Bottom Type Pagination BDC TT0 Tf Td Td EMC BDC TT1 Tf Td UN4 IT-3 ST-4 ATE-3 DI11 S6 CT COUR3 OUT-2 HE-4 RN4 DIST-5 RIC13 OF NEW YOR-8 F6 lainti-3 ff6 GH-5 NE MA-5 XW-3 De6 fe7 nd-9 a4 nt cv RWS COM-5 INED M4 M4 ORAN4 UM6 OF9 AW IN OPP10 OS-5 IT-3 ION XTE-3 ND4 ING9 DEAD3 NE COMP13 D2 OS-5 IT-3 AND M4 OT-4 ION OR AN4 IONS-4 OR VIOL-3 ATIO-3 OF11 RU4 a4 ra7 A e4 nnin-11 e4 e4 ff6 a4 li-3 uc-5 a HA4 DD4 ON4 MORG-9 AN4 AN4 FOR-2 EMAN4 Ea5 st th Ave6 nue De6 nve4 CO Case Document Filed Page of Case Document Filed Page of TABLE OF CONTENTS INTRODUCTION BACKGROUND LEGAL AU THORITY I PLAINTIFF LA CK OF DILIGE NCE Ros Go Jean Luc Brunel Jeffrey Ep tein Nadia Marc in cova and Sa ah Kellen II FIFTH AMENDMENT BY EP STE IN KELLEN OR MARCINCOVA NOT ADMI SS IBLE IN THIS CASE AGAINST MS MAXWEL I PLAINTIFF BAD FAITH DISCOVERY TA TICS HO ULD NO BE REWARDED WITH EXTRA TIME Plaintiff Rule Re vo ing oo Plaintiff RecmTent Rule Vio lati IV MS MAXWELLS GOO FAITH EFFORTS TO CONDUCT DISCOVERY GOOD CAUSE EXISTS TO TAKE RE-DEPOSE PLAINTIFF AND TO DEPOSE SHARON CHURCHER EXISTS VI A LTERN A TIVELY AL OTHER DEADLINES NEED TO BE EXTENDED CE RTIFI CA TE OF ER ICE I Bottom Type Pagination BDC TT0 Tf Tc Td ii Tc Tm TT0 Tf Td EMC BDC TT1 Tf Td ABL-3 OF9 AU4 HO-3 RITI-2 arls-3 v4 Ge6 ne4 v4 a Ci-4 ty c4 hool Dis-2 F6 D.N4 c4 om-7 pare Re5 e4 se3 v4 Virgi-3 nia Intern Term3 inal-3 Inc6 F6 E.D Va6 Fox5 I3 ndust-2 ries I3 nc4 v4 urovic5 No CV E4 D.N4 c4 Groc5 hows-3 k4 i P3 hoe4 nix onst-2 F6 3d Ci-4 Iantosc4 a v4 Be5 nist-4 ar Adm-7 in Svc6 Inc6 F6 upp.2d Ma5 ss iBut-2 ti-3 v4 United States F6 3d 2d Ci-4 M3 urphy3 v4 Board of Educ-6 F6 D.N4 Pe rfec5 Pea3 rl Inc7 v4 Maje5 sti-4 c4 Pe5 arl Ston-11 e4 Inc7 F6 upp 2d D.N4 Sok4 ol Holdi-3 ngs Inc6 v4 M3 M5 unai Inc5 Ci-4 KMW-4 DF a4 S.D.N3 A4 Usov5 v4 azar cv a4 N.Y4 e4 Case Document Filed Page of Case Document Filed Page of Defendant Ghislaine Maxwell Ms Maxwell files this Combined Response Response in Opposition to Plaintiffs Motion to Extend Deadline to Complete Depositions Motion and Motion for Sanctions For Violation of Rule and states as follows INTRODUCTION Apparently Plaintiff seeks to take six depositions beyond the scheduling order deadline of July yet has failed to demonstrate good cause or diligence as to any The witnesses include a witness that Plaintiff initiated inf01mal attempts to depose on Jlme and Ross Gow who Plaintiff began steps to depose under the Hague Convention in London last Friday June Plaintiff also seeks to untimely depose Jean Luc Brunel a witness she had noticed for a mid June deposition who apparently did not appear on that date with agreement and consent of Plaintiffs counsel The remaining three witnesses Plaintiff seeks to untimely depose are ones who repeatedly have expressed their intention to take the Fifth Amendment as to all questions posed Cmmsel for Jeffrey Epstein offered to accept se1vice on or about April but Plaintiff ignored that offer for more than six weeks Plaintiff only began on June any attempt to schedule that deposition in the Virgin Islands Last week Mr Epsteins cmmsel filed a Motion to Quash his deposition subpoena The final rmtimely depositions sought by Plaintiff are for witnesses Sarah Kellen and Nadia Marcincova about whom Plaintiff has made no public claims and thus have no testimony relevant to this defamation action concerning whether Plaintiffs public In her Amended CoITected Reply In Support of Motion to Exceed Ten Depositions Plaintiff represents that she only seeks to take three depositions beyond the litnit of ten and that she no longer seeks depositions of witnesses Emmy Taylor Dana Bums JoJo Fontanilla and Michael Reiter Doc at She does not state her intentions with respect to other witnesses like Maria Alessi that she noticed but never deposed However comparing that Reply with her other motions counsel has deduced the remaining witnesses from whom Plaintiff apparently seeks to secm-e deposition testimony in July Plaintiff has already taken depositions and another scheduled tom01Tow Thus by the close of discove1y she will have taken of her allotted IO depositions Bottom Type Pagination BDC GS0 gs TT0 Tf Td Tm TT0 Tf Td EMC BDC TT0 Tf TD a4 ll-3 e4 ga4 ti-3 ons a3 bout Ghis-2 laine4 Max-6 we6 ll-3 a4 re7 or3 ra7 e4 a7 e4 not true5 Th-8 e4 a4 e4 mpt-3 e4 ser6 vic-7 e4 of subpoe3 na4 on Epst-2 e4 in e4 ll-3 e4 a4 nd Mar-3 c4 incova6 a4 ll-3 viol-3 a4 ule a4 shoul-2 be4 sa3 nc4 ti-3 one4 thi-3 ourt-2 As to a3 ll-4 of3 these5 witness-9 e4 Ru le to odif-18 he4 c4 he4 duli-3 ng10 O2 rde-2 r2 fa7 c4 for4 e4 most-4 pa4 rt he-4 f6 a4 il-3 ur3 e4 to c4 ti-3 ve4 pursue6 de4 posi-2 ti-3 ons wit-2 these5 witnesse4 qua3 li-3 fie5 a4 in e4 c4 usable4 ne-5 le-7 c4 he4 f3 ritter4 e4 se3 ve4 of3 the e4 ig8 ht-2 mont-3 of the4 discove5 e4 riod a4 nd now ha6 la-7 c4 e4 Ms Max-6 we6 ll-3 thi-3 ourt a4 nd the it-3 ne4 sses in he4 untena6 ble posit-2 ion of tr-7 ng10 to c4 c4 omm-3 oda4 te e4 a4 st-5 mi-3 nute sc5 ra7 mbl-3 e4 the a4 bsen-6 c4 e4 of a4 a4 e4 ptable4 e4 c4 uses a6 nd fo-6 he4 li-3 mi-3 ted e6 videntiar-14 va-5 lue tha4 ost of the re7 que4 sted w3 it-3 ne4 e4 ca7 pr3 thi-3 ourt should den-7 e4 r3 e4 qu-9 e4 st for3 the-7 e4 tra5 ti-3 me to take6 these5 six-12 de4 posi-2 ti-3 ons The5 onl-11 witnesse4 for5 hom deposit-2 ions hould be4 pe4 rmitt-4 e4 followin-10 the disc3 ove4 c4 ut-2 a4 li-3 st wi-2 th he4 Daily M5 ail who f5 il-3 e4 a4 Mot-2 ion Qua6 sh he3 subpoe6 na4 on the e4 for-3 e4 he4 sc6 he4 dul-11 e4 de4 posi-2 ti-3 on a4 nd a4 int-3 iff4 who r5 fuse6 to answ-6 que7 sti-4 ons a3 her5 de4 posi-2 ion conc6 e4 rnin-8 hig8 r3 e4 lev-7 a4 nt pr3 il-3 e4 e4 info-8 rma5 ti-3 on Alter5 na4 ti-3 ve4 if the3 our-6 to g7 ra7 nt additi-3 ona4 im-3 for6 lainti-3 ff6 to a4 ke4 e4 posi-2 ti-3 Ms Max-6 we6 ll-3 will-3 be4 undul-11 pr3 e4 judi-3 c4 e4 without-3 suff5 ic-7 ient a4 ddit-3 ional ti-3 me to a7 se)6 c4 ur3 e4 a4 witnesse4 to re5 but e4 sti-4 mon-11 lea6 fr6 om he4 se3 witnesse4 onduc4 di-3 sc3 ove-5 of lain e4 pe4 rts c4 subm-2 it-3 a4 sum-2 mar-4 jud-11 ment mot-3 ion hich inc4 ludes fa-2 c4 lea5 rn-6 fr6 om he4 se3 late4 de4 posi-2 ti-3 a4 nd pr)6 e4 a4 re7 f3 tr4 de4 a4 dli-3 ne4 in he4 c4 he4 duli-13 ng10 rde7 ou-9 ht be4 ex t8 e4 nde4 c4 c4 or3 din-11 Ms ell a Case Document Filed Page of Case Document Filed Page of BACKGROUND To divert attention away from her own lack of diligence Plaintiff characteristically devotes much of her Motion blaming Ms Maxwell and her counsel for her own problems with depositions Not only is Plaintiffs account factually inaccurate none of it matters to whether she could timely complete the six depositions at issue For example the scheduling of Ms Maxwell deposition which depended among other things an historic snowstonn a disputed protective order Plaintiffs failure to timely produce documents a11d counsel conflicting calendars all of which have been amply documented with this Court does not inform any analysis