1296 13

PDF Document Uploaded Feb 2, 2026 by Unknown Updated by admin 1 views 468.45 KB
Folders as described.
DOJ Epstein Release Interview Victim Statements Evidence Maxwell
← Back to Giuffre v. Maxwell, No. 1;15-cv-07433 (S.D.N.Y. 2015)
Extracted Text

UN4 IT-3 ST-4 ATE-3 DI11 S6 CT COUR3 OUT-2 HE-4 RN4 DIST-5 RIC13 NEW YOR-8 F6 lainti-3 ff6 GH-5 NE MA-5 XW-3 De6 fe7 nd-9 a4 nt cv RWS Re6 ly S6 or4 of-3 M4 ot3 ion-5 t3 Com15 e4 r3 ty W3 itnes-9 t3 Pr5 od-3 c4 e4 Doc6 m3 e4 ts an-3 Re6 sp-4 on-3 t3 De6 osit10 ion-5 Qu-5 e4 stion-3 a4 ra7 A e4 nnin-11 e4 e4 ff6 a4 li-3 uc-5 a e4 ADDON GAN AN Ea5 st th Ave6 nue De6 nve4 CO Case Document Filed Page of Bottom Type Pagination BDC TT0 Tf Td BLE TEN5 TS TRODU4 I MS-4 RANS-2 OME U4 NJ-8 US8 F6 IL14 ED T4 OD4 UCE A IL14 GE OG4 ESU-10 A4 IV5 ER OF6 HER IL14 II16 RANS-2 OME1 EF7 USED TO4 OD4 UCE EVA5 NT RES-2 ON4 DO4 UMEN4 TS THO5 B8 A e4 que4 sts-3 omm-3 unica6 ti-3 ons wit-2 i8 tn8 e4 sses Rela4 ted to thi-3 a4 e4 que4 st F6 e4 e4 re-2 e4 me-7 e4 que4 st hotog8 ra7 ph-9 e4 que4 st a4 ssports Visas a4 nd Othe4 ra7 e4 Doc4 e4 que4 st F4 inanc6 e4 c4 or3 ds uppor3 He4 e4 que4 st Educ3 a4 ti-3 Rec5 or3 e4 que4 st ode4 li-3 ng10 ontra-4 c4 I e4 que4 st oc4 ial Media II6 MS-4 RANS-2 OME U4 NJ-8 US8 EF7 USED A4 NSW-7 ER EL22 VA4 DE4 OST-10 QU4 EST-11 ON4 AN4 SH-9 MUST B6 COMP-4 LED4 TO APP-5 EAR AN4 RES-3 ON4 ON4 ERT-10 ATE4 ERV-9 Case Document Filed Page of Bottom Type Pagination BDC TT0 Tf Td Tm Td EMC BDC Tf Td e4 in uppor3 of3 he4 Mot-2 ion to Non2 a4 rt-8 it-3 ne4 ss roduc7 e4 Doc6 ume-7 a4 e4 spond De6 po-9 sit-4 ion Que4 sti-4 D5 oc4 a4 nd fu3 rthe-4 state3 as f5 oll-3 INTRODUC4 D5 oc4 fe7 ll-3 woe6 full-20 short of3 a4 c4 tuall-21 a4 dd-9 re7 ssi-13 ng10 the c4 a4 te-7 or3 e4 of doc6 ments a3 nd de4 posi-2 ti-3 on pr3 oduc4 e4 e4 of do-7 c4 uments thr3 e4 e4 a4 fte-4 the5 Mot-2 ion Com-4 pe4 wa4 filed a4 incomplete4 c4 op-9 one7 of old pa-4 ssports and photog10 a4 phs which3 we-3 re7 iven to-9 he4 short the O4 posi-2 ti-3 on se3 e4 ms sug9 ge4 be4 c4 a4 use sh-7 e4 prod3 c4 e4 e4 se3 pa-5 e4 e4 shoul-2 not have6 to answ3 othe5 of3 the subpoe5 na4 re7 que4 sts-3 nor a7 nswe-4 de7 posi-2 ti-3 on que4 sti-4 ons which-12.3 a4 re7 de4 sig7 ne4 to a4 to admis-12 sibl-4 e4 e4 videnc6 e4 a4 nd whic4 c4 onc4 e4 e4 do not c4 a4 ll-3 for6 privil-2 e4 a4 nswe5 Th-8 e4 Opposit-2 ion ong10 on sc3 e4 e4 nshot-2 of hotos-2 a4 nd doc4 uments but-2 short on law4 or a4 ument a4 im-3 e4 a4 he4 oti-3 on to ompel f3 a4 il-3 to a4 rticula5 te a6 a4 c4 a4 sis-3 f3 or3 r3 fusa6 pr3 oduc4 e4 or to a4 nswe5 a4 Ms a4 nsom-2 e4 shoul-2 be4 orde7 e4 to compl-21 AR4 G8 M4 NT-3 I M4 RA4 NSO-3 M4 UN4 JU-7 IF10 IABL-4 AILE-4 P9 RODU4 CE A PRIV4 IL-3 G8 OG6 RES-4 ULT-3 ING9 IN A3 WA-7 IV OF11 HE-4 RIV3 G8 Ms a4 nsom-2 e4 c4 onc4 e4 e4 she pr5 oduc4 e4 privil-2 e4 log8 de4 e4 he-5 a7 sse-7 rtion of pr5 ivi-3 