1296 11

PDF Document Uploaded Feb 2, 2026 by Unknown Updated by admin 1 views 387.36 KB
Folders as described.
DOJ Epstein Release Interview Victim Statements Evidence Maxwell
← Back to Giuffre v. Maxwell, No. 1;15-cv-07433 (S.D.N.Y. 2015)
Extracted Text

Case Document Filed Page of Bottom Subtype Footer Type Pagination BDC TT0 Tf Td TT1 Tf Tm Td EMC BDC TT2 Tf Td UN4 ITED TA4 ES3 DI-3 ST3 RICT CO-4 UR4 SOUT3 HER-2 D4 IST-2 RI-3 CT4 OF NEW Virgi-3 ni3 a Giuf3 Plai-3 nt3 iff4 Case No cv W9 Ghisl-2 aine M5 axwell-3 Def4 endant-3 TO Sara-2 Ranso5 m8 a non-1 art-4 to this a4 cti-4 on-3 he4 reby res-3 ponds-2 to3 the Subpoena Duces Tecum noti-3 ced by Def4 endant-3 Maxwell-11.667 docum7 ent equest-4 con3 tained therei-3 PR3 EL4 IMI-2 NARY3 ST3 AT-5 EME3 NT4 AND GENE-4 RA4 OBJE-5 CT4 IONS Def4 endant-3 Maxwell-4 ha4 ser-3 ved-7 no5 par-2 ty-3 Sa5 rah Ranso-4 m8 with a subpoena duces tecum seeki-4 ng an4 arr-4 ay of do5 cum7 ents-3 that-4 are-3 bo5 th irrelevant to3 thi-3 m8 att-4 er and entirel5 pri-3 vi3 lege-3 d5 is solel-3 m8 eant-3 to harass and plac-2 an undue burden on Ms Ransom7 To be disc-3 over-2 able inform7 ati-4 on sought-2 m8 ust be rel-3 ev4 ant to th3 under-2 lyi-3 n5 act-3 ion Fed Civ W9 her-2 disc-3 over-2 is sought-2 fro-3 m8 thi-3 rd parti3 es,3 the Court m3 ust weigh the proba-2 ti-3 v5 valu-3 of th3 inform7 ati-4 on agai-3 ns4 th3 b5 urde-2 of produ3 cti-4 on on5 s4 aid p5 arty In re Bio4 vail-4 Corp6 Sec Lit-2 ig F.R3 N.Y4 citi-3 ng Concord Boat Co-2 rp Brunswick Corp F.R3 S.D.N3 Fed.R.C4 iv.P In order to determine whethe3 a subpoena im6 poses-2 an undue burde-2 n5 the Court shoul-2 consider:-3 relev4 ance the need of the-7 par-2 ty for the docum7 ents-3 the breadt4 of the docu-5 m8 ent req-2 ue4 st the ti-3 m8 per-2 iod cov4 ere-3 by it,6 he pa3 rtic3 ularit-3 with which d4 ocum7 ents-3 ar-2 desc-3 ribed and the burden m8 posed Id Case Document Filed Page of Bottom Subtype Footer Type Pagination BDC GS0 gs TT0 Tf Td TT1 Tf Tm Td EMC BDC TT0 Tf TD Specifica-3 lly,6 the subpoe3 na ser-3 ved o5 Ms Ranso-4 m8 seeks-3 docum7 ents-3 that-4 are-3 who7 ll-3 y5 ir-3 relevan3 to3 the underly5 ing action-7.667 in3 cludi-4 ng-1 p5 rotected fina5 ncia-3 information-7.667 and d5 ocum7 ents-3 or comm5 unica-3 ti-3 ons between Sara-2 Ransom8 and he-5 att-4 orneys which are-3 protected by the att-4 orney-21.3 cli-4 en4 p5 ri-3 vi3 lege and the work produ3 ct doc4 trine Notably th3 face of th3 subpoena dem7 onst-2 rat-4 e4 that-4 Def4 endant-3 is no5 e4 ven seeki-4 ng5 docum7 ents-3 rel-4 ev4 ant to th3 m8 att-4 er before thi-3 C7 ourt-3 and is7 inst-4 e4 ad atte3 m3 pti-3 ng to obtain backdo6 or di-3 scovery5 for other-3 ac3 ti-3 ons objec-3 tions which apply to each and4 ever-3 req-2 ue4 and are-3 in3 cor-2 porated in full by th3 is refere-3 n5 ce-6 int-3 ea3 ch an3 ever-3 resp6 onse be-2 low as f6 ull-3 se3 fort-2 therein:-9.3 Ranso-4 m8 objec-3 ts to Def4 e4 ndant non par-2 ty3 su4 bpoena as it plac-3 es an undue burde-2 on her-2 to have to sear-4 ch for the broa-2 scope-2 m8 ate-3 ri-3 al-5 requeste-2 m3 ost of which seeks-4 information that-4 is ir-3 relevan3 to the Def4 am7 at-7 ion Action a4 nd cle-3 a4 rl-3 in3 tende-3 so4 lely to har-2 as3 s4 em7 bar-2 ras-3 in3 ti-3 m8 idat-4 a4 nd oppre-2 ss thi-3 p5 arty by seeking highl-3 p5 ers-3 onal and4 sens-2 itive-6 inform7 ati-4 on Ranso-4 m8 ob-4 jec as she3 issue5 subpoena req-2 uests that a4 re int-3 end4 ed to3 obtain5 disc-3 ov5 ery-2 f8 or th3 dev4 elop-2 m8 ent of anothe-3 acti4 on re-2 lating to3 thi-3 p5 art-4 and are cle-2 a4 rl-3 unr3 e4 lat-4 ed to h5 is case Ranso-4 m8 e4 sp-3 onds o5 th3 eque3 sts as4 she rea-3 sona3 bly n5 ter-4 p5 rets and unders4 tands-3 the req-2 uests Should Def4 en-5 dant subse-2 q5 uentl-4 assert an int-3 erp-2 ret5 ati-4 on of any indi-3 vidual request that diff4 ers-3 fro-3 m8 her-2 under-2 s4 tanding she reser-3 ves the r5 ight-3 to suppl5 em7 ent he e4 sponse-2 To he ext-3 en4 a equest s4 eeks doc-3 um3 ents-3 protecte6 fro-3 m8 disc-3 over-2 by the-2 att-4 o5 rne-2 cli-4 en4 privile4 ge or-2 any4 ot3 her-2 privi4 lege or pr-2 o5 tection no such d5 ocum7 ents-3 shal-3 b3 pr-2 odu5 ced eve-3 if Case Document Filed Page of Bottom Subtype Footer Type Pagination BDC GS0 gs TT0 Tf Td TT1 Tf Tm Td EMC BDC TT0 Tf TD no speci-4 fic objec-3 tion is sserte-2 in response to e4 ach indi-3 v5 idu3 al req-2 u5 est-3 ver-2 tent id3 enti-4 fica4 ti-3 o5 n5 or pr-3 oductio5 of p3 ri-3 vil-3 eg4 ed docum6 en-5 ts or-4 inform7 ati-4 on is not-4 a waiver-4 of any appl-3 icab6 le privi-3 Ranso-4 m8 objec-3 ts to the Def4 ini-3 ti-3 ons and Ins-2 truct3 ions and to each Reque5 st to the exte-3 nt th3 ey seek to alter or expand upon the obli-3 ga4 ti-3 im6 posed by the Feder-2 al Rules of Civil-8 Proce-2 dure-2 Ranso-4 m8 objec-3 ts to the Def4 ini-3 ti-3 ons and Ins-2 truct3 ions and to each Reque5 st to the exte-3 nt that-4 it calls for th3 produc-2 ti6 on of docu-5 m8 ents-3 that-4 are-3 not in he4 cust-3 ody p5 osses-3 sion o5 contr-4 o5 A sta-3 tem5 ent in res ponse to3 a spe3 cific request that Ranso-4 m8 will-3 p5 roduc-2 d5 ocum7 ents-8 is not a state3 m8 ent that-4 any such docum7 ents-3 exis-3 but rat-4 h5 m8 eans only that-4 such do5 cum7 ents-3 that do exis-3 and are-3 responsive to a speci4 fic Request-2 will-3 be p4 roduced.-6.3 To the exte-3 n5 that-4 Ranso5 m8 produc-2 es docu-5 m8 ents-3 in res-3 ponse to3 speci-4 fic requests-2 to3 which she h5 as objected,3 Ransom8 eser-4 ves3 the ri-3 ght to m8 aint-4 ain su4 ch o5 bjec-3 tions wi5 th res-3 p5 ect to8 any additional inform7 and suc3 objecti-2 ons4 are-3 no5 wai4 ved by the produc-2 tion of res-3 ponsi-2 v5 docum7 ents-3 Ranso-4 m8 objec-3 ts to3 th3 req-2 uests to th3 extent4 th3 ey seek priv6 ate-3 and conf7 identia-2 financia-3 inform7 ati-4 on or ot-3 her-2 confid5 enti-4 a4 nfor6 m8 ati-4 on of3 an-5 Ranso-4 m8 ob-4 jec-3 ts to the requests-2 to th3 exte-3 nt th3 e4 seek per-2 so4 nal and-3 confidential financia-3 inform7 ati-4 on elated third3 par-2 ties.3 Ranso-4 m8 objec-3 ts to3 th3 requests to3 th3 extent that5 they seek d5 ocum7 ents-3 already in Def4 endant-3 posse-2 ssi-3 on o5 th3 ext-3 e4 nt hey a3 re p5 ubli-3 c4 ly ava-3 il6 able-3 Case Document Filed Page of Bottom Subtype Footer Type Pagination BDC GS0 gs TT0 Tf Td TT1 Tf Tm Td EMC BDC TT0 Tf Td TT2 Tf Tm TT0 Tf Td Ranso-4 m8 bjec-3 ts to the req-2 uest-3 a4 over-2 broa-2 d5 where ti-3 m8 li-3 m8 it-3 ha-5 not been3 spe-2 cified-4.667 T6 the exte-3 n5 th3 Court direct-2 s4 disc-3 ov5 e4 ry from9 thi-3 par-2 ty,3 it6 shoul-2 d5 lim9 it-3 ed to th3 date-3 of the f3 ili-3 ng of3 thi-3 a4 cti-4 on to he pre-2 sent-3 Ranso-4 m8 bjec-3 ts to th3 Request-2 as they seek to plac-3 an undue burde-2 on Ranso-4 m8 who a non-3 par-2 ty to pending lit-3 ig3 ati-4 RE4 SPONSES A3 ND OBJECTIONS-1.667 All Doc6 m8 ents-3 containi-2 ng Com5 m3 unica-3 ti-3 ons4 with Virgi6 nia Rober4 ts Giuff6 or any of he4 att-4 o5 rne-2 ys ag3 ents-3 inv3 esti4 gator-4 from3 the pe-3 riod pre-2 sen3 RE4 In addition to3 the Prel-3 im6 inar-4 Sta3 tement and General-4 Objec3 tions Ransom8 objec-3 ts to3 thi-3 req-2 uest-3 in th3 at she is a no5 par-2 ty and th3 is req-2 ue4 sts-3 seeks-3 fundam10 enta-3 ll-3 privil-2 eged comm5 unica-3 ti-3 on5 s4 between a par-2 ty and4 her-2 counse-2 