198

PDF Document Uploaded Feb 1, 2026 by Unknown Updated by admin 1 views 83.41 KB
Court Records as described by folder names.
Epstein Release Interview Victim Statements Evidence Maxwell
← Back to Doe v. United States, No. 9;08-cv-80736 (S.D. Fla. 2008)
Extracted Text

Top BBox Subtype Header Type Pagination BDC CS0 cs scn TT0 Tf Tm EMC Artifact Attached Bottom BBox Subtype Footer Type Pagination BDC Td Td EMC MCID BDC TT1 Tf TD EMC MCID BDC TD Tc Tw Td UNI-3TE-5D S-6TAT-5ES-1 DI-8S-1TRI-3C-5T C-5O-4URT S-1O-4UTH-4ER-5N DI-3S-1T-5RI-8CT N2o Ci-4v JA-2NE JA-7NE DO-4E UNI-3TE-5D S-6TAT-5ES JA-2NE A-4ND J-7ANE 5DO-4E RES-1P-6O-4NS-1E I-3N TO I-3NTER-5VE-5NO-4RS-1 TO-4 S-1TAY COM-3E Jane1 D3oe1 2and 2Jan6e D3oe1 1r-1ef4er4r-1ed 1as vi5ct-1i-1m9s 5by a-1nd t-2hr-2ough und5e-1r-2s-1i-2gne-1d t-2o r-2e-1s4pond i-2n oppos-1i-2t-2i-2on In7te1rve3no9rs1 5M1ot2ion 4f5or2 S3ta1y 2P3e1ndi4n7g-3 T1he-1 Jef4f4r-1ey 1E2ps1t-1e i-1n 1and 2hi5s t4eam9 de1f4e-5ns1e l-1aw3ye1r4s r-1ef4er-1r-1ed6 1coll-1e5ct-1i-1v6el-1y 1as ha-1ve4 of3 t-2he4 r3e-1qui-2r3i-2ng5 o5f3 c-1onne4c-1t-2e-1d ne-1got-2i-2a4t-2i3ons-1 on of re1la1t5ing 4to c1rim10e1s1 he3 c6o-3m5m10itte v5i3c-1t i D2E1 pe-1ndi-2ng a-1n int2e6rloc3u7tor7y appe2al4 E1l3e-1ve-1nt3h m8ot-2i-2on s-1houl-2d f3or3 t3w2o s-1uc4h a-1n 5on a-1ny ou5l3d be1 ba1sel4ess a-1nd t-2hus-1 c-1a-1nnot3 a 2of5 suc1cess on m9er-1i4t-1s and f3or-2 pe-1ndi-2ng I CA-5NNO-9T AN-5 I-3NT-5ERLO-4C-5UT-5O-4RY AP-6P-6EAL-5 CO-4URT 5DI-3S-1CO-4VE-5RY E2ps1t-1ei-1n6 5ha1s aske C7our-2t-2 f3or-2 s4t3a-1y D2E1 T2hi5s r4ai-1s5es t-1he6 of3 how2 w2oul-2d ove-1r-2 a-1n Case Document Entered on FLSD Docket Page of Top BBox Subtype Header Type Pagination BDC CS0 cs scn TT0 Tf Tm EMC Artifact Attached Bottom BBox Subtype Footer Type Pagination BDC Td Td EMC MCID BDC Tw TD doe-1s4 not-2 on w2hi-2c-1h di-2s-1c re6tion 4to7 c5i-1vil4 case5s w3he1r-1e 1i-1m9m9ediat-1e app7eal-1 t-1he1 orde1r4 m10a1te1ria1lly7 a6dva5nc3e1 th7e1 5ul2tim10a1te1 t5e1r5m10ina3tion 4of7 the3 l5i i-2ga-1t3i-2on A T3h2e S2u2p2re-5m-1e C3ou3rt-1 5R3ecen2t-1 D3eci4si-1on3 M-1oh6aw2k T4h3at2 A-1ttor3n3e1y P3r1ivi2l5e1ge3 R4u3lin3g ar3e1 5N4ot2 I1mme1d8iat2e6ly A6p3p3e1al2ab5le1 L-1i-5mit-5s D3oc1t-1ri-1n2e t-2o N2on L4itiga9n3ts1 in3 a C6as3e I-1ns1t4ead 7E2ps1t-1ei-1n 6cl-1a5i4m9s he1 i4s a4n u5nde-1r-2 P2erl-1m3a6n 1v St-2at-2e-1s E2ps1t-1ei4n6 of8 a-1n5d by non pa3rti5e1s1 to 2the3 5li5tiga8tion pa1r-1adigm10at-1i4c exa1m9ples 5of5 ci-1r-1cum10st-1anc1es w3hi5ch 1i-1n6t-1er4l-1oc1ut5ory 1appe7al-1s5 5ar-1e D2E1 at-1 a-1nd5 hi-2s4 of3 how2e-1ve-1r-2 r4ecen6t4 f3r-2om3 C2our-2t-2 w2hi-2c-1h not-2 C4ont4ra1ry 2to 7E3ps3te1in7 c1l5a1im10 tha3t pr2ivi2le1ge3 l5it5iga8tion 4is1 a1 pa3r5a1di2gm12a1tic1 e1xa3m10pl2e1 w2he-1n a-1ppe-1a-1l pr-2ope-1r t-2he4 C-3ou ha-1s4 5a-1nd c-1on5c-1l-2ude4d I-2n M-2ohaw2k-1 C2ar-1pe-1nt-2e-1r a-1n opi-2ni-2on appe2ar-1s w3he6n 1pe1r-1f4or-5m9i-1ng 2ba1si-1c r-1ese5ar-1ch 1on 2t-1his 5i-1ssue1 C4ou-1rt a1f5f5irm10e1d-3 the3 E3le1ve3nt2h C4irc1ui7t a1nd 4re1je6c1te1d 2a by a-1n of3 de4nyi-2ng a-1n a4t3t-2or-2ne-1y c1l5ie1nt7 pr2ivi7le1ge8 c6la1im10 M-2ohaw2k-1 e1xpl4a1in7e1d 2tha8t 5p7e1r-5m10ittin7g7 i-1ecem9eal-1 1p6r-1ej-1udgm12ent appe2al-1s 6unde3r-1m9i-1ne1s ef4f4i-1ci-1ent adm10i-1nist-1r-1a5t-1i-1on 7and 7enc1r oa1ch6es5 upon o5f3 j-2udge4s-1 5w2ho pl-2a-1y i-2n m8a-1na-1gi-2ng ongoi-2ng t-2ha