lege6 a4 to e4 que4 sts-3 a4 nd-9 Menninge5 D5 c4 a5 e4 sponses the f5 a4 e4 of the5 plain lang12 e4 in ule A a4 we5 ll-3 a4 the le-6 of c4 it-3 e4 c4 a4 e4 re6 quirin-10 a4 privil-2 e4 ge4 Motion at Ms a4 some subm-2 ts wo unpe6 rsua6 sive a5 nd inapposit-2 e4 guments:-2 a4 log8 Case Document Filed Page of thre5 e4 diff-5 e4 re7 nt rm he4 f3 irst sp-2 oke4 to hose a4 tt-3 or-6 ne-5 som-3 e4 ti-3 me in c4 tobe-7 or6 Nove6 mbe-7 so he4 e4 nti-3 re7 volum-3 e4 of he4 ir c5 omm-3 unica6 ti-3 ons c3 a4 not be sig9 nific-6 a4 nt and sh-8 e4 subm-2 it-3 no proof5 to the Court that it-3 is he4 a4 off5 re7 no e4 plana6 ti-3 on-9 a4 to e4 f6 e4 or3 a4 tt-3 or3 ne-5 re7 una4 ble to pr3 e4 pa-5 re7 a4 privil-2 e4 ge4 a4 to he4 ir c5 omm-13 unica6 ti-3 ons wit-2 he4 or6 a4 other5 oc4 uments withheld a4 privil-3 e4 ge4 The5 c4 a4 e4 cite3 lainti-3 ff6 do not uppor3 her5 posi-12 ti-3 on F6 or3 e4 a4 mpl-3 e4 e4 ll-3 Fargo Bank4 A ha4 not-2 hing8 to do th The5 pe-5 rmiss-2 ibl-3 e4 sc3 ope4 of disc4 ov-9 e4 f3 rom a4 pa4 is e4 e4 ra7 he4 same5 a4 that a4 ppli-3 c4 a4 e4 discove5 sou-10 ht e4 ll-3 Far-10 go Bank5 N.A Konov3 e4 No CF5 a4 D3 Con-2 Ma3 The)5 non-10 a4 rt-8 witness in M3 e4 mpone6 nts Inc4 v4 lass-3 ic M5 e4 In3 c4 M.D.N3 a4 c4 tuall-21 off-3 e4 e4 to provide3 a4 privil-2 e4 log8 And the4 pa4 witness in F6 D5 Con-2 full-10 c4 ompl-3 ied w4 it-3 two pr3 e4 vious-2 discove5 re7 que-5 sts-3 but obj-3 e4 c4 ted to ins-2 pe4 c4 ti-3 on of3 it-3 ele5 c4 tronic3 se3 rve7 rs to loc-7 a4 te e6 mails-2 whose5 e4 ist-4 e4 nc4 e4 wa6 spe-7 c4 ulative se3 c4 ond rg13 ument-1 the un-7 re7 ma-7 rka7 le posit-2 ion that witness in8 ter5 views a5 e4 c4 ove4 re7 wor5 pro3 du-9 c4 prote5 c4 ti-3 on doe4 not-2 hing8 to addr5 e4 ss he4 iss-3 ue4 in e4 sti-4 on i.e whe6 ther5 she should ha4 ve4 prov3 ided-7 a4 privil-2 e4 ge4 identif-18 a4 c4 privil-2 e4 do-9 c4 uments ule e7 A re7 quir-8 e4 as a4 withheld rote5 c4 ti-3 on a4 trial-1 pr3 e4 pa-5 ra7 ti-3 on pa4 wi-9 tness must-4 0F Gu5 at er-5 as ies Ms er-5 ar-5 ein5 ass5 ll ite th5 as er-5 at er-5 at Sch-5 Ms Sch-5 er-5 at cv Case Document Filed Page of Bottom Type Pagination BDC GS0 gs TT0 Tf Td Tm Td EMC BDC Tf TD pr3 otec6 ted w4 il-3 ena6 e4 the-7 pa4 a4 dmi-3 tt-3 e4 did not-3 e4 pr3 e4 ssl-13 make6 a4 such3 c4 a4 im-3 nor d3 id he-5 e4 sc3 ribe5 e4 na4 ture5 of the5 withheld doc4 uments unjus-2 ti-3 fie5 fa7 il-3 ur3 e4 to provide3 a4 privi-10 lege6 log8 a4 to e4 sponses a4 nd e4 ff6 c4 ted a6 wa6 iver5 a7 pr3 ivi-3 leg12 e4 e4 e4 Mot-2 a4 One6 Be5 ac4 on Ins Co Forman I5 nt-7 td RW-5 a4 D.N4 D4 c4 re A4 ppli-3 c4 ati-3 on for-2 Subpoe4 na to roll-4 F6 E4 D.N4 abatt-3 td v4 olson-2 Bre4 e4 ries Nos CV S.D.N3 a4 In re6 Grand J5 y4 Subpoe4 na F6 3d st ir II M4 RA4 NSO-3 M4 REF10 TO-2 RODU4 CE VA4 NT RES-5 ONS-3 IVE DOCU4 M4 NTS-4 WIT-3 HO-3 UT IS-6 A Re6 e4 sts-1 Co-7 m3 icat5 ion-5 ith