regarding Plaintiffs lack of diligence in pursuing depositions of these six witllesses See Rule Unless the patties stipulate or the comt orders otherwise for the parties and witllesses convenience and in the interests of justice A methods of discovery may be used in any sequence and discovery by one paity does no require any other party to delay i discove1y Likewise receipt of Ms Maxwells Rule disclosures in Febrnaiy also had nothing to do with these witllesses Id Notably each of the witllesses who Plaintiff now seeks to depose were know11 to her from the outset all but were included in her initial Rule disclosm se1ved on November and two of the six were specifically mentioned in Plaintiffs Complaint Finally the fac tha witlless Rinaldo Rizzo had a deposition re-scheduled from April until June does not have a11y beai-ing on the issue presented by this motion Mr Rizzo was deposed on June and he has nothing to do with the remaining depositions Mr Rizzo in fact was practically gleeful to be a witlless Doc Tr of Hearing of Mar at Case Document Filed Page of Plaintiffs claim that Mr Rizzo is an examp le of delay that has haimed her ability to obtain all depositions in a timely manner Mot at is specious Contra1y to Plaintiffs asse1iion discovery began in this case on October following the pa1iies Rule confenal See Fed.R.Civ At the Rule scheduling conference on October this Court directed the pa1iies to complete all fact discove1yby July oc On November contemporaneous with the filing of her Rule Motion to ismiss Ms Maxwell also requested of this Court a stay of discove1ypursuant to Rule Doc That motion was denied on Januaiy with an additional two-week period granted to respond to Plaintiffs First Request for Production of ocuments The discove1y was thus never stayed laintiff enoneously asse1is that that discove1y did not commence in this matter until Febmaiy What she means is that she neglected to seek any non witness depositions until then nothing in the Rules of Civil Procedure this Courts Orders or the law prevented Plaintiff from doing so at any point after October Plaintiff has had over eight months to subpoena See Menninger Declaration Ex A Rizzo deposition transcript excerpts Of course Plaintiffs counsel has engaged in their own last minute unavailability for a deposition scheduled by Ms Maxwell as to Plaintiffs former fianc a witness who is hostile required numerous service attempts at great cost and inconvenience and who then because of Plaintiffs last minute unavailability had to be re-served by a process server who swam through a swamp to get to his home at additional cost and inconvenience By agreement of the parties the time to respond was extended an additional six days because defense counsel was in a jury trial at the time the Court Order was handed down See e.g Pltfs Opp to Mot to Stay Doc at As of the date of this filing zero disposition sic notices have been propounded on the Defendant Bottom Type Pagination BDC TT0 Tf Td Tm TT0 Tf Td EMC BDC TT0 Tf TD witnesse4 sche6 dule e4 po-9 sit-4 ions and c5 onduc4 he4 nste-8 a4 she3 a4 it-3 e4 unt-4 il-3 the la4 st inut-3 e4 a4 nd now c6 ompl-3 a4 ins of lac6 of-6 ti-3 An-7 la-7 c4 of tim-2 e4 is a pr4 oduc4 of e4 ow5 ba-5 fa7 it-3 a4 nd ne-5 e4 nt li-3 ti-3 a4 ti-3 on tac6 ti-3 c4 and3 sho-10 uld not-3 be4 sanc7 ti-3 one4 thi-3 The5 f3 a4 il-3 ur3 e4 to im-3 e4 sec-2 ur3 e4 the de6 posi-2 ti-3 ons of the-5 r3 e4 maining8 six-12 witness e4 is-3 throug11 no fa7 ult-3 of Ms Ma4 we6 ll-3 or he7 c7 ounse3 As thes-8 e4 witnesse4 Ms-2 Max-6 we6 ll-3 a4 nd he4 c7 ouns-10 e4 have6 six-13 lainti-3 ff6 a4 tt-3 e4 mpt-3 e4 to e4 rve7 subpoe3 na4 the w4 it-3 e4 sses be5 fo-6 re7 e4 e4 pr6 ovidi-13 ng10 noti-3 c4 e4 to he4 de4 fe7 nse in c4 lea6 viol-3 a4 ti-3 of Rule a4 G8 AL AU3 HO-3 show ha4 de4 spi-12 te its av4 in-5 e4 xe4 rc3 ised dil-2 igence Sok4 ol Holdings-2 I3 nc4 v4 BM4 unai Inc5 Ci-4 KMW-4 DF8 a4 S.D.N3 A4 e7 mphasis add-7 e4 c4 it-3 ing Re3 A1 e4 nter I4 c4 v4 Ma3 marone5 k4 Av-4 e4 orp F6 D.N4 Maho3 ac4 c4 ord Park-6 e4 Columbia Picture4 Indus F6 2d Ci-4 Pe5 e4 c4 Pea3 rl Inc7 v4 Maj-8 e4 sti-4 c4 Pe5 arl Stone Inc7 F6 upp 2d D.N4 ha4 bee7 dil-3 igent mea6 nin-11 that de4 spit-4 e4 it-3 hav3 e4 e4 rc7 ised dil-2 ig8 e4 c4 e4 the ppli-3 c4 a4 ble de6 a4 dli-3 ne4 c4 ould not have6 be-5 e4 re-2 a4 Good c6 a4 use e4 pe4 nds on he4 dil-3 igenc6 of3 the movin-11 pa-5 rt-8 in e4 e4 kin-11 to e4 he4 sc3 he4 duli-3 ng10 rde7 Groc5 ows-3 k4 i P3 hoe4 nix Const-3 F6 3d 2d Ci-4 The5 Ox-7 for6 a4 e4 ful a5 nd e4 sis-3 tent wor5 or e7 ff6 rt e4 e4 htt-3 w4 ox-9 for6 ddictio8 na4 rie5 s.com/us/-3 de4 finiti-4 on/ame4 ric5 a4 e4 li-3 sh/di-4 li-3 e4 c4 la5 st c4 e4 ssed on Case Document Filed Page of Case Document Filed Page of June Good cause and diligence were not shown when a pa11y raised the prospect of a deposition nine day prior to the discove1y deadline Carlson Geneva Ci ty School Dist F.R.D W.D.N.Y I compare Reese Virginia Intern Terminals Inc F.R.D E.D Va depositions noticed ve1y early in discove1y period and movant engaged in continuing meet and confer dialogue with defendants throughout five month discove1y period Iantosca Benistar Admin Svcs Inc F.Supp.2d Mass con.-espondence indicated that the plaintiffs had tried on numerous occasions to schedule the deposition and to extend the discove1y schedule but that the defendants had either refused or failed to respond good cause found ARGUMENT I PLAINTIFFS LACK OF DILIGENCE Plaintiff has demonstrated an extreme lack of diligence in securing the remaining six depositions that she seeks A Plaintiffs Motion failed to mention any desire to take the deposition of No Notice of Deposition has been served and no scheduling of his deposition has commenced Indeed first appeared on Plaintiffs Thn Revised Rule Disclosures two weeks ago on June Then last week in her Reply In Support of Motion to Exceed Ten Depositions filed on June Reply Plaintiff avened that deposition is necessruy because Ms Maxwell in her deposition on April raised Ms Giuffres comments about as one of the obvious lies to which she was refe1ring in her public statement that formed the basis of this suit Reply at This is utter nonsense and nothing more than a transparent ploy by Plaintiff to increase media exposure for her sensational stories through deposition side show This witness has nothing relevan to add Case Document Filed Page of to this case and Plaintiff has made no eff011 much less one in good faith to timely secme his testimony Plaintiff admits she has made not allegations of illegal actions by Id But Plaintiff has asse11ed that she spent time with on the island of Little St James US Virgin Islands and that she flew there with the in a helicopter piloted by Ms Maxwell In one ruiicle au hored by Sharon Churcher Plain iff related one occasion she adds Epstein did invite two young bmnettes to dinner which he gave on his Caribbean island for Mr Clinton shortly