Case Document Filed Page of EXHIBIT Case Document Filed Page of UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT SOUTHERN DISTRICT OF NEW YORK VIRGINIA GIUFFRE Plaintiff against GHISLAINE MAXWELL Defendants Case No CONFIDENTIAL Videotaped deposition of GHISLAINE MAXWELL taken pursuant to subpoena was held at the law offices of BOIES SCHILLER FLEXNER Lexington Avenue New York New York commencing April a.m on the above date before Leslie Fagin a Court Reporter and Notary Public in the State of New York MAGNA LEGAL SERVICES Avenue of the Americas New York New York MAGNA9 LEGAL SERVICES Page Case Document Filed Page of APPEARANCES BOIES SCHILLER FLEXNER LLP Attorneys for Plaintiff BY East Las Olas Boulevard Fort Lauderdatle Florida SIGRID McCAWLEY ESQUIRE MEREDITH SCHULTZ ESQUIRE EMMA ROSEN PARALEGAL FARMER JAFFE WEISSING EDWARDS FISTOS LEHRMAN P.L BY Attorneys for Plaintiff Andrews Avenue Fort Lauderdale Florida BRAD EDWARDS ESQUIRE PAUL CASSELL ESQUIRE Attorneys for Plaintiff South University Street Salt Lake City Utah HADDON MORGAN FOREMAN Attorneys for Defendant BY East 10th Avenu Denver Colorado JEFFREYS PAGLIUCA ESQUIRE LAURA A MENNINGER ESQUIRE Also Present James Christe videographer MAGNA9 LEGAL SERVICES Page E??jY?cg n휥BO k?g?v5 K??T?j?ٮ?g nQ K?l RYS U??S NpQM?Me??yud F?9b?o Ium tj ut??ʧw8 e?k??J W?ry??Y??ퟩ B?.ZS儞 X?p wx??Ӟ Xϭ u??GX?uh V0 Vv i wo?uS?Y ʴeaR8?m?淅 JV?xY?H??u?:m J?TSI?T??뱴 tN Z?Cf??FP I Ç?K?Yjv CGT sr:?xiyP?7?q Tu?;J?U x;k w??J6?S?H?IyIbO s??.h?ޑ?pvח ocOמ UsG-?_?ߴ 뱿)?ڗ?f?h O8 aStڋ??W4R?ѱ qeN?ҍ GO??no??ξ v?r?XS??p t?e 麅??L 8Y z?8gw R??l j?;zT?MƜVWN??k?Pj3?NY?m.?M H?I?u n?N W?c Xe?y?L 2ӕ?Y?MsA 5?i??m?Fޝfӓ z?G RSR c?u1?N?g NX??O9 F8I?v ԝ4 Vhkь?:m??Dx;?Ù is;K?z?8 xB??j m?o??IN5 q??C?V 5X?mB dװ??u?U uk?R?Σ旔 Q??ym8ʤ Yl R?T?r ت?y Qq??k V?j2 6Gɷ tk u:?Z Zd?4 Z?B x?ė QJ?x?gь c?K yF4n ݟQ?X vqV?5 SJK m?ʑ?gKd?N I?Ke i?hԩ g?UU?J0?q gF/t?ף B?SL bM퓷9 i?T??c g?n??r AKQ?Me4?ɞ!?z?.T?g J?k crCZ m?F it??K uS 굄??ZR?Z?f ӞiA?D T??Q?R I ɬ??GT HB6t?1?nXy KP?)