itnesse3 Re5 late5 t3 thi-2 e4 que4 sts-3 a4 nd e4 que4 sted c5 omm-3 unica6 ti-3 on-9 betw3 e4 e4 Ms a4 nsom-2 e4 a4 nd a4 number5 of3 diff4 e4 e4 nt wit-3 ne4 sses in his ca5 se3 e4 sponse a4 nsom-2 e4 prod3 uc4 e4 pa4 ge4 e4 mails-2 he4 testified tha4 she c4 onduc4 e4 the se5 rc7 fo-6 r6 e4 sponsi-13 ve4 e4 mails-2 he4 rse6 of6 he-5 Ya6 hoo a4 c4 ount nbox-9 ott-3 ing8 e4 D5 e4 Ex-8 a4 Ms a4 nsom-2 e4 did not-3 sea7 rc7 a4 othe-7 a7 c4 c4 ounts-2 f3 re7 sponsi-3 ve4 c4 omm-3 unica6 ons no for5 e4 nsic se-5 a4 rc7 a4 con3 duc4 ted the5 c4 c4 unt nor did he3 a4 tt-3 or3 con3 duc4 a4 sea-2 rc-2 of h3 e4 c7 omput-3 includ-9 ing8 the a6 tt-3 or3 re6 re7 se-6 nti-3 ng10 he4 in he-4 J4 an-9 e4 Doe c4 ompl-3 a4 int-3 Ac6 c4 or3 din-11 to a4 nso-10 a4 her5 de4 posi-2 ti-3 on she3 possesse4 ot-2 he4 e4 sponsi-3 ve4 c4 omm-3 unica6 ti-3 ons F5 or3 e4 a4 mpl-3 e4 she testified tha4 he4 wr5 ote to the Pos-2 re5 porte5 Ma6 re-2 e4 a4 ll-3 a4 ha4 in an a6 tt-3 e4 mpt-3 to sell-2 he4 stor-16 to he4 me-7 dia in or3 a4 bout Oc4 tobe-7 ott-3 ing8 e4 E4 0C id a4 Case Document Filed Page of Bottom Type Pagination BDC GS0 gs TT0 Tf Td Tm Td EMC BDC Tf TD he4 testified tha4 those-8 e4 mails-2 a4 re7 sti-4 ll-3 on he4 c7 omput-3 e4 in e4 Y5 a4 oo a4 c4 c4 ount Id a4 he4 re7 is he4 e4 mail ha4 ou rote5 he4 A Th-8 we-3 re7 not pr3 oduc4 e4 ompare5 e4 ning8 e4 De6 c4 Re que-5 st-4 No se3 e4 kin-11 doc4 ume-7 nts ha4 re5 fe7 e4 nc-5 e4 he4 a4 lso po-2 ssesse4 ema5 with-2 witness to whom she a5 ll-3 e4 e4 ha4 c4 ompl-3 a4 ined a6 bout e4 ff6 Epstein but onl-13 prod3 uc-5 e4 sele5 c4 ted e4 mails-2 withi-3 e4 same5 e4 mai c4 ha4 in B7 e4 a4 use a4 thorou-8 sea-2 rc-2 of e7 mail communi-3 c4 a4 ti-3 ns wa5 not-2 pe4 rf6 rme5 wit-11 hin he4 Ya6 hoo a4 c4 ount or a5 he4 a7 c4 ount us-2 e4 Ms a4 nsom-2 e4 ther5 e4 is no-2 ua-5 ra7 ntee6 that a4 ll-3 re7 sponsi-3 ve4 doc4 uments ha-6 ve4 be4 e4 pro3 du-9 c4 e4 Af5 ter5 c4 ounse3 for4 Ms a4 e4 ll-3 r3 a4 ised dur4 loca6 te a6 ddit-3 ional r3 e4 sponsi-13 ve4 doc4 uments whic3 ha4 e4 be4 e4 pro3 du-9 c4 e4 in di-3 ff-3 e4 re7 nt batc4 e4 The4 ourt should orde5 a7 thor-8 oug10 a4 nd c4 ompl-3 e4 te se-4 a4 rc-2 of Ms e4 nsure6 that ther-4 e4 re7 no ther5 mi-3 ssi-3 ng10 c4 omm-3 unica6 ions and tha3 he4 identifie3 c4 omm-3 unica6 ti-3 ons with a4 ll-3 a4 ha4 a4 nd Ms a4 re7 prod3 uc-5 e4 Re6 e4 st e4 Agr-3 e4 m3 e4 re7 sponse to e4 qu-9 e4 st a4 nsom-2 e4 prod3 uc4 e4 he4 f6 e4 e4 e4 ment with Messr4 Edw3 a4 rds Pot-3 ti-3 ng10 a7 nd a4 ssell purpor4 ti-3 ng10 to e4 lec6 he4 ir pr4 bono e4 pr3 e4 e4 ntation of he5 a4 a witness in his a4 tt-3 e4 S9 he4 ha4 not-2 prod3 uc-5 e4 nor3 indi-3 c4 a4 ted a6 ba4 sis-3 f3 it-3 hholdi-3 ng10 he4 e4 e4 a4 gr3 e4 e4 e4 nt assoc4 iate4 with her5 c4 ivi-3 plaint ane4 Doe6 v4 Epstein e4 al including8 a4 f3 Mr Casse5 ll-3 Mr E3 dwa6 rd-6 Mr B8 oies Ms McCa-6 wle-5 Ms c4 