Uni-3te7d-3 S-3tat6e4s Distr5ic-7t 6Court5 S-3ou-3ther7n-3 Distr6ict5 of-6 Yor6k-3 Virg13ini-3a4 9Giuff6r-6e4 P-3lainti-3ff6 C-2a4se3 No cv Ghisl-2a4ine Ma5x-9we6ll-3 De6fe7nd-9a4nt S-3UBJE-3CT T-3O IMP12ROP11E-2R OB-2JECT-3ION AN-6D C4L-2AIM-4 OF9 re7spe-6c4tfull-12y20 subm-2it-3s thi-3s Mot-3ion t-3o 10C-2ompel P-3r13oduc4ti-3on of3 Doc6uments e4sponse to e4qu-9e4st os a4nd Ame4nde4d P-3rivilege5 F6or3 the r-4e4a4son Mot-2ion i-3n it-3s entire6t-11y30 I F11A-7CTUA3L-2 B-2AC4KG6R-7OUND On W-3e4dne4sda-16y20 J-10une4 a4 a4nd d-9e4tailed R-2e4que4st for3 P-3roduc7ti-3on Se4e S-3c4hult-3z-5 De6c4l at Ex-8hibi-3t I23n that letter5 the un-7de4rsig10n-9e4d pr3opose3d we6 mee6t and 7c4onfe-2r ove4r th-8e4 ne4x-9t couple4 On Monda-6y20 J-10une4 the f5oll-3owing10 busi-2ne4ss the und-7e4rsi-9g10ne4d w-7rote5 9a4ga4in re5qu-9e4sti-4ng10 mee6t and c6onf-6e4r 6c4a4ll off4e4rin-8g10 the ne6x-9t couple4 to h-2a4ve4 the 7c4a4ll S-9e4e S-3c4hult-3z-5 De6c4l at Ex-8hibi6t the und-7e4rsig10n-9e4d re-2c4e4ived no 7re7sp-10onse wha6tsoeve-4r Te5ll-3ing8l-21y20 i wa4s not-2 unti-3l whe6n De6f-6e4n-3dan-3t wa6nted to mee6t a-7nd c4onfe7r a4nd c4onfe-2r took on 9a4nd lasted tw3o hour3s Se-5e 9De6c4l C-2ompos-2it-3e4 E11x-9hibi-3t Email fr5om P-15a4ul C-4a4ssell t-3o a4n-9d Email fr5om P-5a4ul C-4a4ssell t-3o Ge-3e4 Case Document Filed Page of lainti-3 ff6 ser6 ve4 he4 Se-6 c4 nd Reque5 st for3 roduc7 ti-3 on Apr5 il-3 De6 pit-3 e4 the e4 quiring9 De6 e4 nda4 nt tur-8 ove4 doc7 uments subj-3 e4 c4 to mprope5 objec6 ti-3 ons a3 nd im-3 pr3 ope4 c4 laims-2 of pr6 ivi-3 lege6 De-3 fe-2 nda4 nt fa5 il-3 e4 to produc-4 e4 e4 leva6 nt re5 sponsi-3 ve4 non pr3 ivi-3 lege6 doc4 uments.-10 im-4 porta5 nt note Ms Giuff4 re a4 had3 to it-3 ig8 a4 te for6 e4 e4 sin le other5 doc4 ument that De-3 fe-2 nda4 nt has pr4 oduc-5 e4 in his ca5 se3 Tha5 inappr4 op-9 ri-8 a4 te disc3 ove4 be4 ha4 vior Ottos-2 on v4 SM-6 BC e4 asing-2 and Finance7 I3 nc Swe-4 e4 W4 a4 S.D.N3 gr3 a4 nti-3 mot-3 ion c4 ompel int-3 e4 rna7 quot-3 a4 ti-3 ons omi-3 tt-3 e4 Sti-3 nson v3 it-3 y4 of e4 ork we6 e4 D.N4 gr6 a4 nti-3 in par5 mot-3 ion c4 ompel pr3 oduc4 ti-3 on A pa6 shoul-2 not ha ve4 to it-3 ig8 a4 te ov-7 e4 the5 roduc7 ti-3 on of3 e4 e4 ry3 singl-4 a4 c4 e4 pt such stonew4 a4 ll-3 a4 a lit-2 ig8 a4 ti-3 on tac6 ti-3 c4 the Se-7 c4 ond irc5 uit-3 c4 ur3 ts have5 dism-4 iss-3 e4 a4 c4 ti-3 ns whe5 re7 a4 pa4 a4 dem-8 onst-2 ra7 ted will-3 ful disre5 rd f6 or3 it-3 iscove5 obli-3 ga4 ti-3 ons Edwar-2 ds Am A4 irl-4 ines I4 nc4 No SAS-2 a4 S.D.N.Y3 Au-7 Se4 e4 also Inte5 rnat-2 onal Mini-2 ng Co-2 Inc7 v4 Allen and Co we6 e4 F6 upp D.N4 fa7 il-3 ur3 to produc5 doc4 uments a3 nd suppl-12 a4 e4 qua4 te a6 nsw-8 e4 rs to int-3 e4 rr6 a4 tori-10 e4 with-2 out usti-4 fia5 ble e6 c4 use w5 a4 rr-3 a4 nted discove5 is akin the onduc4 for6 whic4 the Se-7 ond irc5 uit-3 ha4 aw5 a4 rd-6 e4 sa3 nc4 ti-3 ons pe4 c4 ifica7 De-3 fe7 nda4 nt re6 fusin-9 to produc-4 e4 doc-5 uments c4 onc4 e4 rn de4 fa7 mator-16 stat-10 e4 ments the me4 dia a6 nd doc4 uments c3 onc4 rnin-8 Ms Giuff-5 re7 both c4 a4 te-7 or3 ies doc7 uments dire c4 to he4 c4 laim ssue in thi-3 li5 ti-3 a4 ti-3 on The5 re7 fo-6 re7 thi-3 ourt shoul-2 c4 ompel he4 to pr4 duc4 e4 them Case Document Filed Page of II L-2E-2G8AL AR3GUM4E-2NT A L-2e4gal S-5tand-4ar4d-3 Unde6r 6F6e4de-5ra7l R-4ule of5 C-2ivi-3l P-5roc7e4dure7 r-6e4que4st t-4ha4t anoth-9e4r pr3oduc4e4 doc4um-11e4nts i-4n it-3s poss-2e4ssi-3on a4s long7 a4s the-8 doc4uments a3re7 9withi-3n the sc5ope4 of 6F6e4d C-2iv b3 w)5hich a6ll-3ows f4or3 broa7d 9re-2g10a-5rding11 non p-9rivilege5d ma tt-3e4r tha5t i-3s e4nc4ompass matte-7r tha5t bea6rs on or-4 that r3e-5a4sonab3l-11y20 9c ould l-3e4a4d to ot-3he4r 6matter5 that c4ould bea-3r Stat-3e4 Far-9m Auto Ins Co F3ay4da 9No a4t 6(gr3a4nti-3ng10 mot-3ion t-3o c4ompel the5 opposi-2n-9g10 obj-11e4c4ts t-4o pro3duc4in-11g the do-7c4uments t-2he4 pa4rt-8y20 9se-6e4king produc5ti-3on c4a4n file3 a4 mot-3ion t-3o c4om-11pe4l wit-3h the c6ourt pur4sua-6nt t-3o F6e4d 2C-2iv 10Aga6inst-4 thi-3s bac7kdrop3 of3 broa7d discov-8e4r-16y20 Max-6we6ll-3 ha4s re6fuse6d to 11pr3oduc4e4 r-6e4sponsi-3ve4 doc4u-9ments F11ail i R5e4q-3u-3e4st 7No Re6q-3u-3e4st N4o P-3roduc7e4 doc4uments t-2ha4t Your3 re6vie-7we6d a4nd/o-11r r6e4li-3e4d upon in t-3he4 Mar6c4h me-7e4t an-7d c4onfe7r disc4ussi-3on Mr Pag12li-3uc-5a state3d that P-3lainti-3ff6 made6 fa7lse a5ll-3e-5ga4ti-3ons c3onc4e-5rning11 he-5r se6x-9ua4l assa4ult-3 she ma5de4 them in 9the ti-3me