years ld All video tapes audio tapes photographs i ud ing film negatives film slides CDs or an other print or electronic media taken that relates to Emmy Taylor Sarah Kell en or Nadia Marcinkova All documents ha re lat to Alan Dcrshow itz Virgini.:1 Roberts Alan Dershowitz in the presence of Virginia Roberts and Alan Dershowitz in he pre se nce of Je ffrey Eps tei and or any female agent or employee of Jeffre Epstein Case Document Filed Page of All docume nts relating to models or females at you employed who also worked for or i nteracted with Jeffrey pstein or Ghislaine Maxwell All documents re ating to Jeffrey Epstein from present All documents relat ing to Ghislaine Maxwell from present All documents relating to communicat i ons with any of the following indi iduah from present mmy Taylor Sarnh Kellen an Nadia Marcinkova All video tapes audio tapes pho ographs or any her prinL or electronic media taken at a time when you were vvith effrey Epste in or Ghislaine Maxwell All video tar,es audio tapes photographs or any other print or electronic media taken at a time when you were at or nearby Jeffrey Eps te in or Ghislaine Maxwells residences hotel rooms/suites automobiles or aircraft All documents rdati ng lo your travel from the period of when that travel vas either with Ghislaine Maxwell or Je fi.-ey Epstein or to meet Ghislaine Maxwell or Jeffrey Epstein inc lud ing but not limited to comrnetcial flightc helic pter pa ssport reco rd records indicating passengers traveling with you hotel records and credit card receipts All documents relating to payments made from Jeffrey Ep st ein Ghislaine Maxv ell or any related entity to you from pre sent All documents i-elating to or describing any work you perfo rmed wi th Jeffrey Epstein Ghislaine Maxwell OJ any affiliated entity from All documents rela ing to any credit cards used that 1.rere paid for by Jeffrey Epstein Ghis la ine Maxvvcll or any da ted en it from present All telephone records associated with you including cell phone records from pr esent that show any communicalions with either Jeffre Epstei or Ghislaine Maxwell Case Document Filed Page of All documents relating to calendars SL:hedules or appointments for you from that relate to visits with or communications wilh either Jeffrey Epstein or Ghislaine Maxwell All documents identifying any individuals to whom Virginia Robe1is provided a massage All documents relating to any employee lists or records assoL:iated wilh you Jeffrey Epstein Ghislaine Maxwell or any related ent i ty Uni-3te7d-3 S-3tat6e4s Distr5ic-7t C-4ou-3r4t S-3ou-3ther7n-3 Distr6ict5 of-6 Yor6k-3 Virg13ini-3a4 9Giuff6r-6e4 P-3lainti-3ff6 cv Ghisl-2a4ine Ma5x-9we6ll-3 De6fe7nd-9a4nt T-2AK10IN-8G VI-8DEO-2T-2AP13E-2D DEP10OS-5IT-3ION OF9 JEA-10N LUC3 B-2RU4NEL NOT-2ICE T-4HAT pursua6nt t-3o t8he4 sub poe4na4 ser6v-9e4d c-5ounse3l the unde4rsig10n-9e4d c4ouns-10e4l pr3o-9vides thi-2s Noti-2c4e4 of ak i-11ng the id-11e4otape6d e4pos-10it-3ion the be6low na4med indivi-3dua4l on t-3he4 da4te a6nd hour3 indi-3c-5a4ted NA4M4E-2 9B7run-6e4l AN4D TIME J-10une4 a4t a4.m L-2OCATIO-3N B7oies S-2c4hil-3ler5 F6lex-7ne4r,-6 9L21e4x-9ing8ton Av-9e4nue Ne6w Y4or3k 9NY4 The5 videota4pe4d d-9e4posi-2ti-3on will-3 be4 take6n upon or3a4l 11e4x-9a4mi-3na4ti-3on be4for6e4 Ma-6gna4 S-3e4rvic5e4s or other5 no-9tar-4y20 publi-3c4 9a4utho riz-4e4d law4 to t-3a4ke4 de4posi-2ti-3ons The4 ora7l ex-7a4mi-3na4ti-3on The5 video ope6r-6a4tor sha4ll-3 9be4 prov3ided 9Le5ga4l S-5e4rvic5e4s This-2 d-9e4posi-2ti-3on is 2be4ing8 take6n for6 the pu-7rpose6 of 6discove5r-16y20 f3or3 a4t or f6or3 such3 othe-7r pur6pos-10e4s as pe4rmitt-4e4d unde4r the5 r3ules o-8f this C-4ourt Case Document Filed Page of Da6ted B7O-7I13ES F-3L11EX-6NER 9LL22P S-3ig8rid Mc4C-2a-5wle-5y S-3ig8rid Pro Vic-5e4 Mer6e4dit-3h S-3c4hult-3z-5 H5a4c4 Vic-5e4 B7oies S-2c4hil-3ler5 F6lex-7ne4r 6LL12P Ola4s 10B7lvd S-5uit-3e4 F6t 11L11a4ude-5rda7le Da6vid B5oies B7oies S-2c4hil-3ler5 F6lex-7ne4r 6LL12P Main S-2tre5e4t Ar5monk NY Edw3a4rds 6Ha6c4 Vic-5e4 F6ARMER-3 J-10AF8F6E EDW-2ARDS-2 F-3I23S-3TOS 9L11EHRMAN3 Nor5th Andr3e4ws Ave-3nue4 