after he left office But as far as she knows the ex-President did not take the bait Id have been about at the time she says I flew to the Caribbean with Jeffrey and then Ghislaine Maxwell went to pick up Bill in a huge black helicopter that Jeffrey bought her Shed always wanted to fly and Jeffrey paid for her to take lessons and I remember she was very excited because she got her license around the first year we met I used to get frightened flying with her but Bill had the Secret ervice with him and I remember him talking about what a good job she did I only met Bill twice but Jeffrey told me they were good friends We all dined together that night Jeffrey was at the head of the table Bill was at his left I sat across from him Emmy Taylor Ghislaines blonde British assistant sat at my right Ghislaine was at Bills left and at the left of Ghislaine there were two olive skinned brunettes whod flown in with us from New Ymk Id never met them before Id say they were no older than ve1y innocent-looking TI1ey werent there for me They werent there for Jeffrey or Ghislaine because I was there to have sex with Jeffrey on the trip Maybe Jeffrey thought they would entertain Bill but I saw no evidence that he was interested in them He and Jeffrey and Ghislaine seemed to have a very good relationship Bill was ve1y funny He made me laugh a few times And he and Jeffrey and Ghislaine told blokey jokes and the bmnettes listened politely and giggled After dinner I gave Jeffrey an erotic massage I don remember seeing Bill again on the trip but I assume Ghislaine flew him back See Sharon Church er Teenage girl recruited by peadophile Jeffrey Epstein reveals how she twice met Bill Clinton DAILY MAIL Mar attached to Declaration of Shru Churcher Ex Doc Similru in Plaintiffs unpublished and un dated book manuscript The Billionaire Pla bo Club she writes The next big dinner pruiy on the island had another significant guest appearance being the one and only Bill Clinton He is the only president in the world to be TF?"t ǼX??DAKI??PS l?8k un kj g1 I srZ n?xv?D?W?oe ZĽ A?VTI Pͱ?y Uo 1?K?KU lM?3v?b4 8ؠ?V Q6j N?O x?ww TAKQ n?,?Ul 5EK?X?bs c?w v4 WE?9X I ln.K L??u b2?Ino Ů?p??s p?6fIM5 bE L?GQ k6 U?v J?Y lM?o A i?6Pc SÙ kM C??e f?i?j d?C Ý?k?l h/ܠm Ec sC iiІ Ϋ3 AQ-;eda Sp tr an?s?2ͳ??l3o K?s?Kp??z?K qN S??ˎKJ zV RC r?n E??G A ikC xppw Q5TQŹ j9 L?e I k?N?ړ KQ Śnz?n?V?O;j?l Bɢ W9?n u??ɗ Α?h d?P R?Ia 8h Xߨ a??E 0J cv Zg h??Ap k??c s?ap d?k vl??Asm.u TW hk??g??s?v s?O ăa?X?i rC A вf_ 6"?T?jj?VYi_O,ѾW t??Ú??;VqVm vz 6ph ν?c h?㧒 Z?M?/g o?F?H ls?k?7 y?U?I4a?g m??d?wCh nN q?ޠV??_IO3 e??C FSsn?xv I U?QLjH R?ח WڪGWA x?.yl qs?"?t?G Y?m ӶC m?Y l4?z?q?UUKI4b9!k g69s k_?e Li 4Y?sK m?E Kc??m?H qx?W f?X Vj 0C LTf DMd zY A hu J??M i r?od b?-â N?Cf X?En rG ܠ6㣏Ce b?Zv 7v?E?w g?h Nw3?иKM mz mnG qy?H?h 6RkNՌ Hk_ X?sA f6 lG i?a b.?b g?6?Zm ec?v?e??n G?-Lc?SZƱ dp m?i A,x Hc??6V?ƗX?i q??s fw1 Vo??V z??Q G6 DV i F?c?f?mlj CQ 똪??K?H g?k?q?xO s?_E4a?l F?ڧAO n?F ͼu 6U t8 ۼh a0K?F i ϏI dd k??Yǃ E??U lR c?H nڇӱ A?X S?KiO m?X vf?ě mM s2??Զi Hț)?d??o 2s?f?v Ћ?X Lc??p Lѽ 魒Hz t?Hf?rƽ?;3H9 i 2M Hj g?I??D xq O?z?_ǚF d༩ǥ?J?rC MZ.?ѕ q?Q L?U?ʊ R٥s T?p?b ec?C ph a??x Hq 3h Do r??3ctӶ9Ll?K E??d m?l Z㻲H Tu?6X qZ?-w?D?O??s?AیV?8J??F?c o?F??t ox?N??G b?O u??z e?i 7?zsZ?kl?3?Z m?l?V 1H KN iR V9?Vq?r n?I C?.ya ܝl _ġ?eDr?F piw?r_1 ne??Yb?f KY?ђ Ӆ?ó V?9!sd stQ WP?LH μMΪ 9G J?r?mԹ nd XL ř?R2?y lG?,?ձ?кy g??E PIN?g8 ޗi K?fnP G?HX xw??L S.z?x d,ssf XL cc?4r0K9 rڒpعζ?C_W?rL A?l G??h 7C Ph Ro Q??F L_ n2 G?M Jq IFj??k 7K U?CE,І?1 nz l??T wW m?䨒??a Mù?b g??AN tӈ 3h?MƷ WH?o gnW?k k?qa s?l O?s k?k S?HD??ac E?Xw 7UO??e OrFT 6W 7nO WU?um?n?wd 2v nZ??Ϛ A Y?ύ?vS 9A gZ??ϯ?F?mا?Kl?on 1JZ7?䕌s M?IE g??cok?l vaa?S TQ K?Q I KB 2V q6 ž?G A f?U?㑛Ƹ z??dd?x?pu 6?DŽӾ?Of6?ۏ l?p n?H ls_?a?8X a C?f?A r?:-gi i ڼN?4?w lK BW??TΗp a j,š?J??qS LR Ip pϮ?ԡA i?v tu/fg x?tA r?u??G?gn?t c?T2?v F?q d?q pJV?au YB??k O?a VbԒ??4e OQ kGQ5 G?W5?HC E?l Ul ȵm TS ѸY?Ǩ IH FǛY q?k L7?C?E?og??kq?k Q??S 3o?G?Y Vz?N??䞭 g?d Vz?N??䞭 g?d Vz?N??䞭 t?E 9o TAY??:?z?N g?d Vz?N??䫱 VȈ(?I dico?y?۹J?l?G??Y V??y??ղu Q??OV??y l?G Q??Vh??ղu l?G??Y V??y??ղu Q??OV??y l?G Q??Vh??ղu G?lmf Sf?IkLnw oD ղu l?G??Y V??y??ղu Q??OV??y l?G Q??Vh??M DD DD DD DD DD DD DA??ꨈ u;n??o i??X?m VCSQ a?:prK kC SLڻ i?ƌź i xp ppvn Tf fԒs Fbor?x _g V.yq rb øX yn_ EM xt c?ܯ v߈ gm?Cu6?fhha dw.m?a?4 WE?PG eрlH b4 k?v z?r UѺI Fȹ A Tʚ r?U Q?L j"k Fl sik eUEh?ngn?et a?Zѩ b?ԍ ݧY Im vF??L t?rW i?gv?p 2W y?_J?k?E Z8S5??h3C?nư ڈ?Ȳ I㠹56?RRT vK S?jl?U k;5?jG?R?g ʪ?e??t?k z?y?H?a sK 3c GB?p S?_KT WhGv d?Sf?o?J6 d??pJ g?VJ xl V?v?W m?t.?ۼ ca?q F??U N??Z ijh I iy vs ݜj Tmc ghu _1 A 6F ڴ,L d??amK HsJ ZX7 i ˉl x??8jA y?Q h??VN s?nW?6j?Y1 nM M??IAuO ȱ??f?Ώ Ȉ1 Ȉ1 Ȉ1 Ȉ1 Ȉ1 Ȉ1 Ȉ1 Ȉ1 Ȉ1 Ȉ1 Ȉ1 Ȉ1 Ȉ1 Ȉ1 Ȉ1 Ȉ1 Ȉ1 Ȉ1 Ȉ1 Ȉ1 S?yw??y?Z 7Q A eF?Q?La Af?kh??Z _K?YQU O?Ǽ??cok??S?u f?H An 6S E?Z 8s DD M?-?j?Akߒ bq KXG j?fk EB?/?P Z?X?ػ Tz Ƞ??j m?iw ȨQ A 4d ok LG ZCN?m m?Q A ȴ?lz Ud Qjx.3 Ž?c??Y xoa uѣ?A?"?ݏ k?A Wb?CI?8 济?G A J;M W?K khsq A n6 c??ί mȨQ py Tz ZH?6 K??WZ 3KE x?Ǫ EB?/?P qxtm 8ـ Zߩ?Tb?tol??R sLRG g0?Z 8?za b0 v??KO U1 nI a?c a??Ğ?R?υS UO Ɨ7 h殻 Ib3?TL?L Tt?x O??K?hp BtIưF UC??sѸ:9C?m??H?-ac _aǪ l8?Fa WG?VC X?h V?2?LԒB Q?F 5Ų k_ SS oD??Ü?e?n RL D??k?p mU8?n ks ڍm??f aѴ KA?nE?QTb??V te?s UŠ wm x?w X?ƨ bTT5 KQ 0X k?ǹ rq ݴ?u їp?O7J??o s?s?H?X XDYC ak x?h I s6 g?/G?f E?C o?s IJ rT?i1 v?k KSOR?Y쥷 q?ʺ?C rE ٹ?S FJ S?F m?I x?ݼ 0?Yrlx 9w z?S Ǫ??JyDf:?持??-h e?Qq O?Fs?ݷ s?,X VPN?I2Ҹ U??X SOQ Tq UUo?t qp no 圆K?b k飮A bUU?3 ϐ?h ŧä a S?Y?C tRnX2??ie eE Case Document Filed Page of dismissed from his role as a world leader because he was caught with his trousers around his ankles and had the stain to prove it Publicly humiliating his wife and himself he retired from his title bu not from his lifestyle This wasnt a big party as such only a few ofus eating at he diner table There was Jeffrey at the head of it all as always On the left side was Emmy Ghislaine and I sitting across the table from us was Bill with two lovely girls who were visiting from New York Bills wife Hillarys absence from the night made it easy for his apparent provocative cheeky side to come out Teasing the girls on either side of him with playful pokes and brassy comments there was no modesty between any of them We all finished our meals and scattered in our own different directions Menninger Deel Ex at Each and eve1y par of Plaintiffs claims regarding been proven false ha conclusively Remarkably Plaintiff now even denies telling Churcher that she ever witnessed Ms Maxwell anywhere or joking with about what a good job she did Menninger Deel Ex Plaintiffs counsel remarkably instmcted Plaintiff not to answer any addi ional questions about the other things Sharon Churcher inaccurately repoded Id Lending even more incredulity to Plaintiffs story Ms Maxwell only received her pilot license in mid casting insurmountable doubt that Case Document Filed Page of The only pmpose for seek i ng this depo ition is for the calculated media strategy that Plaintiff and her publicity