UNITED STATES COURT SOUTHERN DIST-4.7RIC13.5T OF NEW Plaintiff7 Motion to Appoint Special Maste5.7r3.7 to 9Pr esid-6e Third Deposition of A ADDON ORGAN OREM-9.5AN P.C East th Ave5.1nue De5.4nver CO Case Document Filed Page of Ghislaine Ms pursua6.1nt to Rule 7of Civil Proc7edure7 9.9files this Motion to Appoint a Spec6ial Master to Pre7s.4ide ov-7.8er 5the Third D-6.6e4position of Ghislaine and states as fo-7.3llows STATEMENT CONF13.7ERRAL-6.8 The undersi-9.6g9.6ned with counsel Plaintiff who stated that not agree to the 9appointment of a master to Ms third deposition INTRODUCTION Plaintiff5.9 has deposed Def-6.1e3.7ndant for than thir-6.1tee5.7n hours of testimon-19.1y19.9 the During7.4 pre6.2vious depo-9.6sitions a issu 9.5arose includin-11.5g9.5 rep-9.5e3.3titive and duplicative questioning7.4 on a subject-9.9s outside of Court?s pre5.8vious orde6.9rs re7.3sulting8.4 the 6.7need for6 objec5.8tions to the ques-9.8t-.2ioning8 and instructions not to answer The Court 8has per5.6m-.6itted Ms to be de5.7posed a third time on limi ted subjec6.7t limited to non-duplicative ex-9.3amination for5.7 a of two hours To a-5.5void the possibilit-13.5y29.7 of another deposition of 6.9submit it in the be5.4st interest of parties to appoint a spec6.7ial master to preside 8over the deposition to pr-8.4ovide immediate ruling9.6s 10on obj-11.6ections that 9arise qu-9.6estions that are outside of scope of deposition as set forth in this Court March 8.8and 8.8Orders or other issu-9.5es that arise during11.5 the d-8.5e4.3position I THE SCOP12.2E THE DEPOSITION On November Court granted Plaintiff?-6.4s Motion to permit a third de7position of Ms concerni-8.4ng9.8 the followin-9.2g9.8 J-9.5ohanna Sjoberg10.3 Mar5.4ia and 8Annie women Case Document Filed Page of other who to pstein and eviden-8.6ce circumstanc-6e3s or reco-10.8rds at i ng to the 9massages.-16.3 Order Nov at During7.6 on 9N-7.2ovember this Court g10r-6anted Plaintiff?s 7Motion to permit this third depositi5.8on to include que5.8stioning conc5.8ernin-8g10 two 9e-7mails produced Au-7g10u0st Doc5.6 of6 Nov heari-8.2n0g10 at On November moved for5.6 onsidera6.5t-.5ion or of portions of the Novembe-7.9r-.7 Order With re7spe-5.9c4t to the third deposition of Ms the Court g9.8r-6.2anted the motion for which 9re6.6que that the Court the deposition would be limited to non duplicative questioning7.7 limited to the four 10of to in the Order 6at Sealed Order at Pursuant to Civ the Court app-9o0int a spec6.9ial master6 to ddre6.7ss pr-8.2etrial and post-trial matter4.6s ca5.4nnot be addr-6.4essed an 9available district judg7.7e or of the district of the tri al in this matter sc5.9heduled to it is in all parties best interest to c-5.1o.1mplete this final two hours of de6position and 9Given that in the prior de-5.2positions of Ms counsel for Plaintiff6 has same questions we lieve ther-6.2e is a likelihood that this re6.7petitive duplicative que-5.3stioning7.9 will occur necessitatin-11.5g9.5 objec5.3tions couns-10.3el to enfor-6.5c3.4e this Court Marc6.8h Or5der is permitted by20 8.9Fed Civ Should this occur an immediate on issue 9a spe-6.8c3.1ial would prev-9.7ent the need for5.3 fu-9.7rther on these matter-6.8s Motion for 9Protective Or4.9der otherwise.