fr6a4me tha4t P-5lainti-3ff6 w-7a4s a-6bused3 Epstein;-11 that the a6ll-3e-5g10a4ti-3ons w-8e4re7 mad-7e4 a-5g10a4inst-4 a4 number5 of indivi-2dua4ls i-4n the a6re-2a4 a4nd th)-8a4t t-3he4 9a4ll-3e4ga4ti-3ons we5r-6e4 f3ound be4 unfo3unde4d loca6l pol-3ice6 Re6sp-4on-3se Ms ha4s no knowle3d-9g10e4 of 9state3ments Mr-7 du-9ring11 Mar6c4h me-7e4t an-7d c4onfe7r 6a4nd he4n-9c4e4 ha4s doc4uments re6sponsi-3ve4 thi-3s R-3e4que4st F6ur3th the Ma5rc7h a4nd c4onfe-2r Ms f3ur3ther5 objec6ts t-4o thi-3s R-3e4que4st t-4o the e6x-9tent it-3 see7ks doc3ume-7nts or infor4mation prote3c4ted 9the a6tt-3or3ne-15y20/client pr ivi-3le-7g10e4 wor5k p-9roduc7t doc-7trine,3 the c6omm-3on int-3e4re7st privi-3lege6 or 9other5 a4ppli-3c4a4ble p-7rivilege-4 Case Document Filed Page of Ms a4lso ob-2jec6ts t-4o thi-3s R-3e4que4st t-4o the e6x-9tent it-3 c4a4ll-3s for5 infor4mation re5lating8 to Virg13ini-3a4 R-2obe-5rts Giuf3fr-3e4 9that e4x-9ist-4s with7in t-3he4 publi-3c4 domain the inter5ne4t in publi-2c4 c4ourt re7c4or3ds 10a4nd whic4h 9a4re7 a4v-9a4il-3a4ble to both pa-7rties a6nd c4a4n obtaine4d 9fr6om so-2me othe4r sourc6e4 that is-2 more5 9c4onve-5nient less bur3de4nsom-2e4 a-5nd less e4x-9pe4nsive Sub-2jec6t t-3o a4nd without-3 wa6iver5 of th-8e4 f3or-6e-5g10oing8 9De6fe7nd-9a4nt re5f e4rs to the p-7ubli-3c4 doc4uments a3nd ne4w-7s re6ports r3e-5ga4rdin-8g10 pr3oduc4e4d a-5re7 9a4va4il-3a4ble i-9n the public doma4in or r-5e4fe7r-6e4nc-5e4d in cour5t pap-7e4rs-7 De6fe7nd-9a4nt also re7fe-2rs Pl-3a int-3iff4 to docume4nts wi-2thi-3n the posse4ssi-3on c4ustod-12y20 9a4nd c4ontrol of 7P-3lainti-3ff6 a4nd he4r c4ounse3l i-3nc4ludi-3ng10 witho-11ut l-3im-3it-3a4ti-3on Mr B9ra7dle-7y10 Edw3a4rds w4hich r3e-5que4sted in of3 W-5it-3hout wa4iver5 of such3 objec6ti-3ons Ms-2 Max-6we6ll-3 ha4s made5 a4v-9a4il-3a4ble do-7c4uments re6late4d to e4ntal F6e4d C-2iv a7 disc)4losure4s The5 poli-3c4e4 r-6e4ports a4t i-3ssue de4pict the se5x-9ua4l assa4ul-11t of Ms Giuff5re7 wh-7e4n wa6s a four6tee6n old 11g10irl a4s-10sa3ult-3s that occ7ur3r-6e4d in F4l-11or3ida Dur5in-11g10 a4 M-10a4rc7h mee6t and c4onfe7r c4ouns-10e4l De4f to t-3he4se3 poli-3c-5e4 r3e-5ports doc4umenting8 Ms Giuff6re7 b-9e4ing8 9ra7p-9e4d prior-5 to whe4n she3 wa6s 10a4bused3 D-7e4fe7nd-9a4nt The5 poli-3c4e4 r-6e4ports pr3odu-9c4e4d in r-6e4sponse to t-3his 12R-2e4que4st bea5r d-6a4te stamps-11 on them f3rom the issui-3ng10 A ll-3 o-9f the5 da4te stamps post d-9a-5te the4 Mar6c4h p-9hone4 c4a4ll-3 S-3pe4c4ific-6a4ll-13y20 the-7y20 9a4re7 9fr6om Apr5il-3 A-7pr3il-3 a4nd Apr5il-3 these5 9a4re7 n-13ot li-3e4d upon in t-3he4 Mar6c4h mee6t a4nd c4onfe-2r a7s da4te on the4 do-9c4uments show that obtaine4d c4opies of4 thes-8e4 9poli-3c4e4 r3e4ports othe-7r 6mea6ns prior3 to t-3he4 Mar-3c4h-9 mee6t and c4onfe7r 6De6f-6e4nda4nt f-8a4il-3e4d 9to m-3a4ke4 prod3uc4ti-3on re7sponse to thi-3s R-3e4que4s-10t re7ports in Apr3il-3 aft-3e4r mee6t a4nd c4onf-6e4r 6a4nd aft-3e4r Ms Giuff4re7 iss-3ue4d Re4que4st inst-4e4a4d of De6fe7nd-9a4nt for4 r-6e4a4sons u-11nstate3d see7ks t-2o c4ha4ll-3e4n-9ge4 the c6onfide5nti-3a4li-3t-21y20 of th-8e4se3 r3e4po-9rts de4taili-3ng10 the r5a4pe4 o-9f Ms Giuff4r-6e4 w-7he4n she3 wa6s mi-3nor c7hil-3d Case Document Filed Page of p-9roduc7in-11g10 the c6op-9ies the-6y20 ha4ve4 9ra7i-11se3s que3sti-4ons a4s to whe6n ori-8g10inall-21y20 ha4d the doc6uments who obtaine4d the doc6uments 10fr6om a4nd D-7e4fe7nd-9a4n-9t we6nt t-3o th trouble to obt-3a4in a4 ne4w c6op-19y ol-11ice6 r3e4po-9rts minors those de5taili-3n-9g10 se-6x-9ua4l cr5im-3e4s a4nd a4ga4inst-4 mi-3nors a6re7 prot-8e-5c4ted f5rom publi-2c4 diss-3e4mi-13na4ti-3on 9F6lorida3 law4 S-3pe4c4ifica7ll-23y20 mi-3nor w5ho is 2a4ll-3e4ge4d to be or5 who is Additi-3ona4ll-13y20 F6la 7S-3tat pr3otec6ts re4c4or3ds wh-8e4re7 juvenile is a3 victim-3 of a7 c-5rime.3 F6ur3the-7r Sec7ti-3on F6la St-3a4t cr5e-5a4tes c4ivi-3l rig9ht of 8a4c4ti-3o a4ga4inst-4 a4n indi-3vidual who c6omm-3unica6tes to ot-2he4r-6s identi-2f-6y20in-11g10 infor4mation-11 c4onc4e4rnin-8g10 the vi-9c4ti-3m of3 a4 sex-6ua4l off4e4ns-10e4 F6ur3th-11e4r F6la St-3a4t an-7d F6la St-3a4t juvenile la4w e4nf3or3c-5e4ment r3e-5c4or3ds co3n-9f-6idential f3rom me3mber5s of-7 the public a6nd st-2a4tes tha-6t i-3nf3or3mation obtaine4d law4 9e4nf3or-6c-5e4ment a-5g10e4nt pa-7rticipa5ti-3ng in t-3he4 a4ssessment of3 a4 ju-11ve4nil-3e4 is conf4idential F6in De6pa4rtmen3t of Chi-3ldre5n 9a4nd F6a4mi-3li-3e4s se-6e4 e4.g and if4 such3 r3e-5ports a4re7 pa-5rt of4 the 11pursua6nt