S-3uit-3e4 F6or3t 11L11a4ud-9e4rda7le 7F6lorida3 P-3a4ul C-2a4ssell P-2ro H5a4c4 9Vic4e4 Quinne-5y30 of Unive4rsit-11y20 o-9f U5tah Unive4rsit-11y20 S-3t UT This 39busi-2ne4ss 41a-5ddre7ss 41is 42pr3ovided 47for6 39id-11e4nti-3fic5a4ti-3on 39a4nd 49c4or3r-6e4spo-10nde4nc4e4 39pu-9rpose6s a4nd 49is 52not 51int-3e4nd-9e4d 49to 49inst-4it-3uti-3ona4l 51e4ndorse-3ment 59the 57Unive4rsit-21y20 49thi-3s 50pr3ivate-5 re7pr3e4s-10e4ntation Case Document Filed Page of CERTI-2F11ICA3T-2E-2 S-3E-2RV4ICE I4 H-2ER4EBY4 C3ER4TI4F-3Y on t7he-3 23rd doc-3um7e-3nt-2 OT13ICE 5OF AK4ING I-13DEOTA15P-16ED EP-19OSI11T11ION4 2OF EA13N UC RUN4E-15L c-3ouns4e-3l-2 of10 re-3c-3or10d R-2obe4rt Ha7ntm-3a4n Esq Ha6ntm-3a4n 9Assoc4iate4s Ave6nue4 of th-8e4 Ame-5ric5a4s th F6loor Ne6w Y4or3k 9NY4 Email:-2 rha7ntm-3a4n ha5ntm-3a4nlaw4.c4om A M-8e4nnin-11g10e4r Esq HA4DD4ON4 MORG-9AN4 F-3OREMAN3 Ea5st th Ave6nue De6nve4r Color-8a4do Email:-2 lm-3e4nning8e4r 4hmf-8law4.c4om Email:-2 jpag12li-3uc4a4 hmfl-9a-5w.c6om S-3ig8rid McCa4wle-5y S-3ig8rid McCa4wle-15y Case Document Filed Page of Case Document Filed Page of Case Document Filed Page of Case Document Filed Page of AO Rev Subpoena to Testity at a Deposition in a Civil Action To UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT Virginia Giuffre Plaintiff Ghislain Maxwell Defendant for the Southern District of New York Civil Action No SUBPOENA TO TESTIFY AT A DEPOSITION IN A CIVIL ACTION Jean Luc Brunel c/o Robert Hantman Esq Hantman Associates Avenue of the Americas 4th Floor New York NY Name of rson to whom this subpoena is directed I Testimony YOU ARE COMMANDED to appear at tlte time date and place set forth below to testify at a deposition to be taken in this civil action If you are an organization you must designate one or more officers directors or managing agents or designate other persons who consent to testify on your behalf about the following matters or those set forth in an attachment Gi-es Schiller Flexner LL Place Lexington Ave 7th Floor Date and Time New York NY June at a.m The deposition will be recorded by this method og a a id ra Production You or your representatives must also bring with you to the deposition the following documents electronically stored information or objects and must permit inspection copying testing or sampling of the material The following provisions offed Civ are attached Rule relating to the place of compliance Rule relating to your protection as a person subject to a subpoena and Rule and relating to your duty to respond to this subpoena and the potential consequences of not doing so Date CLERK OF COURT OR Signature of Clerk or puty Clerk The name address e-mail address and telephone number of the attorney representing name of part Virgina Gi Sigrid Mccawley BSF LLP who issues or requests this subpoena are Las Dias Blvd Suite Ft Lauderdale FL smccawley bsfllp.com Notice to the person who issues or requests this subpoena If this subpoena commands the production of documents electronically stored information or tangible things before trial a notice and a copy of the subpoena must be served on each party in this case before it is served on the person to whom it is directed Fed Civ a Case Document Filed Page of AO Rev Subpoena to Testif at a Deposition in a Civil Action Page Civil Action No PROOF OF SERVICE This section should not be filed with the court unless required by Fed Civ I received this subpoena for name of individual and title if any on date I served the subpoena by delivering a copy to the named individual as follows on date I returned the subpoena unexecuted because or Uniess the subpoena was issued on behaif of the United States or one of its officers or agents I have also tendered to the witness the fees for one days attendance and the mileage allowed by law in the amount of My fees are for travel and for services for a total of I declare under penalty of perjury that this information is true Date Servers signature Printed name and title Servers address Additional information regarding attempted service etc Case Document Filed Page of AO Rev Subpoena to Testify