hult-3 a4 ll-3 of3 whom ha4 ve4 e4 nter5 e4 a4 ppe4 a4 a4 nc-5 e4 in ha4 a4 tt-3 e4 Se4 e4 Do-7 c4 k4 e4 e4 port J4 ne4 Doe6 v4 Epstein e4 cv GK4 Case Document Filed Page of Bottom Type Pagination BDC GS0 gs TT0 Tf Td Tm Td EMC BDC TD he4 a4 lso di-4 not produc5 e4 a4 wr5 it-3 ing8 re7 fle-4 c4 ti-3 ng10 e4 e4 nga-5 e4 ment of3 G5 uir-8 uis as he-5 c7 ounse3 fina5 nc4 ial rr6 a4 ge4 ments it-3 thos-2 e4 c4 ounse3 all ar5 e4 e4 leva6 nt and discov-8 e4 ra7 e4 Re6 e4 st ot3 ogr4 Ms a4 nsom-2 e4 prod3 uc4 e4 ome photogra5 phs which3 he4 c4 laims-2 doc4 uments he3 ti-3 me on the4 isl-4 a4 nd ome photos fa7 c4 ca6 ptur-8 e4 he-5 ima3 ge4 on-9 wha6 appe-3 a4 rs to it-3 tl-3 e4 a4 mes sland nd-9 e4 e4 she3 ins-12 e4 rte5 phot-11 og10 a4 phs he4 e4 sponse a4 nd sugge3 sted that suc4 hotog8 ra7 hs of Ms Max-6 we6 ll-3 ha4 be4 e4 take6 he-5 Se4 e4 a4 D5 oc4 c4 mpl-3 ica6 ti-3 on would be4 fa7 lse A3 a4 nsom-2 e4 e4 sti-4 fie5 a4 nd a4 subs-2 e4 qu-9 e4 nve4 sti-4 a4 ti-3 on ha4 re6 e4 a4 e4 the photogr3 a4 phs of3 Ms a4 we6 ll-3 we6 re4 c4 ua4 tak-7 e4 pl-3 c4 e4 on a4 disk,-2 a4 nd give6 to Ms Ransome ott-3 ing8 e4 De6 c4 Ex-8 a4 00AB ome of5 the photo we6 re7 tak-7 e4 whe6 Ms nsom-2 e4 wa6 not-2 e4 ve4 on he4 isl-4 a4 nd jum-3 ps se3 que4 nti-3 a4 number5 ther5 e4 ha4 vin-11 omi-3 tt-3 e4 a4 number5 of ph3 otos purp-6 or3 tedl-9 tak-7 e4 on the isl-4 a4 nd Case Document Filed Page of PM JPG File KB PM JPG File KB PM JPG File KB PM JPG File KB PM JPG File KB PM JPG File KB PM JPG File KB rnn?c A IDf Cilo kR Bottom Type Pagination BDC TT0 Tf Td Tm Td EMC BDC Td EMC BDC TT1 Tf Td Se4 e4 e4 Men-6 ninger5 e4 sc6 re7 e4 nshot-2 of ontents of disk produc6 e4 photog8 ra-2 phs she pr5 ovide-7 som-2 e4 c4 opies of4 the ron-6 ts of photos and some ba-3 c4 ks of photos she pr3 oduc4 e4 the fr6 onts and a4 c4 ks sepa-3 ra7 tel-19 so he4 e4 no to di-3 sc3 e4 rn w5 fr6 ont g8 e4 with-2 whic4 ba4 c4 Ms a4 nsom-2 e4 shoul-2 be4 orde7 re7 to pro-8 duc4 e4 all-3 sponsi-3 ve4 photog8 a4 phs their3 na4 ti-3 ve4 for6 mat or3 pe-5 rmit nspec7 ti-3 on of3 the sa5 Re6 e4 st ass-2 or4 Visas-2 an-3 Other5 r4 ave4 Doc4 e4 e4 spons-11 e4 Ms a4 ome pr5 omi-3 se3 that De6 c4 a4 a4 not a4 nsom-2 e4 inst-4 e4 a4 pr3 oduc4 e4 on-9 e3 of3 he-5 e4 pire5 pa4 ssports spec7 ifica7 he-5 Briti-2 sh pa3 ssports.-7.167 he4 did not-3 prod3 uc4 e4 he4 Sout-2 Af-4 ric5 a4 a4 ssport fr5 om nor d3 id she pr4 oduc-5 e4 e4 it-3 he-5 he7 c7 rr6 e4 nt or e4 pr6 outh Af3 ric5 a4 pa4 ssports fa7 c4 Ms-3 a4 nsom-2 e4 ha4 he4 c4 ur3 e4 nt passpor3 bot-3 in NY a6 nd-9 she p3 re7 se3 nted-7 it-3 a4 he4 ti-3 me she5 sig7 e4 he4 de4 c4 lar-4 a4 ti-3 in B5 a4 c4 e4 lona.