In the nited ates istrict Cou-10 rt for the uthern rict of New York IA5 F6 lainti-3 ff6 GH-5 LA-6 NE3 MA-8 XW6 EL-7 De6 fe7 nd-9 a4 nt cv AP MS EPLY RTHER RT OF NS LED ALS TO RIES La5 ura7 A e4 nninger Je3 ff6 e4 a4 gli-3 uc4 a ADDON AN AN Ea5 st th Ave6 nue De6 nve4 CO Case Document Filed Page I-4nt-4roduct-3ion found3e4d obje-7c4ti-3ons t-2o the r5e4lea6s-10e4 he4r July c4ompelled 7de4posi-2ti-3on testi-2mony or i9nfor6mation conc-3e4rning v-8a4rious Non P-3a4rtie3s of w5hom re5li-3e4d on the Pr-8otec6ti-3ve4 Or5de-5r issue3d by 9the Court The5 objec6ti-3ons-10 a4t i-3ssue he6re7 invol-3ve4 diff4e4re7nt 11fa7c4ts i-4nfor6m-11a4ti-3on a4nd c4ir c4umst-4a4n-9c4e4s th-11a4n thos-2e4 pre7se-6nt i-3n the f5ir-8st round of3 objec6ti-3ons including a pe6nding i-3ndictment a4ga4inst-4 Ms Maxw3e4ll-3 in t-3his Di-2strict The5 S6e4c4ond C-2irc5uit-3 a4lre-4a4dy de4ter5mi-3ne4d that Ms Max-8we6ll re7li-3e4d on the P-3rote-4c4ti-3ve4 Or5de4r to e4r July c4ompelled de6p-9osit-4ion he4 publi-3c4 tre5a4tm-3e4nt of the inf4orma5ti-3on unse3a4led in r3ound on-9e4 lea6ve4s no doubt-2 that the 7unse3a4li-3ng of3 the mate4ri-8a4ls a4t i-3ssue he6re7 will-3 unfa7i-11r-6ly pre5judi-3c4e4 Ms ue4n-9c4ing wit-3ne4ss t-3e4sti-4mony F4or re7a4sons di-3sc3ussed the Court shoul-2d de4c4li-3ne4 to uns-2e4a4l t-3he4 identifie3d S-3e4a4led 7I13tems I Ms-3 Maxwe4ll July d-3epos-4it-3ion 10re3m-3ain s-7ealed B-2y fa7il-3ing t-3o re7spond plainti-3ff6 c4onc4e4d-9e4s e3a-5c4h e4sse-7nti-3a4l fa5c4t lea6ding t-3o Ms 11Ma3xwe6ll July de4posi-2ti-3on P-3lainti-3ff6 moved to Brie-4f a-2t Ms Max we6ll-3 objec6ted to-9 the se5c4ond de4posi-2ti-3on b-9a4se3d in par5t on he-7r pr6iva-7c-5y c4onc4e4rns 7a4bout t-3e4sti-4fying to he3r a7dult-3 c4onse3nsua3l id Judge3 S-3we6e4t over-4rule5d 9Ms Maxw3e4ll obj-2e4c4ti-3on-9s to t-3he4 de4posi-2ti-3on ruling9 that he4r id The5 Jul-2y de4posi-2ti-3on wa6s c3onfine5d to Ms Ma4xw-7e4ll id Se4e4 e4.g Brow-2n v4 c4ounter5va4il-3ing value4s ma-8y include4 de4pe4nding on c4irc5umst-4a4n-9c4e4s priva5c4y int-3e-5re7st of those w3ho re7sis-3t di-3sc3losure4 quoti-3ng SEC TheStree7t.C-4om C-2ir T)4ha Case Document Filed Page of other5s se3xua4l 11a4c4ti-3vit-3y c4a-5nnot be a4nd wa6s not-2 c-5onteste3d by plainti-3ff6 lainti-3ff6 a4lso a4dmi-3ts c4ruc7ial ly ha4t he4 S-3e4c4ond C-2irc5uit by it-3s re7da4c4t ions im-3pli-3c4it-3ly held that the li-3ke4ly onl-3y pe4rmitt-4e4d a4nd the r5e4sponses only co-6mpelled be4c4a4us-10e4 of a7 st-12rong 3e4xpe4c4t-11a4ti-3on of3 c4onti-3nue4d c4onfide5nti-3a4li-3ty Se4e4 e4d-9a4c4ti-3ons for Th-8e4re7 thus fr6om t-3he4 de4posi-2ti-3on shoul-2d re7main se3a4led P-3lainti-3ff re7sponse c4on-9c-5e4rning the b3a4lan-7c4e4 of th-8e4 9de4posi-2ti-3on mi-3sc3onst-2rue7s Ma3xwe6ll objec6ti-3ons a4nd mi-3sst-3a4tes the3 fa7c4ts and law4 of u-9nse3a4li-3ng pr3e4vious-2ly sea5le-7d judi-3c4ial doc4uments F6irst plainti-3ff a3rgum-8e4n-9t t-3ha4t t-3he4 S-3e4c4ond C-2irc5uit-3 unse3a4led two pa6g-9e4s of th-9e4 Jul-2y tra5nsc3ript e4rgo a4ll-3 other5 n-9on int-3im-3a4te que6sti-4ons a3nd a4nswe5rs should li-3ke4wis-10e4 be4 unse3a4l-11e4d re7li-3e4s on fa7ult-3y logi-3c4 a4nd a4n im-13prope7r le5g-9a4l pre5mi-3se3 u-9mm-3a4ry judgme3nt pl-3e4a4dings-2 li-3ke the e6xc-5e4r pts fr6om t-3he4 Jul-2y tra5nsc-6ript c3onsi-2de4re7d by the Se-7c4ond