Щ E)?K?z mB?愻?M??F ۮ??x?Z J?J V?EeeQ?v 愖?k zM?s _ӧ 9N rI jT?_?NS 8gIs?Y WU Nm?O1??e?i j?M eq h??m,?Z?G?S?Q?kR E?jRi ƞ??i R?n VqU ύKY JJ x?M Ѧ?n ӞiA?D kj5 S?QJU k??wu I F??uK OU Q?J/w?Ny t?Z 7,?NK??ʓϱ?qf Iw Nr?擓O a k?SY?I t擌 φ/4y7cQ G?OW?:?c MQ??o?r f?jT hp?i:2 Mg zE??S Bڴ u5 P?W cR 9q AQ??t?,vYYx??M um??q ӹNp KQ?tf?o Ѫ?Q?ZU??i?;c?yH sos I Me C?jZ S?o q?z?t lGu l??x Xԅo s_?z?O E?m?D Y??F woAP?i?K vX2 z??KS??V s2?k UK?el ɺi?ˬ弟?kG??I??mE?3 W?T XY p??S??O?xz oqF f??wd iu zQjO?d?a?ū?M t?zU5B??Sow?d?,!?AѪ uDn VVP?Mb v?r?d K?唛 w?y 2SG?Q gv?t?tuLx?r W?O?d/?z Y?m 4Sr?C q??T Ҩ?n x6y?u 3GQ6m h?Fŧ?g w5 JRi X?9o MO A 6t ۋǓ ɦqͶ?QP??4?f8O?t C?Ix?Jr I?E?y?T JM6?ʽ ċ6 KS??B??hќ 8?Tڋ??yǫ 0_Wv??Qu zl?q jZ sz U?ac F?ǐ Zi,?ac s?R??q?U l??ޏ zxs u?KQ ܩGw d?R?F V?x x?Z5?4Zk ˡ?5?_Ӡ?g8??JI?iUUR?Zi?i O?K c?u s?f N?r?o h?NriEum?/??/??W Wy շu y?r zv?J Mŝ?INߑ?Ie?o?hռ??Y a GZq?X g2Y?K?kTt?i?9t LV Io J?vY?3?Z 1sV v?QJK?t?o 1?ԥu Rs6?B?!k?ƅhFs b?o Xm X?q?p?j MveuǠ?Z?F1??C?H Oi??-N.td uk 8?4?uJNJyn Nr Rx nb?A?E?qy Dj?ao?mK Zѧ B7?t Ө?UH4 C?U I S?S Ir I ko?m z?Dc?j 谍IFS?1 L?Zo?K 8TN jagѱ?5 G;J??V o?L OO??S?5?G9yx?O?t?2vWU Ӣ?ԜS X?N?D SU uaB KX:p?_U I f?OL??Eb t??w c?숎 ZJ5W?s?K i?G?i?s?n Z7tix?JU??e 6s WNT??y?3 qX t?Nθ 9f5d Ia X?f e??qK 얺?s IJ ԏnM kW ɼu۰?o BMɬch зo OG k?Ԛ?N U?j?u?Є Mf;?Rd cR??qm?x??M 2?jS?t?o?V?uK YgR e?q?I ǖ8 co Xӭ KwY?F OƨἼe?C?Rz 6sp?3?m?lKG??X?m?u U8:ZMݻ??:JYy?G I xB?ӡR?0?W(?Y CNnT 9n Ex?e R?p n??KՇJ1x?t Y?i O0 p??U Oe _澠?ei MFv ڴ?;J վ?ОN i??g WTW Էϣo??q SQK?3?_Y ME?4 R?ޟV?kp?a t?o 5N oJ K?Qr?k?x Tq?,6?vO 3Ft!wQs Y5?tZƃGP R?YO W?gYԴ?y ӈ?n?ޝ8 ic W?ҩY?S?c?6?M?K?tcA 5O?F g?TUk?F?7 Dp?z??gjۄ IaƝ ǭ?Q?ѣ P?J1XItG!?.MV uS hU_7 E?ܣ ٳ?L W?ـq?U tc??/e?c Wun t??f sR?Q??RK dD?N?I?W 8Vj Q??n x?ɾ e?c P?ZMc 8?ZS?I E?q?6T F4?鸬ss7 ߕ??仍?OO??NT SF s-V?O??q?Gfr V?j T?c OC?Ɖm Rʦ q?RY R7?b vԥ 1I?J?N KR??NQRnPy?e t?p?glq lgF V?f?Ҵ nP?e ݖJ J?k_?j Q??C kZ P?P?O xv aU?I?i?w??C AJ gO 4?O?rꠓo SP?8?R?J Q??k ayIsm UTW3k X?s??ߞ?ӵ T?Z nq??ޅ?n _G c?jU?U n1K ʶ??RY wX9 bsۿe ş?l N?