Specifica-3 ll-3 y5 Ranso-4 m8 bjec-3 ts thi-3 s4 req-2 uest-3 on th3 grounds of pri-3 vilege,4 the work5 produ3 ct doc4 tri4 ne the comm5 on int-3 erest3 pri-3 v5 il-3 eg4 o5 any o5 ther pri-3 vi3 lege or prot-3 ec3 ti-3 on Ranso-4 m8 fur-3 ther obj3 ect-3 s4 to thi-3 s4 Request-2 in th3 at it is vague3 an4 am7 biguou-6 with res-3 pe4 ct to8 it-3 refere-3 nc4 e4 to Ransom8 objec-3 ts to3 th3 is Reques4 a4 over-2 broa-2 har-2 assing-5.667 a4 nd not cal-3 c4 ulat-4 ed to lead to disc-3 o5 rab-2 le evidence relev4 ant to th3 Def4 m8 ati-4 on Action Ransom8 objec-8 ts to thi-3 Re6 quest-3 to the exte-3 nt it seeks confidential-2 ial inform7 ati-4 on fro-3 m8 a par-2 ty Rans5 m8 objec-3 ts to thi-3 Requ6 est-3 in that it plac-3 es an un5 due burde-2 on thi-3 non2.3 par-2 ty incl-4 ud5 in3 for example req-2 u5 irin4 the p5 a4 rt-3 to3 search for docu-2 m8 which has be-2 en ve4 ry broa-2 dly de4 fined for a per-2 iod of tim10 la-3 ing more han seventee-2 ye4 ars W9 it-3 hout wa-3 ivi-3 ng such objec-3 tions Ranso-4 m8 is not in posse-2 ssi-3 on of any non-1 pri-3 vi3 leged-3 docum7 ents-3 re-2 sponsi-3 ve to3 thi-3 reques4 Case Document Filed Page of Bottom Subtype Footer Type Pagination BDC GS0 gs TT0 Tf Td TT1 Tf Tm Td EMC BDC TT0 Tf TD All fee6 ag4 ree-3 m8 ents-3 for Your engag3 em7 ents-3 with any a4 tt-3 o5 rneys for th3 p5 urpos-2 of pu5 rs-2 uing an4 y5 civil or cri-4 m8 inal-4 claim7 reg-2 ard-2 ing Jef6 frey Epstei-4 n5 Ghisl-2 aine-3 Maxwell-4 and RE4 In addition to3 the Prel-3 im1 inar-4 Sta3 tement and General-4 Objec3 tions Ransom8 objec-3 ts to3 thi-3 req-2 uest-3 in th3 at she is a no5 par-2 ty and th3 is req-2 ue4 sts-3 seeks-3 fundam10 enta-3 ll-3 privil-2 eged comm5 unica-3 ti-3 on5 s4 between a par-2 ty and4 her-2 counse-2 Specifica-3 lly Ranso-4 m8 objec-3 ts to this req-2 uest-3 on the ounds4 of pri-3 vilege,4 the work5 produ3 ct doc4 tri4 ne the comm5 on int-3 erest3 pri-3 v5 il-3 eg4 o5 any o5 ther pri-3 vi3 lege or prot-3 ec3 ti-3 on.5 Ranso-4 m8 further obj3 ect-3 s4 to thi-3 s4 Requ6 est-3 a4 ove4 rbroad harassing and no5 c4 alc-3 ul3 ate-3 d5 to3 lea-3 to d5 isc-3 o5 ver-2 able ev4 id3 ence rel-4 ev4 an4 to3 the Def4 am7 ti-3 on Action Ranso5 m8 objec-3 ts to3 this Reque5 st to he ex3 tent it-3 se3 eks on5 fidenti-3 a4 financ-2 ial infor4 m8 ati-4 on fro-3 m3 a party.5 W9 it-3 hout waiving such ob5 jec-3 tions a c4 opy of is attach3 ed h5 ere-3 to as RA4 NS3 whic-1 shoul-2 be treate-3 as Conf5 ident-4 ial pursuant to3 th3 e4 Ms Rans5 m8 res-3 erve6 the ri-3 gh5 to3 suppl-2 em7 ent th3 is respo6 nse shoul-2 d5 additiona-2 responsive-2 do5 cum7 enta-3 ti-3 on becom6 avai-4 lable All Docum9 ents-3 that-4 refere-3 nce rela4 te to or m8 en-5 ti-3 whethe3 by na-5 m8 or other-4 wise th3 following indi-3 vidu3 als:4 Virgi-3 nia R7 ober-2 ts Ghis4 lai-4 ne M4 axwell-3 Jeff4 rey-2 Epstei-4 and RE4 In addition to3 the Prel-3 im6 inar-4 Sta3 tement and General-4 Objec3 tions Ransom8 ts to3 thi-3 req-2 uest-3 in th3 at she is a no5 par-2 ty and th3 is req-2 ue4 sts-3 seeks-3 fundam10 enta-3 ll-3 privil-2 eged comm5 unica-3 ti-3 on5 s4 between a par-2 ty and4 her-2 counse-2 Specifica-3 ll-3 y5 Ranso-4 m8 bjec-3 ts to thi-3 s4 req-2 uest-3 on th3 grounds of pri-3 vilege,4 the work5 produ3 ct doc4 tri4 ne the m3 on int-3 erest3 pri-3 v5 il-3 eg4 o5 any o5 ther pri-3 vi3 lege or prot-3 ec3 ti-3 on.5 Ranso-4 m8 further-3 ob5 jects to th3 is Requ6 est-3 in that it is vagu4 and4 am7 biguous-2 with respec4 Case Document Filed Page of Bottom Subtype Footer Type Pagination BDC GS0 gs TT0 Tf Td TT1 Tf Tm Td EMC BDC TT0 Tf TD Ranso-4 m8 further-3 ob5 jects to3 thi-3 s4 Reque5 st as3 over-2 b5 road harassi-2 n5 not3 ca3 lcul-4 a4 ted to lead to disc-3 ove4 rable evide-3 n5 ce3 rel-4 evan3 to th3 Def4 m8 ati-4 on Action Ranso-4 m8 objec-3 ts to th3 is Request-2 to the ex4 tent it6 seeks confi5 denti-4 a4 finan5 cia-3 inform7 ati-4 on from9 a par-2 ty.3 Ranso-4 m8 objec-3 ts to3 th3 is Request-2 in th3 at it-3 places4 an undue den on this par-2 ty incl-4 ud5 ing for exam6 ple req-2 uiring th3 non par-2 ty to3 sear-4 ch a4 ll-4 docu-2 m8 ents-3 which has been br-3 o5 a4 dly de-2 W9 it-3 hout waiving such objec-3 tions all res-3 ponsi-2 v5 docum7 ents-3 in posse-2 ssi-3 on are-3 attach3 ed4 her-2 eto as NSOME-4 which shoul-2 be tr-3 ea3 ted a4 s4 All Com5 m3 unica-3 ti-3 ons4 You have had in what4 ever-3 form9 with any o5 th3 er fem10 ale-3 who you ever-3 witnes-3 sed a4 or in a property hom3 busi-2 ness-2 plane-3 or a4 utom6 other-4 veh4 icl-4 e4 owned or contr-4 o5 ll-3 ed b4 Jeff4 rey-2 Epste-2 in RE4 In addition to3 the Prel-3 im6 inar-4 Sta3 tement and General-4 Objec3 tions Ransom8 objec-3 ts to3 thi-3 req-2 uest in th3 at she is a n5 par-2 ty3 and4 thi-3 req-2 ues3 ts seeks-3 an u5 nli-3 m8 it-3 ed num3 ber-2 of-3 comm5 unica-3 ti-3 o5 ns be-1 tween a n5 par-2 ty3 and4 an unl3 im6 it-3 ed num8 ber-2 of unidentified indi-3 vidu3 als-5 Def4 endant-3 has m8 ade no5 eff5 ort-3 to spe3 cifica-3 lly identify a s4 ingle indi-3 v5 idual-4 and instead cas-2 ts an in3 credibl-2 un5 reasonabl-2 n5 e4 Ran-3 som7 objec-3 ts to thi-3 Req6 st in that-4 it plac-3 e4 an u5 ndue burde-2 on thi-3 non2.3 par-2 ty incl-4 ud5 in3 for example req-2 u5 irin4 the p5 a4 rt-3 to3 search for docu-2 m8 which has been broadly defined4 for an unspec-2 ified pe4 ri-3 o5 of ti-3 m8 his-4 req-2 ue4 st-4 is entire-2 ly un5 rea-3 sonab3 le and the v7 ry definition o5 over-2 ly broad Ransom3 further obj3 ect-3 to th3 is Request-2 in3 th3 at i5 is vag4 ue and am7 bigu-6 ous har-2 assi5 ng and not3 cal-3 cu4 lated to3 lea-3 to d5 iscoverable e4 videnc-3 rel-4 e4 vant to the Def4 m8 ati-4 on Acti-2 on All Com5 m3 unica-3 ti-3 ons4 You have had with3 Virginia Rober4 ts Ghisl-2 a4 in3 e4 Maxwell-4 Je3 ff6 rey-2 Epste-2 in3 or-4 RE4 Case Document Filed Page of Bottom Subtype Footer Type Pagination BDC GS0 gs TT0 Tf Td TT1 Tf Tm Td EMC BDC TT0 Tf TD In addition to3 the Prel-3 im6 inar-4 Sta3 tement and General-4 Objec3 tions Ransom8 objec-3 ts to3 thi-3 req-2 uest in3 th3 at she3 is a4 non-5 party and this req7 uest-3 seeks an unli-3 m8 it-3 e4 num8 ber-2 of unspec-2 ifie3 comm5 unica-3 ti-3 Specifi3 cal-3 ly Ranso5 m8 objec-3 ts to thi-3 req-2 u5 e4 st on the groun3 ds of pri-3 vil-3 ege th3 e4 work produ3 ct doctrin3 the comm5 on int-3 e4 res-3 pri-3 vi3 lege-3 o5 any oth3 er pri-3 vi3 o5 protection5 Ranso-4 m8 fur-3 ther-4 ob5 ject4 to this e4 quest-3 in that it-3 is vagu4 and am7 biguous-2 with res-3 pec3 to its-4 comm10 nica-3 tions-2 Ranso-4 m8 ob-4 jec-3 ts to thi-3 Request-2 as over-2 broa-2 ha4 ras-3 sing and4 not cal-3 cu4 lat5 ed to lea-3 to3 disc-3 overa6 ble evide-3 n5 c4 rel-4 ev4 ant to3 the Def4 am7 ati-4 on Action Ranso-4 m3 objec-3 ts th3 is Reques4 in3 that it plac6 es an undue burde-3 on th8 is pa4 rt-3 y5 incl-4 ud5 ing for exam6 ple,-7 req-2 uiring th3 party to search for comm10 uni-6 cat-3 ion3 which has be4 en4 broa-2 dly def7 ined for an4 unli-3 m8 it-3 ed pe3 ri-3 od of tim7 W9 it-3 hout waiving such objec-3 tions all res-3 ponsi-2 v5 docum7 ents-3 in posse-2 ssi-3 on are-3 attach3 ed4 her-2 eto as RA4 NSOME-4 which shoul-2 be tr-3 ea3 ted a4 s4 Any photogr-3 aphs containi-2 ng any im11 age Virgi-3 nia Rober4 ts Ghisl-2 aine Maxwell-4 Je3 ff6 rey-2 Epstei-4 or RE4 In addition to3 the