-7 Ms a4 nsom-2 e4 a4 lso pr3 oduc4 e4 no doc4 uments e3 it-3 he-5 re7 fle-4 c4 ti-3 ng10 e4 visa4 to ra-2 ve4 wor3 or stud-12 in he4 US Reque6 a7 c4 omm-3 unic-7 a4 ti-3 on re-2 a4 rdin-8 c4 visas e4 que4 st The5 se3 doc4 uments re7 c4 a4 c4 ulate4 to e4 a4 to admis-2 sibl-4 e4 discove5 not as the witness ba4 ldl-13 Case Document Filed Page of PM JPG File KB PM JPG File KB PM JPG File KB PM JPG File KB PM JPG File KB PM JPG File KB PM JPG File KB PM JPG File KB PM JPG File KB Bottom Type Pagination BDC GS0 gs TT0 Tf Td Tm Td EMC BDC Tf TD he-5 re7 in a4 te She a4 nd that Ms a4 we6 ll-3 a4 lso a4 de4 such3 e4 tra5 or3 dina-7 pr3 omi-3 se3 he4 ther5 Ransome ha6 pe4 rmiss-2 ion a4 tt-3 e4 nd sc3 hool the U4 or to w3 he4 re7 be-5 a4 rs dir-6 e4 c4 on he4 ther5 she e4 a4 son-10 a4 c4 ould have6 e4 li-3 e4 on a4 such a4 ll-3 e4 pro3 mi-3 se3 a4 nd fr6 om he4 U.S a4 nd-9 f3 rom outh Af3 ric5 a4 a4 nd to and f5 rom other6 c4 ountrie-6 re6 late4 di-2 re-2 c4 to whe6 ther5 or no3 e4 wa6 fa7 c4 pr-8 e4 se3 nt the U4 whe6 she3 c4 laims-2 that she3 wa6 The4 e4 que4 sted doc4 uments shoul-3 be4 pro-6 duc4 e4 Re6 e4 st in-5 an-3 c4 ial-3 Re6 c4 or4 to Su-5 or4 He5 r4 Clai-11 e4 J4 an-9 e4 Doe6 Max-6 we6 ll-3 c4 nti-3 nue4 to provide3 he4 with hing8 of va6 lue in e4 c4 ha4 e4 f3 he4 c4 onti-3 nue4 pr3 omi-3 se3 to e4 lp he4 be4 a4 dmi-3 tt-3 e4 to F4 or4 a4 no-9 ther5 scho3 ol or to provide-5 f3 inanc6 supp-2 or3 for4 c4 oll-3 e4 ge4 a4 dmi-3 ssi-3 on or3 Se-5 e4 J4 ne4 Doe6 v4 Epstein e4 cv ompl-3 a4 int-3 Doc6 The5 subpoe3 a4 thus a4 ll-3 e4 for6 Ms a4 nsom-2 e4 prod3 uc4 e4 doc4 e4 nts re7 fle-4 c4 ti-3 ng10 a4 ments e4 c4 e4 ived e4 rom Mr3 Epstein his assoc3 iate4 nd he4 fina5 nc4 ial re7 c4 or3 ds fr6 om he4 a4 rs whe6 she3 c4 laims-2 she w5 a4 e4 c4 e4 ivi-3 e4 mune-7 ra7 ti-3 on fr6 om Epstein re7 sponse Ms a4 nsom-12 is har4 to mag12 ine do-7 c4 e4 nts re4 fle-4 c4 ti-3 ng10 e4 f6 inan-7 ial pa-5 e4 nts fr3 om pstein be3 ing8 a4 re7 re7 le2 va4 nt Du-9 ring11 e4 de7 osit-4 ion a4 nsom-2 e4 tes11 ti-3 fie5 that she3 ha4 a4 a4 nk-9 a4 c4 c4 ount NY4 in De6 c4 a4 he4 testified tha4 that a4 c4 ount he4 plac6 e4 e4 e4 a4 rn-6 ing8 fr5 om e4 Case Document Filed Page of Bottom Type Pagination BDC TT0 Tf Td Tm Td EMC BDC Tf TD Id-6 he4 a4 lso e4 sti-4 fie5 that ur3 ing8 the op-7 e4 ra7 ti-3 ve4 ti-3 me ra7 me she a4 makin-10 he-5 som-2 e4 ti-3 mes e5 nga-5 e4 in ua4 re5 lations-2 on he4 Id a4 jobs mone-7 rom Mr3 stein,-10 whe6 a4 nd how muc4 a4 ll-3 be4 a4 si-9 nifc-4 a4 nt re5 lev-7 a4 nc-5 e4 to her5 c4 laims-2 that she w5 a4 iven f5 a4 nc4 ial nc4 e4 nti-3 ve4 Epstein a4 nd Max-6 we6 ll-3 in ex-7 c4 ha4 ng10 e4 f3 or-6 sex-6 ua4 compli-3 a4 nc4 e4 The5 subpoe3 na4 is na-8 rr6 owl-9 tailore5 to a7 mone)-14 re7 c4 f3 rom Epste3 in or his-11 a4 ssocia4 or3 fr6 om he4 ti-3 me f5 ra7 e4 priva5 c4 onc-5 rns c6 a4 be4 a4 ll-3 e4 viate4 a4 se-6 on the pr5 otec6 ti-3 ve4 or3 de4 e7 e4 re7 in his ca5 pr3 oduc4 e4 a4 ott-3 ing8 D5 c4 Ex-8 a4 wa4 not-2 ne4 ws r4 e4 po-9 rte5 rom the e4 Y4 or3 ost or3 a4 nt de4 nti-3 infor4 mation fr4 om which ba4 c4 round3 