E1ps4t-2e-1i3n doe-1s-1 not-2 on he-1 do5e-1s4 not3 w3ant t-1he1 ex6pa1ns1i-1ve1 d6i-1sc5ove2r-1y w3oul1d 1f4oll-1ow4 cha1r-1ac5t-1er4i-1zi-1ng 7t-1his 5cases a5s a ca5se5,6 as w3el4l-1 as5 t4he1 of3 hi3s-1 w4a1s1ting 6int7e1rlo7c1ut2o7ry a-1ppe-1a w2oul3d of3 Case Document Entered on FLSD Docket Page of Top BBox Subtype Header Type Pagination BDC CS0 cs scn TT0 Tf Tm EMC Artifact Attached Bottom BBox Subtype Footer Type Pagination BDC Td Td EMC MCID BDC Tw TD I-2d quot3a-1t-2i-2ons-1 M-2ohaw7k not-2e-1d r-2ul3i-2ngs-1 not-2 a-1nd t-2hus-1 5not-2 a-1ppe-1a4l-2a4bl-2e I M-2oh spe1ci-1f4i-1ca5l-1l-1y he-4l-6d at4t-1o6r-1ne1y c6lie1n7t5 pr2ivi7le1g t-2o be-1 5no t-2ha-1n ot-2he4r3 r-2ul-2i-2ngs our-2 pos4t j-2udgm8e-1nt-2 s-1uf3f3i-2c t5o 2pr2ot2e6c1t 5the8 righ9ts1 of7 l5it5iga3nt2s6 a1nd 9a6s1s1ur2e1 5the3 v7it5a1li5ty 2of7 the8 a1tto7rne3y c6lie6nt2 pr2iv7ile1g7e I-2d R4a1the3r th7a1n 7c1ite1 5thi2s6 re1c6e1nt2 2c1ont9rol7l5ing 4de3c1i5s1ion9 2E3ps3te1in7 r5e1lie6s1 on P1e-1r4l-2m2an St-2at-2e-1s gr-2oun5ds-1 f3or-2 a-1n in7te1r5loc3ut2o7ry appe2al-1.6 O3f4 cour1se 6app7el-1l-1a5t-1e 5cour1t4 jur2is1d7ic6tion 4is1 5typ9ic1a6lly 2c1onf9ine3d 3to judg11m10e1nt2s1 5of7 5t he-1 re1c6ogni6z1e1d n7a1rrow6 e1xc3e1p7tion 4to 2the3 f10ina3l judgm16e1nt2 rul2e1 in 2s6it5ua3tions5 w4he8re1 a1 di2s1t5ric6t de4ni-2e-1d m8ot-2i-2on t-2o qua-1s-1h gr-2a-1nd j-2ur-2y 5s-1ubpoe-1na-1 a d6i-1si-1nt5er-1e5st-1ed thi2rd 2pa8rty,9 non li5tiga3n7t,7 le1a1vi2ng 4t he-1 t-2o r-1em9ed-4y P2erl-1m3an w4ith M3ohaw2k-1 P2erl-1m3an ha1s al-1so be2en 6de1scr-1i-1b6ed a1s5 223D3el-1phi1c b6y no l2ess an 6author6i-1t-1y th6a5n J1udge3 S6e5e I-1n r1e Se1a6l-1e5d C4as1e W4L1 at-1 D.3C t-2o Pe r-1l3m2an e-1xpa-1ns-1i3ve-1l-2y Nat-6 Supe-1r-1 5Spuds-1 v4 A3s t-1he1 S2eve1nt5h h6as re1c6e1nt2ly7 M-2ohaw2k-1 cal4l-1s P6e-1r-1l3m2an a-1nd 5t-2he or2de3r 5is1 d7ire6c1te1d 2a1g7a1ins8t5 a1 l5itig7a1nt2 o7r a1 t5hi2rd7 pa3r5ty 4a1n 2a1pp9e1a6l f5rom12 the3 f5ina3l de3c6is1ion9 w4ill 5a1ll ow-7 re1vi2e1w4 of7 5th7e1 di2s6tr5ic1t5 c1o7ur2t s6 ru7ling W-1i-1l4son O3 ac-1c-1or-1d H2ol-2t O3rst-1ed 1v of D3i-1ck5son M-2ohaw2k-6 ha1s5 al-1t4er-1ed 5l-1ega1l4 l-1ands7c5ape1 r-1e5l-1at4ed 1t4o 1coll4at-1e5r-1al-1 5appe2al-1s5 of5 discove2r-1y6 ord6er-1s adve7r-1s5e5 to 2the3 a1tto7rn7e1y a-1nd t-2he4 of3 f3or-2 r-1ec e-6nt c1ou9rt of7 a1ppe5a1l5s1 a1ut2hor9it5ie1s6 ot2he3r c1irc1u7its1 th7e1 E3le1ve3nt7h7 Case Document Entered on FLSD Docket Page of Top BBox Subtype Header Type Pagination BDC CS0 cs scn TT0 Tf Tm EMC Artifact Attached Bottom BBox Subtype Footer Type Pagination BDC Td Td EMC MCID BDC Tw TD not-2 P2erl-1m3an r-1ecent5l-1y O3nly 1w3he1n pe1r-1son 2w3ho 2asser-1t-1s a p6r-1i-1vi5l-1ege1 i-1s a non li5tiga3n7t 5w4ill a1n7 a1pp9e1a1l f5rom12 the3 f5ina3l d7e1c1i5s1ion 4be3 5ina8de3qua5te Wils1on,11 Hol-6t O3rst-1ea6d In 2light4 of7 th7e1s1e1 l-1at4est E1ps4t3e-1i-2n c-1a-1nnot-2 of3 a-1n he-1 i-6s a1 l5i5tiga8nt2 in7 th7is1 c6a1s6e1 If5 he8 is6 a6 l5it5iga3nt2,7 the8n7 he3 c6a1n 2s6im10p-3ly 2w4a1i5t 5(like8 e6ve3ry 2o7the3r5 l5itig7a1nt2 t-2o a4n e-1ous4 or3de-1r-2 5a-1ny on f3r-2om8 a-1n j-2udg5m8e-1nt hi-2m pr-2e-1vi-2ous ly f5il5i5ng 5m10ot2ion 4f5or2 lim10ite1d 2int2e1rve3n7tion in t-1his case5 t-2he4 see D2E1 gr-2a-1nt3i-2n5g D2E1 2E3ps3te1in 7is1 a6 lit5iga3n7t in t4his cas5e an-4d c-1a-1nnot-2 a-1n 5a-1ppe4a-1l now ha-1s4 a4nnounc-1e-1d