Î??HR W?Y?Z I?O??x?P A P?sQ?y Ok??d jX רK1?Ia v?i?VH k?)R ie dݱ?ԯ?Fs?iQ x??E?G?8?L?w奟W CR?IR GM?ԩʅE L?ь mglw i?rxNi?r xk??gVW?SS?4?-?ߣe j?h qv??Kw?t o?KG??u?u Y?ģ?Y JI W,ˤ Ӛ?q?0qURO??9 C?R?u F?e(Tk?,?b a hSX Ϳ?j?U1?yK9ߧ t?WNޢDž?u:??Դd??G ml?ـ V?g 4MZ P??Ar vg Fm Vϧ?N Jz Z??R t?bK Zm??ɪ nm a?Nv wV?XR?c?B?ԥ?㬲 Nr?c ܟ_y7O??O?P?kJR?5V k?P??c?V y?C?/kJ mm hF d?og9 ɻ?R o??vt4 rR?E?c p?M Jmv??Y t?IW?R1?t?K??ia姎?ө?w j4 jM4??x 2?sTǟ tऒqO1鎙Q 5Z??IG W??έE?Z?K?o?ǣp I t?j0tj?i??VS?Y kN c?t R5?s?8nM?M L?x w?l a pm l?ۏ gh?_?N?ѩա M??KOJ4?r F6Қ RX Fŗ?l Y?NOl?ŕ ⅛Z m_ MO?N?OЏ mf?z_ K,ڴXFp 6?m4?VקɊ??Gf r6 x?h 5I??lr RO?L I Sp םM?N?p ل?Iy?M R浵?H?4 9?Of Ui?(Ie5 LZǒ Xq Z5?Ԍd Ie ut?Z Y?oM/i mB ܛ?.V?Y?Iv Eu 5hj?n qr??JK)?f?T9?NW js?-??yO C??u V?8G mFM?4?o?yVI X?bp YĔ?W sS?c q?L Y??G?ӕ b?㹿 ǝ??z ӽ?G?ӷ?QM?N x?o?J t?r Yi Tu ǖK??g??v?eYŧ E?5jT eӱ?W?B yCH?G I N5?Y?Ig j?Q y?z?t n2Y?ވ G?u6 m迚??x U梥m?oʩ dΝ I v??t S?M ӾEi t?JF 9Iz 6T?t q4tN7?Ju1S?k?o nuz??;?M?l w??Ӧ a qM쬹 zm??z a?a CЩ??E,?ۓ?m v?e _?mhOx 䗧w vg?Z8j6 bQ jKv J?q??m?H?8K??jќUWN?jIJ1m96 v??u iV ki j?shT?K _k 2O?hZQzN?8??u ίn㧿 I?gf??M?oc ו??m m??aKE?Rt qI s?Cp vt?ҭ?9d ŝ?;K IԩU o?RΫi6?k x?y e??v gMK?T?h śJ?G/q V?)R pO uz G??wXģ C??L xz?v W?S 醗b vx?-n i ukRT??X Fr:?Įu yT RR?5 so T?I??ZX??gZr Y?O EL.?l??g I?t i?j uj2 x??ٺ K?V?M.?lpN?RΔ?U??M n?Χ jU A?խ?X?V2 ʚ?m m?V?K i ש?f c??v2p u?Z me?/?b ݷ?e MO?N?OЏ cRT ryܯ Ӌ?viR?k9TO M?c A Xԯn?Xѕ rr??Z?/Y?F T?T3Fo?J)?M kh Qy?Ӎ ub V??C?P _k Y??ۮ A?S??U kʏi R?S 4ׯf G?u U?n?R LNj 8gJ l??J p?YV uM M?KeM4 A CV N1 ɟz eN4 j0XYi?y f_ z2?xNKf?p??Z r?9sG VQ R_b?j Y?Qm O??m?tM Ҩ??N m?kNuj P?4s?g?r?v 9x ЭB0 md?gY?I?nQ?s??nP?w W?Z?m gw ΝO fں 6q??jJry?O?o ͽe?U Dx;y?s??Ҁ I??K;rKn??ai?4 jj?4j 6q?J sj?df Sf?C8 M?F ww cվ?EqE?c sv kJ č?K gUC?K I n?!h?0?q?IEg Fqo?f s?p O?KCX_?K?Kx?T sPYo w?E չ?s?q?y nQ?9 sڙ?U?z5?N3 _P?9P?a?Ӄ?wZ?jJQYrofw 1t t?f _L?t?n ݧ?YRj?r N?d??r ɮg gn?o Zo1??d zQt?jT o?n ʮj ϯs.?Z Nkz?Ěo s??ojrѬ?ВI?yk??G??DM FMsw Z_ Fj h?B ʵz ˊO FJ c?o S?W zv?s??MT I?Q?q Tom?S N?o??x?