t-3o F6la St-3a4t B-2a4se3d upon 9the m-9y20ria5d o-9f F9lorid-10a4 S-3tatutes tha3t protec7t t-3he4 c4onf-6identialit-13y20 of the5se3 pr3ior to t-2he4 Mar6c4h mee6t a4nd c4onf-6e4r obtaine4d them I13n sum-2 D-7e4fe7nd-9a4nt di-3d n-3ot pr3oduc4e4 the doc6um-11e4nts her4 c4ounse3l r-8e4li-3e4d upon-9 in t-3he4 Mar6c4h mee6t and c6onf-6e-5r c7a4ll-3 De6f-6e-5nda4nt sho-2uld produc5e4 the-7 r3e4que4sted doc4uments I13f suc6h do-9c4u-9ments we5re7 obtain-9e4d in c-5ontra5ve4nti-3on of3 F6lorid-10a4 S-3tatutes it-2 c4a4nnot be hidden be6hind a pr5oduc4ti-13on of3 late4r a4c4quir-8e4d poli-3c-5e4 r3e4ports C-2ourt should c4ompel pr3oduc4ti-3on of3 the-7se3 doc4uments Case Document Filed Page of ii R5e4q-3u-3e4sts N3o-9s R5e4q-3u-3e4st 7No P-3roduc7e4 a4ll-3 doc4um-11e4nts c4onc4e4rnin-8g10 ho-9w suc-6h poli-3c4e4 r3e4port or4 how such3 r-6e4c4ounti-3n-9g re7telli-3ng10 sum-2mar-14y20 o-9r d-6e4sc3riptio-2n of such3 po-9li-3c4e4 r3e4port re7fe-2re7nc-5e4d in 9No c-5a4me into You-9r posse5ssi-3on This re5que-5st i-4nc4ludes but i-2s not-2 li-3mi-3ted to a4ll-3 doc4uments c4onc4e4rnin-8g10 ho-9w w4he4n 9a-5nd whom suc3h 9re7ports-9 de4sc-6riptio-2ns of Re6sp-4on-3se whic4h the Re3que4st c4or-6re7s-10ponds S-4he4 f3ur3ther5 obje-7c4ts t-4o the Re3que4st i-4n that it-3 10im-3pr3ope4rl-8y20 s-10e4e4ks t-2o pr3opound a4n 9in t-3he4 f3o-9rm of4 a4 R-2e4qu-9e4st for3 P-3roduc7ti-3on of3 Doc6u-9ments a3nd is e4s The4 R-2e4que4st embe3ds a n3umbe-7r of6 a4ssum-3pti-3ons t-2ha4t ar5e4 9not t-3rue7 a4nd fo3r 6whic4h P-3lainti-3ff6 suppl-2ies no ba4sis-3 f3or3 a4sse-7rtion of the4ir Ms li-3ke4wise 3objec6ts t-4o thi-3s R-3e4que4st bec5a-5use it see6ks doc3uments or-7 infor4mation pr3otec6ted the 7a4tt-3or3ne-15y10/cli e4nt privi-2leg12e4 wor-4k pr3oduc4t doctr3ine th-9e4 c-5omm-3on int-3e4re7st pr3ivi-3leg12e4 o-9r othe-7r a7p-9pli-3c4a4ble pr5ivi-3le-7g10e4 F6inall-11y20 Ms a4lso ob-2jec6ts t-4o thi-3s R-3e4que4st t-4o the e6x-9tent it-3 c4a4ll-3s for5 infor4mation re7lating8 to R-2obe-5rts Giuf3fr6e4 that 9e4x-9ist-4s wit7hin t-3he4 publi-3c4 domain the inter5ne4t or in publ-2ic c4ourt r4e-5c4or3ds an3d whi-9c4h 9a4re7 9a4va4il-3a4ble to b-9oth par5ti-3e4s and3 c-5a4n be4 ob-9taine4d fr6om so-2me other5 sourc6e4 th-11a4t i-3s more4 9c4onve4nient less bur3de4ns-10ome a6nd less e4x-9pe4nsive D3e4fe7nd-9a4nt re5f-6e4rs to the public doc6uments a3n-9d ne investi-2g10a4ti-3on of3 the whic4h ha4ve4 b-9e4e4n pr-6e4vious-2l-11y20 prod3uc-5e4d a-5re7 a4v-9a4il-3a-5ble in the public domain or3 r3e4f-6e4re7n-9c4e4d in 11c4ourt pa5pe-5rs D4e4f-6e4nda4nt 11a4lso re4fe-2rs Pl-3a4int-3iff4 to docume4nts wi-2thi-3n the pos se3ssi-3on c4ustod-12y20 a4nd 9c4ontrol of Pl-3a4int-3iff4 a4nd h-9e4r c7ounse3l i-3nc4ludi-3n-9g10 wit-11hout l-3im-3it-3a4ti-3on Mr e4l t-13ha4t such Response4s we6re7 truthful 9a4nd c4ompl-3e-5te W-5it-3hout wa4iver5 of such3 objec6ti-3ons Ms-2 Max-6we6ll-3 ha4s made5 a4v-9a4il-3a4ble do-7c4uments F6e4d 2C-2iv a7 disclosure5s Ms-2 Max-6we6ll-3 is wi-2thhol-3ding8 doc4u-9ments re6sponsi-3ve4 to thi-3s re6que4st on 2the ba6sis-3 of the5 a4tt-3or3ne-15y c4li-3e4nt and-7 wor5k pro3duc4t privi-2le-7g10e4s R5e4q-3u-3e4st 7No P-3roduc7e4 a4ll-3 doc4um-11e4nts conc5e4rnin-8g10 ho-9w inf3or3ma-7ti-3on or3 knowle4dge4 of mi-3nor c7hil-3d c4a4me into Y-9our p3ossession i-3nc4ludi-3ng but not-3 li-3mi-3ted to doc4um8e4nts conc5e-5rning11 state3ments m-2a4de4 law4 9e4nf3or3c-5e4ment or3 st-12a4te wr5it-3ten or5 o-9ra7l 11c4onc4e4rn su-10c4h a4ll-3e4ga4ti-3ons Re6sp-4on-3se3 Ms objec6ts t-4o thi-3s R-3e4que4st t-4o the e6x-9tent it-3 see7ks doc3uments or inf3or3mation pr3otec6ted the 7a4tt-3or3ne-15y10/client pr3ivi-3leg12e4 wor-4k pr3oduc4t doctr3ine th-9e4 c-5omm-3on int-3e4re7st pr3ivi-3leg12e4 o-9r othe-7r a7p-9pli-3c4a4ble pr5ivi-3le-7g10e4 Ms Max-6we6ll-3 a4lso ob-2jec6ts t-4o thi-3s R-3e4que4st t-4o the e6x-9tent it-3 c4a4ll-3s for5 infor4mation re5lating8 to Virg13ini-3a4 R-2obe-5rts Giuf3fr-3e4 9that e4x-9ist-4s with7in t-3he4 publi-3c4 domain the inter5ne4t in publi-2c4 c4ourt Case Document Filed Page of re7c4or3ds 10a4nd whic4h 9a4re7 a4v-9a4il-3a4ble to both pa-7rties a6nd c4a4n obta ined 7fr6om so-2me othe4r sourc6e4 that is-2 more5 9c4onve-5nient less bur3de4nsom-2e4 a-5nd less e4x-9pe4nsive Sub-2jec6t t-3o a4nd without-3 wa6iver5 of th-8e4 f3or-6e-5g10oing8 9De6fe7nd-9a4nt re5f-6e4rs to the p-7ubli-3c4 doc4uments a3nd ne4w-7s re6ports r3e-5ga4rdin-8g10 ti-3ga4ti-3on of3 the sa5me w4hich 7ha4ve4 be-5e4n pre7vious-2l-21y20 