he4 seek t-7o f3ur-2t-2he4r3 i-2n s-1houl-2d 5a-1ny be-1 by t-2o s-1e4e4k w2oul-2d hi-7m D2E1 c1l5a1im10ing 4tha3t5 E3ps3te6in 7ha3s1 a1n 2231in7te6re1s1t in7 th7e6 non pros1ecu6t-1i-1on 2agreem9ent 5and7 w2oul-2d la6te1r5 be1com10e t-1he1 C3our1t-1 w3er-1e t-1o T3h2e C3ou3rt-1 D3i-1scove2ry 6O-1rd2er R3eq2u2i-1ri-1n2g th2e S2t-1at5es t-1o P3r ert-1ain2 P2l-1e5a A4gr1eem-1e5n2t-1 C3or1resp2on3d2en2ce i-1s 5N3ot Im-1m-1ed7i-1ate5l-1y A4p2p2ealab3l-1e Un d2er P2erl-1m-1an A3s a r-1esu6l-1t4 of5 his curr-1e5nt pos2t-1ur5e i n6 t-1his c5ase E7ps1t-1ei-1n can6 a-1ppe-1a a-1ny pr3i-2vi3l3e-1ge-1 r-2ul3i-2ng hi-2m3 at-1 t-1he1 conc2l-1us1i-1on 2of5 case T1he4 a-1c-1c4or-2di-2ngl-2y l3a-1c4k t-2o a-1ny f3r-2om8 unde4r-2 M-2ohaw2k E1ve-1n f4or s5o-4m9e r-1eason E2ps1t-1ei-1n c-1oul3d not-2 a4n t3he-1 of3 t-1he1 cas5e w4oul4d7 s1til5l not4 a6ll5ow6 E3ps3te1in 7to 2ta1ke3 a4n appe2al-1 f4or m4ult-1i-1p6l-1e r4easo6ns1 T3he3 vi2c1t5im5s1 re1s1e6rve3 th7e6ir r5ight4 5to c3h7a1lle1ng9e1 a1ny 9s1uc3h be5la6te1d7 int2e6rve3nt7ion9 Case Document Entered on FLSD Docket Page of Top BBox Subtype Header Type Pagination BDC CS0 cs scn TT0 Tf Tm EMC Artifact Attached Bottom BBox Subtype Footer Type Pagination BDC Td Td EMC MCID BDC TT1 Tf TD Tc Tw Td E8p3s1te1in3 i5s1 N4ot2 a P5r1iv7ile1ge3 5Hol2d3e6r1 T3he3 f5irs1t hu9rdl2e1 h6at-1 E2p6st-1ei-1n 1c5annot7 cl-1ear-1 t-1he1 5f4act-1 t-2o of3 not3 or-2 i4ssue1s G2r-1and P1r-1oc-1e4e4di-2ngs P2erl-1m3an of3 a1tto7rne3y c6lie6nt2 pr2iv7ile1g7e1 c1la1im10 E2ps1t-1ei-1n not-2 s4e-1e-1ki-2ng t-2o a-1n of3 i-1s trul2y7 a pr6i-1vi4l4ege1 i-1ssu6e h7e1 f5i5rs1t pu9rpor4t5s1 5to 2a1ppe5a6l a1n7 is1s1ue3 5re1ga8r5di2ng 4the8 a1pp9lic1a1b7il5ity 2of2 of3 of3 w2hi-2c4h so-4m9e plea disc5us1si-1ons2 adm10i-1ssi-1ble in 2c1e1r5ta1in 7li5m10ite1d 2s1itua3t5i5on Se1e F1e-1d R2 E1vi-2d 5e-1vi3de-1nc-1e of3 f3ol-2l-2ow2i-2ng not-2 T1hus-1 doe-1s-1 not-2 pur-2por-2t-2 t-2o it 5on9ly 2pr2ot2e1c6ts1 a1ga8ins3t the8ir int7roduc7t5ion 1in7to ev5i-1de1nc1e in 2l5im10ite1d 2s1i5tua3t5ions5 5In7 t-2a-1ki-2ng of3 a-1n go5ve-1r-2ni-2ng of-2 e-1vi-2de-1nc4e of-3 fa-4c-4t ob5vi-2ous-1l-2y t-2he4 5of3 P2erl4m3an St-2at3e4s-1 C2opar-1 C2o how-3 P2erl-1m3an doc-1t onl-2y t-2o w8he1r-1e a pa1r-1t-1y 1ha1s a1 jus3ti5c1ia1b7le6 int2e1r5e1s1t in pr-2e-1ve-1nt3i-2ng a4 discl-1os1u6re of-2 doc-1u-5m8e-1nt-2s E3ps3te1in 7a1ls1o7 pur4por4t5s1 to 7a1ppe5a1l 5a1n 2is6s1ue3 of7 w4he3the3r th7is1 C4ou9rt e6rre1d 7in 2f5a6iling 9to i-2nve4nt a br-2a-1nd ne-1w2 f3or i-2n of3 B2ut-2 s-1uc4h5 a spe1cula5t-1i-1v6e cl-1ai-1m9 out1si-1de1 5r-1each 1of5 t-1he6 P2erl-1m3an P2erl4m3an t-2o s-1om8e-1one-6 w2ho hol-2ds no5t-2 s-1om8e-1one-1 w-3ho a-1r-2gui-2n5g f3or-2 ne-1w2 S6ee I-1n 1re Se1al e-1d C2as-1e at-1 P2erl-1m8an a pr3iv6ile1g7e hol-2de-1r to 2a6ppe5a1l a6 di2s6c6los3ur2e6 or2de8r5 di2re6c1te1d7 a1t5 a1 di2s6int2e6re6s1te1d 7thi2rd7 p7a1rty adde2d ar-1e aw3ar4e o6f4 no 2case 1(a5nd 2E2ps1t-1ei-1n non8e i n5 w2hi-2c-1h a-1n Case Document Entered on FLSD Docket Page of Top BBox Subtype Header Type Pagination BDC CS0 cs scn TT0 Tf Tm EMC Artifact Attached Bottom BBox Subtype Footer Type Pagination BDC Td Td EMC MCID BDC TD und5e-1r-2 P1e-1r4l-2m2an by pa4r-2t-2y 5w2ho t3o creat5e a4 de-1f3e-1nd one I-1n 1sum10 seek6s 1t4ake1 an6 i4nter4l-1oc1uto6r-1y6 appe2a5l-1 of5 5an 1evid6enti4a5r-1y 1i-1s5sue1 5an6d pr-2i-2vi3l-2e-1ge