Prel-3 im6 inar-4 Sta3 tement and General-4 Objec3 tions Ransom8 objec-3 ts to3 thi-3 req-2 ue-2 st in3 th3 at she3 is a4 party and this req7 uest-3 seeks an unli-3 m8 it-3 e4 num8 ber-2 of unspec-2 ifie3 photogr-3 aphs Ransom8 fur-3 ther obj3 ects to thi-3 s4 req-2 u5 est-3 in th3 at it is vague and am7 biguous-2 with respec4 to it-3 refere-3 n5 ce to all pho5 togr-3 aphs R7 ansom6 objec-3 ts to thi-3 R7 est-3 as ov5 erb-2 roa-2 ha4 rassing and not cal-3 cu4 lat5 ed to lea-3 to3 disc-3 overa6 ble evide-3 n5 c4 rel-4 ev4 ant to3 the Def4 am7 ati-4 on Action Ranso-4 m3 objec-3 ts th3 is Reques4 in3 that it plac6 es an undue burde-3 on th8 is pa4 rt-3 y5 incl-4 ud5 ing for exam6 ple,-7 req-2 uiring h5 party to sear-2 ch for photogr-3 aphs2 for an unlim9 it-3 ed per-3 iod3 of tim7 Case Document Filed Page of Bottom Subtype Footer Type Pagination BDC GS0 gs TT0 Tf Td TT1 Tf Tm Td EMC BDC TT0 Tf TD W9 it-3 hout waiving such3 objecti-2 ons,4 all respon6 sive-3 pho5 tog3 rap-2 hs in n5 par-2 ty3 Sa5 rah-2 which shoul-2 be4 tr-3 ea3 ted a4 Any photogr-3 aphs taken by You or containi-2 n5 any im6 ag-5 of You,-2 at in or near-3 any ho-4 m8 busi-2 ness-2 p5 rivate-2 veh4 icl-4 nc4 ludi-3 ng a4 irplane or a4 ny other-4 property wned6 or contr-4 o5 ll-3 e4 by Jeff4 rey-2 Epstei-4 RE4 In addition to3 the Prel-3 im6 inar-4 Sta3 tement and General-4 Objec3 tions Ransom8 objec-3 ts to3 thi-3 req-2 uest in3 th3 at she3 is a4 party and this req7 uest-3 seeks an unli-3 m8 it-3 e4 num8 ber-2 of unspec-2 ifie3 photogr-3 aphs3 Ransom8 fur-3 ther obj3 ects to thi-3 s4 req-2 u5 est-3 in th3 at it is vague and am7 biguous-2 with respec4 to it-3 reference to any photogr-3 aphs3 Ranso-4 m8 objec-3 ts to th3 is Request-2 as over-2 broad har-2 assi-4 ng5 and not c4 alculat-3 ed4 to lead to discove5 rab-2 le evide-3 n5 ce relevan3 to3 the Def4 amation c4 ti-3 on5 Ransom8 objec-3 ts th3 is Reques4 in3 that it plac6 es an undue burde-3 on th8 is pa4 rt-3 y5 incl-4 ud5 ing for exam6 ple,-7 req-2 uiring h5 party to searc-2 for photogr-3 aphs2 for an unlim9 it-3 ed per-3 iod3 of tim7 W9 it-3 hout waiving such3 objecti-2 ons-6 all respon6 sive-3 pho5 tog3 phs in n5 on-2 par-2 ty3 Sa5 rah-2 Any photogr-3 aphs that5 depic-3 any ho-4 m8 busi-2 pri-3 v5 ate-3 vehic-3 le n5 cluding air-4 p5 lane or any4 other-4 prop3 erty owned or contr-4 o5 ll-3 ed b4 Jeff4 rey-2 Epste-2 in RE4 In addition to3 the Prel-3 im6 inar-4 Sta3 tement and General-4 Objec3 tions Ransom8 objec-3 ts to3 thi-3 req-2 uest in3 th3 at she3 is a4 party and this req7 uest-3 seeks an unli-3 m8 it-3 e4 num8 ber-2 of unspec-2 ifie3 photogr-3 aphs3 Ransom8 fur-3 ther obj3 ects to thi-3 s4 req-2 u5 est-3 in th3 at it is vague and am7 biguous-2 with respec4 to it-3 reference to any photogr-3 aphs3 Ranso-4 m8 objec-3 ts to th3 is Request-2 as over-2 broad har-2 assi-4 ng5 Case Document Filed Page of Bottom Subtype Footer Type Pagination BDC GS0 gs TT0 Tf Td TT1 Tf Tm Td EMC BDC TT0 Tf TD and not c4 alculat-3 ed4 to lead to discove5 rab-2 le evide-3 n5 ce relevan3 to3 the Def4 amation Ac6 ti-3 on5 Ransom8 objec-3 ts th3 is Reques4 in3 that it plac6 es an undue burde-3 on th8 is pa4 rt-3 y5 incl-4 ud5 ing for exam6 ple,-7 re quiring h5 party to searc-2 for photogr-3 aphs3 for an unlim9 it-3 ed per-3 iod3 of tim7 W9 it-3 hout waiving such3 objecti-2 ons,4 all respon6 sive-3 pho5 tog3 rap-2 hs in n5 par-2 ty3 Sa5 rah-2 which should be tr-3 e4 ate-3 d5 as Co All of Yo7 ur pass-2 po5 rt-3 travel visas,5 or p5 erm5 iss-3 io3 ns to li-3 v5 work or s4 tu3 dy in a forei3 gn country rel-4 a4 ted th3 year-4 pre-2 sen3 RE4 In addition to3 the Prel-3 im6 inar-4 Sta3 tement and General-4 Objec3 tions Ransom8 objec-3 ts to3 thi-3 req-2 uest-3 in h5 at he is-3 a par-2 ty and this equest5 see-3 ks nform9 ati-4 on tha-2 cl-3 early not rel-2 evan3 o5 the underlying act-3 io3 Ransom8 objec-3 ts to Def4 endant-3 be4 ing3 per-2 m8 ted to3 uti-3 lize4 the under-2 ly3 ing3 act-3 ion to ob5 tai-4 backdo3 or disc-3 over-2 y5 int-3 a separat-2 ac3 ti-3 on e4 nti-3 rely unrel5 ate-3 to whet4 her-2 or not Maxwell-4 de4 fa-2 ed Virgi-3 nia Roberts-3 Giuff6 Ra-3 nsom7 further-3 objects to3 thi-3 request in that-4 th3 e4 face of the request dem7 onst-2 rates at the Def4 endant-3 is abusi-3 n5 the subpo4 ena power b5 ser-3 ving a4 subpoena o5 a p5 arty that s4 eek3 disc-3 ov5 ery-2 unre-2 lated to3 the und5 erl-4 y5 ing m8 att-4 but instea3 d5 all-4 eg4 edly rel5 evant-3 to no5 ther-5 Fede4 ral Action styl5 ed JANE3 DOE Jef-3 frey Epstei5 Ghisl-2 aine Max-2 well Case Num5 er cv JGK S.D.N3 Ransom8 bjec-3 ts to this Request-2 a4 s4 over-2 broa-2 har-2 assing a4 nd not ca3 lculate-3 to lead to disc-3 ove4 rable evide-3 n5 ce3 rel-4 evan3 to th3 Def4 m8 ati-4 on Action Ranso-4 m8 objec-3 ts to th3 is Request-2 in that-4 it-1 represents a com7 let-4 invas-3 io3 of pri-3 vacy A par-2 ty shoul-2 no5 be subj-2 ec3 ted to undue4 har-2 assm5 ent erv-2 ing no ad-2 m8 iss-3 ibl-3 pu4 rpos-2 Case Document Filed Page of Bottom Subtype Footer Type Pagination BDC GS0 gs TT0 Tf Td TT1 Tf Tm Td EMC BDC TT0 Tf TD W9 it-3 hout waiving such objec-3 tions a copy of is attach3 ed her-2 eto as R7 AN4 which shoul-2 be4 tr-3 ea3 ted as Conf5 ident-4 ial Or5 der-3 All Co7 m3 m3 unica-3 ti-3 o5 ns regardi-2 n5 any of Y7 our pass-2 po5 rts v5 isa-3 vi3 sa app4 li-3 ca3 tions or oth3 er per-2 m8 iss-3 ion to live-3 work or tudy a4 foreign u5 ntr-3 for the year-3 pre-2 sent-3 RE4 In addition to3 the Prel-3 im6 inar-4 Sta3 tement and General-4 Objec3 tions Ransom8 objec-3 ts to3 thi-3 req-2 uest-3 in h5 at he is-3 a par-2 ty and this equest5 see-3 ks nform9 ati-4 on tha-2 cl-3 early not rel-2 evan3 o5 the underlying tion Ransom8 objec-3 ts to Def4 endant-3 be4 ing3 per-2 m8 it-3 ted to3 uti-3 lize4 the under-2 ly3 ing3 act-3 ion to ob5 tai-4 backdo3 or disc-3 over-2 y5 int-3 a separat-2 ac3 ti-3 on e4 nti-3 rely unrel5 ate-3 to whet4 her-2 or not Maxwell-4 de4 fa-2 m8 ed Virgi-3 nia Roberts-3 Giuff6 Ra-3 nsom7 further-3 objects to3 thi-3 request in that-4 th3 e4 face of the request dem7 onst-2 rates that the Def4 endant-3 is abusi-3 n5 the subpo4 ena power b5 ser-3 ving a4 subpoena o5 a p5 arty that s4 eek3 disc-3 ov5 ery-2 unre-2 lated to3 the und5 erl-4 y5 ing m8 att-4 but instea3 d5 all-4 eg4 edly rel5 evant-3 to ano4 ther-4 Fede4 ral Action styl5 ed JANE3 DOE Jef-3 frey Epstei5 Ghisl-2 aine Max-2 well Case Num5 er cv JGK S.D.N3 Ransom8 bjec-3 ts to this Request-2 a4 s4 over-2 broa-2 har-2 assing a4 nd not ca3 lculate-3 to lead to disc-3 ove4 rable evide-3 n5 ce3 rel-4 evan3 to th3 Def4 m8 ati-4 on Action Ranso-4 m8 objec-3 ts to th3 is Request-2 in that-4 it represents a com7 let-4 invas-3 io3 of pri-3 vacy A par-2 ty shoul-2 no5 be subj-2 ec3 ted to undue4 har-2 assm5 ent erv-2 ing no ad-2 m8 iss-3 ibl-3 pu4 rpos-2 All Docu-5 m8 ents-3 re-2 fer5 enci-3 ng any c3 m3 m8 erc-3 ial-4 p5 lane-3 t3 cke3 ts boarding passes or-4 any other-4 m8 ode of trave-2 du3 ring the ti-3 m8 per-3 iod RE4 In addition to3 the Prel-3 im6 inar-4 Sta3 tement and General-4 Objec3 tions Ransom8 objec-3 ts to3 thi-3 req-2 uest-3 in h5 at he is-3 a par-2 ty and this equest5 see-3 ks nform9 ati-4 that-4 is lea-3 rly not4 re-2 leva-3 n5 o5 the underlying act-3 io3 Ransom8 objec-3 ts to Def4 endant-3 be4 ing3 per-2 m8 it-3 ted to3 uti-3 