C-2irc5uit i.e pre7sump-2ti-3on of3 publi-3c4 a4c-5c4e4ss Brow-2n W4hil e4 the S-3e4c-5ond C-2irc5uit de4c4isi-4on to kee6p se3a4led s-8e4ve4n pe3rta5ini-3ng to questi-2ons e3xpli-3c4it-3ly re5fe7r-6ring to se-7xua4l m-3a4tt-3e4rs prove7s p-9e4c-5ific3a4ll-3y the de6c4isi-4on to unse3a4l t-3wo pa6ge4s non int-3i mate4 matter5s doe3s not-2 ove4rc7ome As e4xpl-11a4ined be6low the pr-4e4sum-12pti-3on is 2ove4rc7ome a6s to the July de3posi-2ti-3on in t-3oto S-3e4c4o Although Ms-3 Ma3xwe6ll-3 be4li-3e4ve4s that t-2he4 e4nti-3re7 d-9e-5posi-2ti-3on tra5nsc3ript shoul-3d re7main se3a4led f5or th-8e4 re-2a4sons for6th below in the inter5e-5st of judi-3c4ial e4c4onomy she3 he4re7by unde4r se6a4l pro-8pose3d r-6e4da-5c4ti-3ons in ye5ll-3ow c4onc-5e4r-6ning all int-3im-3a4te ma4tt-3e4rs fr6om t-3he4 Jul-2y de4posi-2ti-3on a4s Exhibi-2t Case Document Filed Page of e4 c4 ond irc5 uit-3 w5 he4 it-3 ff6 irme3 thi-3 ourt orde-3 a7 to he4 fir4 st e4 of de5 osit-4 ion a4 ter5 ials Re4 sp a3 e4 unl-3 ike he4 Jul-2 de4 posi-2 ti-3 on tra5 nsc3 ript a3 ssue re7 e4 fir4 st e4 of de4 posi-2 ti-3 on mate4 ria5 ls wa6 not base5 on a4 spe-6 c4 ific3 pr-6 omi-3 se3 by the ourt a5 nd plainti-3 ff c3 ounse3 ha4 a4 ll of the5 a4 nswe-4 rs w4 ould be4 ke4 pt conf5 idential und-9 the rote5 c4 ti-3 ve4 rd-6 e4 a4 ther5 his ourt ruling re6 ga4 rding the fir4 st deposit-3 ion a4 ff6 irme3 by he4 e4 c4 ond irc5 uit-3 foun3 that Ms Maxw3 e4 ll-3 fa7 il-3 e4 to de4 nti-3 fy de7 posi-2 ti-3 on e4 sti-4 mony int-3 e4 al-2 ia c4 onse3 sua3 adult c4 ti-3 vit-3 be4 ha4 vior a5 nd e4 ne4 a4 ll-3 discla3 im-3 e4 a4 ny knowle4 dg-9 e4 of un3 de4 ra7 e4 Th is ourt de5 c4 li-3 ne4 to kee6 se3 a4 led thi-3 Id The5 Jul-2 de4 posi-12 ti-3 on testi-2 mony obtaine4 unde4 f6 dif4 fe-2 re7 nt c4 ir-8 c4 mst-4 a4 nc4 e4 is full-3 of In f6 c4 the only author-2 ized que4 sti-4 ons we5 re7 ow4 a4 The5 unse3 a4 li-3 ng of3 the A4 pril de4 posi-2 ti-3 on ha4 not-2 hing do with he4 potential unse3 a4 li-3 ng of3 the July de4 posi-2 ti-3 on e4 posi-2 ti-3 on c4 ontains e4 sti-4 mony ha4 shou-2 ld re5 main se3 a4 led F8 rst Judge3 we-3 e4 author3 ize6 only que4 sti-4 ons ha4 per5 taine4 int-3 im-3 a4 te ma4 tt-3 e4 rs D4 a4 Any que6 sti-4 on-9 be3 yond the a4 uthoriz3 e4 topi-3 c4 e4 re7 mprope5 Se-5 e4 e4 DE3 a4 se3 e4 also DE3 a4 e4 taili-3 ng the r5 e4 c4 rd suppor5 for4 he4 a4 rgume5 nt ha4 de-7 fe7 nse-6 ounse3 nstruc4 ted Ma3 xwe6 ll-3 not a4 nswe5 to-8 e4 nfor6 e4 the ourt rde a4 nd to pre5 e4 nt har5 a4 ssm-13 e4 nt by pl-3 a4 int-3 iff Case Document Filed Page 0R 0X 0Q 0V 0O Additi-3 ona4 ll-3 e4 ve4 que4 sti-4 ons a3 bou ssage6 we5 0R 0Q 0O 0S 0H 0P 0W 0G 0E 0W 0K 0H 0R 0X 0U 0W 0V 0R 0U 0G 0U 0V 0W 0K 0H 0S 0U 0W 0L 0G 0W 0R 0V 0X 0O 0W 0Y 0L 0Q 0G in pl-3 a4 int-3 iff vi-2 e4 que6 sti-4 on-9 a3 bout massa4 ge4 we6 re7 qu-9 e4 sti-4 ons a3 bout se3 DE3 a4 Ms Ma4 xw-7 e4 ll-3 orde7 re7 to a4 nswe5 qu-6 sti-4 ons 0U 0O 0D 0W 0L 0Q 0J 0R De6 fe7 nd-9 a4 nt 0V 0R 0Z 0Q 0V 0O 0D 0W 0Y 0L 0R 0U 0O 0D 0W 0L 0Q 0J 0R 0K 0U 0N 0Q 0Z 0O 0G 0J 0R 0I 0V 0O 0W 0Y 0L 0L 0H 0V 0R 0R 0W 0K 0H 0V invol-3 ving or inc3 ludi-3 ng massa4 ge4 with ndivi-3 dua4 ls De3 fe7 nd-9 a4 nt knew4 to e4 or b3 e4 li-3 e4 ve4 mi-3 ght 0E 0R 0P 0H 0N 0Q 0R 0Q 0W 0R 0S 0V 0Q I plainti-3 ff e4 he4 e4 ve4 qu-9 e4 sti-4 ons a4 bout a4 ssage6 we6 e4 que