cr-1e5at-1i-1on 2i-1ssue1 1n e1ithe8r of7 w4hi2c1h f7a1ll w4i5t5hi2n t2he3 na8rro7w4 E4p3s1te1in3 I6s1 N4ot2 C4h3al2le1n3gi2n3g a G-3r3an-1d Ju-1r-2y S-5ubpoe-3na A3s t-1he1 C3our1t-1 i-1s aw3ar-1e 1t4his i-1s a case5 brought3 by vict-1i4m9s-5 t-1o 1enf5or-5ce cr-1i-1m9e vict-1i-1m9s right4s6 unde12r5 the8 C4rim10e1 V4ic1tim10s1 R4i5ght4s1 5T3hi2s1 ki nd7 o6f4 case no7t-1 sub7j-1ect4 P2erl-1m3an a-1ppl-2i3e i-2n i-2nvol-2vi-2n5g gr-2a-1nd s-1ubpoe-1na-1s-1 F1or-2 E2l-1eve1nth cases 5discus1s5i-1ng P2erl-1m3an ove4r-2 t3he-1 ha-1ve4 i-2nvo5l-2ve4d gr-2a-1nd j-2ur-2y 5s-1ubpoe-1na-1s-1 I-2n G2r-1an-5d Subpoe-1nas I-6n F2ede1ral G3rand 3Jur1y P2roc1eedings2 C2ohe-1n I-6n G2r-1and P1r-1oc-1e-1e-1di-2ngs 5re G3rand 3Ju6ry P2roc1eed6i4ngs2 i-1n Mat2t5e1r1 of2 F8in I-2n G2r-1and P1r-1oc4e-1e-1di-2ngs T1he-1 not3 5unus-1ua-1l-2 T1e4nt-2h e1xpl4a1in7e1d 2ju7s1t la1s1t m10ont4h:2 ar-1e aw3ar-1e of5 no-3 case extends2 P2erl-1m3an be-1yond c-1r im10ina3l gr-2a-1nd j-2ur-2y 5t3o do s-1o St3at-2e-1s C2opa5r-1 C2o May6 5(int2e6rn7a1l quot11a1t5ion9 om12itte1d 5(e1m10pha5s1is1 in 2or2ig7ina3l5 no f3or-2 e-1xt-2e4ndi-2ng P2erl-1m3an t-2he4 ne-1w2 of3 c1rim5e-4 vict4i-1m9s r-1i-1ght1s case5s m5uc1h less a p6e5r-1sua1si-1v6e one T3h2e D3oc1u2m-1en2t-1s A3re Not-6 B2y a D4is1in3te1r1e6s1te6d3 T4h3ir1d3 P3ar3ty L6itigan7t 7B ut B2y a P1ar-1t-2y i3n1 Case Document Entered on FLSD Docket Page of Top BBox Subtype Header Type Pagination BDC CS0 cs scn TT0 Tf Tm EMC Artifact Attached Bottom BBox Subtype Footer Type Pagination BDC Td Td EMC MCID BDC TD Tc Tw Td Y3et-1 anot1h6er4 r-1eason7 E2ps6t-1ei-1n6 cannot7 t-1ake6 an 6i-1n6t-1er4l-1oc1uto6r-1y 6appe2al4 i-1s th7a1t 5thi2s6 is6 n7ot2 a6 ha-1s4 i-2n t-2he4 he4l-2d b5y G2ove-1r-2nm3e-1nt It is1 ge3n7e1ra6l5ly 2a1gr2e1e1d 7th7a1t rul2e1 on5l-2y w2he-1n pr3i-2v i-1l4ege1 hol1d6er-1 i-1s pow5er-1l-1ess t4o t-1he1 5m9i-1schief4 a c5our1t-1 6s discove2r-1y 1orde1r-1 5be1caus1e t-1he6 5m9at-1er-1i-1al4s i-1n que-1s-1t-2i-2on he-1l-2d by pa4r-2t-2y Hol-6t O3rst-1e5d 1v of D3i-1ckson int2e6rna3l quot6a6ti5ons5 o-3m10itte T2ha1t-1 i-1s t-1he1 case he6r-1e The not4 a1 di2s6int7e1re1s1t5e1d 2pa3rty 5to 7thi2s1 It i5s1 a1 pa8rty w4hi2c1h 2is6 5a1c1tiv7e1ly 2lit5iga3t5ing 1in7 oppos-1i-2t-2i-2o5n t3o A2c-1c-1or-2di-2ngl-2y s-1houl3d a-1ny be-1 of-2 be-1t-2w2e a-1nd t-2he-1n t-2he4 no doubt-2 poi-2nt-2 out-2 t-2o di2s1tr5ic6t c1our9t5 or2 seek r-1evi5ew3 at-1 t4he1 end of7 t-1hi5s case I-2nde-1e-1d und5e-1r-2 a-1ppa4r-2e-1nt3l3y c-1o ho5l-2de4r-2 of3 i-2n que-1s-1t-2i-2on ha4s-1 t-2o ne-1w2 f3or-2 ne-1got3i-2a4t-2i-2ons-1 w2oul-7d e-1xt-2e-1nd no5t3 c-1ouns-1e4l-2 5but-2 t-2o A3s a r-1esult-1,6 t-1he1 G3ove2r-1n6m9ent i-1s not1 223disi-1n6t-1er4est-1e5d i-1n as5ser-1t-1ed p7riv7il5e1ge but-2 i-2n w2oul-2d pos2sess 5pri-1vi5l-1ege6 t-1h6eory be1 r4ecogni2z5ed t-2o e-1ve-1n 5t-2h5ough a4nd c-1a-1nnot-2 now2 a-1n f3r-2om8 or-2de4r3 r-1el-1e5asi-1ng corr-1espon8de1nc1e Se1e by G3ove2r-1nm10ent-5 i-1n cases 1ord6e w2oul-2d5 be-1 a-1nom8a-1l-2ous-1 t-2o a-1n b5y r-2e4ga-1r-2di-2ng t-2he4 G2ove-1r-2nm8e-1nt-7 t-2a-1ki-2ng a4n P2erl-1m3a6n t-2hi3s4 r-1eason a2s Case Document Entered on FLSD Docket Page of Top BBox Subtype Header Type Pagination BDC CS0 cs scn TT0 Tf Tm EMC Artifact Attached Bottom BBox Subtype Footer Type Pagination BDC Td Td EMC MCID BDC TT1 Tf TD TT0 Tf Tc Tw Td F2or t-1he1s5e 