lize4 the under-2 ly3 ing3 Case Document Filed Page of Bottom Subtype Footer Type Pagination BDC GS0 gs TT0 Tf Td TT1 Tf Tm Td EMC BDC TT0 Tf TD act-3 ion to ob5 tai-4 backdo3 or disc-3 over-2 y5 int-3 a separat-2 ac3 ti-3 on e4 nti-3 rely unrel5 ate-3 to whet4 her-2 or not Maxwell-4 de4 fa-2 m8 ed Virgi-3 nia Roberts-11.667 Giuff6 Ra-3 nsom7 further-3 objects to3 thi-3 request in that-4 th3 e4 face of the request dem7 onst-2 rates that the Def4 endant-3 is abusi-3 n5 the subpo4 ena power b5 ser-3 ving a4 subpoena o5 a p5 arty that s4 eek3 disc-3 ov5 ery-2 unre-2 lated to3 the und5 erl-4 y5 ing m8 att-4 but instea3 d5 all-4 eg3 edly rel5 evant-3 to ano4 ther-4 Fede4 ral Action styl5 ed JANE3 DOE Jef-3 frey Epstei5 Ghisl-2 aine Max-2 well Case Num5 er cv JGK S.D.N3 Ransom8 bjec-3 ts to this Request-2 a4 s4 over-2 broa-2 har-2 assing a4 nd not a4 lculate-3 to lead to disc-3 ove4 rable evide-3 n5 ce3 rel-4 evan3 to th3 Def4 m8 ati-4 on Action Ranso-4 m8 objec-3 ts to th3 is Request-2 in that-4 it represents a com7 let-4 invas-3 io3 of pri-3 vacy A par-2 ty shoul-2 no5 be subj-2 ec3 ted to undue4 har-2 assm5 ent erv-2 ing no ad-2 m8 iss-3 ibl-3 pu4 rpos-2 W9 it-3 hout waiving such objec-3 tions all res-3 ponsi-2 v5 docum7 ents-3 in posse-2 ssi-3 on a4 re attached her-2 eto as R7 AN4 which-5 Any cre-3 d5 it-3 car-3 d5 recei3 pt can3 cel-3 ed4 check o5 an4 other Doc6 m8 ent reflecti-2 ng tr-3 av4 el b5 You duri-3 n5 g5 the tim6 per-3 iod RE4 In addition to3 the Prel-3 im6 inar-4 Sta3 tement and General-4 Objec3 tions Ransom8 objec-3 ts to3 thi-3 req-2 uest-3 in h5 at he is-3 a par-2 ty and this equest5 see-3 ks nform9 ati-4 on tha-2 cl-3 early not rel-2 evan3 o5 the underlying act-3 io3 Ransom8 objec-3 ts to Def4 endant-3 be4 ing3 per-2 m8 it-3 ted to3 uti-3 lize4 the under-2 ly3 ing3 act-3 ion to ob5 tai-4 backdo3 or disc-3 over-2 y5 int-3 a separat-2 ac3 ti-3 on e4 nti-3 rely unrel5 ate-3 to whet4 or not Maxwell-4 de4 fa-2 m8 ed Virgi-3 nia Roberts-3 Giuff6 Ra-3 nsom7 further-3 objects to3 thi-3 request in that-4 th3 e4 face of the request dem7 onst-2 rates that the Def4 endant-3 is abusi-3 n5 the subpo4 ena power b5 ser-3 ving a4 subpoena o5 a p5 arty that s4 eek3 disc-3 ov5 ery-2 unre-2 lated to3 the und5 erl-4 y5 ing m8 att-4 but instea3 d5 all-4 eg4 edly rel5 evant-3 to ano4 ther-4 Fede4 ral Action styl5 ed JANE3 DOE Jef-3 frey Epstei5 Ghisl-2 aine Case Document Filed Page of Bottom Subtype Footer Type Pagination BDC GS0 gs TT0 Tf Td TT1 Tf Tm Td EMC BDC TT2 Tf TD Max-2 well Case Num5 er cv JGK S.D.N3 Ranso-4 m8 fur-3 ther-4 o5 bject4 to-8 th3 is Req6 uest-3 as ov5 erbroad haras5 sing and no5 calculated to lea-3 to d5 isc-3 overable evide-3 nce rel5 evant-3 to the Def4 m8 ati-4 on Action ansom6 obj-6 ect-3 to th3 is Request-2 in that ep4 resents com7 pl-6 ete-3 invasion of privac-3 A par-2 ty sho-2 uld not-3 be subj-3 ected5 to und-2 ue harassm6 ent erv-2 ing no dm3 iss-3 ib3 le pur-4 p5 s4 eek pri-3 v5 ate-3 and confident-2 ial5 financia-3 in3 for-3 m8 ati-4 on or other-4 dential info6 rm6 ati-4 on of ny kind fro-3 m3 thi-3 par-2 ty Rans5 m8 further objec-3 ts on the bas3 is th3 at he confident-2 ial and pri-3 va4 te fina5 ncia-3 rec-3 o5 rds-2 sought-2 by Def4 endant-3 relati-4 ng to th3 is par-2 ty ha4 ve no rel-4 eva3 nce to proving the alleg4 ati-4 ons in he4 com7 plai-4 nt and are-3 not di3 scove-2 rable DeLeonardis-2 Hara N.Y4 S.3d N.Y App Di All phon5 rec-3 o5 rds-2 for6 any ce3 ll-3 pho5 ne owned used or pos4 se3 ssed by You7 duri-3 ng the-2 y5 ear-3 RE4 In addition to3 the Prel-3 im6 inar-4 Sta3 tement and General-4 Objec3 tions Ransom8 objec-3 ts to3 thi-3 req-2 uest-3 in h5 at he is-3 a par-2 ty and this equest5 see-3 ks nform9 ati-4 on tha-2 cl-3 early not rel-2 evan3 o5 the underlying act-3 io3 Ransom8 objec-3 ts to Def4 endant-3 be4 ing3 per-2 m8 ted to3 uti-3 lize4 the under-2 ly3 ing3 act-3 ion to ob5 tai-4 backdo3 or disc-3 over-2 y5 int-3 a separat-2 ac3 ti-3 on e4 nti-3 rely unrel5 ate-3 to whet4 her-2 or not Maxwell-4 de4 fa-2 m8 ed Virgi-3 nia Roberts-3 Giuff6 Ra-3 nsom7 further-3 objects to3 thi-3 request in that-4 th3 e4 face of the request dem7 onst-2 rates at the Def4 endant-3 is abusi-3 n5 the subpo4 ena power b5 ser-3 ving a4 subpoena o5 a p5 arty that s4 eek3 disc-3 ov5 ery-2 unre-2 lated to3 the und5 erl-4 y5 ing m8 att-4 but instea3 d5 all-4 eg4 edly rel5 evant-3 to ano4 ther-4 Fede4 ral Action styl5 ed JANE3 DOE Jef-3 frey Epstei5 Ghisl-2 aine Max-2 well Case Num5 er cv JGK S.D.N3 Ransom8 bjec-3 ts to this Request-2 a4 s4 over-2 broa-2 har-2 assing a4 nd not ca3 lculate-3 to lead Case Document Filed Page of Bottom Subtype Footer Type Pagination BDC GS0 gs TT0 Tf Td TT1 Tf Tm Td EMC BDC TT0 Tf TD to disc-3 ove4 rable evide-3 n5 ce3 rel-4 evan3 to th3 Def4 m8 ati-4 on Action Ranso-4 m8 objec-3 ts to th3 is Request-2 in that-4 it represents a com7 let-4 invas-3 io3 of pri-3 vacy A par-2 ty shoul-2 no5 be subj-2 ec3 ted to undue4 har-2 assm5 ent erv-2 ing no ad-2 m8 iss-3 ibl-3 pu4 rpos-2 W9 it-3 hout waiving such o5 bjec-3 tions Ransom8 is ot in posse-2 s4 sion of docum7 ents-3 res-3 ponsi-2 ve4 to his reque3 st All Doc6 m8 ents-3 refl3 ect-3 ing3 or relating to3 an4 Co-2 m3 m8 uni-6 cat-3 ion3 betw4 een Jeff4 rey-2 Epstei-4 n5 o5 Ghisl-2 aine M5 axwell-3 and e3 it-3 he4 of Y3 ou-4 pa-2 rents ste5 par-2 en4 ts or-4 other-4 fam10 il-3 m8 m8 ber-2 RE4 In addition to3 the Prel-3 im6 inar-4 Sta3 tement and General-4 Objec3 tions Ransom8 objec-3 ts to3 thi-3 req-2 uest-3 in h5 at he is-3 a par-2 ty and this equest5 see-3 ks nform9 ati-4 on tha-2 cl-3 early not rel-2 evan3 o5 the underlying act-3 io3 Ransom2.3 objec-3 ts to Def4 endant-3 be4 ing3 per-2 m8 it-3 ted to3 uti-3 lize4 the under-2 ly3 ing3 act-3 ion to ob5 tai-4 backdo3 or disc-3 over-2 y5 int-3 a separat-2 ac3 ti-3 on e4 nti-3 rely unrel5 ate-3 to whet4 her-2 or not Maxwell-4 de4 fa-2 m8 ed Virgi-3 nia Roberts-3 Giuff6 Ra-3 nsom7 further-3 objects to3 thi-3 request in that-4 th3 e4 face of the request dem7 onst-2 rates that the Def4 endant-3 is abusi-3 n5 the subpo4 ena power b5 ser-3 ving a4 subpoena o5 a p5 arty that s4 eek3 disc-3 ov5 ery-2 unre-2 lated to3 the und5 erl-4 y5 ing m8 att-4 but instea3 d5 all-4 eg4 edly rel5 evant-3 to ano4 ther-4 Fede4 ral Action styl5 ed JANE3 DOE eff-4 re3 Epstei5 Ghisl-2 aine Max-2 well Case Num5 er cv JGK S.D.N3 Ransom8 bjec-3 ts to this Request-2 a4 s4 over-2 broa-2 har-2 assing a4 nd not ca3 lculate-3 to lead to disc-3 ove4 rable evide-3 n5 ce3 rel-4 evan3 to th3 Def4 m8 ati-4 on Action Ranso-4 m8 objec-3 ts to th3 is Request-2 in that-4 it represents a com7 let-4 invas-3 io3 of pri-3 vacy A par-2 ty shoul-2 no5 subj-2 ec3 ted to undue4 har-2 assm5 ent erv-2 ing no ad-2 m8 iss-3 ibl-3 pu4 rpos-2 W9 it-3 hout waiti-4 ng5 such objec-3 tions Ranso-4 m8 is not in po5 sses-3 sion of any docu4 m8 ents-8 res-3 ponsi-2 v5 to this-2 reques5 Case Document Filed Page of Bottom Subtype Footer Type Pagination BDC GS0 gs TT0 Tf Td TT1 Tf Tm Td EMC BDC TT0 Tf TD All Docu-5 m8 ents-3 re-2 fle5 cti-4 ng any m7 oney paym6 nt val-4 uab4 le conside-2 rat5 io3 or ot-3 her-2 m3 uner-2 ati-4 on rec-3 e4 ived by Y4 ou fro-3 m8 Je-6 ff6 rey-2 Epste-2 in3 or ny person know3 by You to be aff4 il-3 iat-4 ed wi4 th Je-3 ff6 rey-2 Epstei-4 RE4 In addition to3 the Prel-3 