pr3oduc4e4d a-5re7 9a4va4il-3a4ble i-9n the public doma4in or r-5e4fe7r-6e4nc-5e4d in cour5t pap-7e4rs-7 De6fe7nd-9a4nt also re7fe-2rs Pl-3a4int-3iff4 to docume4nts wi-2thi-3n the posse4ssi-3on c4ustod-12y20 9a4nd c4ontrol of 7P-3lainti-3ff6 a4nd he4r c4ounse3l i-3nc4ludi-3ng10 it-3ho-9ut l-3im-3it-3a4ti-3on Mr B9ra7dle-7y10 Edw3a4rds w4hich r3e-5que4sted in of3 a such3 obje-7c4ti-3ons Ms-2 Max-6we6ll-3 ha4s made5 a-5va4il-3a4ble doc6uments r-7e4late-5d to s-2ome of5 Ms a7 6A dis-12c4losure4s 10Ms is wi-2thhol-3d10ing8 doc4uments r-7e4sponsi-3ve4 to t-3his e4que4st on 2the ba4sis-3 of the5 a4tt-3or3ne-15y c4li-3e-5nt and w4or3k pro3duc4t p-11rivilege5s The5 r3e4sponse to Do-7c4ume-7nt R-4e4que4st No i-2s inade5qua4te f5or3 the 7re7a4sons s-2tat-9e4d R-2e4que4st No a3nd be-5c4a4u-9se3 ther5e4 is no-2 c4li-13e4nt or w3or3k pro3du-9c4t privi-2lege6 that pr3otec6ts co mm-3unica6ti-3ons wit-2h non c4li-3e4nt t-3hird pa4rties wh-7e4n thos-2e4 c4om-11muni-3c4a4ti-3ons a3re7 with publi-3c4 a4dmi-3nist-4ra7ti-3on pe4rsonne6l for4 the pur5pos-10e4 of-6 see7king8 poli-3c4e r-6e4c4or3ds De-3fe7nda4nt c4it-3e4s to n-2o c4a4se3 or 6a4uthor-8it-13y20 f3or3 thi-3s spec6ious of pr6ivi-3lege6 The5r-6e4for-3e-5 the c6omm-3unica6ti-3ons pr3ope4rl-18y20 withheld Additi-3ona4ll-13y20 state3m-11e4nts or c4omm-3unica6ti-3ons m-2a4de4 publi-3c4 off6ici-9a4ls to re5que4st re7c4or3ds a4re7 n-9e4it-3he4r pr6ivi-3l-11e4g e4d nor pr3ot-11e4c4ted the-7 wor5k pr3odu-9c4t doctr3ine c4it-3e4s no a3uthorit-12y20 9for6 suc-6h a4 pr3oposi-2ti-3on F6a4il-3ur3e4 re7spond t-2o these5 r-6e4que4s-10ts s-3ugg10e4sts-3 that the poli-3c4e4 r3e4ports r-6e4li-3e4d upo-9n in the Mar6c4h me-7e4t a4nd c4onfe7r we6r-6e4 proc7u-9re7d 9im-3pr3ope4r me5a4ns whic4he4ve4r indivi-2dua4l fu-8r-6nished De6fe7nd-9a4nt with t-3he4m par5ti-3c4ular5l-21y20 sinc-8e4 F6lo-11rida5 law4 prote-4c4ts s-3uc4h re7ports a4nd ke-5e4ps t-2he4m c-7onfide5nti-3a4l Ac6c4o-9rding11l-21y20 infor4mation conc6e-5rning11 9how a6nd whom these5 doc4uments we-4re7 pr-6oc4ur3e4d is Additi-3ona4ll-13y20 ther5e4 is no-2 9wor5k pro3duc4t prot-10e4c4ti-3on fo3r ill-2e4ga4ll-13y20 o-9r imprope6rl-8y20 a-5c4quire5d doc4uments a3nd poli-3c4e4 r-6e-5ports doc4umenting8 the assa4ult-3 of c7hil-3dr3e4n a-5re g10e4ne-5ra7ll-23y not publi-3c4a4ll-13y20 a4v-9a4il-3a4ble in F6l-11or3ida Se4e4 supra Th-8e4 pro-6c4e4sses whic4h 9De6f-6e4nda-5nt obt-3a4ined the4se3 doc4uments i-2s re6leva6nt t-3o 9thi-3s ac7ti-3on Case Document Filed Page of i Re6q-3u-3e4sts N3o Re6q-3u-3e4sts N3o P-3roduc-2e-5 J-10oint-3 De6fe7ns-10e4 A-7g10re-2e-5ment e4nter5e4d int-3o be4tw-9e4e-5n You a6nd Epstein f3rom to t-2he4 pre7se3nt Re6sp-4on-3se Ms objec6ts t-4o thi-3s R-3e4que4st t-4o the e6x-9tent it-3 see7ks doc3uments or inf3or3mation pr3otec6ted the 7a4tt-3or3ne-15y10/client pr3ivi-3leg12e4 wor-4k pr3oduc4t doctr3ine th-9e4 c-5omm-3on int-3e4re7st pr3ivi-3leg12e4 o-9r othe-7r a7p-9pli-3c4a4ble pr5ivi-3le-7g10e4 D-7e4fe7n-9da4nt i-3s with-2holdi-3ng10 prod-6uc4ti-3o of such3 a4gr3e4e4m-11e4nt on t-3he4 ba4sis-3 of-6 such3 privil-2e4ge4s Re6q-3u-3e4st N4o P-3roduc-2e4 do-9c4uments c3onc-5e4rnin-8g10 J-10oint-3 De6fe7ns-10e4 A-7g10re-2e4ment e4nter-4e4d int-3o be4twe4e4n You 7a4nd Epstein f3rom to t-2he4 pre7se3nt Re6sp-4on-3se Ms objec6ts t-4o thi-3s R-3e4que4st t-4o the e4x-9tent it-3 see7ks doc3uments or inf3or3mation pr3otec6ted the 7a4tt-3or3ne-15y10/client pr3ivi-3leg12e4 wor-4k pr3oduc4t doctr3ine th-9e4 c-5omm-3on int-3e4re7st pr3ivi-3leg12e4 o-9r othe-7r a7p-9pli-3c4a4ble pr5ivi-3le-7g10e4 D-7e4fe7n-9da4nt i-3s with-2holdi-3ng10 doc4u-9ments on t-2he4 ba4sis-3 of such 3pr3ivi-3lege6s Re6q-3u-3e4st P-3roduc-2e-5 J-10oint-3 De6fe7ns-10e4 A-7g10re-2e-5ment e4nter5e4d int-3o be4tw-9e4e-5n You a6nd Ala4n De6rshow4it-3z-5 f3rom to t-2he4 pre7se3nt Re6sp-4on-3se Ms objec6ts t-4o thi-3s R-3e4que4st t-4o the e6x-9tent it-3 see7ks doc3uments or inf3or3mation pr3otec6ted the 7a4tt-3or3ne-15y10/client pr3ivi-3leg12e4 wor-4k pr3oduc4t doctr3ine th-9e4 c-5omm-3on int-3e4re7st pr3ivi-3leg12e4 o-9r othe-7r a7p-9pli-3c4a4ble pr5ivi-3le-7g10e4 S-3ubje-7c4t t-3o a4nd without-3 wa6iver5 9of3 he4 De6fe7nd-9a4nt has be-4e4n una4b-9le to loca6te do-9c4umen-7ts re4sponsi-3ve4 to t-3his R-5e4que4st Re6q-3u-3e4st N4o P-3roduc-2e4 doc4uments c3on-9c4e-5rn-6ing8 J-10oint-3 De6fe7nse 6A-7gr3e4e4ment e4nt-11e4re7d int-3o be4twe4e4n You 7a4nd Ala4n D-7e4rshow4it-3z-5 f3rom to t-2he4 pre7se3nt Re6sp-4on-3se Ms a4x-9we6ll-3 objec6ts t-4o thi-3s R-3e4que4st t-4o the