5r-1ea5sons2 1t4he1 P2erl-1m3an doc5tr5ine8 is6 not4 a1pp9li5c1a6bl2e1 5to 2th7e1 5C4our4t o7rd7e1r on a-1nd w2oul-2d t-2o 5a-1ny T1he-1 C2our-7t-7 s-1houl-2d de-1ny on gr-2ou5nd II A S-1T-5AY 5P-1ENDI-8NG-4 AP-1P-1E-5AL Tc Tw Td E2ps1t-1ei-1n6 al-1so6 s5houl2d r4ecei-1ve6 a5 st-1ay6 pe1ndi ng7 ap6pe1al-1 b6ecaus1e5 he1 c5annot7 s5at-1i-1sf4y any of-7 f3our-2 f3or-2 obt-2a-1i-2n5i-2ng s-1uc4h 5m3ot-2i-2on a he-1 mus-5t s1h7ow6 lik7e1lihood 8tha8t he-7 w4ill pr2e6va3il on9 th7e1 5m10e1rits1 of7 th7e1 a1ppe5a6l;5 ir5re1p ar4able5 inj2ur2y7 to7 hi-8m no t-2o ot-2he-1r3 an-5d no ha4r-2m3 t-2o t-2he4 publ-2i3c-1 I-1n 1re F2ede6r5al G3rand 3Ju6ry P2roc1eed6i4ngs2 C2ohe-1n 5a-1dde-1d he-1 una-1b5l-2e t3o a-1ny one-1 of3 r-1equ7i-1r4em9ents 1t-1he1n 1his ot-2i-2on I-2n he-1 t-2o bur-2de-1n on one-1 of8 po5i-2nt a-1nd m8ot-2i-2o5n f3or-2 i4s com10plet-1el-1y6 5m9er-1i-1t-1l4ess A E4p3s1te1in3 D4oe3s1 N4ot2 Have10 a L6ik-2e1l5ih3oo9d3 Of P2revai6l-1i-1n2g on4 t-1h2e 5Meri4t-1s e-1xpl3a-1i-2ne-1d E1ps-1t3e4i-2n no5t-2 e4ve-1n be-1 t-2o m3uc-1h 5c4onvi-2nc-1e-1 o5f3 of3 F1or-2 s-1houl-2d be-1 de-1ni-2e-1d In 2a1dd9ition,11 E3ps3te6in 5c1la1im10s1 tha t4 5cor5r-1espond9enc1e 1an 1adve2r-1sar4y so-4m9eh-4ow4 223conf6i-1de1nti4a5l-1 and 223pro6t4ect-1ed f4ar f4et-1che1d.7 hi-2s4 pl-2e4a4di-2ng C2our-2t-2 or-2de4r-2 ar-1e aw3ar-1e,6 rde8rs1 di2s1c6los3u7re1 to 2thi7rd pa3rty 7lit5ig7a1nt2s1 of7 pr2iva3te1 a1nd 9c1onf9ide3nt2ia6l be4t-2w2e-1e4n 5w2ho s4e-1e-1ki-2ng a4 DE-1 Case Document Entered on FLSD Docket Page of Top BBox Subtype Header Type Pagination BDC CS0 cs scn TT0 Tf Tm EMC Artifact Attached Bottom BBox Subtype Footer Type Pagination BDC Td Td EMC MCID BDC Tw TD E2ps1t-1ei-1n 6seem4s t-1o 1ha1ve1 f4or5got1t-1en t-1w3o 1ye1a5r4s ago 3he1 t-1he1 5sam9e ba1t-1t4l-1e i-2n t-2he4 ci-1vi5l-1 cas5e f4i4l-1ed 1by 2vi5ct4i4m9s aga1i-1ns1t-1 him9 A3s t-1his C3our1t-1 5ex6plai-1ne1d6:-1 A9t the3 ou9ts1e6t,7 the3 c1ou9rt-5 obj3e-1c-1t3i3ons-1 t-2o publ-2i3c-1 of3 i-2n que2st-1i-1on prev6i-1ous2l4y 1r-1ej-1e5ct-1ed 1b6y 1Magist4r-1a5t4e Judge3 L2i-1n6ne1a J-1ohns-1on5 i-2n or-2de4r-2 i-2n a4 D2oe-1 N2o CI-4V M-3ARRA D2E1 T1hi-2s4 C2our-2t-2 t-2o not-2 ne-1w2 gr-2ound I-2nde-1e-1d a-1nyt-2hi-2ng w2oul be-1 ne-1w2 gr-2ound t-2o hol-2d by de-1f3e-1nda-1nt-2 t-2o t-2r3yi-2ng t-2o E2ps1t-1ei-1n cont1ends2 4he1 C3our1t-1 d6eci4si-1o6n 1drast4i-1ca5l-1l-1y6 r-1esha1pe6s t-1h6e l-1ands2c5ape1 5of c1rim10ina3l s1e1t5tle na-1ught3 of3 a-1nd on5 w2hi-2c-1h r-2e4a-1s-1ona4bl-2y f3or-2 m8a-1ny D2E1 A2ga-1i-2n no5t3 s-1o T1hi-2s4 n5ot-2 t-2he4 di2s1c1us3s6ions5;5 the3 C4rim10e1 5V4ic1tim10s1 R4ight4s1 A4c1t ha8s1 done7 s1o C4rim10e1 vi2c1tim10s1 a1re1 now8 e1nt2itl5e1d 2t5o w2i3t-2h a-1bou5t-2 of3 pr-2oc-1e4e-1di-2ngs-1 5i-2nc-1l3udi-2ng pl3e-1a4 E2ps1t-1ei-1n6 and 2oth6er-1 d6ef4ens1e t3o i3n5 now2 t-2ha4t3 c-1onf3e4r3 a-1bout-2 I-2nde-1e-1d r3e-1qui-2r3i-2ng s-1uc4h Se1e of3 A2t-2t-2or3ne-1y f5or2 V4ic1tim W10i-1t-1ne1ss A3s-5si-1st-1an6ce F2e5de1r-1al-1 p6r-1os1ec5utors shou8l-1d6 be1 ava1i-1l4abl5e t-1o 1conf6er4 1vic5t-1i-1m9s about2 m9aj-1or case de6ci s-1uc-1h ne-1got-2i-2a4t-2i-2ons A2nd w2he-1n de4f3e-1nda nt-2 w2or-2ks-1 t3o c1re6a1t5e1d 2right4 to7 de-1f3e-1nda-1nt c4a-1n a-1bo5ut-2 w2ha-1t3 he-1 don5e-1 I-2n Case Document Entered on FLSD Docket Page of Top BBox Subtype Header Type Pagination BDC CS0 cs scn TT0 Tf Tm EMC Artifact