he4 c4 ks a4 nd ther5 investi-2 ga4 ti-3 on c4 a4 oc-5 c4 ur3 primar5 a4 publi-3 c4 doc4 ument B7 ut fo-8 the5 f3 c4 ha4 Ms-3 Ransome lives in pa4 in and ha6 dua3 citi-3 e4 nshi-2 ps with he4 UK4 a4 nd outh Af3 ric5 a4 such3 do-9 c4 ument c4 ou-9 be4 obtaine4 a4 sim-4 ple visi-2 the De6 pa4 e4 nt of Motor Ve-3 hicle4 ne4 found3 ivac-13 c4 onc-5 e4 rns a4 be4 a4 ll-3 e4 viate4 a4 0F licl-10 el Ms Ms th5 alleg3.996 llo-15 es Case Document Filed Page of Bottom Type Pagination BDC GS0 gs TT0 Tf Td Tm Td EMC BDC TT1 Tf Tc Td TT2 Tf Tc Td TT1 Tf Td Re6 e4 st Ed-3 c4 at3 on-3 Re6 c4 or4 Ms a4 nsom-2 e4 wa6 re6 qu-9 e4 ted to pr3 oduc4 e4 he-5 othe5 se3 c4 onda4 e4 duc-5 a4 ti-3 on de4 gr3 e4 e4 tra5 nscr6 ipt-3 and3 a4 tt-3 e4 nd-9 a4 nc-5 e4 a4 nd ra7 e4 e4 c4 or3 ds a4 e4 ll-3 a4 her6 a4 ppli-3 a4 ti-3 ons fa7 shion-2 c4 oll-3 e4 modeling8 or othe-4 te5 c4 hni-11 c4 a4 colle-7 e4 Ms a4 nso-10 me te4 sti-4 fie5 a4 her5 e4 posi-2 ti-3 on a4 nd noted in he4 J4 ane4 Doe6 c4 ompl-3 a4 int-3 that she3 f3 il-3 e4 out an a6 ppli-13 c4 a4 ti-3 on fo3 c4 e4 ptanc6 e4 a4 he4 F6 a4 shion-2 nsti-4 tut-3 e4 of a4 dmi-3 ssi-3 on but he-5 did whic4 for6 ms he4 ba4 sis-3 of3 he4 c7 a4 im-3 that he4 se6 ua4 fa5 vors to Mr Epste he4 fa7 il-3 e4 to pr3 oduc-5 e4 he4 a4 ppli-3 a4 ti-3 on-3 without-3 just-4 ifica7 ti-3 on-2 he4 a4 lso fa-5 il-3 e4 to pr3 oduc4 e4 a4 oth-11 e4 e4 c4 or3 con3 c4 e4 rnin-8 e4 othe5 po-6 se3 c4 onda4 ra7 ini-3 ng10 ppli-3 c4 a4 ti-3 ons The4 se3 doc4 uments re6 late4 to he4 ll-3 e4 a4 ti-3 ons he4 a4 ne4 Do-7 e4 c4 ompl-3 a4 int-3 pa4 ra7 phs nd a4 lso he4 f6 inan-7 c4 ial mot-3 ivation testi-2 in his ca5 se3 Re6 e4 st M7 od-3 e4 Contr5 ac4 ts im-3 il-3 a4 rl-8 Ms a4 nsom-2 e4 re7 fuse6 to produ-8 c4 e4 e4 ode4 li-3 ng10 c4 ontr-8 a4 c4 ts or e4 a4 rni-8 ng10 which dire5 c4 re7 late4 to ra-2 ph of3 he4 J4 an-9 e4 Doe c4 mpl-3 a4 int-3 he4 did not-3 indi6 c4 a4 te she5 e4 a4 c4 he4 fo-6 a4 c4 doc4 uments nd-9 e4 e4 she3 e4 fuse6 to a4 nswe-4 que7 sti-4 ons a3 bout her5 de4 li-3 ng10 a4 rnin-8 as discusse3 inf ra I Re6 e4 st oc4 ial-3 M4 ia-4 F6 inall-11 Ms a4 nsom-2 a4 aske6 to produ-8 c4 e4 he-5 oc4 ial media4 post-2 ing8 e4 de4 nied ha4 ving8 a4 such3 c4 c4 ount-11 ott-3 ing8 e4 D5 c4 Ex-8 K2 Ms a4 nsom-2 e4 ha4 at lea7 st a Twitt-2 e4 a7 c4 as w3 e4 ll-3 an nsta-8 ra7 a4 c4 c4 ount hil-3 e4 som-2 e4 post-2 ar6 e4 publi-3 c4 other5 ar6 e4 onl-21 shar6 e4 with he-7 f6 rie5 nds Ms a4 nsom-2 e4 shoul-2 be4 r3 e4 quire5 to produc-4 e4 a4 he7 postin-11 on a3 socia5 e4 dia pla4 tfor4 Case Document Filed Page of Bottom Type Pagination BDC TT0 Tf Td Tm Td EMC BDC TT1 Tf Tc TD I TT2 Tf Tc Td TT1 Tf Td M4 RA4 NSO-3 M4 UN4 JU-7 IF10 IABL-4 R4 USE AN4 WER REL-4 E7 VA4 NT DEP10 ION UES-4 I9 ONS-3 AN4 HE-4 M4 UST5 COM4 TO-2 APP14 A4 ND4 RES-14 to answ3 e4 a7 numb-11 e4 of6 no-9 pr3 ivi-3 lege6 que4 sti-4 ons The5 r3 c4 or3 of the5 