e6x-9tent it-3 see7ks doc3uments or inf3or3mation pr3otec6ted the 7a4tt-3or3ne-15y10/client pr3ivi-3leg12e4 wor-4k pr3oduc4t doctr3ine th-9e4 c-5omm-3on int-3e4re7st pr3ivi-3leg12e4 o-9r othe-7r a7p-9pli-3c4a4ble pr5ivi-3le-7g10e4 S-3ubjec-3t t-3o a4nd without-3 wa6iver5 o-9f the5 f3or3e De6fe7nd-9a4nt has be-4e4n una4b-9le to loca6te do-9c4umen-7ts re4sponsi-3ve4 to t-3his R-5e4que4st I13n Requ-8e4sts-3 Nos 8a4nd Ms Giuff4r-6e4 ha4s r-7e4que4sted J-9oint-3 De6fe7nse A-4g10r-6e4e4ments a7nd re7l-11a4ted doc6uments a4mong8 D-7e4fe7n-9da4nt and Epstein 9a4nd De-3fe7n-9da4nt and Ala4n e4rshow4it-3z-5 De6fe7nd-9a4nt bee7n wo-7rking11 9c4losel-20y20 9with Alan D4e4rshow4it-3z-5 who ha6s said that he4 is in a joint-3 de4fe7nse a-2gr3e4e4m-11e4nt wit-3h De6fe7nd-9a4nt De6f-6e-5nda4nt has no va5li-3d ba4sis-3 f-6or3 r3e4fusin-9g10 to pr3odu c4e4 he-5r joint-2 de4fe7ns-10e-5 a4gr3e4e4m-11e4nts pa4rticula5rl-18y20 9whe6n Ms Giuff4r-6e4 ha4s pr-6oduc4e4d he4r joint-2 de4fe7nse 6a-5g10re-2e4ment Case Document Filed Page of Se-5e4 S-3c4hult-3z De6c4l at 9Ex-8hibi6t T-8hird A3mende6d P-3rivileg11e4 Th-8e4 9a4sser5ti-3ng10 9pr3ivi-3le-7g10e4 c-5a4r ri-8e-5s the bur4de4n to prove5 9e4leme4nt of the pr3ivi-3leg12e4 Pe5ople Mitc-6he4ll The5 a4ss-11e4rting9 p-9rivilege5 a4lso has the bu-7rde7n e4stabli-2sh t-2ha4t t-3he4re7 ha4s 10be4e4n no wa6iv-11e4r Egiazar-2y4an v4 Z-3almay4e4v S-3uc4h sho-10wing10s mus-3t be ba6s-10e4d on c4ompete4nt evide4n-9c4e4 u-9suall-10y20 throu-8g10h a-5ff6idavits-2,-9 de4posi-2ti-3on testi-2mon-11y30 or 6other5 a4dmi-3ssi-3ble e4videnc6e4 Von Bulo-9w-2 by4 Aue5rsperg v5 Von B-7ulow Ci-4r c4e4rt d-8e4nied U.S Bowne of I13nc4 v4 Am3Base-5 C-2orp Egiazar-2y4a-9n v4 Z-3almay4e4v I13n re-2fusing10 to pro-8duc4e4 he4r joint-2 de-5fe7nse 6a-5gr3e4e4ments wit-2h De-3rshow4it-3z a4nd Epstein a4nd ther5e4for-3e4 ha4s not-2 met he-5r bur6de4n fo-6r he7r 6c4laim of 8c4omm-3on int-3e4re7st privi-3lege6 Additi-3ona4ll-13y20 these5 doc4u-9ments a3re7 r-6e4leva6nt t-3o the li-3ti-3ga4ti-3on in t-3he4ir ow3n ri-8g10ht a4s the-8y20 sho-10w the4 na4tur-8e4 o-9f the5 ongoing8 9re7lations-2hip betwe6e4n D-7e4fe7nd-9a nt and-7 he4r c7o c4onspi-2ra7tor De6rshow4it-3z a4nd potentia-7ll-13y20 other5 witnesse4s 10for6 w-7hom De4fe7nda-5nt c-5laimi-3ng10 a4 c4omm-3on int-3e4re7st privi-3lege thi-3s C-3ourt should ire5c4t De-5fe7nda4nt t-3o pro3du-9c4e4 a4ll-3 doc4uments re7sponsi-3ve4 to R-4e4que4sts-3 N-7os a3nd iv R5e4q-3u-3e4st 7No R5e4q-3u-3e4st 7No P-3roduc7e4 do-9c4ume-7nts conc5e4rnin-8g10 o-9f Y5o-9ur Re6sp-4on-3se Ms objec6ts t-4o thi-3s R-3e4que4st t-4o the e6x-9tent it-3 see7ks doc3uments or inf3or3mation pr3otec6ted the 7a4tt-3or3ne-15y10/client pr3ivi-3leg12e4 wor-4k roduc7t doctr3ine th-9e4 c-5omm-3on int-3e4re7st pr3ivi-3leg12e4 o-9r othe-7r a7p-9pli-3c4a4ble pr5ivi-3le-7g10e4 D-7e4fe7n-9da4nt i-3s with-2holdi-3ng10 c4omm-3unica6ti-3ons be3twe4e4n joi-3nt def5e4nse o3r c7omm-3on 9int-3e4re7st m-4a4tt e4rs Case Document Filed Page of De-3fe7nd-9a-5nt to t-3ur3n ove4r the5 va4st m-4a4jorit-12y20 of th-8e4 doc4uments on he4r fir4st pr-9ivi-3leg12e4 thi-3s C-3ourt or-5de4re7d D-7e4fe7nd-9a4nt to t-3ur3n ove4r he4r c4omm-3unica6ti-3ons wit-2h Ala4n De6rshow4it-3z-5 be4c-5a4use it rule4d that suc3h c4omm-3uni-11c4a4ti-3ons a4re7 not pr3ivi-3leg12e4d S-9e4e S-3c4hult-3z De6c4l at Ex-8hibi-3t Apr5il-3 S-3e4a4led O4rd-6e4r G-4ra7nti-3ng10 in P-5a4rt P-3rivileg11e4 Ye6t onc-7e4 a-5g10a4in D-9e4fe7nd-9a4nt i-3s c4omm-3unica6ti-3ons wit-2h Ala4n De6rshow4it-3z-5 D-7e4fe7nd-9a4nt cla4im-3s to be w4it-3hholdi-3ng10 while a6t t-3he4 tim-3e4 r3e4pr3e4s-10e4nti-3ng10 that she is De6rshow4it-3z-5 How4e4ve-5r th-5e4 C-2ou-3rt al-4re3ady4 ru-4led a12gain-5st De3fe7n-3dan-3t on-5 t8h-3is iss-3u-3e she h3a4s to pr3oduc4e4 thes-8e4 mate4ria5ls Se4e Apr5il-3 S-3e4a4le-7d Or5de4r C-2ompel f3or3 9I23mp-11rope7r Cla-7im-3 of Privil-3e4g10e4 The-4re7fo-6r-6e4 i suc6h a4 do-9c4ument e4x-9ist-4s then the3 mea6ns of pr3oc4ur3in-11g10 a4 of the5 is cr4e-5a4ted pur5suant the doc6ument De4f-6e4nda4n-9t ca6n sim-4pl-11y a4sk De6rshow4it-3z-5 f3or3 a4 the J-8DA4 pursua6nt to t-3he4 As the c7a4se3 law4 9a4b-9ove4 e4stabli-2shes De6fe7nd-9a4nt c4a4nnot c4laim a joint-3 de4fe7nse o-9r 6c4omm-3on int-3e4re7st pr3ivi-3lege6 while sim-4ult-3a4ne4ousl-12y20 to produc5e4 the joint-3 de4f-6e4nse-6 a4gr3e4e4m-11e4nt ba4se3d upon the for6e-5g10oin-11g a4nd b-9a4se3d upo-9n Ms Giuff4re7 r-6e4que4sts-3 tha-7t t-3he4 C-2ourt dire6c4t t-3he4 De6fe7nd-9a4nt t-3o pro3duc4e4 