-8.3 B-5.9e.9cause th8.1e Order pertain7.1ing7.1 dep-5.9o sition7.2 th8.2e e-12m8ails af7.2ter th8.2e Order,11.4 it address7.6e2.2d Mo-5.6tion 38R6.3e1.8con8s5.2ideration8,0 th9er-15ef ore iden5.6ti-7.6f9.6ied as on7.6e th8.4e li-7.8m8.2ited topics third It is cle ar tra-11.7n7.5script th8.5at th8.5e an7.5d recog7.1n7.1ized-6.9 t-9.1opics be th8.1e Case Document Filed Page of There6.7 is also a c5.6oncern 6regardin-8.2g9.8 Plaintiff5.8?s c5.6ounsel?s tr-8.2eatment 11of Ms during10.7 her as evidenced ta-7.5ctics in the prior depositions 5.5such as refusing9.7 to permit Ms take5.7 requ-9.1ested 10scolding9.9 Ms that she could not spea6.7k with her counsel at and other deposition tac tics imprope-5.1r und-5.9er Fed Civ of ex-9.3ample in her sec6.5ond de-5.5position the following9.7 THE take a MR if commit not to talk to counsel the THE MR You want bre6.7ak to talk to THE wa5.5nt use the MR You want talk to c6.7ouns-9.9el THE talk couns-10.1el all the MR don-9 9y20ou talkin-11g10 to 21y20our c6.8oun-9sel while in the of this MR PAGL10.8I13U.2CA 2m to talk to her so are6.8 9g10o0ing8 to sit here and fo-6r the rest of the until MR No but to the rest of this line of questioning8.1 unless tak-7.2e her 6and wa5.6lk and then to p-11.2rotest that to the MR is refusin-9.2g9.8 a bath-11.2room brea-5.4k to now See A Obviously19.8,-9.2 the risk impro-9.2p-.2er oppre6.6ssive conduct counsel woul-11.8d be with the 8.9presen-10.1ce of 18.2arbiter in the r5.5oom Thus for pu-9.4rp-6.4oses a5.4nd to protect Ms from hara6.4ssmen-9.4t and oppre6.7ssion r-6.2e3.6quest th-9.2at the Court appoint a Special Master to Ms third de6.6position and be following9.8 Case Document Filed Page of Provide immediate a5.7nd ruling9.9s on all objec5.4tions conce-5.5rning10.6 wh-7.4ether the questi-4.8oning7.4 ex-9.6ceeds 5.5the imposed Court including8.4 questioning8.5 Provide immediate a5.7nd ruling9.9s on 10an clai-9.4ms of 12.2oppre6.7ssion or har-6.2a-5.4ssment of the witnesses Provide immediate a5.9nd ruling10.1s on obj-11.6ections that would other-6.4w-.2ise necessitate 9a Motion for 9Protective Or4.5der othe th-8an instruc6.8tions not to answer on privileg11.4e 9which shall be 9preserv-6.6e3.2d in the dep-9.1o-.6sition record.-13.3 Provide immediate a5.7nd ruling9.9s on 10an matter the deposition that will eff6.1e3.9ctuate the letion of 8Ms hour deposition Consistent with Civ f6 the 8.3Special aster?s on these 9questions will be reviewed unde-5.7r ab-9.5use of discre6.3tion standa-5.7r-6.5d propose that each 9side share6.3 in the cost of the special master5.9 pursu-7.1a3.7nt to Civ Within 9.9after the Court?s approva6.9l of this r-6.5e3.3quest Ms will 10propose a list of three qu-9.5alified special masters a5.4nd r-6.4e3.4quest that the Court selec5.4t one these individuals to act as Special Master this deposition CONCLUSION W-5.4H0EREF7ORE request-8.9s the a5.6ppoint ment of a Special u-9.7nder Fed Civ to oversee rule of obje-7.7c3.3tions raised other than fo-9.5rm foundation objec5.7tions in Ms final two hours of d-7.9e4.9position Case Document Filed Page of Da5.9ted April Respec7tfull-12y20.2 submitted,-13.4 Laura A Menninger A pro hac 10vice ADDON ORGAN OREM-9.5AN P.C East th Ave5.1nue De5.5nver CO Phone Fax-14 lmenning7.4er-6.6 hmflaw.c5.2o-9.6m Attorneys for Ghislaine Max6.8well-7.3 Case Document Filed Page of CERTIF11.4ICATE SERVI-7.9C2.8E that on Ap-7.2ril served this Motion to Appoi6.8nt Spec5.9i-.2al Master to Preside Over Third Depo-9.1sition of De5.7fendant via ECF6.3 on the Sig8.1r.1id McCawle-15.1y7.4 Mer7.1e4.9dith Schultz-7.4 LEX-13.2NER East Olas Ste smccawle-15.8y19.4 7bs-9.4fllp.com mschultz-4.9 bsfllp.com9.5 Paul Cassell-6 Universit-11.7y19.5 Street Salt UT cassellp law.utah.-9.7e3.1du Edwards F6.4A.4RMER EDW-5A.4RDS FI13.9STOS North Andrews Ste brad pathtojustice5.5.com-14.1 S7.2tanley21 Twin Rd South Salem NY StanPotting10.1e3.9r aol.com Nicole Simmons Nicole Simmons5.7 Case Document Filed Page of