seeking attorneys have devised Plaint i ff fai ed to i sclose as a witness until 1e failed to ice hi depos i tion failed to di li gently purs a subpoena him and has elevant testimo to offe Accordingly Plaintiff leave to modify the sc eduling order to pe1mit is deposit i should be denied oss Gow As the Comt likely recall Ros Gow actua ll i ss ed the tatement pert i nent to this defamation uit aintiff ha known about Ross Gow and i ro in thi law uit since the outset She referenced him epeatedly by ame in the Complaint filed on September See e.g Complaint paragraph As pa1t of Maxwell campaign she di ected her agent oss Gow to attack Giuffre ho esty and thfulne ss and to acc se i uffre flying Pla in tiff also ha been well aware roug that Mr Gow re ide in London See e.g Pla i ntiffs Motion to Compel hnproper i i ege at oc Afte filing that Complaint i Septembe and li i gat i ng the Motion to Compel ba se on pr i ilege related Mr Gow in March Plaintiff took exactly zero teps to depose Mr Gow unti she filed thi Motion Now in mont after filing he Complaint Plaintiff contends ere i not uffic i ent time for her to go tlrrough Hague Convention for service on Mr Gow so as to co mplete th i proces befo the June deadline at Indeed Plaintiff only init i ated that proce ss three days ago on iday une two weeks hy of the discove1y cut off Plaint i ff once again trie to blame Maxwell for he wn ack of diligence mi epre enting thi Court that i uffre asked at efe dant produce her agent Bottom Type Pagination BDC GS0 gs TT0 Tf Td Tm TT0 Tf Td EMC BDC TT0 Tf TD Gow4 f3 or3 a4 e4 posi-2 ti-3 on but De4 fe7 nda4 nt a4 re-3 fuse6 Id tru-8 th-3 lainti-3 ff6 sent a5 letter5 on Ma-6 whic4 re-2 a4 for6 de4 posi-2 ti-3 on a4 the inconve6 nienc-3 e4 lea6 se3 dvise e4 dne4 Ma-6 wh-7 e4 ther5 ou will-3 prod3 uc4 e4 Mr G4 ow or3 whe6 ther5 we6 will-3 ne4 e4 see7 re7 li-3 f6 rom the Co-9 ur3 wi De6 c4 E1 Tha5 wa4 e4 f3 irst communi-3 c4 a4 ti-3 on re-2 rding11 a ny de4 posi-2 ti-3 on Mr5 Gow4 Two late4 e4 e4 nse c6 ouns-10 e4 le-7 ga4 author3 that woul oss Gow f5 or3 a4 de4 posi-2 ti-3 a4 rule5 or c4 a4 se3 a4 would either5 e4 a4 ble or5 re7 quire5 e4 to do so Id lainti-3 ff6 ne4 ve4 e4 spo-10 nde4 he4 a4 lso has not plaine4 whe6 or h3 ow Ms Ma3 we6 ll-3 is re4 e4 va4 to w2 he4 ther5 lainti-3 ff6 ha4 mons-2 tra5 ted ood c4 a4 use or3 he4 ow5 fa7 il-3 ur3 e4 to a4 steps to depose5 a4 for6 e4 witness de4 posi-2 ti-3 on unti-3 une4 for6 a4 witness she wa6 wa6 e4 be4 fo-6 e4 e4 ve4 filin-12 the ompl-3 a4 int-3 Dur5 ing8 e4 he4 ring11 on a4 rc7 his ourt state4 that wou2 ld c4 onsi-2 de4 e4 pe4 c4 see7 be4 for6 e4 it-3 would c4 onsi-2 de-5 ha4 ng10 the c4 e4 duli-3 ng10 O2 rde7 r3 Ms a4 we6 ll-3 subm-2 it-3 that wa5 it-3 ing8 unti-3 une4 two we6 e4 bef6 re7 the e6 nd disc4 ove4 e4 ve4 be-5 in he4 Ha-3 ue4 onve4 nti-3 on pr3 oc-5 ss fa5 ll-3 fa6 shor5 of a4 uc4 ood fa7 it-3 showin-10 nd the r5 e4 que4 st fo-9 Je4 an-3 c4 r4 e4 it-3 re7 a4 rd to e4 a4 uc4 B7 rune7 fa-2 c4 ts that would Case Document Filed Page of Bottom Type Pagination BDC TT0 Tf Td Tm TT0 Tf Td EMC BDC TT0 Tf TD inst-4 e4 a4 de4 onst-2 ra7 te he-5 lac6 of a4 lso how tha4 she h3 a4 wa5 ived a4 r3 ht to see5 a4 of-7 ti-3 me de-3 posi-2 ti-3 lainti-3 ff6 f3 irst ssued a6 Notice6 of a7 ule subpoe5 a4 f3 or3 doc4 e4 nts fr3 om B7 rune7 on F6 e4 br3 a4 a4 a4 a4 ddr-6 e3 a4 tt-3 or3 oe4 Tit-2 one4 No doc6 uments e4 re7 e4 ve4 pr6 odu-9 c4 e4 pursua6 nt that subpoe3 na4 Menn3 e4 e4 c4 F6 The5 on lainti-3 ff6 iss-3 ue4 a4 ubpoe4 na4 f3 or3 de4 posi-2 ti-3 on testi-4 mon-11 to c4 c4 ur on une4 a4 a4 Ne6 Y4 or3 Id ga in he4 subpoe3 na4 a4 a4 tt-3 or3 obe4 rt Ha7 ntm-3 a4 The5 une4 laint8 iff a4 e4 mail that the-7 a4 a4 e4 a4 il-3 e4 ste-8 rda-12 rom Mr3 Brune4 attorne-13 ne4 e4 ds re7 sc-6 he4 dule e4 li-3 e4 ve4 he4 is to ge4 us e4 da6 tes toda-16 tomorr5 ow Id c4 ounse3 sa3 id hi-3 clie3 nt had on-9 e4 F6 ra7 c4 e4 a4 nd it-3 a4 unc3 le-7 a4 w5 he4 e4 would be4 e4 rning11 to he4 United tate4 F6 oll-3 owing10 the filing7 of th-8 e4 inst-4 a4 nt oti-3 c4 ounse3 for4 Ms a4 we6 ll-3 r3 e4 que4 e4 c4 opies of4 the c6 e4 rtific-5 a4 tes of4 se-6 rvic5 f3 or3 ule-7 subpoe3 nas-1 pr3 ovided rtific4 a4 tes on une4 Nota4 a4 bsent wa6 e4 rtific4 a4 e4 of se-3 vice6 f3 or3 Mr B7 run-6 e4 Thus e4 it he4 Mr5 B7 rune7 wa6 nev3 se6 rv-6 e4 or he4 wa6 ser5 e4 a4 nd lainti-3 ff6 unil-3 a4 ter5 a4 e4 tende6 his compl-2 ianc6 e4 da4 te to a4 unsc3 he4 duled tim-3 e4 in he4 futur4 e4 Eith-2 e4 the me to c4 ompl-3 a4 in about c4 ompl-3 ian-7 c4 e4 is at or ne-3 a4 the5 ti-3 me oc4 c4 ur3 F6 a4 il-3 ur3 e4 ti-3 mel-9 c4 ompl-3 a4 in rding11 non c4 ompl-3 ianc6 e4 with a ubpoe4 na4 c4 onst-2 it-3 utes a5 iver5 a4 e4 ve4 nt whe4 e4 se6 rv-6 e4 or n3 ot B7 rune7 a4 ppa4 e4 ntl-13 romised to pr3 ovide ne6 a4 tes be4 for6 e4 his e4 osit-4 ion date4 c4 a4 me a4 nd we6 nt di-3 not do ha4 lef4 he4 c4 untr-8 a4 nd-9 not Case Document Filed Page of Bottom Type Pagination BDC TT0 Tf Td Tm TT0 Tf Td EMC BDC Tf TD take6 the de6 posi-2 ti-3 on of3 Mr-7 B7 rune7 a4 fte5 Je4 r4 e4 Ep-6 ste6 As w3 it-3 the othe4 w5 it-3 ne4 e4 lainti to depose5.3 e4 ff6 Epstein-9 out of ti-2 me Pl-3 a4 int-3 iff4 c4 laims-2 that she3 wa6 una3 ble sec7 ur3 e4 e4 rvic-4 e4 on Mr E3 pstein unt-2 il-3 Ma-6 he4 on fo3 a7 lt-3 e4 rn-6 a4 ti-3 ve4 ser6 vic-7 T1 he4 doc4 e4 nts re4 fle5 c4 a4 gr3 e4 e4 to a4 c4 e4 pt ser4 vic-7 e4 on Apr5 il-3 a4 nd it-3 wa6 onl-12 on that Plai-2 nti-3 ff a4 gr3 e4 e4 e4 oe4 De6 c4 la-7 ra7 ion uppor3 of Moti-3 on10 to Qua4 sh Epst-2 e4 in De4 posi-12 on Ex-8 D5 oc4 lainti-3 ff6 f3 a4 il-3 to ex-8 plain he4 stra7 te-7 ic de-3 c4 isi-4 on or3 ne4 e4 c4 e4 in a4 il-3 ing8 to re5 spond-5.5 fo-6 ove4 six-9 we6 e4 ks to nde-5 e4 in anothe4 fa7 il-3 ur-6 e4 of c4 a4 ndor,3 ne-5 lec5 ted to tell his ourt a5 bout he4 e4 mail off4 e4 fr6 om e4 inber5 e4 it-3 he4 in the3 stant oti-3 on or3 in her5 mot-3 ion ser6 ve4 Mr E3 pstein a4 lt-3 rna7 te me-5 a4 ns Mot-2 a4 Doc6 lainti-3 ff6 a4 ppa4 re7 ntl-23 now c4 laims-2 that she3 ne4 ve4 re-2 e4 ived tha4 ema4 il-3 f3 rom Ma-5 rtin e4 inber5 All of the3 pre7 e4 din-11 c4 muni-3 c4 a4 ti-3 ons howe5 ve4 dica6 te tha4 Mr e4 inber-4 pro3 mpt-3 r3 e4 spond-10 e4 Se4 e4 e4 oe4 De-3 c4 la-7 ra7 ti-3 on Ex-8 e7 mail of Apr6 il-3 rom e4 inber-4 to McCaw4 of-6 fe7 rin-8 let he4 kno3 a4 rdin-8 c4 e4 e4 of se6 rvi-8 c4 e4 on Apr5 il-3 mail of 0C Thus if Ms Mc-7 a4 wle-5 re-2 c4 e4 ived no follow up r4 e4 sponse rom Mr3 e4 inber5 a4 she no-7 c6 laims-2 whe6 he4 a4 e4 e4 c4 or-6 re7 spondi-2 a 0F er-5 es at a er-5 at a Vir-15 lan5 er-5 Qu5 a ef-5 ar-5 Ye er-5 ice er-5 Case Document Filed Page of Bottom Type Pagination BDC GS0 gs TT0 Tf Td Tm TT0 Tf Td EMC BDC TT0 Tf TD with her5 pre7 vious-2 ther-4 tofor4 e4 she ha-5 a4 dut-21 to foll-2 ow up on tha4 nquir-8 A f5 a4 il-3 ur3 e4 to do is plain va4 nil-3 la ne-3 lec6 Eve5 loca6 ti-3 on of3 the de6 posi-2 ti-3 on in he4 U.S Virg11 in sland-8 and3 subj-2 e4 c4 