Attached Bottom BBox Subtype Footer Type Pagination BDC Td Td EMC MCID BDC Tw TD gove4r-2nm8e-1nt-2 how2 t-2o a-1voi-2d of-2 5a-1nd t-2he-1n t-2o be-1 t-2o hi-2de4 be-1hi-2nd ne-1bul-2ous-1 t-2o f3or-2 v5i3ol-2a-1t3i-2on of3 t-2o t-2hi-2nk on 7appe2al-1 he1 be1 ab6l4e t-1o t-1h6at4 s4o-5m8e-1how of3 of3 of3 B2ut-2 he-1 t-2o de3m10ons5tra1te6 tha3t f5a1lls1 w4ith7in7 the3 t-1ext4 of3 C2our-2t-2 he1 co6m4m4uni1cat-1i-1o6ns1 c-1ouns el-1 and 2f4ede6r4al-1 pros6ecuto6r-1s at4 i-1s5sue h7e1re1 u7ltim10a1te1l5y di-2d in of-3 a1 of3 gui-2l-2t3y by t-1o 1spe1c5i-1f4i-1c st-1at4e cour1t-1 cha1r-1ge6s t-2he-1r3e-1by r3e-1m8ovi-2ng na-1r3r-2ow2 or-2bi3t-2 of3 dur-2i3ng pl-2e-1a di-2s4c4us-1s-1i-2ons if di-8s di-2d5 not-2 re1s1ul7t in7 a1 g7ui2lty7 pl2e6a w3hi5ch i-1n6adm10i-1ssi-1ble i-1n pr-2oc4e4e-1di-2ngs-1 m8a-1ki-2ng5 unde-1r-2 D2E1 c1it5ing P1ade-1n s1ta6te1m10e1nt2s1 m10a1de3 dur4in-3g 2ne3got4ia1t5io ns1 r-1esu6l-1t-1ed 1a f4i4na1l-1 plea of3 gui-2l-2t-2y no5t3 un5de-1r-2 cert-1 d7eni5ed o5f3 ba-1s4e-1d o5n t-2hi3s4 C2our-2t-2 f3or-2 f3or-2 t-2he4 cr4eat i-2on of br-2a-1nd 5ne w2 f3or-2 of3 D2E1 hi-2s4 E1ps4t-2e-1i3n doe-1s-1 not-2hi-2n5g t-2ha-1n C2our-2t-2 a-1nd pe1r-1sua1s5i-1ve1l-1y6 r-1ej-1ec5t-1ed A3s thi2s1 C4our4t c1a6re1f5ul2ly 7e1xpl4a1in7e1d:2 C3ongr2ess h6as al-1r4eady 2a5ddr1essed c-1om8pe-1t-2i-2ng 5by evi5de1nc1e pa1ssage6 of t-1he1 plea f3ound R2 P1 5a-1nd F1e-1d E1vi-2d pr-2ohi-2b5i-2t3s adm10i-1ssi-1on 2at4 of5 a d6e5f4enda2nt 5st4at-1em9ents m9a-5de1 dur6i-1ng 2pl5ea out3 Case Document Entered on FLSD Docket Page of Top BBox Subtype Header Type Pagination BDC CS0 cs scn TT0 Tf Tm EMC Artifact Attached Bottom BBox Subtype Footer Type Pagination BDC Td Td EMC MCID BDC Tc Tw TD any 2spe1c5i-1al4 pri-1v6i-1l-1ege6 r4el-1at4i-1ng 1p6l-1ea d6i-1scus1s5i4on 2m9at-1er-1i-1al4s C2ons-1i-2de4r-2i-2ng on a-1nd publ-2i3c-1 plea ag6r-1ee5m9ents i-1n 1t-1his5 D4is1tri5c1t t-2o e-1x5pa-1nd R2ul-2e by c-1om3m3on f3or-2 D2E1 s-1u5ppor-2t-2i-2ng od5ds-1 of3 on t1he1 m9er-1i4t-1s of5 his c5l-1ai-1m9s ar-1e sl4i4m4 t-1o none4 E4p3s1te1in3 D4oe3s1 N4ot2 S3u3ffe6r1 I1r1r1e6me1d3ia7b3le1 Har8m fr6om2 D4is1c1los8u3r1e1 of2 th3e1 C3or1resp2on3d2en2ce t-1o th2e m3ot-2i-2on f3or-2 f3ounde-1r-2s-1 on he4 no5t-2 ir5re1p ar-6abl-10e inj2ur2y7 f5rom ha-1vi-2ng E1ps-1t3e4i-2n huf3f3s-1 a-1nd puf3f3s-1 a-1bout-7 of3 ba4r-2ga-1i-2n5i-2ng Se1e D2E6 B2ut-2 he-6 e-1xpl3a4i-2ns-1 how2 t-2ur-2ni-2ng ove-1r-2 t-2o f3or-2 vi2c1t5im10s1 5w4ill s1pe3c1if5ic1a6lly7 ha3rm10 hi-2m not3 e-1nou5gh f3or-2 s-1how2 he4 doe-1s-1 not3 t3he-1 vi2c1t5im10s1 to 2re1a1d 2the c-1or3r-2e4s-1ponde-1nc-1e presen6t-1 evi5de1nc1e he1 be1 i-1n6j4ured t-1he1 vict4i-1m9s r-1ead corr-1esp6onde3nc1e F1l-2or-1i-2da C2hapt-2e-1r-1 of-2 1n of-2 of-2 of-2 F1l-2a B3ecaus1e prese5nted 1no 2evid6enc1e on 5i-1ssue1 1w3e ca5nnot2 agree i-1r4r-1epa6r-1ab6l-1e i-1nju6r-1y t-2o va-1ni-2s4hi-2ng poi-2nt-2 5i3n of3 t3he-1 t-2ha4t3 of3 t-2he4 i-2n J4udge-1 J-1ohns-1o5n 5pr-2oduc-1e-1d i-2n I-2n a-1n e1f5f5o-3rt to 2pr7ove10 irre1p7a1ra1b7le6 inj2ur2y 4E8ps3te1in 2c6it5e1s6 va3rious5 a6ut2hor4i5tie6s1 a bout-2 doc-1um8e-1nt-2s-1 B2ut-2 none-1 5of3 i-2nvol-2v5e-1d 5a-1nyt-2hi-2ng Case Document Entered on FLSD Docket Page of Top BBox Subtype Header Type Pagination BDC CS0 cs scn TT0 Tf Tm EMC Artifact Attached Bottom BBox Subtype Footer Type Pagination BDC Td Td EMC