at a Deposition in a Civil Action Page Federal Rule of Civil Procedure and Effective Place of Compliance For a Trial Hearing or Deposition A subpoena may command a person to attend a trial hearing or deposition only as follows A within I miles of where the person resides is employed or regularly transacts business in person or within the state where the person resides is employed or regularly transacts business in person if the person i is a party or a partys officer or ii is commanded to attend a trial and would not incur substantial expense For Other Discovery A subpoena may command A production of documents electronically stored information or tangible things at a place within miles of where the person resides is employed or regularly transacts business in person and inspection of premises at the premises to be inspected Protecting a Person Subject to a Subpoena Enforcement A1 oidi11g Undue Burden or Expense Sanctions A party or attorney responsible for issuing and serving a subpoena must take reasonable steps to avoid imposing undue burden or expense on a 265e,son subjed to the subpoena The court for the district where compliance is required must enforce this duty and impose an appropriate sanction-which may include lost earnings and reasonable attorneys fees-on a party or attorney who fails to comply Commuml to Produce Materials or Permit Inspection A Appearance Not Required A person commanded to produce documents electronically stored information or tangible things or to permit the inspection of premises need not appear in person at the place of production or inspection unless also commanded to appear for a deposition hearing or trial Objections A person commanded to produce documents or tangible things or to permit inspection may serve on the party or attorney designated in the subpoena a written objection to inspecting copying testing or sampling any or all of the materials or to inspecting the premises-or to producing electronically stored information in the form or forms requested The objection must be served before the earlier of the time specified for compliance or days after the subpoena is served If an objection is made the following rules apply i At any time on notice to the commanded per on the serving party may move the court for the district where compliance is required for an order compel ing production or inspection ii These acts may be required only as directed in the order and the order must protect a person who is neither a party nor a partys officer from significant expense resulting from compliance Quashing or Modifying a Subpoena A 245hen Required On timely motion the court for the district where compliance is required must quash or modify a subpoena that i fails to allow a reasonable time to comply ii requires a person to comply beyond the geographical limits specified in Rule i requires disclosure of privileged or other protected matter if no exception or waiver applies or iv subjects a person to undue burden IVhen Permitted To protect a person subject to or affoctcd by a subpoena the court for the district where compliance is required may on motion quash or modify the subpoena if it requires i disclosing a trade secret or other confidential research development or commercial information or ii disclosing an unretained experts opinion or information that does not describe specific occurrences in dispute and results from the experts study that was not requested by a party Specifying Conditions as an Alternative tn the circumstances described in Rule the court may instead of quashing or modifying a subpoena order appearance or production under specified conditions if the serving party i shows a substantial need for the testimony or material that cannot be otherwise met without undue hardship and ii ensures that the subpoenaed person will be reasonably compensated Duties in Responding to a S11bpoena Producing Documents or Electronically Stored Information These procedures apply to producing documents or electronically stored information A Documents A person responding to a subpoena to produce documents must