Ҏ xXg q?W ц?Uz K?zZgQ r?x?s Ay??s?O mK?TK?L T?l?ʥ 8a it QS O??y CS I??М i l?UUXAKt Iw??Q V?Yڧ?iT?h En?f ӯKV O?y 9o L?zL4?Q K?y K??q c??q Ս?f b"?V?T 1mg uUX?Ί N?f vg?I?i??K ÀZ t??Aes Cs?TVڂ zt 3sA R??r RV ƃt 0Ԥ 2?Εq v??kԕV?o BMG q??ļm:??Ryە d?Ԓ8k?R牮 ki 5RS??jK sZ yߧvM?G h??m?F snMw7?l yP??R i j??l LΒ V??R nq hʽ:4?Y,.ܦut T?H o?S Ҫ??iͼ?S?o Y?f?o?M R?W?Gf G2 aJ i j_bh?Ѯu Q?Bښ ݟo??:3坶R w?J V?6k ӳ??rM?v?f?f?r r?9e M?Ԣ?c ћپ N?y?f??t U8 J2?S?,F;sڽ SS W?f?8fޥ??VMN z?f 7?iUKjuSo?c ѩc Gfq?_?D V?e N0 ze F4R?RQ ks v4 R?G??鞅?q v?gaf-z jQ??.E RXy5 S??K?ϸ DZ?o?.cBҳ??pq l??y?gF2 v?r 8پ?SwF qRK?4?M?g i4 yN ƙJ??ԧ vZ8??Xh v?v KY?U i e?J dc K??q x?x nn 8ߡ Է8 o?W קc:z?ciI9xؼ.?y R9 PQp n?E?u?G c?j Xm?y v:g qe hB P?i Kǹ ժ?u7 g??k Xj v??e μy v?Q??b?DZ Z?z1 Ģ?yh?j?6 kAΌ fs T4j nnv?a?c??u nR?K 8?vl vru9U:k ZƗ R?k?s S8 v?3ou Yj?o Z??Ns wۦ jU sK a?U z??N O_ s?c?б?Ӓ 7?ݨ??cCZ M?9ySo Ss?i qZ Γ?n.??ǚ?M?xSu JN M:?j 0?Ia rN뗛??l?9 Ը?Z?zt QIy v?Ɋ i mߺ?S?WR?n?JU?4??p X?le?o??8?Qӫo 1QmJY?yK n?j?F g?i k?U q??C sV Z?P _3 Z?n??t nO C??YƦ m?_r qo ʔ?c 8E O?k?T?S?1rI??d W?wD??F6?ݬ Ք?Tm?,?-?IfX PJa s?a3OK??t?q?N eI q?W:qQ w6 K??b J??j?f?䦞q?u 3p Nt?N6_a 繽Gx r?Km ua V??ݝ J棼?ד??j Gi??B t?i a F??J q?Kg TVs k?oۃ 7ڒ?g xʴ?9 ʼwn b?e ZM 4Ŋ0?vkyXo8ryo?f?s?ѺN3 Vф?y??ތ F5v?MzVO fQM F?r O?AKv OA?X?_ Fp J?F K6 ī6 ڼ?Y _T?ȟ _4 i Z/?C??vk a Q??kU?W?w Ϗl??W?տ W?"?JQ EmZJ 3j Ưd?a?O??Fj y?ݤ Q?k Uh cN??jM ԚYig?CR m?Sm?K??D??Ӌ I I??Z.ʟ?Kj WF G?yߣ?g Qm jT?qO Zܯ-?o ĖW?5 a?M G?4I q?U?N?Z5 zg 춫??D?V kNuc _Q?V gl ߣ?t N?b?U.?v??vv ZEը?c t??ζ X?v?8I?zM ݤ?bn8?p?ȭW I K?J XQ Ie6 z7 G?K It tw?iJrq??k yg z?a??iT?B F??m Wg?..Դ?B h?R?ڊIɶ Z?Q ݘ?q?OS F?M ez WV?N?5 a O??p Nڝ?LsO?8XI??kqW WW?r??i v?k c??r E?t Ynk??ӱ?f y??9my B?9F??oW-n n??V Q?G TԴH sA uyx gM nNn Ǩд?W rI?b Uc GV?Z nKl i ui?Ue?6K??;gl N?T B??e Vs sXX J2q ъyI R?毌䥟F?O??gj r?n1?J ze5?YXk?5Rƽ k??Juj?u?T R?K a?X?T?Tt v??Y?i?Q?f3r B?V??NT?aNm OP??V IRI??M ԫN2 XX_a?1oq?W??3N R?S 8h?V PQ?7 WH??G ۿc?4 NO 9o?IT??o?Q ϱ??fH Վ?qN 妩,am B??J g9rA Ԥ??m qM t(S?c 2O K?e?v t??a Wa?q Qi ė7fV s?ߡ9 EJ Td?