MCID BDC Tc Tw TD i-1s at-1t4em9pti-1ng 1asser-1t-1 i4s 223conf6i-1de1nt5i-1al-1 di5scus1si-1ons2 no9t w4ith 2hi2s1 a1l5lie1s1 but4 w4ith7 adve2r-1sar4i-1es5 c1r5im10ina3l pr2os3e6c1ut2o7rs1 hi-2m8 t-2o gui3l-2t3y t-2o c-1ha-1r-2ge Moreove2r-1,6 t4he1 C3our1t-1 r-1ecogn8i-1z5e al4l-1 o6f4 t-1he1se ca5se5s w3er-1e old6e5r-1 case5s 1de1c5i-1de1d i-2n M-2ohaw2k T-4h M-2oha5w2k de1ci-1si on7 m14ake1s cl-1ear-1 t4ha1t-1 ev6en 1as t-2o hi-2gh5l-2y a4t-2t3or-2ne-1y cour1t4s can6 r-1em9edy i-1m9prope2r4 discl-1os1u6r-1e o6f4 pri-1vil4ege1d6 t-1he1 s5am9e w3ay 1t-1he1y 1r4em9edy 2a hos2t-1 of5 othe6r4 er-1r-1on7eous2 r3ul-2i-2ngs-1 by a-1n 5j-2udg a-1nd r-2e-1m8a-1ndi-2ng f3or-7 ne-1w2 5i3n w2hi-2c-1h protec5t-1ed m5at-1er4i-1al4s a i5t-1s f4r-1uit-1s 5ar-1e 5exc1l-1ude2d evide1nc1e.6 ha-1s4 not-2 s-1how2n he-1 i-2nj3ur-2y C2our-2t-2 m8uc-1h irre1p7a1ra1b7le1 i5nj2ur2y T4h3e1 V4ic1tim5s Wi2ll B4e1 P8r1e1ju3d3ic1e1d3 B9y a S7tay ne-1xt3 c-1ont-2e-1nds-1 not-2 be-1 by I-2n of3 m9aking 2his 5ar-1gum11ents m9ak-4es a 5ser4i-1es5 o6f4 i-1na1ccur5at-1e5 5r-1epres5enta5t-1i4ons2 about7 t-1h6e cour1s5e of5 pr-2oc-1e4e4di-2ngs-1 ove4r-2 t-2he4 of3 ke-1e-1pi-2ng5 r3e-1s-1pons4e-1 t-2he4 onl-2y r-2e-1s-1pon5d t-2o of-2 obvi-2ous-1 di-2s4t-2or3t3i-2ons-1 ha-1ve-6 5m8ove-1d f3or-2 pr-2ove-1s-1 t3he-1y do not-2 c-1or D2E1 B2ut-2 know2 C2our-2t-2 ha-1s4 f3ound j-2udgm8e-1nt-2 w2hi-2c-1h one-1 of3 seve1r-1al w7hy ne-1e-1d t-2o m8ove-6 for-8w-1a rd 2w4ith 2the3ir c1a1s6e c-1ont-2e-1nds-1 on cl-1ai-1m9s f4or ye1ar-1s D2E1 B3ut 5as t4he1 C3our1t-1 a5w3ar-1e 1m9uc1h 1of5 t-1he1 de1l-1ay6 ca5se of3 t-2he4 w2hi-2c-1h e1a6te6d 2e1f5f5or2ts1 by 4the3 vi2c6tim10s-4 Case Document Entered on FLSD Docket Page of Top BBox Subtype Header Type Pagination BDC CS0 cs scn TT0 Tf Tm EMC Artifact Attached Bottom BBox Subtype Footer Type Pagination BDC Td Td EMC MCID BDC Tc Tw TD ha1s be1en6 r-1e5ach 1any7 agr5eem9ent on t-1he6 f4ac5t-1s a5r-1e 6t-1his5 case.6 A3nd C3our6t-1 i4s5 al-1so 1aw3ar-1e o6f4 de1l-1ay 1caus6ed 1by 2r-1epe1at4ed 4m9oti-1ons2 f4i-1l-1ed 1by 2E2ps1t4ei-1n 1him9sel-1f4 i-1n ci-1vi5l-1 case,6 w2hi-2c-1h i3m3pe-1de-1d of7 the8 vi2c1t5im10s1 to r2e1s1ol2ve3 a6ll 5th7e1ir 5lit5iga3t5ion9 w4ith hi4m10 E3ps3te1in7 a1ls1o7 c1ont4e1nds10 th7a1t th7e1 2236tim10ing 4of7 tha3t5 re6li5e1f5 5tha3t th7e1 v7ic1t5im10s1 s1e1e1k7 m10a1tte s1 l5itt5le6 at-1 al4l-1 D2E1 A2ga-1i-2n not-2 no do5ubt-2 f9or pros1ecu6t-1i4ng 2him4 f4or sex 1abus2e cl-1ai-1m9s appe2ar-1s t-1o 1b6e t-1en 1ye1ar-1s E1ps-1t3e4i-2n a-1bus4e-1d 2(a4nd ot-2he4r-2 young f3r-2om8 r-2oughl-2y A3s r-1esul5t-1 E2ps1t-1ei-1n6 can 6suc6ceed 1s5t-1al4l-1i4ng a-1not-2he4r-2 t3w2o he4 w4ill ha3ve3 s1u7c1c1e1s1s1f5ul2ly 4out4 the3 c1l5oc3k on 4hi2s1 c1rim10ina3l lia1b7ili5ty A4t thi7s1 poi4nt2 2the3 5vi2c1t5im10s1 a1re-4 i-2n 5t3o pr-2os4e4c-1ut-2i-2on of3 by da-1y re1s1ol2u7tion of10 t-1he1 cas5e E2ps1t-1ei-1n 1al4so6 at-1t-1em9pts t-1o 1pre l5itig7a1te6 w4he3the3r th7e1 non pr-2os-1e4c-1ut-2i-2on c-1oul-2d be-6 r-1esci-1nd7ed 5I-1nter4est4i-1ngl1y6 do7es not1 d6i-1scu6ss C2our3t-2 r-2ul-2i3ng on5 t-2hi i4n 1w3hich car-1ef4ull-1y 6ex6plai-1ne1d6:-1 a t-1hr5esho7l-1d 1t4he1 cour1t-1 i3nds-1 C2V2R2A2 pr-2ope-1r3l-2y int2e6rpr2e6te1d 2t5o 2a1ut2hor4iz6e1 t5he3 re1s1c1i5s1s1io7n 2or2 re ope4ni-2ng of5 a pros1ecutor5i-1a5l-1 agreem9ent i-2nc-1l-2udi-2ng a4 non pros1ecu6t-1i-1on 2ag6r-1eem4ent