sti-4 ons a3 nd a4 nswe5 rs 0R 0X 0W 0V 0X 0O 0D 0W 0Y 0L 0Q 0G 0W 0K 0H 0I 0R 0V 0K 0R 0X 0G 0U 0P 0D 0L 0Q 0O 0H 0G Ne6 xt lainti-3 ff6 mi-3 sc3 onst-2 rue7 M3 arti-4 nde4 ll F6 2d ir he4 c4 laims-2 it-3 i irr4 e4 leva6 nt e4 c4 a4 e4 it-3 c4 onc-5 e4 rne7 the gov-7 e4 rnme5 nt ra7 ther5 than th-9 e4 publi-3 right a4 c4 c4 e4 ss doc4 uments c3 ove4 e4 by a4 prote5 c4 ti-3 ve4 ord-6 e4 a4 c4 thi-3 unse3 a4 li-3 ng c4 a4 me a6 bou-9 af5 ter5 a re7 que4 st by 0W 0Z 0R 0L 0Q 0U 0Y 0Q 0R 0U 0V 0W 0R 0P 0R 0G 0I 0W 0K 0S 0U 0R 0W 0W 0Y 0U 0G 0R 0R 0E 0W 0D 0L 0Q 0V 0V 0R 0V 0O 0H 0G 0G 0R 0X 0P 0H 0Q 0W 0V A M3 arti-4 nde4 ll-3 0L 0Q 0V 0U 0X 0W 0V 0Q 0O 0H 0V 0V 0Y 0O 0G 0X 0O 0H 0R 0W 0H 0W 0Y 0R rde-2 is to be f5 ly and f5 a4 irly e4 nfor6 e4 a4 ble witnesse4 re-3 lyi-3 ng upon suc3 ord3 e4 rs il-3 be inhibi-3 ted f5 rom givi7 ng e4 ssential testi-2 mony in civil-3 li-3 ti-3 ga4 ti-3 on thus de4 rmini-2 ng a4 proc-2 e4 dura7 ystem ha4 has be5 e4 suc-6 e4 ssfull-2 de4 ve4 loped ove4 the5 ye-5 a4 rs f5 or dispo-2 sit-4 ion c7 ivi-3 dispu-2 tes F6 2d a4 And the-5 e4 c4 ond irc5 uit-3 ther5 e4 found3 that true5 0Q 0L 0Q 0K 0I 0R 0I 0W 0K 0H 0S 0X 0E 0O 0L 0F 0L 0Q 0W 0H 0V 0W 0Q 0R 0E 0W 0D 0L 0Q 0L 0Q 0J 0D 0O 0O 0U 0O 0H 0Y 0Q 0W 0H 0Y 0L 0G 0Q 0T 0X 0L 0U 0G for6 law4 e4 for6 e4 ment pur3 ose3 id a4 ar5 gu-9 a4 bly a w4 e4 ight ier int-3 e4 e4 st ha-5 the r5 ight-3 of a7 tabloid to publ-3 ish and e5 xploi-3 sala3 c4 ious ossi-3 a4 rising fr4 a c6 ompelled de6 posi-2 ti-3 on The5 pa4 rtie3 a3 tt-3 e4 mpt-3 e4 to c4 a4 ll-3 the ourt f4 a7 ruling during the3 de4 posi-2 ti-3 on but we4 re7 0G 0Y 0L 0V 0H 0G 0E 0K 0P 0E 0U 0V 0W 0R 0E 0U 0L 0Q 0J 0Q 0L 0V 0X 0W 0R 0K 0P 0D 0W 0H 0W 0K 0H 0R 0O 0X 0V 0R 0Q 0R 0W 0K 0H 0S 0R 0V 0W 0R 0Q Se4 e4 a4 Exhibi-2 a tt-3 a4 c4 he4 he4 to hi-3 ghli-3 ght in lue 0T 0X 0V 0W 0R 0Q 0V 0K 0W 0S 0H 0W 0D 0L 0Q 0W 0R 0P 0V 0V 0D 0J without-3 spe3 c4 ific3 a4 ll-3 re-2 fe7 e4 nc4 ing se3 xua4 c4 ti-3 vit-3 Case Document Filed Page of Nor5 doe4s SEC TheStre-6e4t.com C-2ir a4id pl-3a4int-3iff4 he4 de4posi-2ti-3on a4t i-3ssue in T-3he4Stree5t two pa4rtie3s who w-6e4re7 not s-2ignator3ies to Id a4t F-3urthe5r the5 S-3e4c4ond C-2irc5uit-3 foun3d that the sim-2ple a6c4t of submi-3tt-3ing deposit-2ion t-3e4sti-4mony t-3o 10the ourt to dec7ide whe6ther5 or no3t t-3o e4nt-11e4r th-8e Id a4t Ana6logous-2ly Ms Maxw-6e4ll-3 subm-2it-3ted he6r c7ompl-3e4te July de4posi-2ti-3on to t-3he4 ourt f4or r6e4view4 opposi-2ng a4 re7que4st t-4o re-2ope4n that de4posi-2ti-3on Ms-3 Ma3xwe6ll-3 wa6s fo-7rc7e to sho-2w the4 ourt all the que6sti-4ons she ha6d a4nswe-4r-6e4d be4yond thos-2e4 a4uthori-10z-5e4d by the ourt orde7r a4nd number5 of 6re7pe4ti-3ti-3ve4 a4nd ha-5ra7ssi-3ng que4sti-4ons This subm-2iss-3i8on of3 the July Brow-2n a4t nli-3ke4 T-3he4Stree5t Ms Maxw3e4ll-3 re7li-3e4d on the 7prote5c4ti-3ve4 ord-6e4r whe6n a4nsw-8e4ring the qu3e4s-10ti-3ons i-2n the July de3posi-2ti-3on be4c4a4use3 unli-3ke4 T-3he4Stree5t no thi-3rd pa4rtie3s we5r-6e4 pr-6e4se3nt duri-10ng he4r de4posi-2ti-3on he4r-6e-5for6e the M3arti-4nde4ll pr-6e4s-10umpt-3ion aga6inst-4 disclosure5 a4ppli-3e4s II T4hird p-3arty relianc-9e o-9n t-4he rotective rder-5 j-3us-6t-3if5ies-3 cont-3inu-3ed s-4ea11lin-2g W4it-3hout any suppor4t lainti-3ff6 a4rgue7s that Non who did not-2 objec6t to any