do-9c4uments re6sponsi-3ve4 to t-3his re4que4st including8 h-9e4r 6c-5omm-3unica6ti-3ons wit-2h Ala4n De6rshow4it-3z-5 or his a-5tt-3or3ne-5y20s a-2g10e4nts 9with a4 of the5 J-10oint-3 De6fe7ns-10e4 nt upon whic4h she3 purp3or3ts 12to cla4im-3 a4 privil-2e4ge R5e4q-3u-3e4st 7No R5e4q-3u-3e4st 7No P-3roduc7e4 a4ll-3 doc4um-11e4n-9ts conc5e4rnin-8g10 Vir-6g10ini-3a4 Gi-9uf3fr6e4 Vir-6g10ini-3a4 R-2obe4rts w)5he4the-7r or6 not he-5r na-5me T3his re4que4st i-4nc4ludes-8 but i-3s not-2 li-3m8it-3e4d to a4ll-3 c4omm-3unica6ti-3ons di-2a4rie5s jou-2rna7ls ca5lend-7a4rs bl-9og10 post-2s w4h-9e4ther5 publi-3s-10he4d or n3ot notes Case Document Filed Page of Case Document Filed Page of handwritten or not memoranda mobile phone agreements wire transfer receipts or any other document that concerns Plaintiff in any way whether or not they reference her by name Response Ms Maxwell objects to this Request as overly broad unduly burdensome and interposed for improper purposes Response to this Reque st would literally entail defense counsel reviewing for privilege eve1y ingle document in their po ssessio related to this case Ms Maxwell further objects to this Reque st on the grounds that it is cumulative and duplicative Ms Maxwell further objects to this reque st as exceeding the scope of this Com1s March Order Ms Maxwell also objects to thi Request to the extent it calls for infonnation relating to Virginia Robe11 Giuffre that exists within the public domain the internet or in public com1 records and which are equally available to both pai1ies and can be obtained from some other so urce that is more convenient le ss burdensome and le ss expensive Ms Maxwell fm1her objects to this Request to the extent it seeks documents or info1mation protected by the attorney client privilege the work-product doctrine the common intere st privilege or any other applicable privilege Subject to the foregoing objections Ms Maxwell and her counsel ai not going to review eve1y document in their possession for any additional documents re spo nsive to this Request As explained in Ms Giuffre Supplement to her Motion for Adverse Inference Jmy In st rnction Defendant cannot withhold documents concerning the Plaintiff in this defamation action and Defendant cites no authority for uch an absurd position Frankly the se documents should ha ve been produced already as pai1 of Defendant Rule Di sclos ures See Fed Civ a Therefore based on the foregoing and based on the ai 267gument made in Ms Giuffres Supplement to her Motion for Adverse Inference Jmy In st mction Ms Giuffre requests that the Com1 require Defendant to tmn over all document that concern Ms Giuffre vi Document Requests Nos and Document Request No Produce all documents concerning an statement made by You or on Your behalf to the press or an other group or individual including draft sta tement concerning Ms Giuffre by You or any other individual from to the present including the dates of any publication and if published online the Unifo1m Re so urce Identifier URL address Response Ms Maxwell objects to this Request on the grounds that it is cumulative and duplicative Ms Maxwell also objects to this Reque to the extent it calls for info1mation that exists within the public domain the internet or in public com1 records and which ai equally available to both pa11ie and can be obtained from so me other so urce that i more convenient le ss burdensome and less expensive Ms Maxwell fui1her objects to this Request to the extent it seeks document or infonnation protected by the attorney client privilege the work-product Case Document Filed Page of oc trin an ot a ppli ca bl pri il ege axwe ll i ot produ in oc ts hat a av ailabl in publi a in Ms Ma xwe ll as ee unabl to oc at an a ddi i a oc ts es i ve thi qu est Document Request No ro du ce a ll oc um ts co ce rnin hi in i idu a i i es Yo ur age ts i st ribut ed se nt an tat ts co ce rnin Giuffr fer ce in eq est a ur half Response Maxwe ll bj ects to hi qu est gro und th a i i umulati ve an dupli cat i ve Ms Ma xwe ll al so jects to hi qu es to exte it all fo in fo 1mati ha exists i hin publi a in th int rn et in publi co mt eco ds and hi a quall av ailabl ot patti es and an bt a in fr so th so ur ce hat i co ve ni ess burd so an ess ex i ve Maxwe ll fin bj ects to hi qu est to th ex i see oc um ts in fo nn at i prot ec ed at rn ey cl i pri il ege wo rk-produ ct oct rin an ot a ppli ca bl pri il ege axwe ll i ot produ in oc ts hat a av ailabl in publi a in Ms Ma xwe ll