rig11 ht ppose3 the ubpoe4 na4 lainti-3 ff6 then w4 a4 it-3 e4 a4 ddit-3 ional-3 three5 e4 e4 k4 unti-3 une4 to eve6 a4 tt-3 e4 pt sch3 e4 dule de4 posi-2 ti-3 on Epstein Me3 mora5 ndum uppor3 of Mot Qua6 sh at-8 D5 oc4 Agr5 e4 e4 to a4 ke4 a4 de4 posi-12 ti-3 on in he4 Virg13 in slands-9 on Ma-6 e4 wa6 it-3 ing unt-3 il-3 une4 to to sche5 dule a6 da4 e4 f3 or3 tha-7 deposit-2 ion whe4 numer-4 ous ot-2 he4 de7 posi-2 ti-3 ons ha3 a4 lre5 a4 e4 e4 sc3 he4 duled in Ne-3 Y4 or3 F6 lorida3 a4 nd Cali-2 fo-6 rnia5 f3 the5 ba4 lanc-3 e4 of une4 is it-3 he4 ne-2 lec6 or stra4 te-7 ic posturin-9 lainti-3 ff6 Eith-2 e4 de4 posi-2 ti-3 on to a4 ke4 plac6 e4 ond F6 inall-11 lainti-3 ff6 gg10 e4 wit-2 hout fa5 c4 tual f3 ounda4 ion ha4 Ms-3 Max-6 we6 ll-3 pl8 som-2 e4 Se-5 e4 Mot-2 a4 doc4 uments now r4 e4 e4 a4 owe6 ve4 Pl-2 a4 int-3 iff4 a4 il-3 e4 pro3 noti-3 c4 e4 to Max-7 we6 ll-3 that she3 wa6 a4 tt-3 e4 mpt-3 ing8 to ser4 e4 a4 ule subpoe5 na4 on Mr stein for5 more5 than e4 ks Id lainti-3 ff6 state3 that she be-3 a4 e4 se3 rvic5 e4 a4 tt-3 e4 mpt-3 on Mar5 The5 ve4 fir4 st Not-2 ice6 of Subpoe3 na4 a4 nd De6 posi-2 ti-3 on se3 rve7 on-9 Ms a4 we6 ll-3 howe6 ve4 is dated A5 pr3 il-3 Menn3 ing8 D5 c4 Thus be4 twe4 e4 a4 rc7 nd Apr5 il-3 Ms c4 a4 le-7 e4 e4 in e4 pe-5 a4 ted tt-3 e4 mpt-3 to e4 rve7 Mr Epstein a4 ule subpoe-4 na4 including8 a4 e4 que4 st-5 fo-6 doc7 uments it-3 hout pro-8 vidi-3 ng10 the pr5 ope-5 noti-3 c4 e4 to he4 pa4 rties purs-7 ua4 nt Rul-4 e4 0C0B doc be4 for-12 e4 it-3 is e4 rv3 e4 on the pe-3 rson to whom it-3 is di-4 re7 c4 ted a6 noti-3 c4 e4 a4 nd a4 c4 0B Case Document Filed Page of Bottom Type Pagination BDC TT0 Tf Td Tm TT0 Tf Td EMC BDC TT0 Tf TD not an isol-2 a4 ted inc4 ident nd mer5 it-3 sanc6 ti-3 on a4 e4 e4 nt iff4 icult im-3 a4 ine ho-7 it Max-6 we6 ser4 ve4 Mr Epstein whe6 she3 a4 ne-6 ve4 put on noti-2 c4 e4 of a4 a4 tt-3 e4 mpt-3 to do Give4 that lainti-3 kne4 a4 of A4 pr3 il-3 the c6 ondit-13 ions ur3 suant to which Mr5 Epstein would a4 c4 e4 pt ser4 e4 thr-8 oug10 c4 ouns-10 e4 e4 wa4 it-3 e4 unti-3 Ma-8 to e4 e4 to hose ter5 ms and the3 wa6 it-3 e4 a4 nother5 e4 rl-8 thr-8 e4 e4 discove5 c4 ff6 Nadi-3 a M4 ar4 c4 in-5 c4 ova an-3 ar4 ah-3 K8 e4 ll-3 e4 F6 inall-11 lainti-3 ff6 se-6 e4 ks e4 de4 posi-2 ti-3 ons of two othe4 w5 it-3 ne4 sses a4 ra7 Ke6 ll-3 a4 nd Na6 dia Mar6 c4 incov-7 who sh-8 e4 ompl-3 a4 ins Mot-2 a4 lai10 nti-3 ff6 c4 laims-2 that he4 pr6 e4 ss ser4 ve-5 rs trie5 for6 thr-8 e4 we6 e4 ks fr6 om Apr3 il-3 unti-3 Ma-8 to pe)5 rso-7 na4 se-6 rve7 Ms Ke4 ll-3 e4 nd Ms a4 rc7 incova6 subpoe3 na4 duc4 e4 tec6 um he4 did not-3 e4 plain-5.5 howe6 ve4 e4 wa6 ted until-3 Apr5 il-3 to to se-8 rve7 these5 two witnesse4 a4 bout whom e4 a7 tt-3 or3 a4 ve4 known since5 he4 a4 lso has-9 not ex-7 plaine4 to his ourt a5 le-7 ga4 re7 lev-7 a4 or a5 dmi-3 ssi-3 ble e6 videnc6 e4 a4 either5 possess nor3 ho-9 she5 int-3 e4 nds int-3 roduc7 e4 that e4 viden-7 c4 e4 a4 trial of4 thi-3 def6 a4 a4 ti-3 on c4 be4 twe4 e4 lainti-3 ff-3 a4 nd Ms a4 we6 Apa6 rt f4 rom thes-7 e4 witness-9 e4 st-3 a4 ted intent to a4 ke4 the F8 ifth Amen3 whi-9 re7 nde4 rs the4 testim-4 on-9 a4 dmi-3 ssi-3 a4 di-2 c4 ussed mor3 e4 f3 ull-23 be-5 low ne4 it-3 he4 w5 it-3 ne4 ss has a4 re7 lev-7 a4 nt testim-4 on-9 to ff6 be7 a4 e4 lainti-3 ff6 ne4 ve4 ma5 e4 a4 publi-3 c4 state3 ment a4 bout ei-9 ther5 one4 of the5 0F er-5 er-5 at el Ms Giu-5 er-5 el icate-15 at er-5 ice as is u5 er-5 at Ms cin5 a el ice,-5 er-5 Ms cin5 a er-5 mer Case Document Filed Page of Bottom Type Pagination BDC TT0 Tf Td Tm TT0 Tf Td EMC BDC TT0 Tf TD lainti-3 ff6 did not-3 include4 e4 it-3 he4 w5 oman in he4 Sha3 ro-6 Chu-2 rc7 he4 a4 id nter5 vie-7 ws nor4 we6 e4 the-17 mentioned in Joind-2 knowle4 dge4 a4 e4 im-3 pli-3 c4 a4 te-7 a4 thi-3 that Ms e4 ll-3 e4 or Ms Ma4 c4 incova6 ma-7 a4 ve4 done4 th ot mention either5 of them F6 inall-11 a4 to he4 se3 witnes-8 se3 lainti ff onc4 e4 ga4 in doc4 umente4 he4 wn1 fa7 ur3 e4 to compl-11 with ule in r3 e4 ga4 rd to-8 a4 tt-3 e4 mpt-3 to e4 rve7 these5 wo w4 it-3 ne4 sses of the5 se3 rvic5 e4 a4 tt-3 e4 mpt-3 oc4 c4 ur3 e4 on Apr5 il-3 a4 nd-9 Apr5 il-3 Ye6 lainti-3 ff6 onl-11 prov3 ided Notice6 to Max-7 we6 ll-3 of he7 int-3 e4 nt se3 rve7 th-2 e4 subpoe-6 na4 on Apr4 il-3 Menn3 D5 c4 II AM4 ND-5 M4 NT IN K9 OR M6 RC4 IN-8 COVA4 NOT-2 AD4 M4 IS-4 IB-3 IN TH-3 I9 ASE-4 AG10 AIN3 M4 M4 AX4 ELL modi-3 the sc5 e4 duli-3 ng10 in thi-2 ca7 se3 f3 the5 a4 dit-3 ional r3 e4 a4 son ha4 a4 ll-3 ha4 ve4 r3 e4 re7 se3 e4 to lainti-3 ff6 their3 int-3 e4 nti-3 on to8 a4 sser5 he4 F6 ifth Amen3 e4 nt protec7 ti-3 on a4 to all-3 que4 sti-4 ons a3 nd suc3 a4 sser5 ti-3 on will-3 not be a6 dmi-3 ssi-3 ble e6 videnc6 e4 in his ria5 nd-9 e4 e4 c4 ounse3 for4 Mr E3 tein r3 e4 e4 ntl-13 filed a4 Mot-2 ion Qua6 sh hi-2 subpoena6 ba4 se3 on e4 same5 le-7 a4 rinc5 ipl-3 e4 tha-7 hi-3 dep3 osit-4 ion undul-11 burd-6 e4 nsom-2 e4 in ig8 ht of the fa7 c4 ha4 wil-3 not-3 lea6 to admis-2 sibl-4 e4 e4 videnc6 e4 Doc6 The5 ourt sho-9 uld consider6 thi-3 a4 ddit-3 io-3 na4 fa5 c4 tor to e4 c4 li-3 ne4 a4 finding9 for6 e4 tending10 he4 discov-8 e4 a4 dli-3 lainti-3 ff6 wr5 ongfu3 c4 ontends that a4 a4 sse-7 rtion of the4 F6 ifth Amen3 dment du-9 ring11 the de4 posi-2 ti-3 ons of E3 pstein Ke5 ll-3 e4 a4 nd Mar6 c4 ova4 will-13 be4 a4 dmi-3 ssi-3 ble in the tr3 ial of3 thi-3 fa7 mation matter5 w5 he-5 re7 none4 th-8 ose indivi-2 dua4 ls ar4 e4 pa-5 rtie-6 ba4 se3 on a4 dv-9 e4 rse6 Case Document Filed Page of Bottom Type Pagination BDC TT0 Tf Td Tm TT0 Tf Td EMC BDC TT0 Tf TD dr3 a4 wn ga4 inst-4 Ms a4 we6 ll-3 Se4 e4 iBut-2 ti-3 v4 United States F6 3d ir fa7 c4 none the5 iBut-2 ti-3 fa7 c4 tors support he-5 a4 e4 nt hil-3 noti-3 ng10 that Ms a4 we6 ll-3 a4 nti c4 ipate4 more5 e4 tensive3 br3 ief5 thi-3 fe7 a4 c4 ts bea-4 me5 nti-3 ing8 he-5 Ms a4 we6 ll-3 a4 the e5 mpl-3 e4 of Mr5 Epstein in he4 not he4 other5 a4 round3 Mr E3 pstein ha3 ne4 ve4 w5 rke7 fo-6 or6 be-5 e4 in contr3 ol of Ms Max-7 we6 ll-3 Ms a4 we6 ll-3 a4 nd Mr E3 pstein ha3 ve4 ha4 no f3 a4 nc4 a4 prof4 e4 ssi-3 ona4 or e4 mpl-3 oy20 e4 nt re7 lations-2 hip more5 than-7 a4 de4 a4 de4 man-17 a4 rs for6 e4 wh-7 e4 the pur5 or3 tedl-9 de4 fa7 mator-16 stat-10 e4 ment wa-3 publi-3 shed.3 Ms a4 we6 ll-3 testified tha4 she ha5 not-2 spoke3 to Mr E3 pstein a4 Max-6 we6 ll-5 c4 As the Court is-2 we6 ll-3 a4 wa6 e4 f3 om re5 view4 of e4 mails-2 subm-2 it-3 ted in c4 ame ra a4 nd late4 roduc-2 e4 to lainti-3 ff6 Mr E3 pstein a3 nd his-2 c4 oun-9 se3 g8 a4 e4 a4 dvic-7 e4 to a4 we6 ll-3 r3 a4 rdin-8 wh-7 e4 ther5 shoul-2 iss-3 ue4 a4 state3 ment aft-3 e4 a4 nua4 one4 Mr E3 pstein e3 ve4 sugg9 e4 sted wha6 such a4 state3 ment mi-3 ht a4 we6 ll-3 ne4 ve4 issue a4 a4 dit-3 ional state3 ment Max-6 we6 ll-3 ha4 he4 ow5 c4 unsel w3 ho ope4 ra7 e4 inde-7 pe4 nde4 ntl-13 Mr5 Epstein-9 a4 nd his-2 c4 ounse3 Epstein lainti-3 ff6 soug9 ht of discove5 a4 be4 twe4 e4 Ms a4 we6 ll-3 a4 