im6 inar-4 Sta3 tement and General-4 Objec3 tions Ransom8 objec-3 ts to3 thi-3 req-2 uest-3 in h5 at he is-3 a par-2 ty and th-1 is equest5 see-3 ks nform9 ati-4 on tha-2 cl-3 early not rel-2 evan3 o5 the underlying act-3 io3 Ransom8 objec-3 ts to Def4 endant-3 be4 ing3 per-2 m8 it-3 ted to3 uti-3 lize4 the under-2 ly3 ing3 act-3 ion to ob5 tai-4 backdo3 or disc-3 over-2 y5 int-3 a separat-2 ac3 ti-3 on e4 nti-3 rely unrel5 ate-3 to whet4 her-2 or not Maxw ell-4 de4 fa-2 m8 ed Virgi-3 nia Roberts-3 Giuff6 Ra-3 nsom7 further-3 objects to3 thi-3 request in that-4 th3 e4 face of the request dem7 onst-2 rates that the Def4 endant-3 is abusi-3 n5 the subpo4 ena power b5 ser-3 ving a4 subpoena o5 a p5 arty that s4 eek3 disc-3 ov5 ery-2 unre-2 lated to3 the und5 erl-4 y5 ng m8 att-4 but instea3 d5 all-4 eg4 edly rel5 evant-3 to ano4 ther-4 Fede4 ral Action styl5 ed JANE3 DOE Jef-3 frey Epstei5 Ghisl-2 aine Max-2 well Case Num5 er cv JGK S.D.N3 Ransom8 bjec-3 ts to this Request-2 a4 s4 rbr-3 oad,4 har-2 assing a4 nd not ca3 lculate-3 to lead to disc-3 ove4 rable evide-3 n5 ce3 rel-4 evan3 to th3 Def4 m8 ati-4 on Action Ranso-4 m8 objec-3 ts to th3 is Request-2 in that-4 it represents a com7 let-4 invas-3 io3 of pri-3 vacy A par-2 ty shoul-2 no5 be subj-2 ec3 ted to undue4 har-2 assm5 ent erv-2 no a4 m8 iss-3 ibl-3 pu4 rpos-2 confident-2 ial5 financia-3 in3 for-3 m8 ati-4 on or other-4 dential info6 rm6 ati-4 on of ny kind fro-3 m3 thi-3 par-2 ty Rans5 m8 further objec-3 ts on the bas3 is th3 at confident-2 ial and pri-3 va4 te fina5 ncia-3 rec-3 o5 rds-2 sought-2 by Def4 endant-3 relati-4 ng to th3 is par-2 ty ha4 ve no rel-4 eva3 nce to proving the alleg4 ati-4 ons in he4 com7 plai-4 nt and are-3 not di3 scove-2 rable DeLeonardis-2 Hara N.Y4 S.3d N.Y App Div-4 All bank4 sta-3 tem10 ents-3 cre-3 di3 ca3 rd s4 tat-4 em7 ents-3 m3 oney tr-3 ans3 fer rec-3 ords or other stat4 em7 ents-3 fro-3 any financi-3 a4 nstitu3 ti-3 on in3 Your name in whole or part f3 or he ye3 ars-3 Case Document Filed Page of RE4 In addition to3 the Prel-3 im6 inar-4 Sta3 tement and General-4 Objec3 ons Ransom8 objec-3 ts to3 thi-3 req-2 uest-3 in h5 at he is-3 a par-2 ty and this equest5 see-3 ks nform9 ati-4 on tha-2 cl-3 early not rel-2 evan3 o5 the underlying act-3 io3 Ransom8 objec-3 ts to Def4 endant-3 be4 ing3 per-2 m8 it-3 ted to3 uti-3 lize4 the under-2 ly3 ing3 act-3 ion to ob5 tai-4 backdo3 or over-2 y5 int-3 a separat-2 ac3 ti-3 on e4 nti-3 rely unrel5 ate-3 to whet4 her-2 or not Maxwell-4 de4 fa-2 m8 ed Virgi-3 nia Roberts-3 Giuff6 Ra-3 nsom7 further-3 objects to3 thi-3 request in that-4 th3 e4 face of the request dem7 onst-2 rates that the Def4 endant-3 is abusi-3 n5 the subpo4 ena power b5 ser-3 ving a4 subpoena o5 a p5 arty that s4 eek3 disc-3 ov5 ery-2 unre-2 lated to3 the und5 erl-4 y5 ing m8 att-4 but instea3 d5 all-4 eg4 edly rel5 evant-3 to ano4 ther-4 Fede4 ral Action styl5 ed JANE3 DOE Jef-3 frey Epstei5 Ghisl-2 aine Max-2 well Case Num5 er-5 cv JGK S.D.N3 Ransom8 bjec-3 ts to this Request-2 a4 s4 over-2 broa-2 har-2 assing a4 nd not ca3 lculate-3 to lead to disc-3 ove4 rable evide-3 n5 ce3 rel-4 evan3 to th3 Def4 m8 ati-4 on Action Ranso-4 m8 objec-3 ts to th3 is Request-2 in that-4 it represents a com7 let-4 invas-3 io3 of ivac-3 A par-2 ty shoul-2 no5 be subj-2 ec3 ted to undue4 har-2 assm5 ent erv-2 ing no ad-2 m8 iss-3 ibl-3 pu4 rpos-2 confident-2 ial5 financia-3 in3 for-3 m8 ati-4 on or other-4 dential info6 rm6 ati-4 on of ny ind fro-3 m3 thi-3 non-5 par-2 ty Rans5 m8 further objec-3 ts on the bas3 is th3 at the confident-2 ial and pri-3 va4 te fina5 ncia-3 rec-3 o5 rds-2 sought-2 by Def4 endant-3 relati-4 ng to th3 is par-2 ty ha4 ve no rel-4 eva3 nce to proving the alleg4 ati-4 ons in he4 com7 plai-4 nt and are-3 not di3 scove-2 rable DeLeo1 nardi-2 Hara N.Y4 S.3d N.Y App Div-4 Any Doc-3 um8 ents-3 co-5 ncer-3 ning Your res-3 idency6 duri-3 ng the year-3 incl-4 u5 ding lea-3 ses,7 ren-2 tal agree5 m8 ents-3 re-2 nt paym5 ents-3 deeds or-4 t3 rusts RE4 Case Document Filed Page of Bottom Subtype Footer Type Pagination BDC GS0 gs TT0 Tf Td TT1 Tf Tm Td EMC BDC TT0 Tf TD In addition to3 the Prel-3 im6 inar-4 Sta3 tement and General-4 Objec3 tions Ransom8 objec-3 ts to3 thi-3 req-2 uest-3 in h5 at he is-3 a par-2 ty and this equest5 see-3 ks nform9 ati-4 on tha-2 cl-3 early not rel-2 evan3 o5 the underlying act-3 io3 Ransom8 objec-3 ts to Def4 endant-3 be4 ing3 per-2 m8 it-3 ted to3 uti-3 lize4 the under-2 ly3 ing3 act-3 ion to b5 tai-4 backdo3 or disc-3 over-2 y5 int-3 a separat-2 ac3 ti-3 on e4 nti-3 rely unrel5 ate-3 to whet4 her-2 or not Maxwell-4 de4 fa-2 m8 ed Virgi-3 nia Roberts-3 Giuff6 Ra-3 nsom7 further-3 objects to3 thi-3 request in that-4 th3 e4 face of the request dem7 onst-2 rates that the Def4 endant-3 is abusi-3 n5 the subpo4 ena power b5 ser-3 ving a4 subpoena o5 a p5 arty that s4 eek3 disc-3 ov5 ery-2 unre-2 lated to3 the und5 erl-4 y5 ing m8 att-4 but instea3 d5 all-4 eg4 edly rel5 evant-3 to ano4 ther-4 Fede4 ral Action styl5 ed JANE3 DOE Jef-3 frey Epstei5 Ghisl-2 aine Max-2 well Case Num5 er cv JGK S.D.N3 Ransom8 bjec-3 ts to this Request-2 a4 s4 over-2 broa-2 har-2 assing a4 nd not ca3 lculate-3 to lead to disc-3 ove4 rable evide-3 n5 ce3 rel-4 evan3 to th3 Def4 m8 ati-4 on Action Ranso-4 m8 objec-3 ts to th3 is Request-2 in that-4 it represents a com7 let-4 invas-3 io3 of pri-3 vacy A par-2 ty shoul-2 no5 subj-2 ec3 ted to undue4 har-2 assm5 ent erv-2 ing no ad-2 m8 iss-3 ibl-3 pu4 rpos-2 RE4 In addition to3 the Prel-3 im6 inar-4 Sta3 tement and General-4 Objec3 tions Ransom8 objec-3 ts to3 thi-3 req-2 uest-3 in h5 at he is-3 a par-2 ty and this equest5 see-3 ks nform9 ati-4 on tha-2 cl-3 early not rel-2 evan3 o5 the underlying act-3 io3 Ransom8 objec-3 ts to Def4 endant-3 be4 ing3 per-2 m8 ted to3 uti-3 lize4 the under-2 ly3 ing3 act-3 ion to ob5 tai-4 backdo3 or disc-3 over-2 y5 int-3 a separat-2 ac3 ti-3 on e4 nti-3 rely unrel5 ate-3 to whet4 her-2 or not Maxwell-4 de4 fa-2 m8 ed Virgi-3 nia Roberts-3 Giuff6 Ra-3 nsom7 further-3 objects to3 thi-3 request in that-4 th3 e4 face of the request dem7 onst-2 rates at the Def4 endant-3 is abusi-3 n5 the subpo4 ena power b5 ser-3 ving a4 subpoena o5 a p5 arty that s4 eek3 disc-3 ov5 ery-2 unre-2 lated to3 the und5 erl-4 y5 ing m8 att-4 but instea3 d5 all-4 eg4 edly rel5 evant-3 to ano4 ther-4 Fede4 ral Action styl5 ed JANE3 DOE Jef-3 frey Epstei5 Ghisl-2 aine Max-2 well Case Num5 er cv JGK Case Document Filed Page of Bottom Subtype Footer Type Pagination BDC GS0 gs TT0 Tf Td TT1 Tf Tm Td EMC BDC TT0 Tf TD S.D.N3 Ransom8 bjec-3 ts to this Request-2 a4 s4 over-2 broa-2 har-2 assing a4 nd not ca3 lculate-3 to lead to disc-3 ove4 rable evide-3 n5 ce3 rel-4 evan3 to th3 Def4 m8 ati-4 on Action Ranso-4 m8 objec-3 ts to th3 is Request-2 in that-4 it represents a com7 let-4 invas-3 io3 of pri-3 vacy A par-2 ty shoul-2 no5 be subj-2 ec3 ted to undue4 har-2 assm5 ent erv-2 ing no ad-2 m8 iss-3 ibl-3 pu4 rpos-2 will-3 b5 produc-2 ed a4 her-2 deposi-3 in3 thi-3 m7 att-4 er Any Docu-3 m8 ent reflecti-2 ng any of Your s4 econdar-4 tr-3 a4 ini-3 ng or edu4 cat-3 ion3 al deg4 ree-3 or cour-2 s4 of study-2 to3 in3 clude-3 tr-3 an4 s4 cri-4 p5 ts paym7 ents-3 for tuition cour-2 se3 taken da4 tes-3 of att-4 endan3 c4 and