ha ee unabl to oc at an a ddi i a oc ts es i ve thi qu est fu hi fam at i case fendan ca se de famat ate ts at ac kin Giuffr publi in di a utl ets a ll did so lib rat throu gh ro ugh di rect sta nt ed i a and oss ibl an unkn ow Giuffr oc nt co ce rnin efe ndan fam ato ta te and i publi cat i a ce ntral th cla im in hi case fu dee oc nt go a1t th at and efe ndan as ot asse te a goo d-fai ba i fo fu al to ro du ce efe ndan al and ro ugh rofess i a de fam Giuffr a bal age but ow claim i un a bl to oc at oc ts co ce rnin state nt Thi es se in i ca es a se ce a easo a bl sea eove nl efe an as access a co mpr i ve li st fam ato ate nt and utl hi i st ribu te th efe da nt fu al to rod ce oc ts i ll unju st ifi and Giuffr qu est tha Co ir ect fendan ro du ce es i ve doc um ts Defendant has Withheld Documents based on an Improper Claim of Privilege or3 disclosure5 of othe-4rw5is-12e4 c4onfide5nti-3a4l attorn-8e-15y c4l-11ient c4omm-3unica6ti-3ons t-2o a4 thi-3rd pa7rt-8y20 9wa6ives the pr3ivi-3leg12e4 9a4bsent a5nd 9e4x-9c4e-5pti-3on Pe5ople v6 Osorio Id 9a4t e4x-9tends the a7tt-3or3ne-5y fr6om one to t-3he4 f3or3 9a4nother5 wh-7e4re7 a4 joi-3nt de-7fe7nse 6e4ff6o-9rt or4 stra ha4s United States v5 Sc4hwi-4mm4e4r Id a4t F6ur3th-11e4r De6spit-4e4 their3 shortha4nd n-9a4mes ne5it-3he4r the5 9pr3ivi-3leg12e4 no-9r the5 c4omm-3o-9n int-3e4re st pr3ivi-3leg12e4 op-9e4r-6a4te inde4pe4n-9de4ntl-13y20 bot-3h e4x-9ist-4 to par5don the pr5e4sump-12ti-3ve4 wa6iver5 that would r3e4sult-4 f3rom disclosure6 of othe-4rw5ise pr4i-11vil-3e4g10e4d 9a4tt-3or3ne-15y c4li-3e4nt co-7mm-3unica6ti-3ons to a third whe6n that-9 thi-3rd is i-4nc4luded u-7nde4r the5 umbre5ll-3a4 o-9f the5 9a or c4omm-3on int-3e4re7st doctrin-9e4s Id a4t De6f-6e4nda4nt ha4s fa6il-3e4d to m-3e4e4t 6burde7n to s-2how tha4t t-3he4 c-5omm-3unica6ti-3ons she is withhol-3ding8 a4re7 9a4c4tuall-21y20 9pr3otec6ted the 7c4omm-3on int-3e4re7st privi-3lege6 i has Wi-3thh-4e4ld-5 an-3 Je4f-6f r4e4y Ep-6ste6in-5 t3o This C-4ourt pr4e4vious-2l-11y20 he-5ld t-3ha4t De4fe7nda4nt not m-3e4t her5 burd3e4n o-9f pr6ovi-11ng10 p-9rivilege5 a4s to mails-2 be4twe4e4n 9De6f-6e-5nda4nt and Epstein-9 D-9e4fe7nd-9a4nt continues-8 to to wit-3hhold those c5omm-3unica6ti-3ons Se4e4 Apr5il-3 S-3e4a4led-7 Or5de4r in which Epstein for6wa-3rd-6e4d a4 c4omm-3unica6ti-3on fr6om one of5 his to De4fe7nda4nt S-5uc4h 9a4n a-5c4ti-3on wa6ives the pr6ivi-3le-7ge4 a4nd De-3fe7nda4nt not sh-2own tha4t he4 c4omm-3on int-3e4re7st a4ppli-3e4s c4a4ll-3e4d joi-3nt def-4e4nse 6pr3ivi-3leg12e4 o-9r c7omm-3on int-3e4re7st rule se5rv-6e4s prote5c4t t-3he4 c4on-9fide5nti-3a4li-3ty18 9of3 9c4omm-3unica6ti-3ons pa3s-10sing7 f3rom on-8e4 to t-3he4 f3or3 9a4nothe-7r whe-3re7 a4 joi-3nt de-7fe-2nse e7ff6o-9rt or4 stra4te-7g-9y20 h-9a4s be4e4n de-5c4ided upon Case Document Filed Page of he4 v4 ron v4 Donziger F6 D.N4 int-3 e4 rn-6 a4 quot-3 a4 ti-3 on mar5 ks om-2 it-3 ted e4 mph-11 a4 sis-3 a4 dde4 Th-8 e4 be4 invoked whe6 a4 e4 a4 st one a5 tt-3 or3 for6 one4 of the5 pa4 rties is re7 se3 nt for4 e4 c4 omm-3 unica-3 ti-3 on Egiazar-2 y4 an v4 almay4 e4 F6 a4 tt-3 or3 r3 e4 re7 se3 nti-3 B7 nd vi ce pr3 ivi-3 leg12 e4 pr3 otec6 ti-3 on be4 rs the4 burd-6 e4 of p3 rovin-8 a4 c4 e4 e4 me-7 nt of pr4 ivi-3 lege6 a4 nd la-7 c4 w5 a4 iver5 uc4 showing9 must-4 be4 ba4 e4 c4 ompete4 nt evide4 c4 e4 ua4 throu-8 ff6 idavits-2 e4 posi-2 ti-3 on testi-2 mon-11 ompel f3 or3 rope7 Cla-7 im-3 of Privil-3 e4 e4 a4 nter5 na4 citations-2 omi-3 tt-3 e4 The5 re7 fo-6 re7 e4 e4 ment e4 ist-4 e4 De6 fe7 nd-9 a4 nt re5 fus-7 e4 to ro-6 duc4 e4 he4 joint-2 de-5 fe7 nse gr3 e4 e4 ment with Epst-3 e4 in e4 e4 while sim-4 ult-3 a4 ne4 ousl-12 c4 laimi-3 ng10 that pr3 ivi-3 leg12 e4 pr3 ivi-3 leg12 e4 a4 ppli-3 e4 alw-6 re7 sts-3 upon the pe6 rson a4 sser5 ti-3 ng10 it he4 v4 ron orp F6 a6 This howing10 must-4 be4 made6 on a4 do-9 c4 ument by do-9 c4 ument ba4 sis-3 a4 nd ba4 se3 on c4 ompete4 nt e4 videnc6 e4 usu-10 a4 throu-8 gh the a6 dmi-3 ssi-3 on of3 a4 ff6 ida-7 vit-3 dep3 osit-4 ion e4 sti-4 mon8 or3 othe-7 a4 dmi-3 ssi-3 ble e4 videnc6 e4 Id e4 e4 fu-6 sa3 pro3 duc4 e4 he joint-2 de4 fe7 nse re-2 e4 ment De-3 fe7 da4 nt fa5 il-3 to e4 e4 her5 be4 twe4 e4 e4 a7 nd c4 onvicte-5 pe4 dophil-3 e4 e4 ff6 Epste-7 in re7 vious-2 thi-3 ourt or4 de4 re7 a4 e4 mail betwe-3 e4 De6 fe7 nd-9 a4 nt a4 nd Epstein e4 prod3 uc4 e4 a4 De6 fe7 nd-9 a4 nt cla4 im-3 e4 a4 rote5 c4 ted a4 c4 omm-3 on int-3 e4 re7 st privi-3 le-7 e4 Ap-7 ril Or4 de4 Case Document Filed Page