unse3a4li-3ng ha4ve4 fo-6rf6e it-3e4d 9a4ny right t-2o a4n indepe6nde-5nt dete4rmina3ti-3on of3 whe6t-11he4r the5y r-6e4a4sona3bly re7li-3e4d on the rote5c4ti-3ve4 rde7r o-6r ha7ve4 v-9a4luable4 p-9riva5c4y int-3e4r-6e4sts-3 a4t st-4a4ke t-11ha4t over5c4ome th-9e4 This ar-4gument is c4ontra5ry to the Protoc4ol a-5nd doe4s not-2 a c4c4ount for6 the ma4ny pr-6a4c4ti-3c4a4l p-11r-6oblems t-2ha4t per5sis-3t t-3hroug3h no f3a4ult-3 of the5 C-2ourt o-8r the5 pa4rtie3s in a4tt-3e4mpt-3ing t-3o pro3vide a6de4qua4te notice6 to t-3he4 9Non P-3a4rtie3s Se4e4 DE3 de-2taili-3ng iss-3ue4s As to t-2he4 for6mer5 the Prot-10oc4ol explicitl-3y a4dvised N-6on P-3a4rtie3s that their3 pa4rti-10c4ipation i-3s that 0C C-2ourt a4l-11so promised it would Case Document Filed Page of re7view4 of th-8e4 S-3e4a4led Ma5t-11e4ria5ls and w-7e4igh t-3he4 c4om-11pe4ti-3ng int-3e4re7sts-3 re3gardl-2e4s-10s w-3he4ther it-2 re3c4e4ive6s any4 N-2on Party O4bjec6ti-3on Id e7mph-11a4sis-3 suppl-2ied As to t-2he4 latter5 a4ny No-7n P-3a4rtie3s ne3ve-5r r6e-5c4e4ived c4opy of3 the Protoc3ol N-7oti-3c4e re7c-5e4ipt-3 of the5 Notice6 to ne-5a4rly ha-5lf of the5 Non P-3a4rtie3s whom Ms Maxw3e4ll-3 a4tt-3e4mpt-3e4d se3rvic-4e4 wa6s ne4ve4r c7on-9fir4med h-9ow ma4ny of3 the 9Non P-3a4rtie3s pa3rtie3s it se3rve7d a-5c4tually re-4c4e4ived t-9he4 Notice Give4n pla-7in l-3a4ngua4ge4 of the5 P-3rotoc-4ol i-3t would be im-3prope to de4fa7ult-3 a4 9No-7n P-3a4rty f4or f-6a4il-3ure7 to obj-3e-5c4t whe6n Notice6 wa6s ne3v-9e-5r pr6ovided F6o-9r e4xa4mpl-3e4 Doe6 did no-11t re5c4e4ive notic-7e4 a4nd it-3 is unc4onteste3d that Doe6 testified only unde4r the e6xpre7ss promi-2se3 o-9f c7o-9nfide5nti-3a4li-3ty The3 S-3e4c4on-9d C-2irc5uit-3 sua spont-3e4 re7da-5c4t e4d Doe6 n-9a4me fr6om su-2mm-3a4ry judgme3nt pl-3e4a4dings-2 finding t-2ha4t Doe priva5c4y int-3e-5re7sts-3 out-11we6ighed the4 strong pre7sump-2ti-3on of a7c-5c4e4ss i-13nhe4re7nt t-3o thos-2e4 plea6ding-11s Doe ha4s not-2 file3d 9a4n objec6ti-3on to unse3a4li-3ng he4re7 p-9re7suma-8bly sh-2e4 ne4ve4r le-4a4rne7d o-9f t-8he4 ne e4d to do s-2o but plainti-3ff6 would ha4ve4 Doe c4on-9fide5nti-3a4l i-3nfor6mation unse3a4led re7ga-5r-6dless Se4e4 DE3 D-7E P-3lainti-3ff6 incor5re7c4tl-3y a4ss-11e4r-6ts t-4ha4t the pa6rtie3s agre3e4d that they na4mes in doc3uments t-2ha4t ord-6e4re7d uns-10e4a4led fai-3led to obj-3e4c4t t-3o unse3a4li-3ng DE3 3(P-3rof De6rshow4it-3z re7que4st his n-2a4me be6 unre7d-9a4c4ted Ms Maxw3e4ll-3 a4sser5ted only that knowle4dge4 of w5ho wa6s obj-2e-5c4ti-3ng mi-3ght aid the Court in ure Se4e4 DE3 P-3a4rtie3s will-3 give the4 C-2ourt a-4nd the O4r igi-3na4l P-5a4rtie3s more5 infor4mation about sc3ope4 of ob3j-11e4c4tors the-7re7 li-3mi-3tations-2 to t-3he4 e4xtent to which it wil-3l Non P-3a4rtie3s will-4 a4id t-3he4 9C-2ourt in con3duc4ti-3ng The5 S-3e4c4ond C-2irc5uit-3 in M-6arti-4nde4ll T-3he4Stree5t United States v5 Am3ode4o a4nd Brow-2n v4 Case Document Filed Page of M3ax4w-2e4ll ha4s re a4f-6fir4med-7 re7pe4a4t-11e4dly the pr5inciple t-9ha4t t-3hird pa5rtie3s e4nti-3tl-3e4d to re5ly on a va6li-3d prote5c4ti-3ve4 ord-6e4r a7t t-3he4 ti-13me the4y give disc3ove4ry a-5nd that the Court ha4s a3 ro-6le in we6ighi-3ng both t-3he4 e4xe4rc7is-12e4 of the5 A-7rtic3le judi-3c4ial powe6r a7nd the 7re-2sult-4a4nt value4 of suc6h info-8rma5ti-3on to