Epstein or3 a4 e4 nti-3 socia5 ted w4 it-3 Epstein f3 ro-6 the pr3 e4 se3 nt Ms a4 we6 ll-3 r3 sponde3 unde4 oa7 th ha4 he4 re7 re7 no suc3 oc4 ume-7 Epstein pla-7 no r3 ole in the issu-11 a4 nc4 e4 of th-8 e4 a4 nua4 st-2 a4 e4 ment nor3 ha4 he issue3 a4 publi-3 c4 state3 ment r3 rding11 lain-9 ti-3 ff6 nd-9 e4 e4 lainti-3 ff6 a4 nd-9 Epstein f3 ull-13 e4 solved a5 c4 a4 im-3 a4 ga4 inst-4 one4 a4 nothe-7 a4 c4 on-9 fide5 nti-3 a4 settl-4 ment in other5 a4 c4 ion whic4 Ms Max we6 ll-3 ha4 no r3 Quite the c6 ontra5 Ep-8 stein w2 ould be a6 wit-11 ne4 ss he4 suppor5 e4 one4 ra7 ti-3 he4 his proof5 one4 ne-5 e4 look f3 ur3 ther5 than e4 mails-2 a4 lre-4 e4 view4 e4 thi-3 ourt a4 e4 a4 il-3 sent Epstein to Ms Max-6 we6 ll-3 on a4 nua4 while the4 e4 wr5 ote he4 a4 not as a5 e4 Menn3 D5 c4 Case Document Filed Page of Case Document Filed Page of Likewise Epstein drafted a statement for Ms Maxwell to is ue though she never did In that statement Epstein wrote presumably what his testimony would reflect should he not take the Fifth Since JE was charged in for solicitation of a prostitute I have been the target of outright lies innuendo slander defamation and salacious gossip and harassment headlines made up of quotes I have never given statements I have never made trips with people to places I have never been holidays with people I have never met false allegations of impropriety and offensive behavior that I abhor and have never ever been pat1y to witness to events that I have never seen living off trust funds that I have never ever had pat1y to stories that have changed materially both in time place and event depending on what paper you read and the list goes on I have never been a party in any criminal action pe1taining to JE For the record the time of Jeffreys plea I was in a very long-te1m committed relationship with another man and no longer working with Jeffrey Whilst I remained on friendly te1ms with him up until his plea I have had limited contact since Every story in the press innuendo and comment has been taken from civil depositions against JE which were settled many years ago None of the depositions were ever subject to cross examination not one Any standard of tmth and were used for those who claimed they were victims to receive financial payment to be shared between them and their lawyers Need I say more These so called new revelations stem from an alleged diary from VR that reads like the memoirs she is purpo1ting to be selling Also perhaps pe1tinent in a previous complaint against others her claims were rejected by the police due to VR lack of credibility The new interest in this old settled case results from lawyers representing some of JE victims filed a suit against the US government not JE They contend that th US govt violated their rights The documents and deal that JE negotiated with the govemment wa given to the lawyers yeai ago and is a public document I am not a patt of nor did you have anything to do with JE plea bai 267gain I have never even seen the proceedings nor any of the depositions I reserve my right to file complaint and sue for defamation and slander Id Bottom Type Pagination BDC TT0 Tf Td Tm TT0 Tf Td EMC BDC TT0 Tf Td The5 se3 c4 or-6 re7 spond-10 e4 nc4 e4 e4 mons-2 tra5 te tha4 Ms-3 Max-6 we6 ll-3 ha4 no c3 ontrol ove3 Mr E3 pstein re-2 a4 rds to the a4 ll-3 e4 de-5 a4 mation tate4 he4 ha-5 no r3 ole in is-2 suanc7 e4 of he4 state3 ment he4 ha4 no be4 ne4 fit the outc4 ome-7 of this it-3 ig8 a4 ti-3 on a4 nd he4 pla-7 no c4 ontroll-2 ing8 rol-8 e4 in ts re4 spec7 im-3 il-3 a4 rl-8 the-7 re7 is no-2 an-7 e4 vid-11 e4 nc4 e4 a4 all support a4 a4 dve-5 rse6 infe-4 re7 nc-5 e4 be4 dra7 wn knows e5 it-3 he4 w5 oman ve4 w5 or3 e4 with e4 he-5 a4 ve4 a4 nothi-3 ng10 to with his it6 ig8 a4 ti-3 on a4 nd do not st-4 a4 nd to bene6 it-3 f3 rom it-2 e4 spec7 iall-11 a4 lainti-3 ff6 ha4 nev3 ma5 de4 a4 a4 ll-3 ga4 ti-3 ons a3 bout he4 involveme5 nt wit-3 e4 it-3 he4 of6 the two the5 he-5 a4 re7 sim-4 irr-5 e4 leva6 nt thi-3 def6 a4 mation a4 c4 ti-3 I A IT-3 DISCO-2 VERY3 HO-3 ULD N3 OT-4 REWAR3 DED1 WIT-3 XTRA3 IM3 e4 ff6 Epstein si-2 nc4 e4 ser6 ve4 thei-9 ule ini-3 ti-3 a4 di-3 sc3 losure4 on Nove-4 mber5 Those4 disclosure5 li-4 sted indi-2 vidual witnesse4 with-2 knowle4 dge4 r3 ga4 rdin-8 the a4 c4 ts of thi-3 a4 se3 provid-10 e4 a4 ddr-6 e4 sses of3 their c4 ounse3 a4 to ust two e4 ff6 Eps-2 tein a4 nd Ala4 De6 rshow4 it-3 lainti-3 ff6 the2 a4 lso mi-3 nor irls lainti-3 ff6 c4 laimed a6 to Rule disclosure5 The5 opposi-12 te ha6 hap3 pe4 e4 B7 e4 twe-5 e4 Nov-7 e4 mber5 nd Mar6 c4 lainti-3 ff6 mm-3 e4 he4 Rule lis-2 of pe5 rsons w3 it-3 knowle4 dge4 f3 rom to inex-7 pli-3 c4 a4 re7 movi-3 na4 mes but a3 dding8 he4 re7 moved Case Document Filed Page of Case Document Filed Page of for example witnesses Andrea Mitrnvich and Dara Preece but added Senators George Mitchell Bill Richardson and Les Wexner Then between March and June a few weeks before the discove1y cut-off Plaintiff added more witnesses including iPalm Beach officers Recarey and Reiter and purp011ed victims of sexual abuse including a client of Mr Edwards who he has clearly known about for years As to several of these newly added witnesses in particular Recarey and Reiter Plaintiff promptly scheduled their depositions in June despite having just disclosed their names on June And last Friday on the business day just before the depositions fl and Recarey Plaintiff disclosed new documents including for the firnt time the unredacted police reports from Palm Beach that Plaintiff clearly has had in her possession or her counsel possession for years Menninger Deel Ex This is precisely the type of hide-and-seek that Rule is designed to prevent While Ms Maxwell anticipates filing in the near future a separate motion concerning Plaintiffs latest Rule violations and seeking sanctions for the same this Com1 can and should consider this behavior in determining whether Plaintiff has good cause to extend the discove1y cut-off so that she can continue her gamesmanship Plaintiffs Recurrent Rule Violations As this Com1 has previously held Rule requires a pa11y issuing a subpoena for the production of documents to a nonpai1y to provide prior notice to all pai1ies to the litigation which has been interpreted to require that notice be given prior to the issuance of the subpoena not prior to its retmn date Murphy Board of Educ F.R.D W.D.N.Y.2O At least one com1 in this circuit has held that notice provided on the same day that the subpoenas have been se1ved constitutes inadequate notice under Rule See e.g Fox Industries Inc Gurovich No O3 WL E.D.N.Y Oct The Rather than list his client address in the custody of the U.S Marshal Office Mr Edwards said her address is himself Bottom Type Pagination BDC GS0 gs TT0 Tf Td Tm TT0 Tf Td EMC BDC Tf Td mporta3 nt under5 pinni-3 ng10 of3 ootes D3 rive5 v4 I3 nterne5 aw ibrar-3 y4 I3 nc4 No CV D.N4 Ma5 lainti-3 ff6 f3 a4 