e4 posi-2 ti-3 on is re7 plete4 with such3 fr6 ivol-3 ous obj-2 e4 c4 ti-3 ons F5 or3 e4 a4 mpl-3 e4 a4 pa-7 ge4 he4 a7 tt-3 or3 inst-4 ru-6 c4 ted e4 not to g9 ive e4 ions ca5 ll-3 f3 or3 privil-2 infor4 mation ott-3 ing8 e4 e4 c4 Ex-8 a4 he4 a4 sked who w4 a4 f3 or3 e4 hote5 Ne6 Y4 or3 G5 uir-8 uis inst-4 ruc7 ted Ms a4 nsom-2 e4 not a4 nswe5 a7 nd then Ms c4 a4 wle-15 a7 ppe4 rin-8 on be4 ha4 lf Pl-2 a4 int-3 iff4 a4 nd NO4 on be5 lf of3 Ms a4 nsom-2 e4 instr)-8 uc4 ted he6 to a5 we6 Id a4 c4 onsul-2 wit-3 Ms a4 nsom7 e4 be4 for-3 e4 she a7 we6 e4 In sum ther5 e4 we-3 re7 a4 fic5 a4 nt num-3 be4 of6 de4 posi-2 ti-3 on que4 sti-4 ons s9 e4 to a4 nsom-2 e4 that she3 wa6 im-4 pr3 ope-5 rl-8 inst-4 ru-6 c4 ted not to answ3 e4 a4 nd for6 whic4 she3 shoul-2 be4 c4 ompelled to r3 e4 turn to a de4 posi-2 ti-3 on a4 nd a4 nswe5 Cat5 e4 gor4 e4 r4 son-4 al r4 r4 e4 in-5 an-3 c4 ial-3 i8 or4 at3 ion-5 opposi-2 ti-3 on Ms a4 nsom-2 e4 a4 sser5 ts wi-2 thout-3 f3 a4 c4 a4 or le-6 supp-2 or3 ha4 e4 f6 inan-7 c4 ial a4 nsom-2 e4 f3 a4 il-3 e4 a4 ddr-6 e4 the r4 e4 leva6 c4 e4 a4 ument a4 sser5 ted the oti-3 on his ssue should be de4 e4 med a6 dmi-3 tt-3 e4 omp-7 are Mot-2 ion at Cat5 e4 gor4 the e4 ll-3 on-3 e4 e4 r4 of-6 e4 r4 ar4 e4 Ms a4 nsom-2 e4 f3 a4 il-3 e4 to ddre7 ss he4 r3 e4 e4 va4 nc-5 e4 a4 sse-7 rtion a3 sser5 ted the moti-13 on thi-3 is-3 sue should be4 de4 e4 med a4 dmi-3 tt-3 e4 ompare5 Case Document Filed Page of Cat5 e4 gor4 Allege6 ly r4 ivi-3 lege6 c4 omm16 icat5 on-3 it11 Alan-3 De6 r4 sh-4 ow-7 i8 tz opposi-2 ti-3 on Ms a4 nsom-2 e4 ha4 now ba-5 c4 ktra5 c4 fr6 om her5 de-5 posi-2 ti-3 on testi-2 mon-11 a4 nd a4 thi-3 rd pe7 rson Mr4 Epstei-9 wa6 in he4 r3 oom durin-10 he-5 c7 onve-5 rsa6 ti-3 ons wit-2 Mr D4 e4 rshow4 it-3 B7 e4 a4 use the-4 re7 a4 an pr3 ope4 a7 e4 rtion of pr5 ivi-3 lege6 he4 a4 tt-3 or3 to e4 que4 sti-4 ons posed Ms a4 nsom-2 e4 shoul-2 be4 orde7 re7 to e4 spond thos-2 e4 de4 posi-2 ti-3 on que4 sti-4 ons Se4 e4 Mot-2 ion at Aban-5 on6 e4 Ob-5 je7 c4 tions-10.5 Ms a4 nsom-2 e2 did not-3 oppose3 the spe5 c4 ific re7 qu-9 e4 sts-3 that she3 a4 nswe-4 the5 f3 oll-3 wing10 de4 posi-2 ti-3 on que4 sti-4 ons a3 ll-3 of3 whic4 she3 a4 inst-4 ruc7 e4 not a4 nswe5 w5 it-3 hout a4 c4 laim of pr3 ivi-3 leg12 e4 pr6 ote-7 c4 ti-3 on Se4 e4 Mot-2 a4 Ms a4 ome should also be4 r3 e4 qui-11 re7 to answ3 the5 se3 que4 ti-3 0C mot-3 ive f5 or3 fa7 br3 ic-7 a4 ti-3 on a4 nd bias he4 ther5 Ala4 De-3 rshow4 it-3 c4 ontac6 ted a6 one4 on be7 ha4 lf c4 omm-3 unica6 ti-3 on-9 with-2 other5 c4 ouns-10 e4 not-3 privil-2 e4 ge4 the-7 spok-10 e4 with Maxw4 e4 and Mr4 Epstein he4 she3 prov3 ided he6 hotos-2 to her5 law-15 e4 date of3 c4 omm-3 unica6 ti-3 on a4 nd roduc7 ti-3 on to a4 tt-3 or3 not privi-2 le-7 e4 CONC4 USIO-4 F6 or3 the e4 a4 sons rticula5 te-7 in he4 Mot-2 ion Com-4 e4 and f5 ur3 the-7 suppor5 ted