t-3hose3 moni-3toring United States v5 A-8mode6o C-2ir Ms Maxw3e4ll-3 c4a4nnot t-3a4ke4 on the bu-7rde-2n of a7sser5ti-3ng the pr5iva-7c4y-9 int-3e4re7sts-3 of e7a-5c4h Non P-3a4rty w3ho f-6a4il-3e4d to obj-3e4c4t The3 S-3e4c4ond C-2irc-4uit-3 wa6s a3ble to de4ter5mi-3ne-5 for it-3se3lf tha3t Doe4 wa6s e3nti-3tl-3e4d to prote3c4ti-3on-9 This C-4ourt pr4omi-3se3d the N4on P-3a4rtie3s in i-4ts P-6rotoc5ol t-3ha4t i-3t would unde4rta5ke4 that indi-3vidual-9ize6d re7vie-7w I Ms Maxw-9ell Ri-8ght t-9o a Fair Tr-8ial Re-9quire Contin-8ued Se-8aling o-7f her July Dep-8osition 8and t-8he Testim-9ony an-7d Na-8m-9es of Witnesses A F-3air T4rial Eviden-8ce Brow-2n pa4ne4l spe3c4ifi-10c4a-5ll-3y identifie3d the r5ight-3 of 6a4n a4c-5c4use3d to funda7m-11e4ntal f3a4irne5ss i-3n the jur3y s-10e4lec6ti-3on pr3oc4e4ss a4(t quoti-3ng Pre4ss Ente3r C-3o v4 Sup C-2ourt-2 of C-4al Riv3e4rsi-3de4 U.S P-3lainti-3ff6 ignore5s thi-3s e4xpre7ssl-3y c4ond-9one4d c4ounter5v-9a4il-3ing fa5c4to-11r a7nd ins-2tea6d r-6e4li-3e4s on a4se3s ge3n-9e4ra7ll-3y c4on-9c4e-5rning pr4e4tria3l publ-3icity a4nd 9mot-3ions t-4o tra5nsfe6r ve7nue-5 lainti-3ff6 shrugs of4f c7onc-5e-5rns a6bout t-3he4 fa7irn-8e4ss of 8Ms Maxw3e4ll c3rimi-2na4l t-13ria5l as Ye6t Ms 11Ma3xwe6ll-3 de4tailed in he-5r 6brie5f a4nd plainti-3ff6 doe4s not-2 dispu-2te that e)7ve4ry single d-7e4tail re5lat-9e4d to t-3his ca5se3 a4nd Ms 11Ma3xwe6ll c3rimi-2na4l R-2e4sp a3t c4f N-2at Broad C-4o C-2ir pe7rmitt-4ing broa5dc4a4st of vide5otape6s a-6fte5r 6e4nter5e-5d int-3o e4videnc6e4 in cr5im-3in-11a4l t-3ria5l United States v5 9M3artoma W4L Ja5n de7nying m-3oti-3on to s-2e4a4l cour5troom during l-11it-3igation of moti-4ons in l-3imine U.S v4 Volpe F6.S-3upp.2d moti-2on to t-3ra7nsfe6r v-6e4nue4 ba4rr6a4g-9e4 of inf4lammator3y 9a4dve4rse6 publi-3c4it-3y up to da4y of tr4ial Case Document Filed Page of a4 c4 ti-3 on a4 re7 wide4 ly re5 po-9 rte-4 by the pr5 e4 ss nc4 ludi-3 ng the publis-2 hing of the3 fir4 st uns-3 e4 a4 led de6 posi-2 ti-3 on wor5 for wor5 by NPR rie5 a7 e4 e4 led e4 ms conta3 in evide4 c4 e4 in he4 upc4 omi-3 ng c4 rimi-2 na4 ria5 nc4 ludi-3 ng the July dep3 osit-4 ion a4 ssue he6 re7 whic4 is uot-11 e4 in he4 ndictment rie5 a7 and c4 wi-9 tnesse4 in his ca5 se3 will-3 be4 witnesse4 in he4 c4 rimi-2 a4 ca6 se3 e4 c4 a4 e4 int-3 e4 ali-3 a the gove6 nment must-4 prov3 e4 that a4 ny pe-5 rjur4 wa6 mate3 ria5 thi-3 a4 c4 ti-3 ther5 e4 by ne4 c4 e4 ssi-3 tating he4 pro-6 ve4 thi-3 c3 a4 se3 withi-3 a4 a4 se-6 Id a4 ddit-3 ion the pe6 rjur4 c4 ounts-2 Brie5 a7 the)5 re7 e4 xist-4 subs-2 tantial ov-9 e4 rla5 be4 tw-9 e4 e4 the w4 it-3 ne4 sses a5 nd testi-2 mony thi-3 c3 a4 se3 a4 nd hose3 li-3 ke4 ly testi-2 fy in the c4 rimi-2 na4 ac6 ti-3 on F6 irst Ms Maxw3 e4 ll-3 wa6 di-2 re-2 c4 tl-3 a4 ske3 dur3 ing he-7 July de4 posi-2 ti-3 on a4 bout e4 c4 ond a4 ll-3 other5 witnesse4 who te4 sti-4 fie5 in his ac5 ti-3 on may be6 witnesse4 in he4 c4 rimi-2 na4 ria5 under5 e4 it-3 he4 Rule ba4 c4 kgrou3 nd to he4 c4 onspi-12 ra7 c4 bot-3 c4 a4 e4 a3 ll-3 e4 ge4 a4 ongoing c4 on spira4 c4 be4 we6 e4 Ms Maxw-6 e4 ll-3 a4 nd Mr E3 pstein Loc5 a4 rimi-2 na4 ule pr3 ovides tha3 a pr5 e4 sump-2 ti-3 on of-6 int-3 e4 rf6 e4 e4 nc4 e4 with a fa7 ir tria4 atta-7 c4 he4 to ca5 e4 orie5 of doc6 uments nc4 ding 0W 0K 0H 0L 0V 0Q 0I 0Q 0W 0H 0Q 