il-3 to pr3 ovide a6 a4 e4 qua4 te e4 pl8 a4 na4 ti-3 on or3 a4 e4 nt for4 ow a6 noti-3 fic5 a4 on a4 ti-3 sfie4 ule e4 quir-8 e4 ments Se4 e4 e4 for6 the of3 fe7 nding8 pa-5 rt-8 of3 fe7 e4 no e4 plana6 ti-3 on or-6 e4 c4 use f6 or3 their3 a4 il-3 ur3 e4 c4 ompl-13 with he4 r3 ule-7 strictur3 e4 The-15 did not-3 tt-3 e4 mpt-3 to def5 e4 nd the tim-3 e4 li-3 ne4 ss of their4 noti-3 c4 e4 The-4 0C Uso1 v4 v4 azar cv a4 D.N4 Sep-7 gr6 a4 nti-3 mot-3 ion qua4 sh he4 subpoe3 na4 whe-4 re7 noti-3 c4 e4 e4 on the sa5 me a4 nd e4 ve4 ond mi-3 le li-3 mi-3 tation of Rul-3 e4 that c4 a4 se3 lainti-3 ff6 ha4 pr3 ovided same5 day4 noti-3 of3 the issuanc-3 e4 of a7 subpoe3 na4 He-3 e4 ha4 e4 r3 e4 pe-5 a4 ted a6 tt-3 e4 mpt-3 to e4 ve4 a4 subpoe3 na-5 ove4 the5 ourse6 of e4 for-3 e4 a4 noti-3 e4 wa6 iven to Ms a4 we6 ll-3 As de5 sc3 ribe5 pre7 vious-2 lainti-3 ff6 ha4 ampl-10 do-9 c4 umente4 he4 ow5 viol-3 a4 ti-3 ons of the-5 ule de4 taili-3 a7 tt-3 e4 mpt-3 to e4 rve7 subpoe3 na4 duc4 e4 tec5 um be4 fo-6 re7 e4 ve4 pr3 ovidi-3 noti-3 c4 e4 to Ms a4 we6 ll-3 with re5 rd-6 to wi-2 tnesse4 Epst-2 e4 in Ke4 ll-3 e4 a4 nd Mar-3 c4 incova6 ikew4 e4 with re5 spe-6 c4 witness Ale4 a4 ndra7 Ha6 ll-3 lainti-3 ff6 ser6 ve4 the subp-8 oe4 na4 prior4 to pr3 ovidi-3 ng10 noti-3 c4 e4 Se e4 nninger5 De-3 c4 e4 ve4 subpoe3 na4 be-5 for6 e3 ovidi-3 ng10 Notice6 und-9 e4 ule Ac6 c4 or3 din-11 lainti-3 ff6 moves to quash the4 subpoe3 na4 on Epst-2 e4 in Ke6 ll-3 e4 a4 nd Ms a4 we6 ll-3 f3 ur3 th8 e4 r6 e4 qu-9 e4 sts-3 sanc7 ti-3 ons purs2 ua4 nt Rul-4 e4 fo3 the5 se3 doc4 umente4 viol-3 a4 ti-3 ns it-3 re7 spec7 Ms Ha4 ll-3 who w4 a4 dep3 osed-3.5 a4 lre-4 a4 a4 rlier6 tod-11 Ms a4 we6 ll-3 be4 li-3 e4 ve4 he4 te5 sti-4 mon-11 the e4 fe7 e4 r3 e4 se-6 rve7 the r4 ht e4 c4 lude suc5 testi-2 mon-11 bot-11 on e4 videntiar-14 IV AITH-3 FF12 ORT-2 UC4 DISCO-2 VERY-1.5 el Ms ell le ast icate-15 ile a a Ms Case Document Filed Page of unsel ha5 e4 nga-5 e4 in sig7 nific3 a4 nt a4 nd re7 e4 a4 ted e4 ff6 or3 ts c4 ondu-9 c4 di-3 sc3 ove4 in his ca5 se3 in a rof6 ssi-3 ona4 civil-3 manne6 e4 spec7 iall-21 a4 it-4 r3 e4 a4 tes to he4 de4 posi-2 ti-3 ons of pa-5 rties O4 F6 e4 rua7 c4 ounse3 for6 Ms Max-6 we6 ll-3 r3 e4 que4 sted that the la5 e4 rs onfe-2 tele-5 phone4 to ar5 a4 e4 a4 c4 he4 ule f5 or3 the a4 de4 posi-2 ti-3 ons oc4 c4 ur3 in var5 ious tate4 and3 c4 ountri-10 lainti-3 ff6 ig8 nore7 that e4 que4 st and e4 que4 sts-3 of3 the sa5 me ilk a4 de4 on a4 e4 a4 st iff4 re7 nt occ-3 a4 ons Ma3 rc7 a4 nd Ap-7 ril a4 onl-12 on two a be4 c4 omi-3 ng10 c4 lea-3 both sides a5 re7 oin-11 to be e4 e4 din-11 to be c4 oordina5 ti-3 a4 nu-9 mber5 of he4 then pr5 opose3 a4 a4 lenda-3 w5 hich-7 sche7 duled a6 ddit-3 ional de4 posi-2 ti-3 ons for5 lainti-3 ff6 a4 nd onl-11 a7 c4 tuall-21 for6 de-5 e4 nda4 nt de4 pose he-5 r6 e4 a4 ini-3 ng10 witnesse4 De6 fe7 nd-9 a4 nt provide3 a4 c4 a4 e4 nda4 w5 hich a4 ll-3 owe6 fo-6 both ides to a4 ke4 r3 e4 main-9 ing8 de4 ti-3 ons but-2 lainti-3 ff6 ig8 nore7 it-3 a4 nd onti-3 nue4 to c4 he4 dule de6 osit-4 ions da4 tes f4 or3 witnesse4 with-2 out c4 onsul-2 ti-3 ng10 de4 e4 nse c7 ouns-10 e4 for4 their3 a4 a4 il-3 a4 bil-3 f3 ir-8 st e4 nning8 D5 c4 B7 e4 a4 use o3 th-8 e4 bre-2 a4 dow-7 in communi-3 c4 a4 ti-3 ons de3 e4 nse c7 ounse3 a4 lef4 li-3 tt-3 le c6 hoice6 Ne6 Y4 or3 a4 nd b3 iss-3 ue3 subpoe3 na4 for5 witn-11 e4 ss deposit-2 ions other5 da4 tes in une4 F6 or3 e4 a4 mpl-3 e4 lainti-3 ff6 iss-3 ue4 a4 it it at etter-5 0B 0F 0C 0B est at er-5 ic ar-5 al as a er-5 er-5 ein5 ich5 ar-5 tak5 er-5 a lan5 er-5 at izes tr-5 el ar-5 ell ar-5 tice atto-5 er-5 clien3.996 er-5 ates er-5 ar-5 les late er-5 atio-5 el le es a as ar-5 ar-5 er-5 el el atten4.006 tal at at Case Document Filed Page of Bottom Type Pagination BDC GS0 gs TT0 Tf Td Tm TT0 Tf Td EMC BDC TT0 Tf TD Notice6 of D5 e4 osit-4 ion for4 ua4 Ale4 ssi-3 on Ma-6 without-3 a4 c4 on-9 fe7 a4 wit-3 c4 ounse3 F6 lorida3 f3 ull-23 a4 a4 re7 a4 def5 e4 nse c4 ounse3 would e4 tra5 ve4 li-3 f3 rom Col-3 or3 a4 De6 fe7 e4 c4 ounse3 fa7 c4 di-3 ha4 ve4 to a4 ve4 Memor4 ial to F4 lorid-10 a4 f3 or3 the a4 de4 posi-2 ti-3 on Mr Ale4 ssi-3 howe6 ve4 did not a4 ppe4 a4 on th-8 a4 date4 be4 li-3 ving8 that his-2 de4 posi-2 ti-3 on wa6 for5 une4 the sa3 me that his-2 wife7 be4 e4 subpoe3 a4 e4 to ap-7 pe4 a4 a7 nd e4 a4 use h3 e4 a4 nd his wi-2 fe7 li-3 ve4 a4 hour3 sit-4 ion oc4 c4 ur3 e4 on On-7 une4 Mr A4 lessi appe6 re7 but he4 re7 wa6 ins-3 uf3 fi-8 c4 ient ti-3 me to take6 his then ha6 to ra7 ve4 Ne-3 Yor5 for6 the une4 he4 ing8 a4 nd a4 c4 to F4 lorid-10 a4 or3 a4 de4 posi-2 ti-3 on of3 a4 nother5 witness Mr ge4 rs tha4 had be-3 e4 sch3 e4 du-9 led w4 it-3 hout nput fr4 om def5 e4 nse c7 ouns-10 e4 ounse3 for4 lainti-3 ff6 make6 much of4 he-5 e7 ff-3 or3 ts ser6 ve4 witnesse4 Epst-12 e4 in a4 rc7 incov-7 a4 a4 nd Ke6 ll-3 e4 he4 a4 il-3 to advise the4 ourt that Ms a4 we6 ll-3 ha4 bee7 fo-6 rc-2 e4 to ex-7 pe4 nd gr3 e4 a4 mothe4 fat-4 he4 for-3 me6 fi-4 anc4 and for-2 me6 boy4 fri-4 e4 nd As de5 sc3 rib-8 e4 be4 for6 e4 e4 de4 e4 nse e4 e4 re5 for6 mer5 f3 a4 nc4 du-9 e4 a4 ll-3 c4 ouns-10 e4 we6 re7 a4 lre-4 a4 in F4 lorida3 nd ha4 e4 pe4 nde4 hundr3 ds of dollar5 to e4 rve7 him-13 lainti-3 ff6 made6 no e4 ff6 or3 he4 lp se-8 rve7 those c4 losest he4 inc5 ludi-3 ng10 he4 ow5 a4 mi-3 membe-5 rs-7 Unlike lainti-3 ff6 howe6 ve4 Ms Ma4 we6 ll-3 nd he4 c7 ounse3 a4 re7 full-10 wa6 re7 that c4 a4 e4 the dif-6 fic5 ult-3 ies of4 li-3 ti-3 a4 ti-3 on e4 do not asc5 ribe5 to lainti-3 ff6 the bla4 me Ha6 ving8 flow3 to F4 lorida3 a4 tot-3 a4 of f4 our se6 a4 ra7 e4 ti-3 mes to atte3 nd de4 posi-2 ti-3 ons of f5 ive of5 of3 c4 ounse3 and w4 it-3 ne4 ss me D4 e4 fe7 e4 c4 ouns-10 e4 sch-8 e4 duled the4 ir ow3 F6 lorida3 de4 posi-2 ti-3 ons of thr3 e4 e4 witnesse4 to c4 c4 ur3 du-9 ring two of4 the f5 our tr4 ips fe7 nse c7 ouns-10 e4 off4 re7 to a4 nd did c4 he4 dule the4 Case Document Filed Page of two olora5 do tra5 ve4 obl-3 igations-2 laint8 iff4 howe6 ve-5 r6 e4 c4 he4 duled-7 the de6 posi-2 ti-3 on of3 Mr Ri-2 in Ne4 Y4 or3 for6 a4 we6 e4 a4 fte-4 r2 thi-3 ourt ha5 a4 he-5 a4 rin-8 r3 a4 e4 than a4 c4 c4 omm-3 oda4 ti-3 a4 a4 tt-3 e4 mpt-3 to have6 the N4 e4 Yor5 de4 posi-2 ti-3 on oc4 c4 ur3 he4 a4 ll-3 c4 ounse3 we-5 re7 a4 lre-4 a4 re7 se3 nt NY4 To the3 e4 tent the Court wishe3 to consider5 the od fa7 it-3 e4 ff6 rts of3 de4 e4 e4 c4 ounse3 c4 onduc4 ti-3 ng10 e4 posi-2 ti-3 ons whe5 de4 c4 idi-3 whe6 e4 to nt lainti-3 ff6 a4 ddit-3 ional ti-3 me de6 fe7 nse a4 more5 than me4 he4 ir bur4 e4 G8 OO-3 C4 AU4 XIST-5 AK10 RE-3 DEP10 AIN3 IFF11 AN4 DE-2 OS-5 HARON C4 HURC4 HE-4 EXIS TS Max-6 we6 ll-3 e4 ks e4 a4 ve4 of he4 ourt to a4 ke4 de4 posi-2 ti-3 ons be-6 ond une4 F6 irs-9 Ms-3 Max-6 we6 ll-3 a4 Ma-6 il-3 journa5 li-3 st ha4 ron Chur3 c4 f6 a7 de4 posi-2 ti-3 on to occ6 ur3 in Ne-5 Y4 or3 on une4 Menn3 ing8 e4 e4 N2 On une4 the da-3 e4 for-3 e4 he4 he4 a4 rd thi-3 ourt on