thi-3 e4 De6 fe7 nd-9 a4 nt qu-9 e4 sts-3 the ntr-8 of a4 rd-6 e4 ompelli-3 ng10 prod3 uc4 ti-3 on a7 ll-3 oc4 uments re6 sponsi-13 ve4 to he4 subpoe3 na inclu-9 ding8 c4 omm-3 unica6 ti-3 ons wit-2 c4 ounse3 bec6 a4 e4 privil-2 e4 bee7 a4 ived T3 he4 e4 include4 spec7 ifica7 but ar-4 e4 not im-3 it-3 e4 Case Document Filed Page of Bottom Type Pagination BDC GS0 gs TT0 Tf Td Tm Td EMC BDC Tc Td a TT1 Tf Tc Td TT0 Tf Td He6 c7 rr6 e4 nt passpo-9 rt he4 outh Af3 ric5 a4 pa4 sports a4 nd a4 ll-3 mi-3 ssi-3 ng10 pa-5 e4 e4 c4 luded fr6 om he4 pa4 ssport produ-7 e4 He6 e7 mails-2 with a4 ur-6 e4 e4 a4 ll-3 a4 ha4 including8 on-9 e4 whe6 re7 in she e4 nt phot-3 ogra7 ph of3 he4 a7 nd e4 rie5 nd re7 fe-2 re7 nc-5 e4 in her5 e4 posi-2 ti-3 He6 e4 e4 gr3 e4 e4 e4 He6 a5 ppli-3 a4 ti-3 The5 disc of4 photos-2 rovi-8 de4 to her5 c4 ontainin-11 the me-5 tada6 All phot-3 og10 ra7 phs e4 it-3 he4 pr-3 e4 vious-2 prod3 c4 e4 or withheld with e4 tada6 ta or5 in ha4 rd c7 includin-11 the fr6 ont and ba-3 c4 of the5 pho-9 All ema4 il-3 fr5 om be4 twe-5 e4 or re-2 fe7 e4 nc4 a4 De-3 fe7 nda4 nt in a4 ne4 Doe6 or3 c4 omm-3 unica6 ti-3 with e4 rso-7 Ms a4 nsom-2 e4 thr-6 oug10 e4 ff6 Epstein-4.5 or tha5 late4 to her5 c4 laims-2 in his ca5 se3 a4 nd e4 J4 ane4 Doe6 c4 ompl-3 a4 int-3 He6 f6 inan-7 c4 ial re-2 c4 or3 ds ro-6 Epst-3 e4 in or3 f3 rom i He6 mode5 li-3 c4 ontr-8 a4 c4 a4 nd He6 soc6 ial medi-9 e4 quiring9 Ms a4 nsom-2 e4 to a4 pp-9 e4 a4 for6 de4 posi-2 ti-3 a4 nd re7 spond a4 ll-3 que4 ti-3 ons a4 to whic4 she3 wa6 ins-3 truc5 e4 not a4 nswe5 in he5 fir4 st deposit-3 ion ex-7 c4 ludi-3 ng10 the na6 me of5 e4 c4 ur3 re7 nt pr-6 e4 sc3 ribin-12 doc4 Da6 ted Mar-3 c4 e4 spec7 tfull-12 subm-2 it-3 ted aura A M3 e4 nninger a4 ra7 A e4 nnin-11 e4 LM e4 ff6 a4 li-3 uc-5 a pro hac4 v4 ice-3 y4 Ge6 e4 pro c4 v4 ic-7 ADDON GAN AN Ea5 st th Ave6 nue De6 nve4 CO hone4 F6 a4 lm-3 e4 nning8 e4 hmfla4 w.c6 Attor-3 ne4 for Ghi-2 slai-4 ne4 Max7 e4 ll Case Document Filed Page of Bottom Type Pagination BDC TT0 Tf Td Tm Td EMC BDC TT1 Tf Td CERTI-2 ICA3 RV4 I CE c4 e4 rtif-17 that on a4 rc7 e4 lec6 troni-10 c4 a4 ser6 ve4 thi-3 e4 ply in Support-2 of M3 oti-3 on to ompe6 Party it-3 ne4 ss Produc-5 e3 Doc6 ume6 and Re5 spond to De4 posi-2 ti-3 on Que6 sti-4 via E3 F6 on the f5 oll-3 owing10 ig8 rid McCa4 wle-15 Mer6 e4 dit-3 c4 hult-3 LLP Ea5 st a4 Ola3 B7 oule-7 va4 rd St-2 e4 F6 a4 ude-5 rda7 le smcc5 a4 wle-15 bs-9 fllp.c3 om mschult-2 bsfllp.com a4 ul a4 ssell Unive4 rsit-11 tre5 e4 a4 lt-3 a4 ke4 UT c4 a4 ssellp a4 w.uta4 e4 du B7 ra7 Edw3 a4 rds F6 ARMER-3 AF8 F6 ISS-14 NG4 ED3 ARDS-2 TOS HRMAN Nor5 th Andr3 e4 ws Ave6 te F6 a4 ude-5 rda7 le br3 a4 pa5 tht-3 ojust-4 ice6 c4 om S6 tanle-5 ott-3 ing8 Tw3 in a4 ke4 outh a4 lem NY4 tanPot-3 ti-3 ng10 e4 a4 ol.com icole4 Simmons Nic4 ole Si-3 mm-3 ons Case Document Filed Page of
22,687 characters