g5 rad-2 es3 rec-3 e4 ived RE4 In addition to3 the-6 Prel-3 im6 inar-4 Sta3 tement and General-4 Objec3 tions Ransom8 objec-3 ts to3 thi-3 req-2 uest-3 in h5 at he is-3 a par-2 ty and this equest5 see-3 ks nform9 ati-4 on tha-2 cl-3 early not rel-2 evan3 o5 the underlying act-3 io3 Ransom8 objec-3 ts to Def4 endant-3 be4 ing3 per-2 m8 it-3 ted to3 uti-3 lize4 under-2 ly3 ing3 act-3 ion to ob5 tai-4 backdo3 or disc-3 over-2 y5 int-3 a separat-2 ac3 ti-3 on e4 nti-3 rely unrel5 ate-3 to whet4 her-2 or not Maxwell-4 de4 fa-2 m8 ed Virgi-3 nia Roberts-3 Giuff6 Ra-3 nsom7 further-3 objects to3 thi-3 request in that-4 th3 e4 face of the request dem7 onst-2 rates that the Def4 endant-3 abusi-3 n5 the subpo4 ena power b5 ser-3 ving a4 subpoena o5 a p5 arty that s4 eek3 disc-3 ov5 ery-2 unre-2 lated to3 the und5 erl-4 y5 ing m8 att-4 but instea3 d5 all-4 eg4 edly rel5 evant-3 to ano4 ther-4 Fede4 ral Action styl5 ed JANE3 DOE Jef-3 frey Epstei5 Ghisl-2 aine Max-2 well Case Num5 er cv JGK S.D.N3 Ransom8 bjec-3 ts to this Request-2 a4 s4 over-2 broa-2 har-2 assing a4 nd not ca3 lculate-3 to lead to disc-3 ove4 rable evide-3 n5 ce3 rel-4 evan3 to th3 Def4 m8 ati-4 on Action Ranso-4 m8 objec-3 ts to th3 is Request-2 in th at it represents a com7 let-4 invas-3 io3 of pri-3 vacy A par-2 ty shoul-2 no5 be subj-2 ec3 ted to undue4 har-2 assm5 ent erv-2 ing no ad-2 m8 iss-3 ibl-3 pu4 rpos-2 Any appli-4 ca3 ti-3 on for coll-4 eg4 uni3 ver-2 sity or a4 ny other-4 pos4 secondary inst-4 itut4 ion or tec-3 hn5 ical4 coll-4 eg4 fash6 ion co4 ll-3 ege,3 m3 odeli-4 ng tra5 ini-3 ng o5 any4 sim5 il-3 ar in3 stit3 uti-3 on subm7 tt-3 ed4 by You or on Your5 behal-3 durin4 the ye-3 a4 rs-2 pre-2 sen3 Case Document Filed Page of RE4 In ad-2 dition to3 the Prel-3 im6 inar-4 Sta3 tement and General-4 Objec3 tions Ransom8 objec-3 ts to3 thi-3 req-2 uest-3 in h5 at he is-3 a par-2 ty and this equest5 see-3 ks nform9 ati-4 on tha-2 cl-3 early not rel-2 evan3 o5 the underlying act-3 io3 Ransom8 objec-3 ts to Def4 endant-3 be4 ing3 per-2 m8 it-3 ted uti-3 lize4 the under-2 ly3 ing3 act-3 ion to ob5 tai-4 backdo3 or disc-3 over-2 y5 int-3 a separat-2 ac3 ti-3 on e4 nti-3 rely unrel5 ate-3 to whet4 her-2 or not Maxwell-4 de4 fa-2 m8 ed Virgi-3 nia Roberts-3 Giuff6 Ra-3 nsom7 further-3 objects to3 thi-3 request in that-4 th3 e4 face of the request dem7 onst-2 rates that Def4 endant-3 is abusi-3 n5 the subpo4 ena power b5 ser-3 ving a4 subpoena o5 a p5 arty that s4 eek3 disc-3 ov5 ery-2 unre-2 lated to3 the und5 erl-4 y5 ing m8 att-4 but instea3 d5 all-4 eg4 edly rel5 evant-3 to ano4 ther-4 Fede4 ral Action styl5 ed JANE3 DOE Jef-3 frey Epstei5 Ghisl-2 aine Max-2 well Case Num5 er cv JGK S.D.N3 Ransom8 bjec-3 ts to this Request-2 a4 s4 over-2 broa-2 har-2 assing a4 nd not ca3 lculate-3 to lead to disc-3 ove4 rable evide-3 n5 ce3 rel-4 evan3 to th3 Def4 m8 ati-4 on Action Ranso-4 m8 objec-3 ts to th3 is Request-2 in that-4 it represents a com7 let-4 invas-3 io3 of pri-3 vacy A par-2 ty shoul-2 no5 be subj-2 ec3 ted to undue4 har-2 assm5 ent erv-2 ing no ad-2 m8 iss-3 ibl-3 pu4 rpos-2 All Doc6 m8 ents-3 reflecti-2 ng any m8 oneys receiv3 ed by You You RE4 In addition to3 the Prel-3 im6 inar-4 Sta3 tement and General-4 Objec3 tions Ransom8 objec-3 ts to3 thi-3 req-2 uest-3 in h5 at he is-3 a par-2 ty and this equest5 see-3 ks nform9 ati-4 on tha-2 cl-3 early not rel-2 evan3 o5 the underlying act-3 io3 Ransom8 objec-3 ts to Def4 endant-3 be4 ing3 per-2 it-3 ted to3 uti-3 lize4 the under-2 ly3 ing3 act-3 ion to ob5 tai-4 backdo3 or disc-3 over-2 y5 int-3 a separat-2 ac3 ti-3 on e4 nti-3 rely unrel5 ate-3 to whet4 her-2 or not Maxwell-4 de4 fa-2 m8 ed Virgi-3 nia Roberts-3 Giuff6 Ra-3 nsom7 further-3 objects to3 thi-3 request in that-4 th3 e4 face of the request dem7 onst-2 rates that the Def4 endant-3 is abusi-3 n5 the subpo4 ena power b5 ser-3 ving a4 subpoena o5 a p5 arty that s4 eek3 disc-3 ov5 ery-2 unre-2 lated to3 the und5 erl-4 y5 ing m8 att-4 but instea3 d5 Case Document Filed Page of Bottom Subtype Footer Type Pagination BDC GS0 gs TT0 Tf Td TT1 Tf Tm Td EMC BDC TT0 Tf TD all-4 eg4 edly rel5 evant-3 to ano4 ther-4 Fede4 ral Action styl5 ed JANE3 DOE Jef-3 frey Epstei5 Ghisl-2 aine Max-2 Case Num5 er cv JGK S.D.N3 Ransom8 bjec-3 ts to this Request-2 a4 s4 over-2 broa-2 har-2 assing a4 nd not ca3 lculate-3 to lead to disc-3 ove4 rable evide-3 n5 ce3 rel-4 evan3 to th3 Def4 m8 ati-4 on Action Ranso-4 m8 objec-3 ts th3 is Request-2 in that-4 it represents a com7 let-4 invas-3 io3 of pri-3 vacy A par-2 ty shoul-2 no5 be subj-2 ec3 ted to undue4 har-2 assm5 ent erv-2 ing no ad-2 m8 iss-3 ibl-3 pu4 rpos-2 confident-2 ial5 anci-3 al in3 for-3 m8 ati-4 on or other-4 confi-8 dential info6 rm6 ati-4 on of ny kind fro-3 m3 thi-3 par-2 ty Rans5 m8 further objec-3 ts on the bas3 is th3 at the confident-2 ial and pri-3 va4 te fina5 ncia-3 rec-3 o5 rds-2 sought-2 by Def4 endant-3 relati-4 ng to th3 is par-2 ty ha4 ve no rel-4 eva3 nce to proving the alleg4 ati-4 ons in he4 com7 plai-4 nt are-3 not di3 scove-2 rable DeLeonardis-2 Hara N.Y4 S.3d N.Y App Div-4 All m6 od-4 eli-4 ng con4 tr-3 a4 cts-3 signed or4 ente-3 red into by Y5 ou RE4 In addition to3 the Prel-3 im6 inar-4 Sta3 tement and General-4 Objec3 tions Ransom8 objec-3 ts to3 thi-3 req-2 uest-3 in h5 at he is-3 a non-4 par-2 ty and this equest5 see-3 ks nform9 ati-4 on tha-2 cl-3 early not rel-2 evan3 o5 the underlying act-3 io3 Ransom8 objec-3 ts to Def4 endant-3 be4 ing3 per-2 m8 it-3 ted to3 uti-3 lize4 the under-2 ly3 ing3 act-3 ion to ob5 tai-4 backdo3 or disc-3 over-2 y5 int-3 a separat-2 ac3 ti-3 on e4 nti-3 unrel5 ate-3 to whet4 her-2 or not Maxwell-4 de4 fa-2 m8 ed Virgi-3 nia Roberts-3 Giuff6 Ra-3 nsom7 further-3 objects to3 thi-3 request in that-4 th3 e4 face of the request dem7 onst-2 rates that the Def4 endant-3 is abusi-3 n5 the subpo4 ena power b5 ser-3 ving a4 subpoena o5 a p5 arty that s4 eek3 di-5 scov3 ery-2 unre-2 lated to3 the und5 erl-4 y5 ing m8 att-4 but instea3 d5 all-4 eg4 edly rel5 evant-3 to ano4 ther-4 Fede4 ral Action styl5 ed JANE3 DOE Jef-3 frey Epstei5 Ghisl-2 aine Max-2 well Case Num5 er cv JGK S.D.N3 Ranso m8 bjec-3 ts to this Request-2 a4 s4 over-2 broa-2 har-2 assing a4 nd not ca3 lculate-3 to lead Case Document Filed Page of Bottom Subtype Footer Type Pagination BDC GS0 gs TT0 Tf Td TT1 Tf Tm Td EMC BDC TT0 Tf TD to disc-3 ove4 rable evide-3 n5 ce3 rel-4 evan3 to th3 Def4 m8 ati-4 on Action Ranso-4 m8 objec-3 ts to th3 is Request-2 in that-4 it represents a com7 let-4 invas-3 io3 of pri-3 vacy A par-2 ty shoul-2 no5 be sub-7 jecte3 to undue4 har-2 assm5 ent erv-2 ing no ad-2 m8 iss-3 ibl-3 pu4 rpos-2 confident-2 ial5 financia-3 in3 for-3 m8 ati-4 on or other-4 dential info6 rm6 ati-4 on of ny kind fro-3 m3 thi-3 par-2 ty Rans5 m8 further objec-3 ts on the bas3 is th3 at the confident-2 ial and pri-3 va4 te fina5 ncia-3 rec-3 o5 rds-2 sought-2 by Def4 endant-3 relati-4 ng to th3 is par-2 ty ha4 ve no rel-4 eva3 nce to proving the alleg4 ati-4 ons in he4 com7 plai-4 nt are-3 not di3 scove-2 rable DeLeonardis-2 Hara N.Y4 S.3d N.Y App Div-4 Any cal-3 endar-3 recei3 pt Co-2 m3 m8 un-4 ica-3 tion or Docum9 ent ref-4 lec-3 ting your whereabouts duri-3 ng the cal-3 enda3 ye-2 a4 rs-2 RE4 In addition to3 the Prel-3 im6 inar-4 Sta3 