ne4 hould he4 ourt de5 de4 posi-2 ti-3 on would ne4 e4 to be r5 c4 he4 duled Da6 tes e4 a4 would be4 suf-7 fic5 ient f3 or3 c4 ouns-10 e4 im-3 il-3 a4 rl-8 Ms a4 we6 ll-3 is fil-3 ing8 sim-4 ult-3 a4 ne4 ousl-12 it-3 thi-3 Mot-3 ion a r5 e4 que4 st ope4 the de4 posi-2 ti-3 on of3 lainti-3 ff6 on the nds int-3 e4 al-2 ia that she3 f3 a4 il-3 e4 to provide3 numer5 ous doc3 uments or6 de4 e4 to be pr5 odu-9 c4 e4 thi-3 ourt unti-3 a4 fte5 r3 he4 de7 posi-2 ti-3 on a7 nd st-2 il-3 has f4 a4 il-3 e4 to provide3 other5 she mate4 ria5 c4 a4 nge4 subst-3 a4 nti-3 ve4 a4 nd nific-6 a4 nt porti-2 ons of he6 e4 sti-4 mon-11 a4 ft-8 e4 he4 Ms es clu5 er-5 er-5 alia er-5 at er-5 er-5 alia es er-5 at es h5 er-5 er-5 als er-5 0F 0F Case Document Filed Page of fa7 c4 hr3 ou-9 he-5 e4 rrat-3 a he4 e4 on a4 nd e4 re7 fuse6 to ans-8 we6 a4 ter5 a4 questi-2 ons a3 her5 quotes a5 tt-3 ribute3 to her5 e4 re7 inco-7 rr6 c4 Se4 e4 e4 Menn3 inger5 De-3 c4 r5 e4 fe7 e4 nc-5 e4 supra As ope4 ne4 posi-2 ti-3 on of3 lainti-3 ff6 c4 ould occ6 ur3 in a4 a4 ssum-3 ing8 she p3 rovid-8 e4 the Court or3 de4 e4 doc4 ume-7 nts im-3 e4 VI ALT-3 RN4 ATIVE-2 ALL-3 OT-4 H8 DEAD3 INES-5 NEE-3 TO-2 XT9 ND4 F6 inall-11 lainti-3 ff6 li-3 sser5 ts ha4 she se4 e4 ks onl-22 e4 tra5 da-5 to condu-8 c4 he4 de4 posi-2 ti-3 ons but-2 doe4 not-2 wa6 nt other5 a4 tes ve4 Of5 c4 ou-9 rse6 that inur-8 e4 to e4 be7 e4 fit an3 e4 Pl-3 a4 int-3 iff4 ha4 e4 to di-3 sc3 lose he5 r6 e4 a4 ined pe4 rt a5 nd thus-2 the de6 fe7 se3 ha4 bee7 un-9 a4 ble to se3 ur3 e4 a4 e4 butt-3 a4 ex-7 pe4 rt ikew4 e4 shoul-2 a4 ne-5 inf3 or3 mation be le4 rne7 in he4 se3 late4 de4 posi-2 ti-3 ons ha4 re5 quire5 e4 butt-3 a4 Ms a4 we6 ll-3 will-3 be4 una4 ble to se3 c4 ur c4 e4 viden-7 c4 e4 on a4 ti-3 mel-19 ba4 sis-3 F6 ur3 ther5 sum-2 ma-7 judg8 e4 nt oti-3 ons a3 re7 due4 in his ca5 se3 on Au-7 ust de-5 posi-2 ti-3 ons le-7 a4 ne4 infor4 mation he4 a4 nti-3 c4 ipate4 mot-3 will-3 be4 jeopa6 rdiz-4 e4 F6 a4 e4 trial is c4 he4 duled f5 c4 c4 onti-3 nuin-11 including8 pre7 a4 rin-8 witn-11 e4 sses e5 hibi-3 ts and testim6 on-9 HEREF7 ORE Ms a4 xwe6 ll-3 r3 e4 que4 sts-3 that the ti-3 on to tend the4 De6 a4 dli-3 ne4 to ompl-3 e4 te D4 e4 posi-2 ti-3 ons be4 de4 nied a4 lt-3 e4 rna7 ti-3 ve4 if he4 de4 a4 dli-3 ne4 is ex-8 tende6 or3 a4 of the5 li-3 sted six-12 witnesse4 Ms e4 ll-3 r3 e4 que4 sts-3 that the da6 tes-8 f3 or3 e4 pe4 rt discove6 dis-12 posi-2 ti-3 ve4 mot-3 ions and the tr3 ial da4 te e4 tende6 a4 fa7 il-3 ur3 e4 to compl-22 with he4 noti-3 c4 e4 prov3 isi-4 ons of Rul-2 e4 a7 ar-5 at US On5 er-5 er-5 er-5 Au5 alia le eth5 er-5 Case Document Filed Page of Bottom Type Pagination BDC GS0 gs TT0 Tf Td Tm TT0 Tf Td EMC BDC TT0 Tf Td Da6 ted une4 e4 spec7 tfull-12 subm-2 it-3 ted aura A M3 e4 nninger a4 ra7 A e4 nnin-11 e4 LM e4 ff6 a4 li-3 uc-5 a4 pro hac4 v4 ice ADDON GAN AN Ea5 st th Ave6 nue De6 nve4 CO hone4 F6 a4 lm-3 e4 nning8 e4 hmfla4 w.c6 Attor-3 ne4 y4 for-3 Ghisl-2 aine M5 ax4 e4 ll Case Document Filed Page of Bottom Type Pagination BDC GS0 gs TT0 Tf Td Tm TT0 Tf Td EMC BDC TT1 Tf Td CERTI-2 ICA3 RV4 ICE-4 c4 e4 rtif-17 that on une4 e4 lec6 troni-10 c4 a4 ser-3 ve4 thi-3 ig8 rid McCa4 wle-15 Mer6 idi-3 th c4 hult-3 LLP Ea5 st a4 Ola3 B7 oule-7 va4 rd St-2 e4 F6 a4 ude-5 rda7 le smcc5 a4 wle-15 bs-9 fllp.c3 om mschult-2 bsfllp.com a4 ul a4 ssell Unive4 rsit-11 tre5 e4 a4 lt-3 a4 ke4 UT c4 a4 ssellp a4 w.uta4 e4 du ra7 Edw3 a4 rds F6 ARMER-3 AF8 F6 ISS-14 NG4 ED3 ARDS-2 TOS HRMAN Nor5 th Andr3 e4 ws Ave6 te F6 a4 ude-5 rda7 le br3 a4 pa5 tht-3 ojust-4 ice6 c4 om S6 tanle-5 ott-3 ing8 Tw3 in a4 ke4 outh a4 lem NY4 tanPot-3 ti-3 ng10 e4 a4 ol.com icole4 Simmons Nic4 ole Si-3 mm-3 ons Case Document Filed Page of IT-4 I9 IS-5 IC11 a4 nt-2 MA-9 e4 e4 a4 nt-2 c4 WS e4 c4 ar4 au-4 r4 M4 e4 ge4 r4 e4 e4 an-4 e4 sp-5 on-4 e4 e4 ad-4 e4 e4 on-4 an-4 M4 an-4 c4 on-4 ol-2 on-4 Me3 nni-2 e4 c4 a4 a4 ol-2 a4 a4 a4 a4 a4 c4 e4 nse3 a4 e4 a4 a4 a4 c4 c4 ni-2 e4 a4 e4 c4 our2.9 out-2 he4 c4 e4 a4 a e4 be4 a4 a4 a4 c4 ounse3 e4 e4 e4 a4 nt hi-2 a4 Ma3 e4 e4 hi-2 a4 c4 e4 spe3 c4 ul-2 subm-2.9 hi-2 de4 c4 a4 a4 suppor2 of e4 e4 a4 nt-2 e4 spons-1.9 pposi-2.9 e4 ndi-2 e4 a4 dl-2 pl-2 e4 e4 posi-2.9 a4 nd a4 nc4 ol-2 a4 ul-2 a4 c4 he4 a4 Ex-9 hi-2 bi-2 e4 unde4 a4 c4 c4 c4 e4 c4 e4 e4 posi-2.9 na4 z4 a4 de4 na4 e4 a4 nt-2 a4 onf2.9 de4 nt-2 a4 unde4 ot-2 e4 c4 a4 c4 he4 a4 Ex-9 hi-2 bi-2 e4 unde4 a4 c4 c4 c4 Th-9 ona4 book-250 a4 nusc3 a4 a4 nt-2 de4 na4 e4 a4 nt-2 a4 onf2.9 de4 nt-2 a4 unde4 ot-2 e4 c4 Case Document Filed Page of Case Document Filed Page of Attached as Exhibit is a report by former FBI director Louis Freeh Attached as Exhibit fi ed under seal is a hue a co rr ect copy of excerpts of Plaintiffs deposition on May and designated by Plaintiff as Confidential under the Protective Order Attached as Exhibit are hue and coITect copies of May co espondence from Mered i th Shulz and May conespondence from myself Attached as Exhibit Fare trne and conect cop i es of Notices of Subpoena ith attachments for Jean Luc Bnmel se ved on Febrnary and May as well as conespondence regarding Mr Bnmels deposition from co un sel Bradl ey Edwards Attached as Exhibit is a Motion to Quash filed by counsel for Jeffrey Epstein in Broward County Fl orida in Edwards and Cassell Dershowitz Case No on September Attached as Exhibit His a hue and co nect copy of the Notice of Deposition and Subpoena for Jeffrey Epste in se1ved counsel Apri Attached as Exhbit I are trne and conect cop i es of the Notices of Deposition and ubp oena for Sarah Kellen and Nadia Marcincova served on counse Ap ril Attached as Exhibit filed under seal a h11e a conect cop i es of conespondence produced in this case between Ms Maxwell and Jeffrey Epstein from Januaiy and designated as Confidential by Defendant un der the rotect i ve Order for Attached as Exhibit filed under seal are Notices of Deposition and Subpoena Joe Recai and Michael Reiter and a etter of production from Sig ri Mccawley of June designated as Confidentia by Plaintifhmder the rotective Order a4 c4 he4 a4 Ex-9 hi-2 bi-2 e4 unde4 a4 e4 c4 a4 e4 vi-2 or a4 c4 he4 a4 Ex-9 hi-2 bi-2 a4 c4 e4 c4 c4 c4 e4 spond-11 e4 a4 nt-2 c4 ounse3 a4 c4 he4 a4 Ex-9 hi-2 bi-2 ot-2 c4 ubpoe4 a4 e4 posi-2.9 ha4 on hur2.9 c4 he4 a4 c4 e4 a4 vi-2 da4 e4 aura-251 M3 e4 nni-2 ge4 a4 e4 nni-2 e4 IF10 ICA2.9 ICE c4 e4 ha4 e4 e4 c4 oni-12 c4 a4 se3 ve4 hi-2 e4 c4 arat-2.9 aura-251 A M3 e4 nni-2 nge4 Support-253 e4 e4 ndant-2 Re5 spons-12 pposi-2.9 Ex5 e4 ndi-2 e4 adl-2 pl-2 e4 e4 posi-2.9 M3 ot-2 Sanc4 Vi-1 ol-2 at-2 Rul-1 EC-2 he ol-2 ng10 Mc3 a4 Me3 di-2 c4 hul-2 Ea5 a4 a4 oul-2 va4 e4 a4 da4 e4 c4 c4 a4 p.c4 om sc3 hul-2 bsf2.9 p.c4 om a4 a4 e4 ni-2 ve4 e4 e4 a4 a4 c4 a4 e4 a4 ut-2 a4 e4 du a4 Edw2.9 a4 ds MER-3 MAN2.9 ndr2.9 e4 ve4 e4 a4 da4 e4 a4 pa5 ht-2 oj-2 c4 e4 c4 om a4 nl-2 ot-2 ng10 a4 ke4 out-2 a4 e4 a4 nP-4 ot-2 ng10 e4 a5 ol-2 c4 om c4 ol-2 Si-2 ons c4 ol-2 ons Case Document Filed Page of