produce them as they are kept in the ordinary course of business or must organize and label lhem to correspond to the categories in the demand Form/or Producing Electronically Stored Information Not Specified If a subpo dot:s not specify a form for producing eiectronically stored information the person responding must produce it in a form or forms in which it is ordinarily maintained or in a reasonably usable form or forms Electronically Stored Information Produced in Only One Form The person responding need not produce the same electronically stored infonnation in more than one form Inaccessible Electronically Stored Information The person responding need not provide discovery of electronically stored information from sources that the person identifies as not reasonably accessible because of undue burden or cost On motion to compel discovery or for a protective order the person responding must show that the information is not reasonably accessible because of undue burden or cost If that showing is made the court may nonetheless order discovery from such sources if the requesting party shows good cau considering the limitations of Rule The court may specify conditions for the discovery Cluiming Privilege or Protection A Information Withheld A person withholding subpoenaed information under a claim that it is privileged or subject to protection as trial-preparation material must i expressly make the claim and ii describe the nature of the withheld documents communications or tangible things in a manner that without revealing information itself privileged or protected will enable the parties to assess the claim Information Produced lf information produced in response to a subpoena is subject to a claim of privilege or of protection as trial-preparation material the person making the claim may notify any party that received the information of the claim and the basis for it After being notified a party must promptly return sequester or destroy the specified information and any copies it has must not use or disclose the information until the claim is resolved must take reasonable steps to retrieve the information if the party disclosed it before being notified and may promptly present the information under seal to the court for the district where compliance is required for a determination of the claim The person who produced the information must preserve the information until the claim is resolved Contempt The court for the district where compliance is required-and also after a motion is transferred the issuing court-may hold in contempt a person who having been served fails without adequate excuse to obey the subpoena or an order related to it For access to ubpoena materials see Fed Civ a Committee Note From Brad Edwards To Laura Menninger Jeff Pagliuca Cc Smccawley BSFLLP.com cassellp law.utah.edu mschultz BSFLLP.com Subject Depositions next week Date Thursday June AM We got an email yesterday from Mr Brunels attorney saying he needs to reschedule I believe he is trying to get us new dates today or tomorrow We got a similar email from Mr Fontanellas lawyer yesterday saying tha he is also not available next week His email said he is available the week of the 27th I told him I would call him to coordinate a new date once I had spoken with you I have not heard from anyone representing Dana Burns yet I was hoping ou could tell me whether she is represented and whether next week works for her or will also need resett ing As of right now the only confirmed depo for next week is that of Mr Ri zzo Laura can you talk later this afternoon to see what we can do about a eposition schedule that makes sense for everyone going forward I figure Jeff will be flying If we dont connect today then I will try to make time to talk with him after the deposition tomorrow I understand that the hearing did not go forward this morning which is unfortunate as it gives us a little guidance where the court stands on the deposition issues Maybe you and I can talk and try to fig ure out some plan that works in the meantime Brad Sent from my iPhone Case Document Filed Page of