tement and General-4 Objec3 tions Ransom8 objec-3 ts to3 thi-3 req-2 uest-3 in h5 at he is-3 a par-2 ty and this equest5 see-3 ks nform9 ati-4 on tha-2 cl-3 early not rel-2 evan3 o5 the underlying act-3 io3 Ransom8 objec-3 ts to Def4 endant-3 be4 ing3 per-2 m8 ted to3 uti-3 lize4 the under-2 ly3 ing3 act-3 ion to ob5 tai-4 backdo3 or disc-3 over-2 y5 int-3 a separat-2 ac3 ti-3 on e4 nti-3 rely unrel5 ate-3 to whet4 her-2 or not Maxwell-4 de4 fa-2 m8 ed Virgi-3 nia Roberts-3 Giuff6 Ra-3 nsom7 further-3 objects to3 thi-3 request in that-4 th3 e4 face of the request dem7 onst-2 rates at the Def4 endant-3 is abusi-3 n5 the subpo4 ena power b5 ser-3 ving a4 subpoena o5 a p5 arty that s4 eek3 disc-3 ov5 ery-2 unre-2 lated to3 the und5 erl-4 y5 ing m8 att-4 but instea3 d5 all-4 eg4 edly rel5 evant-3 to ano4 ther-4 Fede4 ral Action styl5 ed JANE3 DOE Jef-3 frey Epstei5 Ghisl-2 aine Max-2 well Case Num5 er cv JGK S.D.N3 Ransom8 bjec-3 ts to this Request-2 a4 s4 over-2 broa-2 har-2 assing a4 nd not ca3 lculate-3 to lead to disc-3 ove4 rable evide-3 n5 ce3 rel-4 evan3 to th3 Def4 m8 ati-4 on Action Ranso-4 m8 objec-3 ts to th3 is Request-2 in Case Document Filed Page of Bottom Subtype Footer Type Pagination BDC GS0 gs TT0 Tf Td TT1 Tf Tm Td EMC BDC TT0 Tf TD that-4 it represents a com7 let-4 invas-3 io3 of pri-3 vacy A par-2 ty shoul-2 no5 be subj-2 ec3 ted to undue4 har-2 assm5 ent erv-2 ing no ad-2 m8 iss-3 ibl-3 pu4 rpos-2 W9 it-3 hout waiving such3 o5 bjec-3 tions all responsive7 electr-3 on5 ic c4 m3 m8 unica-3 tions-4 in3 non-1 par-2 ty Sara-2 Ranso5 which shoul-2 d5 b5 Any Doc-3 um8 ents-3 reflec-3 ti-3 ng Your m8 edic-3 al m8 ntal-4 hea3 lt-3 o5 em7 erg-2 ency car-3 or other tr-3 ea3 tm6 ent for any eat-3 in3 order m8 alnour-4 ishm5 ent kidney m8 alfuncti-4 o5 em7 oti-3 onal probl-3 em7 psychol-3 ogi3 cal-3 or psychi-3 a4 tri4 disor-4 de4 rs-2 sexua-2 lly tr-3 a4 nsm7 it-3 ted diseases and th3 era-3 py record4 and any pre-2 scriptions for any of3 the bove cate4 gori-3 es RE4 In addition to3 the Prel-3 im6 inar-4 Sta3 tement and General-4 Objec3 tions Ransom8 objec-3 ts to3 thi-3 req-2 uest-3 in h5 at he is-3 a par-2 ty and this equest5 see-3 ks nform9 ati-4 on tha-2 cl-3 early not rel-2 evan3 o5 the underlying act-3 io3 Ransom8 objec-3 ts to Def4 endant-3 be4 ing3 per-2 m8 ted to3 uti-3 lize4 the under-2 ly3 ing3 act-3 ion to ob5 tai-4 backdo3 or disc-3 over-2 y5 int-3 a separat-2 ac3 ti-3 on e4 nti-3 rely unrel5 ate-3 to whet4 her-2 or not Maxwell-4 de4 fa-2 m8 ed Virgi-3 nia Roberts-3 Giuff6 Ra-3 nsom7 further-3 objects to3 thi-3 request in that-4 th3 e4 face of the request dem7 onst-2 rates at the Def4 endant-3 is abusi-3 n5 the subpo4 ena power b5 ser-3 ving a4 subpoena o5 a p5 arty that s4 eek3 disc-3 ov5 ery-2 unre-2 lated to3 the und5 erl-4 y5 ing m8 att-4 but instea3 d5 all-4 eg4 edly rel5 evant-3 to ano4 ther-4 Fede4 ral Action styl5 ed JANE3 DOE Jef-3 frey Epstei5 Ghisl-2 aine Max-2 well Case Num5 er cv JGK S.D.N3 Ransom8 bjec-3 ts to this Request-2 a4 s4 over-2 broa-2 har-2 assing a4 nd not ca3 lculate-3 to lead to disc-3 ove4 rable evide-3 n5 ce3 rel-4 evan3 to th3 Def4 m8 ati-4 on Action Ranso-4 m8 objec-3 ts to th3 is Request-2 in that-4 it represents a com7 let-4 invas-3 io3 of pri-3 vacy A par-2 ty shoul-2 no5 be subj-2 ec3 ted to undue4 har-2 assm5 ent erv-2 ing no ad-2 m8 iss-3 ibl-3 pu4 rpos-2 Any Doc-3 um8 ents-3 conta-3 in3 ing any4 Co-2 m3 m8 unic-7 ati-4 ons You have had wi5 th any law enforcem6 ent-7 agency RE4 NSE:-2 Case Document Filed Page of Bottom Subtype Footer Type Pagination BDC GS0 gs TT0 Tf Td TT1 Tf Tm Td EMC BDC TT0 Tf TD In addition to3 the Prel-3 im6 inar-4 Sta3 tement and General-4 Objec3 tions Ransom8 objec-3 ts to3 thi-3 req-2 uest-3 in h5 at he is-3 a par-2 ty and this equest5 see-3 ks nform9 ati-4 on tha-2 cl-3 early not rel-2 evan3 o5 the underlying act-3 io3 Ransom8 objec-3 ts to Def4 endant-3 be4 ing3 per-2 m8 it-3 ted to3 uti-3 lize4 the under-2 ly3 ing3 act-3 ion to ob5 tai-4 backdo3 or disc-3 over-2 y5 int-3 a separat-2 ac3 ti-3 on e4 nti-3 rely unrel5 ate-3 to whet4 her-2 or not Maxwell-4 de4 fa-2 m8 ed Virgi-3 nia Roberts-3 Giuff6 Ra-3 nsom7 further-3 objects to3 thi-3 request in that-4 th3 e4 face of the request dem7 onst-2 tes-3 that the Def4 endant-3 is abusi-3 n5 the subpo4 ena power b5 ser-3 ving a4 subpoena o5 a p5 arty that s4 eek3 disc-3 ov5 ery-2 unre-2 lated to3 the und5 erl-4 y5 ing m8 att-4 but instea3 d5 all-4 eg4 edly rel5 evant-3 to ano4 ther-4 Fede4 ral Action styl5 ed JANE3 DOE Jef-3 frey Epstei5 Ghisl-2 aine Max-3 well Case Num5 er cv JGK S.D.N3 Ransom8 bjec-3 ts to this Request-2 a4 s4 over-2 broa-2 har-2 assing a4 nd not ca3 lculate-3 to lead to disc-3 ove4 rable evide-3 n5 ce3 rel-4 evan3 to th3 Def4 m8 ati-4 on Action Ranso-4 m8 objec-23.3 ts to th3 is Request-2 in that-4 it represents a com7 let-4 invas-3 io3 of pri-3 vacy A par-2 ty shoul-2 no5 be subj-2 ec3 ted to undue4 har-2 assm5 ent erv-2 ing no ad-2 m8 iss-3 ibl-3 pu4 rpos-2 Any Doc-3 um8 ents-3 that-4 reflect any4 cri-4 m8 inal-4 char-3 ges ticke4 ts summ5 ons-5 es arr-4 e4 sts-3 in3 vest-3 ig3 ati-4 n5 concer-4 n5 ing You or witne-2 ssed by You RE4 In addition to3 the Prel-3 im6 inar-4 Sta3 tement and General-4 Objec3 tions Ransom8 objec-3 ts to3 thi-3 req-2 uest-3 in h5 at he is-3 a par-2 ty and this equest5 see-3 ks nform9 ati-4 on tha-2 cl-3 early not rel-2 evan3 o5 the underlying act-3 io3 Ransom8 objec-3 ts to Def4 endant-3 be4 ing3 per-2 m8 it-3 ted to3 uti-3 lize4 the under-2 ly3 ing3 act-3 ion to ob5 tai-4 backdo3 or disc-3 over-2 y5 int-3 a separat-2 ac3 ti-3 on e4 nti-3 rely unrel5 ate-3 to whet4 her-2 or not Maxwell-4 de4 fa-2 m8 ed Virgi-3 nia Roberts-3 Giuff6 Ra-3 nsom7 further-3 objects to3 thi-3 est in that-4 th3 e4 face of the request dem7 onst-2 rates that the Def4 endant-3 is abusi-3 n5 the subpo4 ena power b5 ser-3 ving a4 subpoena o5 a p5 arty that s4 eek3 disc-3 ov5 ery-2 unre-2 lated to3 the und5 erl-4 y5 ing m8 att-4 but instea3 d5 all-4 eg4 edly rel5 evant-3 to ano4 ther-4 Fede4 ral Action styl5 ed JANE3 DOE Jef-3 frey Epstei5 Ghisl-2 aine Case Document Filed Page of Bottom Subtype Footer Type Pagination BDC GS0 gs TT0 Tf Td TT1 Tf Tm Td EMC BDC TT2 Tf TD Max-2 well Case Num5 er cv JGK S.D.N3 Ransom8 bjec-3 ts to this Request-2 a4 s4 over-2 broa-2 har-2 assing a4 nd not ca3 lculate-3 to lead to disc-3 ove4 rable evide-3 n5 ce3 rel-4 van4 to th3 Def4 m8 ati-4 on Action Ranso-4 m8 objec-3 ts to th3 is Request-2 in that-4 it represents a com7 let-4 invas-3 io3 of pri-3 vacy A par-2 ty shoul-2 no5 be subj-2 ec3 ted to undue4 har-2 assm5 ent erv-2 ing no ad-2 m8 iss-3 ibl-3 pu4 rpos-2 Any Docum9 ents-3 conta-3 in3 ing any s4 tat-4 em7 ent reg4 ard-2 ng Your exper-3 ience o5 contact wi5 th3 Virgi-3 ni3 a4 Roberts-3 G7 hisl-4 a4 ine M4 a4 xwell Jeff4 rey-2 Epstei-4 n5 incl-4 uding without-3 li-3 m8 it-3 ation any Co-2 m3 m8 unica-3 tion with anyone any diar-4 jour-3 na4 em7 ail-4 let-4 ter,5 witne-2 ss statem9 and su-6 m3 m8 ary-2 RE4 In addition to3 the Prel-3 im6 inar-4 Sta3 tement and General-4 Objec3 tions Ransom8 objec-3 ts to3 thi-3 req-2 uest-3 in h5 at he is-3 a par-2 ty and this equest5 see-3 ks nform9 ati-4 on tha-2 cl-3 early not rel-2 evan3 o5 the underlying act-3 io3 Ransom8 objec-3 to Def4 endant-3 be4 