0W 0V 0R 0I 0Q c4 onfe7 ssi-3 on a4 dmi-3 ssi-3 on or3 state3 ment given by 0W 0K 0H 0X 0V 0G 0Q 0G 0W 0K 0H 0L 0G 0Q 0W 0W 0W 0H 0V 0W 0L 0R 0Q 0R 0U 0G 0L 0E 0O 0W 0R 0I 0S 0R 0V 0S 0W 0Y 0Z 0L 0W 0Q 0H 0V 0V 0V 0U 0E 0R 0W 0K 0W 0H 0J 0R 0L 0H 0V 0R 0G 0X 0P 0H 0Q 0W 0V 0U 0E 0I 0U 0W 0K 0V 0R 0X 0U 0W for6 re7 le-7 a4 se3 he4 c4 ontents of Ms Ma3 xwe6 ll-3 the5 a4 c4 use3 de)6 posi-2 ti-3 on testi-2 mony a4 nd the ide4 nti-3 ty Due6 to he4 prote5 c4 ti-3 e4 de4 in the3 c4 rimi-2 na4 a4 se3 Ms Maxw3 e4 ll-3 is bar4 re7 fr-3 om ar5 ti-3 c4 ulating more5 fulsomely the r5 a4 ns she be6 li-3 e4 ve4 that he4 it-3 ne4 sses in his ca5 se3 who-7 se3 testim-4 ony may be6 on the ve6 rge7 r6 e4 le-7 a4 se3 thi-3 ourt w3 il-3 l6 ikew4 ise be5 witnesse4 in he4 ri-8 mi-3 na4 ac6 ti-3 on identica6 ssues Se4 e4 a4 e4 No cr AJ-8 DE3 a4 a5 pr6 ote-7 c4 ti-3 ve-5 orde7 in c5 rimi-2 na4 a4 se3 0I 0R 0E 0L 0G 0G 0Q 0J 0X 0V 0R 0I 0Q 0U 0P 0Q 0O 0G 0V 0R 0Y 0U 0I 0U 0Q 0L 0Y 0O 0S 0U 0R 0G 0L 0Q 0J id a4 DE a5 Me6 mora5 ndum Opini-3 on nd Or5 de4 e4 nying applica-3 ti-3 on to odify the c7 im-3 in8 a4 protec7 ti-3 ve4 ord-6 e4 to provide5 infor4 mation thi-3 ourt Case Document Filed Page of a4 nd testi-2 mony of prospe6 ti-3 ve4 c4 rimi-2 na4 ria5 wit-3 ne4 sses Hist-2 ory p3 rove7 that ny a4 a4 ll-3 of the5 e4 a4 led tems wil-2 be br5 oa-5 dc4 a4 st the jur3 pool The5 re7 is no int-3 e4 re7 st identifi-10 e4 that outwe4 ighs Ms Maxw3 e4 ll right a4 fa7 ir jury he do-9 c4 uments-10 a4 ssue should re7 main se3 a4 led Ms-3 Maxwe4 ll right-3 0R 0D 0D 0L 0U 0W 0U 0L 0D 0O ves-3 ed pos-6 ind-3 ict7 ent-3 af-3 ter-3 b8 riefin-3 in he prior round of-5 ealing lainti-3 ff a4 sser5 ti-3 on that the manda6 te r5 e4 pre-2 c4 lude th is ourt f4 rom c4 onsi-2 de4 ring una4 ddre7 ssed Si-3 xth Amen-7 dment c4 onc4 e4 rns is ba3 e4 le-7 ss T4 he4 ma-7 nda4 te is c3 ntroll-2 ing onl-3 a4 to matter5 withi-4 it-3 c3 ompass W4 he4 the ma4 nda4 e4 lea-3 ve4 is-3 sue3 ope3 the lowe-3 c7 ourt ma3 disp-2 ose3 0R 0I 0W 0K 0R 0Q 0J 0R 0X 0Q 0G 0V 0R 0W 0G 0H 0O 0Z 0L 0W 0K 0E 0K 0U 0P 0Q 0G 0L 0Q 0J 0D 0S 0S 0O 0W 0H 0R 0X 0U 0W ohe4 v4 DH4 Indus Inc7 F6 App ir int-3 e4 rn-6 a4 quot-3 a4 ti-3 ons om-2 it-3 ted Ms Maxw3 e4 ll ixt-3 Ame4 ndment fa7 ir tria4 rights we6 re fir4 st ra7 ised in he-6 le-4 tt-3 e4 Motion for4 e4 c4 onsi-2 de4 ra7 ti-3 on DE3 a4 nd not e4 a4 rlie-6 be4 a4 e4 she3 wa6 indi-4 c4 ted a4 fte-4 rie5 fing during the la4 st round3 of un3 se3 a4 li-3 ng The5 e4 c4 ond irc5 uit-3 did not-3 de4 c4 ide th ose3 iss-3 ue4 in ts Oc3 tober5 ruling The5 re7 fo-6 re7 they we6 re7 outsi-4 de4 the c4 ope4 of-6 the ma4 nda4 te Se-5 e4 at Union Fi-2 re3 Ins Co v3 Stroh-2 os F6 3d ir e4 ne4 a ll-3 we6 will-3 not co-7 nsider4 a4 a4 rgum-8 e4 nt 0R 0Q 0S 0S 0O 0K 0W 0V 0U 0L 0V 0H 0I 0R 0W 0K 0H 0L 0U 0V 0W 0L 0E 0O 0R 0Z 0Q 0P 0R 0L 0R 0Q 0I 0R 0U 0R 0Q 0V 0W 0R 0Q More6 ov-9 e4 he4 known fa7 c4 ts a4 ve4 c4 nge4 The5 wa-3 in which the ove4 rnme5 nt obt-3 a4 ined both he4 fir4 st and se3 c4 ond Ma3 xw-7 e4 ll-3 de4 posi-2 ti-3 ons diff4 e4 re7 nt rom wha-3 Ms-3 Ma3 xwe6 ll-3 fir4 st be4 li-3 ve4 No Court including his on-2 e4 ha4 ha3 the oppor3 tuni-3 ty to addr5 e4 ss he4 se3 fa-2 c4 tual is-2 sue3 the5 ir fe7 c4 on he4 unse3 a4 li-3 ng pr3 oc4 e4 ss a4 nd Maxw4 e4 ll c3 ounte-7 rva7 il-3 ing nter5 e4 sts-3 