of De6fe7nd-9a4nt has not m-2e4t he-7r bur6de4n with to t-11his ema3il-3 it-3 too s-2hould 8be4 prod3uc4e4d ii This C-4ourt ha5s pre6vious-2ly18 9or3d-9e4re7d 9De6f-6e4nda4nt t-3o p-9roduc7e4 betw3e4e4n 9D-7e4fe7nda4nt 11a4nd De6rshow4it-3z-5 The5 C-2ourt should do t-3he4 same5 f3or3 the-7 e4mails-2 fr6om Se-5e Apr5il-3 De6rshow4it-3z-5 Doc6uments to to produc5e4 joi-3nt def-4e4nse a-2g10r-6e4e4ment be4twe4e4n h-9e4r a7nd Ala4n De-3rshow4it-3z-5 fa7il-3s to m-4e4e4t her5 bu-9rde-2n of e7stabli-2shing7 that c4ounse3l Se4e4 C-2he-5v4ron C-2orp a6t B-2a4se3d on the c-3a4se c4laim of pr4ivi-3le-7g10e4 ove-5r the5se3 c4omm-3unica6ti-3ons i-2s im-4pr3ope4r pr3otec6ti-3on be4a-5rs the4 burd-6e4n of p3rovin e-5a4c4h e4l-11e4me-7nt of pr4ivi-3lege6 a4nd la-7c4k o-9f w5a4iver5 S-3uc4h showing9 must-4 be4 ba4s-10e4d o-9n c4ompete4nt evide4n-9c4e4 throu-8g10h a-5ff6idavits-2 9de4posi-2ti-3on testi-2mon-11y30 C-2ompel f3or3 I23mp-11rope7r Cla-7im-3 of Privil-3e4g10e4 a4t i-10nter5na4l citations-2 omi-3tt-3e4d De6fe7nd-9a4nt has fa7il-3e4d to do she 3shoul-2d pro3du-9c4e4 t-11he4se3 doc4uments i Additi-3ona4ll-13y20 49De-3fe7nda4nt-11 49ha4s 50not 51c4laimed 47that 49is 52one4 he4r in c-5a4pa4c4it-23y Case Document Filed Page of Case Document Filed Page of efe ndan ha ogge an mail a in ith at ac hm date Oc obe and cto hat i to and fr an Laur a nnin ge stat in th at th co mmuni cat i ar rotecte as att rn ey wo rk rod and co mm int est pri il ege fu te es tin th desc ri pt i th co mmuni ati ates th at i i a Co mm fu te est Agree i ste ce a co mm in te es ag ee po hi efe nd ant can eg i im ate claim a co mm int es pri il ege mu st mad ba se co mp ete nt ev id ce uall th ro gh a dmi ss i a ffid av it os i i est im or ot a dmi ss ibl ev id ce Chevron Corp at Li st in a Co mm fu terest Ag ee a pri il ege og does ot ati sfy hi urd Th efo hi cla im pri il ege i un upp 1t ed and Co uld di rec efe ndant to rod ce hi oc um Defendant Refusal to Produce and Admitted Deletions Weigh in Favor of Allowing Plaintiff to Conduct a Forensic Review of Defendant Electronic Data 1m Maxwe ll as prev i claim th at as a a pra ct i ce et in mail a ft ey ave ee ea See fen da nt Res ses and ject i Pl a inti ffs i rs eq es fo ro du ti Du to fend ants fa ilur pro du ce doc um ts a ft rpo te dl mnnin sea te 1m as or thi Co mt and fen dants failur ga th er a il fr two fo ur kn ow a il acco un ts th i ro in i ia th at fend ant ed re ev ant oc um ts Accord in Ms Giuffr li eves i i to a fo i ex amin at i Maxwe ll so nal co mput ev i ces and mail a cco unt to ecover ete data an to di scove a xwe ll ha erfo 1m a ip co mpu ters ev i ces to 1m ane ntl estroy ed a il I CO NC US ION imil a rl fendant as cla im hat i a tto rn eys rese nt in an a pac i ty Case Document Filed Page of For the easo se fo1th a ove plaintiff Virginia Giuffre respectfully reque that the Co urt grant Motion to Co mp and direct Defendant Maxwell produce oc ument responsive to Reque Nos and for the period of to th present and produ ce co mmuni ca ti wro ngfull logged Defendants privilege og hi includ co mmuni cat i wi th Dershowitz atto rn ey Mary o1 ja and co mmuni cat i ith Epstein and the co mmuni catio wi th Dated A gust Re spec tfully ubmi tted BOIES SCHIL FLEXNER LLP By I igrid Mccawley Sigr id Mccawley Pro Hae Vice Me edit Sc hul tz Pro ae Vice Boie Sc hill er Flexner LLP Las Olas Bl uit Ft a der ale David oies Boie Sc hill er Flexner LLP Main Street A nn onk NY Bradley dwar Pro ae Vice FARMER JAFFE EI SSING EDWARDS I STOS EHRMAN No11h Andrew Ave nu uite Fo11 a der ale Flor ida Paul Casse ll Pro ae Vice Quinney Co ll ege of Law Universi ty of ah Universi ty St Salt Lak i ty Thi da time bu ine ss a ddress i provided for i den ifica i on and conesponde ce purposes on and i no in ended imply in st i tution a endo se ment niver i ty Utah for thi p1ivate re pre se tat ion CERTI-2F11ICA3T-2E-2 S-3E-2RV4ICE I HE-5REB-3Y C4E-2RTIF9Y that on the 9th of A5u-9gust-2 e4l-11e4c4tronic-6a4ll-13y10 f3il-3e4d the doc4ument with-11 the Cl-2e4rk of6 C-2ourt usi-12ng10 the CM/-3ECF4 s-20y20stem 9a4lso ce5rtif-17y20 th-11a4t the doc4ument is-2 be-5ing8 ser6v-9e4d thi-3s on the indivi-3dua4ls i-4de4nti-3fie5d be4low via tr3a4nsmi-4ssi-3on of3 Notice6s of E3le-7c4tronic3 9F6il-3ing8 A M-8e4nnin-11g10e4r Esq HA4DD4ON4 MORG-9AN4 F-3OREMAN3 Ea5st th Ave6nue De6nve4r Color-8a4do Email:-2 lm-3e4nning8e4r 4hmf-8law4.c4om jpag12li-3uc-5a4 hmfla4w.-7c4om S-3ig8rid McCa4wle-5y S-3ig8rid McCa4wle-15y Case Document Filed Page of