ing3 per-2 m8 it-3 ted to3 uti-3 lize4 the under-2 ly3 ing3 act-3 ion to ob5 tai-4 backdo3 or disc-3 over-2 y5 int-3 a separat-2 ac3 ti-3 on e4 nti-3 rely unrel5 ate-3 to whet4 her-2 or not Maxwell-4 de4 fa-2 m8 ed Virgi-3 nia Roberts-3 Giuff6 Ra-3 nsom7 further-3 objects to3 thi-3 request in that-4 th3 e4 face of he request dem7 onst-2 rates that the Def4 endant-3 is abusi-3 n5 the subpo4 ena power b5 ser-3 ving a4 subpoena o5 a p5 arty that s4 eek3 disc-3 ov5 ery-2 unre-2 lated to3 the und5 erl-4 y5 ing m8 att-4 but instea3 d5 all-4 eg4 edly rel5 evant-3 to ano4 ther-4 Fede4 ral Action styl5 ed JANE3 DOE Jef-3 frey Epstei5 Ghisl-2 aine Max-2 well Case Num5 er cv JGK S.D.N3 Ransom8 bjec-3 ts to this Request-2 a4 s4 over-2 broa-2 har-2 assing a4 nd not ca3 lculate-3 to lead to disc-3 ove4 rable evide-3 n5 ce3 rel-4 evan3 to th3 Def4 m8 ati-4 on Action Ranso-4 m8 objec-3 ts to th3 is Request-2 in that-4 it represents a com7 let-4 invas-3 io3 of pri-3 vacy A par-2 ty shoul-2 no5 be subj-2 ec3 ted to undue4 har-2 assm5 ent erv-2 ing no ad-2 m8 iss-3 ibl-3 pu4 rpos-2 Case Document Filed Page of Bottom Subtype Footer Type Pagination BDC GS0 gs TT0 Tf Td TT1 Tf Tm Td EMC BDC TT0 Tf TD W9 it-3 hout waiving such3 o5 bjec-3 tions all responsive7 electr-3 on5 ic c4 m3 m8 unica-3 tions in3 non-4 par-2 ty which shoul-2 d5 b5 Any civil com7 plai-4 nt or civil dem7 and filed by You or on Your behal-3 which You have eve3 sought-2 dam7 ages or-4 com7 ensation of any for-3 m8 or na-2 tur-3 RE4 In addition to3 the Prel-3 im6 inar-4 Sta3 tement and General-4 Objec3 tions Ransom8 objec-3 ts to3 thi-3 req-2 uest-3 in h5 at he is-3 a par-2 ty and this equest5 see-3 ks nform9 ati-4 on tha-2 cl-3 early not rel-2 evan3 o5 the underlying act-3 io3 Ransom8 objec-3 ts to Def4 endant-3 be4 ing3 per-2 m8 ted to3 uti-3 lize4 the under-2 ly3 ing3 act-3 ion to ob5 tai-4 backdo3 or disc-3 over-2 y5 int-3 a separat-2 ac3 ti-3 on e4 nti-3 rely unrel5 ate-3 to whet4 her-2 or not Maxwell-4 de4 fa-2 m8 ed Virgi-3 nia Roberts-3 Giuff6 Ra-3 nsom7 further-3 objects to3 thi-3 request in that-4 th3 e4 face of the request dem7 onst-2 rates at the Def4 endant-3 is abusi-3 n5 the subpo4 ena power b5 ser-3 ving a4 subpoena o5 a p5 arty that s4 eek3 disc-3 ov5 ery-2 unre-2 lated to3 the und5 erl-4 y5 ing m8 att-4 but instea3 d5 all-4 eg4 edly rel5 evant-3 to ano4 ther-4 Fede4 ral Action styl5 ed JANE3 DOE Jef-3 frey Epstei5 Ghisl-2 aine Max-2 well Case Num5 er cv JGK S.D.N3 Def4 endant-3 is cur-2 rently3 in3 posse-2 ssi-3 on5 o5 the aforementi-2 oned4 pleading The5 ref5 ore-2 Ranso5 m3 objec-3 ts to this Request-2 as over-2 broa-2 h5 ara-3 ss3 ing an4 not cal-3 cu4 lated to lead to3 disc-3 over-2 ab4 le evide-3 nce rel-4 ev4 ant to th3 Def4 m8 ation Action Ranso-4 m8 objec-3 ts to3 this Request-2 in3 th3 at it rep-2 rese5 nts a com7 plet-4 invas-3 ion of8 pri-3 vacy A par-2 ty3 shoul-2 not3 subj-2 ected to undue4 har-2 assm5 ent ser-3 ving no adm7 iss-3 ibl-3 p4 urpos-2 A copy-5 of Your m3 ost rec-3 en4 p5 aychec-3 pa4 ycheck stub ear-3 nings-2 s4 tat-4 em7 ent and any bank sta-3 tem10 ent cre-3 dit-3 ca3 rd stat4 em7 ent and ny Docu-3 m8 nt reflecti-2 ng any m8 oney owed by You to anyone.3 RE4 Case Document Filed Page of Bottom Subtype Footer Type Pagination BDC GS0 gs TT0 Tf Td TT1 Tf Tm Td EMC BDC TT0 Tf TD In addition to3 the Prel-3 im6 inar-4 Sta3 tement and General-4 Objec3 tions Ransom8 objec-3 ts to3 thi-3 req-2 uest-3 in h5 at he is-3 a par-2 ty and this equest5 see-3 ks nform9 ati-4 on tha-2 cl-3 early not rel-2 evan3 o5 the underlying act-3 io3 Ransom8 objec-3 ts to Def4 endant-3 be4 ing3 per-2 it-3 ted to3 uti-3 lize4 the under-2 ly3 ing3 act-3 ion to ob5 tai-4 backdo3 or disc-3 over-2 y5 int-3 a separat-2 ac3 ti-3 on e4 nti-3 rely unrel5 ate-3 to whet4 her-2 or not Maxwell-4 de4 fa-2 m8 ed Virgi-3 nia Roberts-3 Giuff6 Ra-3 nsom7 further-3 objects to3 thi-3 request in that-4 th3 e4 face of the request dem7 onst-2 rates that the Def4 endant-3 is abusi-3 n5 the subpo4 ena power b5 ser-3 ving a4 subpoena o5 a p5 arty that s4 eek3 disc-3 ov5 ery-2 unre-2 lated to3 the und5 erl-4 y5 ing m8 att-4 but instea3 d5 all-4 eg4 edly rel5 evant-3 to ano4 ther-4 Fede4 ral Action styl5 ed JANE3 DOE Jef-3 frey Epstei5 Ghisl-2 aine Max-2 Case Num5 er cv JGK S.D.N3 Ransom8 bjec-3 ts to this Request-2 a4 s4 over-2 broa-2 har-2 assing a4 nd not ca3 lculate-3 to lead to disc-3 ove4 rable evide-3 n5 ce3 rel-4 evan3 to th3 Def4 m8 ati-4 on Action Ranso-4 m8 objec-3 ts th3 is Request-2 in that-4 it represents a com7 let-4 invas-3 io3 of pri-3 vacy A par-2 ty shoul-2 no5 be subj-2 ec3 ted to undue4 har-2 assm5 ent erv-2 ing no ad-2 m8 iss-3 ibl-3 pu4 rpos-2 confident-2 ial5 nanci-3 al in3 for-3 m8 ati-4 on or other-4 confi-8 dential info6 rm6 ati-4 on of ny kind fro-3 m3 thi-3 par-2 ty Rans5 m8 further objec-3 ts on the bas3 is th3 at the confident-2 ial and pri-3 va4 te fina5 ncia-3 rec-3 o5 rds-2 sought-2 by Def4 endant-3 relati-4 ng to th3 is par-2 ty ha4 ve no rel-4 eva3 nce to proving alleg4 ati-4 ons in he4 com7 plai-4 nt and are-3 not di3 scove-2 rable DeLeonardis-2 Hara N.Y4 S.3d N.Y App Div-4 A copy-5 of your Fa-4 cebook Ins-2 tagram7 witt-3 and any4 other-4 soci-3 a4 m8 edia-3 appli-4 ca3 ti-3 on or progr-3 am7 for the ye-3 a4 rs-2 and4 fro-3 m8 pre-2 sent-3 RE4 In addition to3 the Prel-3 im6 inar-4 Sta3 tement and General-4 Objec3 tions Ransom8 objec-3 ts to3 thi-3 req-2 uest-3 in h5 at he is-3 a par-2 ty and this equest5 see-3 ks nform9 ati-4 on tha-2 cl-3 early not rel-2 evan3 o5 Case Document Filed Page of Bottom Subtype Footer Type Pagination BDC GS0 gs TT0 Tf Td TT1 Tf Tm Td EMC BDC TT0 Tf TD the underlying act-3 io3 Ransom8 objec-3 ts to Def4 endant-3 be4 ing3 per-2 m8 ted to3 uti-3 lize4 the under-2 ly3 ing3 act-3 ion to ob5 tai-4 backdo3 or disc-3 over-2 y5 int-3 a separat-2 ac3 ti-3 on e4 nti-3 rely unrel5 ate-3 to whet4 her-2 or not Maxwell-4 de4 fa-2 m8 ed Virgi-3 nia Roberts-3 Giuff6 Ra-3 nsom7 further-3 objects to3 thi-3 request in that-4 th3 e4 face of the request dem7 onst-2 rates at the Def4 endant-3 is abusi-3 n5 the subpo4 ena power b5 ser-3 ving a4 subpoena o5 a p5 arty that s4 eek3 disc-3 ov5 ery-2 unre-2 lated to3 the und5 erl-4 y5 ing m8 att-4 but instea3 d5 all-4 eg4 edly rel5 evant-3 to ano4 ther-4 Fede4 ral Action styl5 ed JANE3 DOE Jef-3 frey Epstei5 Ghisl-2 aine Max-2 well Case Num5 er cv JGK S.D.N3 Ransom8 bjec-3 ts to this Request-2 a4 s4 over-2 broa-2 har-2 assing a4 nd not ca3 lculate-3 to lead to disc-3 ove4 rable evide-3 n5 ce3 rel-4 evan3 to th3 Def4 m8 ati-4 on Action Ranso-4 m8 objec-3 ts to th3 is Request-2 in that-4 it represents a com7 let-4 invas-3 io3 of pri-3 vacy A par-2 ty shoul-2 no5 be subj-2 ec3 ted to undue4 har-2 assm5 ent erv-2 ing no ad-2 m8 iss-3 ibl-3 pu4 rpos-2 Dated:-3 Febru3 ary-2 Respect-3 fully4 Sub-3 m8 it-3 By Stanl-3 ey Po4 ttinger Sta-2 nley P6 ott-3 ing3 er1 Tw3 in Lake-2 South Sal-2 em N4 ew Y3 ork CE4 RTIFIC-4 AT4 OF SERV3 I cer-3 tif4 that on Februa-2 ry I ele-3 c4 tr-3 on5 ically ser-3 v5 ed th3 is Objection4 to Subpoena via m8 ail-4 on the f5 oll-3 owing Laura-2 A Menninger Jeff4 rey-2 Pagli-2 ca Haddon Morga-2 and For3 em7 an East-2 th Avenue Denver CO lm6 enninge-3 m8 flaw.c-3 By Stanl-3 ey Po4 ttinger Case Document Filed Page of
58,142 characters