Third thi-3 round of5 unse-6 a4 li-3 ng is dist-4 inct fr6 om he4 fir4 st one U3 nde4 Brow-2 a4 nd a4 Ex i nc4 ludes r4 e4 da-5 c4 ti-3 ons pur3 ple f5 or a7 ny re7 e4 re-2 nc4 e4 to otential witnesse or the4 ir 0W 0H 0V 0W 0L 0R 0Q 0R 0Q 0W 0D 0L 0Q 0G 0L 0Q 0Z 0O 0V 0G 0S 0R 0V 0W 0R 0Q 0R 0P 0H 0W 0H 0J 0R 0L 0H 0V 0U 0Y 0U 0O 0S 0S 0L 0Q 0J for6 e4 xa4 mpl-3 e4 a4 pag-7 e4 the e4 ga4 rding othe3 indivi-2 dua4 ls ik8 e4 ly be4 witnesse4 in he-5 c4 rimi-2 na4 ria5 Ms-3 Ma3 xwe6 ll-3 ha4 not-2 e4 thos-2 e4 on he4 c7 ha-5 rt a5 Ex Case Document Filed Page of memor3ialize6d in th unse3a4li-3ng spe3c4if-3ic part-2iculari-2ze3d re7view4 a4n-9d unse3a4l all doc4uments for5 whic4h the 7pre7s umpt-3ion of publi-2c4 a4c-5c4e4ss out-3we6ighs any 8c4ounter5va4il-3ing priva3c4y 9a4t e7mphasis s-2uppli-3e4d he4 S-3ixt-3h Ame4ndment c4onc4e4rns r-4e4lating t-3o Ms Ma3xwe6ll Jul-3y de4p-9osit-4ion could not have6 be4e4n ra7ised in t-2he4 Jul-2y Brow-2n ruling be4c4a4use3 Ms M-12a4xwe6ll-3 ha-5d not bee6n indi-3c4ted A4nd-9 thos-2e4 c4onc4e-5rns a6s we5ll-3 9a4s the othe3r c4ounter5va4il-3ing i-3nter5e4sts-3 c-5ould not-3 ha4ve4 be4e4n r-6a4ised-8 or de7c4ided in conn-7e4c4ti-3on-9 with Ms Maxw3e4ll July de4posi-2ti-3on in t6he4 S-3e4c4ond C-2irc5uit Oc5to-11be4r rde-2r be-2c4a4u-9se3 no portion of Ms Ma3xwe6ll sec6ond d-9e4posi-12ti-3on wa6s a3t i-3ssue in that r3uli-3ng The5 c4ounter5va4il-3in-11g int-3e4re7st of f3a4ir t-10ria5l rights a5s we5ll-3 a4s the othe-6r c7ounter5v-9a4il-3ing i-3nter5e4sts-3 r)6e4quire5s fa7c4tu-11a4l finding on e4a4c4h doc-5ument a4nd how the4 r-6e4lea6se3 o-9f the5 doc4ument a4t i-3ss ue4 in t-3his round of3 unse3a4li-3ng a-5ff6e-5c4ts t-4hose3 int-3e4re7sts-3 The5 only re5lev-7a4nt m-3a4nda-5te is t-2he4 one4 fr6om t-3he4 de-5c-5isi-4on in Brow-2n in which 12the Sec6ond C-2irc5uit-3 re7da4c4ted f-3rom the July de4posi-2ti-3on c4onc4e4rning int-2im-3a4te matter5s whe5r-6e4 the que6sti-14o ns we5re7 li-3ke4ly onl-3y pe4r-6mi-3tt-3e4d a4nd the r5e4sponse-7s onl-2y c4ompelled be4c4a4use3 o-9f a7 strong 9e4xpe-5c4tation of c5onti-3nue4d c4on-9f-6identialit-3y a4t The5 S-3ixt-3h Ame4ndment c4ounter5v-9a4il-3ing i-3nter5e4st c4ombi-3ne4d wit-11h Loc5a4l C-4rimi-2na4l R-4ule c6ompel the c4onc4lusi-4on tha the e4nti-3re-2 de4posi-2ti-3on must-4 re7main se3a4led I-4V P-3lain-2t-3if-3f app-2l9ies-3 a dif-5f-3e11re3nt-4 s-4t-3and-2ard t-3o her own re4qu-2es-3t-3 t-3o keep re3c-7ords-4 s-4ealed lainti-3ff6 a4sks t-3his C-5ourt t9o ke4e4p he4r m-8e4dica6l r-8e4c4or-6ds a6nd other5 r-6e4c4o-9rds on he6r c7ha-5rt se3a4l ed without-3 prov3idi-3ng a4ny ba4sis-3 for6 the 7re7que4st 12The5 tac6ti-3c4a4l r-6e4a4son laint-11iff4 c4hose3 to not objec6t t-3o unse3a4li-3ng these5 9re7c4ords is t-2ha t-3o do so w-8ould a4dmi-3t the inconsist-3e4nc4y in he4r a-5rgume5nt that she like3 Ms Maxw3e-5ll-3 a4nd many on P-3a4rtie3s who ga6ve4 discov-8e4ry priva4c4y int-3e4r-6e4sts-3 re7li-3e4d on the rote5c4ti-3ve4 rde7r in pr4ovidi-3ng dis-2c4o-9ve4ry of6 a4 s-10e4nsit-4ive a6nd pe-5rsona6l natur3e a4nd she3 wa6nts t-4o shi-2e4ld her5 priva5t-11e4 li-3fe7 fr6om publ-3ic c6onsu-10mpt-3ion B-2ut laint8iff4 c4a4n-9not cla4im on one4 Case Document Filed Page of ha4 nd that Ms Maxw3 e4 ll priva4 te li-3 fe7 shoul-2 be4 xpose3 to publ-3 ic sc5 rutiny a3 nd sc3 urr6 il-3 ous e4 dia