i-2n vi-2ol3a-1t3i-2o5n of3 obl3i-2ga-1t3i-2ons-1 unde4r3 the3 s1ta6tut2e1.7 D2E1 r-2ul-2i-2ng now2 of3 by.5 G2i-2ve-1n 5r3ul-2i-2ng ha4r-2m8e-1d 5by i-2n 5a-1ny oppor-2t-2u5ni-2t-2y t-2o A2nd E2ps1t-1ei-1n 1al4so6 f4ai-1l-1s t-1o 1r-1eco6gni1ze unde3r-1 t-1he1 C3V3R3A3 vict-1i-1m9s ha1ve1 r-1i ght-7 t-2o ha-1ve-1 C2our-2t-2 up a-1nd a-1ny m3ot-2i-2on f3or-2t3hw2i-2t-2h A2n by w2oul-2d br-2i-2ng i-7ng Case Document Entered on FLSD Docket Page of Top BBox Subtype Header Type Pagination BDC CS0 cs scn TT0 Tf Tm EMC Artifact Attached Bottom BBox Subtype Footer Type Pagination BDC Td Td EMC MCID BDC Tc Tw TD thi2s1 c1a6s1e1 to re1s1ol2u7tion 2231f5or2thw6ith T1he-1 obvi-2ous-1l-2y 5w be-1 by a-1n appe2al-1 T4h3e1 P3u3b3lic1 I1n3te1r1e1s6t Wi7ll N4ot2 B4e1 S3e6r1ve3d3 B4y A6llow11in3g 3E4p3s1te1in3 to A6p3p3e1al2 a4 de4l-2a-1yi3ng t-2hr-2ough5 a4 s-1om8e-1how2 i-2n 5publ-2i-2c4 not-2hi-2ng c-1o5ul-2d be-1 f3r-2om8 rut2h A4 s1ta1y7 w4ill onl4y 2s6e6rve3 to 2de8la1y 7the3 vi2c6tim10s-4 e1f5f5or2t to 2vi2n7di2c1a1t5e1 the8ir 5right4s1 und11e1r5 the3 a1 c1le1a6r indi9c1a1tion 9tha3t 5t5he3 publ6ic1 5in7te1re1s6t is1 no9t be-1i-2ng Se1e ni-2t-2e4d A6l-2abam2a of-3 fe-4de-7r-5a a-1nd not-2 In 5tra1ns3p7a1re1nt7 e1f5f5or2t to 2t5riv7ia1l5iz6e1 w4ha3t i5s1 a6t s1t5a1ke3 5in 2t5hi2s1 im10por4ta6nt2 c1a1s6e1 re1m10a1rka3bl2y c8la1im10s1 tha3t t10he3 m15a1y 2ha3ve3 lit5tle1 i5nt2e6re1s6t a6t a1l5l in a8 di2s6put4e1 be3tw4e6e6n 2pr2iva8te1 c6iv7il-5 t-2o doc-1um8e-6nt-2s-1 D2E1 T1o know2s-1 publ11ic6 int2e6re1s6t in7 5jus3t how8 5it5 pos5s1ib7l5e1 f5or2 a1 w4e6ll c-1onne-1c4t-2e-1d 5w2ho ha-1d a-1bus4e-1d5 doz-1e-1ns-1 of y-5oung gi2rls1 t5o obt1ai-1n 1a p6l-1ea de1a5l-1 w3i-1t4h f4ede1r-1al-1 gove-1r-2nm8e-1nt-2 i-2n he-1 D2e-1nyi-2ng a4 not3 be-1gi-2n5 t-2o of8 publ-2i-2c4 a4bout-2 B2ut-2 i at-1 l-1ea5st4 5m9ove2 t-1his 5case one2 st-1e5p 1cl-1os1er-1 the3 pub11lic6 int2e6re1s1t d7e6m10a1nds5 CO-4NCL-5US-6I-3O-4N F3or2 a1ll the f3or-2e-1goi-2ng r4easons2 s-1houl3d de-1ny m8ot-2i-2on f3or-2 pr-2oduc-1t3i-2on o5f3 pe-1ndi-2n5g a-1n a-1ppe4a-1l3 t-2o E1l3e-1ve4nt-2h J-1une-1 Case Document Entered on FLSD Docket Page of Top BBox Subtype Header Type Pagination BDC CS0 cs scn TT0 Tf Tm EMC Artifact Attached Bottom BBox Subtype Footer Type Pagination BDC Td Td EMC MCID BDC Tc Tw Td R4e1s1pe3c1tf5ul2ly7 S3ub-1m10itte1d B3r-1adl5ey E2dw4ar-1ds1 E6dw2a-1r-2ds FA1R1M-2ER1 J-8A1FFE 6W3EI-8SSI-3N1G F-1I-3STO1S N2or-2t-2h A2ve-1nue-1 T1e-1l-2e-1phone-1 F3a1c1s1im10ile1 m10a1il br2a1d7 3pa3tht2oj2u7s1t5ic1e1.c3om and P2aul G3 C4assel-1l P2ro H4ac1 V2i-1ce Q2ui-2nne-1y of3 U4ni2ve3rs1i5ty o9f5 U4ta1h S1 E1 C2i3t-2y U2T1 T1e-1l-2e-1phone-1 F2acsi-1m9i-1l-1e Mai4l-1 D2oe-1 a-1nd Case Document Entered on FLSD Docket Page of Top BBox Subtype Header Type Pagination BDC CS0 cs scn TT0 Tf Tm EMC Artifact Attached Bottom BBox Subtype Footer Type Pagination BDC Td Td EMC MCID BDC TT1 Tf Tc Tw Td CER-5TI-3F-1I-3C-5ATE S-6ERVI-8CE T1he-1 f3or-2e-1goi-2ng doc-1u5m8e-1nt-2 ve-1d on Jun7e on f3ol-2l-2o5w2i-2ng us-1i-2ng t3he-1 C4our4t sys1t-1em9 D3exter-1 L2ee A Mar-1i-1e V3i4l-1l-1af4a A4s1s1is1ta1n7t A6ttor2ne3y S1 A2ve-1 F1L1 m10a1il 1us-1d5oj-2.gov m10a1il 1us-1doj-2.gov A4ttor2ne3y G2ove-1r-2n5m8e-1nt R2oy E1s-1q Jackie P2e5r-1cz5ek E4sq K2or-2ns4pa-1n S1t-2um3pf3 S1out-2h F1L1 Case Document Entered on FLSD Docket Page of
26,620 characters