re7 porting whil-2 on the ot-9 he4 he4 wn priva cy shoul-2 be4 prote5 c4 ted lainti-3 ff a4 lso wa6 nts to kee6 c4 onfide5 nti-3 a4 nume-7 rous re7 c4 ords e4 c4 a4 e4 they c4 nc4 e4 rn 0L 0Q 0I 0R 0P 0D 0W 0L 0R 0Q 0D 0E 0R 0X 0W 0Q 0W 0V 0Z 0K 0Q 0S 0O 0D 0L 0Q 0W 0I 0Z 0D 0V 0P 0Q 0R 0U Se4 e4 DE3 a4 Line3 re6 lainti-3 ff6 did not-3 file3 a4 objec6 ti-3 on to uns-2 e4 a4 li-3 ng these5 non medic4 a4 re-4 c4 ords Nor5 did she de4 tail he4 grou3 nd-9 on whic3 the doc6 ument-9 shoul-3 be4 ke4 pt uns-2 e4 a4 led-7 other5 than he6 c4 ha4 rt whic4 st-2 a4 e4 in ipse dix3 it-3 0I 0V 0K 0L 0R 0W 0K 0D 0W 0W 0K 0H 0G 0R 0X 0P 0H 0W 0V 0U 0I 0Q 0L 0Q 0I 0R 0W 0R 0Q 0E 0R 0X 0W 0H 0Y 0Q 0W 0V 0Z 0K 0Q a4 tal to her5 be4 lat-9 e4 re7 qu-9 e4 the f4 a4 c4 ha4 he4 se3 e4 ords w4 e4 e4 not produ3 c4 e4 by lainti-3 ff6 e4 a4 use3 of a4 ny re7 li-3 a4 nc-5 e4 on he4 rote5 c4 ti-3 ve4 Or5 e4 fa-2 he4 re7 c4 rds w4 re7 a4 is-3 c4 lea6 fr6 om he4 a4 tes-8 number5 obt-2 a4 ined by e4 de4 fe7 e4 fr6 om e4 re-2 c4 rds r5 e4 que4 sts-3 a4 publi-3 c4 re7 c4 ords Th-8 e4 na4 mes ny mi-3 nors w4 ho we6 re7 a4 ll-3 ge4 victim-3 or mi-3 nors a4 c4 use3 of rime3 we-4 re7 re7 da4 c4 e4 by the la4 e4 nfor-3 c4 e4 ment a4 e4 nc4 ies Se-5 e4 DE3 a4 nd ther5 sim-4 il-3 a4 doc4 uments ha4 we4 e4 a4 tt-3 c4 he4 to he4 sum-2 mar5 jud-11 gment plea6 dings-2 we6 e4 re7 e4 a4 se3 by the Se-7 c4 ond irc5 uit in he4 re7 da4 c4 ted fo-6 rm pr4 ovided by the4 re7 e4 a4 nt a4 e6 nfo-6 rc7 e4 e4 nt age-3 nc4 ies DE3 CONCL5 USI-5 ON F6 or the5 fo-6 re7 going e4 a4 son-10 Ms-2 Ma3 xwe6 ll-3 re7 spe-6 c4 tfu-8 ll-3 re7 que4 sts-3 that the Court gr3 a4 nt her5 objec6 ti-3 ons unse3 a4 li-3 ng Case Document Filed Page of Da6 ted De-3 c4 e4 mber5 e4 spe3 c4 tfully-2 subm-2 it-3 ted aura A M3 e4 nninger La5 ura7 A e4 nninger5 Je3 ff6 e4 a4 gli-3 uc4 a4 pro hac4 v4 ice-3 Ha6 ddon Morga6 a4 nd F6 e4 man Ea5 st th Ave6 nue De6 nve4 CO hone4 F6 a4 lm-3 e4 nninger5 hmfla4 w.c6 Attor-3 ne4 y4 for-3 Ghisl-2 aine M5 ax4 e4 ll Case Document Filed Page of CERTI-2 FICA4 OF E7 RV4 ICE c4 e4 rtify tha4 on e4 e4 mbe-7 e4 le-7 c4 tronic3 a4 ll-3 se3 rve7 thi-3 Re5 ply e4 mor-8 andum in Further upport-2 of Objec6 ti-3 ons Unse5 ali-3 ng Se4 aled M5 ateri-10 als Related to Doc6 k4 e4 Ent-12 ries via E3 F6 on the f5 oll-3 owing igrid Mc3 a4 wle4 Me3 re7 dit-3 c4 hult-3 LLP Ea5 st Las O3 las Boul-3 va4 rd St-2 e4 F6 La3 ude-5 rda7 le F6 smcc5 a4 wle4 bs-9 fllp.c3 om mschult-2 z4 bsfllp.com a4 ul a4 ssell Unive4 rsity tre5 e4 a4 lt-3 La5 ke4 it-3 UT3 c4 a4 ssellp a4 w.uta4 e4 du ra7 dley Edw4 rds tan ott-3 inger ED3 W4 ARDS OT3 NG4 LLC Nor5 th Andr3 e4 ws Ave6 te F6 La3 ude-5 rda7 le F6 bra7 pa5 tht-3 ojust-4 ice6 c4 om tanPot-3 ti-3 nge4 a4 ol.com Andr5 e4 G4 e4 ll-3 i Da6 vid Le3 bowitz Eme3 ry Ce4 ll-3 i rinc5 ke4 rhof-3 A3 ba4 dy LLP F6 ifth Ave5 nu-9 e4 a4 oc-5 ke4 e4 ll-3 e4 Ce4 e4 th F6 loor Ne6 Y4 ork NY4 a4 c4 e4 ll-3 i e3 c4 a4 law4 c4 om dlebow4 it-3 z4 e5 c4 a4 law4 c4 om hristi-3 ne4 W6 a4 lz HO4 LLA4 ND4 GH4 LLP W4 e4 st nd tre5 e4 Ne6 Y4 ork NY4 hristi-3 ne4 wa6 lz hklaw4 om Ja3 W3 olm-3 a4 Ma3 rc7 a4 nda-5 z4 a AN4 DA4 ZZA4 LEG-5 AL3 OU4 LLC e4 a4 rl tre5 e4 th F6 loor Ha6 rtf4 ord CT jm-3 ra7 nda4 z4 a4 c4 om mj-3 ra7 nda4 z4 a4 c4 om icole4 Simmons Nic4 ole Si-3 mm-3 ons Case Document Filed Page of
26,573 characters