/t Ի?w 5IS?iO Z?M?c PXK N3?vv?jG qjpJMaJ)),n?ȿ Ӷ??jE?m s?uZ 7?qM ݖzz yo aQ?O Ԗ?qOI??yS l?YB Ec?kk K;yB?e I8?r 2k??mk uM w?E?x W?t ΗoG?e?X4 AUxu W?y Q蚊 oE?ǜ G??ƪ?m Jk Zi?Ĝ vX?N x?Zk?"?V?N4ܔ ZRnO _Y?h L?K T??x c?4W Ef?kI?)??t ¼ӊ z?_Z JRI gw w?kBP S?"N bK wz3 O??t 8n ۹g bТ?ES?ъIz??"??CZ I Wڎ?U??M?Ī9u 9Ռ q?C mYf/??raÕ ZΫ gv?k?k yN 㔪F2Y yf??K ea st(?d?7י?z uh x??p V5ne?Q?ZJ?6 V?8թm W3 k;f U?w?iT??;G Ѩ?wv ӂ?b?K V??3Z?kNU?e t枯??S?;i 8Ԝz?E?ф??bʱ I m8ʊ v?RM _a a To8 I/bI Vн gA?mi b?DX gdq?_??b9?nIav 68W?e?Tt?W,c ss,?ay?O?MiZig?k?dᇛZ dG q?y??E?K?nY h?x0ڍX?V d?Xk a cSZe xΆ??V?jJ?i9M?G h??B?n ecf?Aա?эhtk Eo?ҵZz?5 dUǃkZ?9 ye?H?R??yn??u(E U?w dW??qg h?I?/a F?T?U?v??Nބ??k KzT??F?S?x4 U?w j?v 8Z?KP N?g??W?YV??J 6?hJ Yo wN Eg _A C??l J?Fȿ o6?GX HQ EO ۇ?m u3?Vp mJ l?ol!o?Qq_ S??w s?x?e OP??NU?o q?gs?W?X?a Q?ht5 z5?C?Z?JZ hK?)??Ec sK I R6O tj W8Nj8R j??RO r?T WBp p?ӭ M?EC?,c u?M?:qm?:?ߕE Y?X?A굪)G?RK?q nvt?F??i??O B?vR?UF??I??I H?ǫ 1yoѕ js??k?4Ⲛq EM9 YoЎ u-?N?e?Xy??w gK Tz?)n?O?kp?Ӥ?UJ??yQ?Җ lN i uN?c XJ fqء G?M k?jD n?S?vo 6t?Χ?2ϫt??Ep?e?Q ђM q??e ݬn SY??O vգ?FRʒ?u R?ym Vq?gg x?,?Mam lk UCN?J2??Z I?q gN?٥9n i Sy BV NU F?R Fz p?S2?K)cu?o i Case Document Filed Page of Maxwell Confidential understand the bounds that I put on it MS MCCAWLEY No I dont I wi ll continue to ask my questions and you can continue to make your objections Did you ever participate from the time period of to did you ever participate in a massage with Jeffrey Epstein and another female MR PAGLIUCA Objection Do not answer that question Again to the extent you are asking for some sort of illegal activity as youve construed in connection with this case I dont have any problem with you asking that question To the extent these questions involve consensual acts between adults frankly theyre none of your business and I will instruct the wi tness not to answer MS McCAWLEY This case involves sexual trafficking sexual abuse questions about her having interactions with other females is relevant to this case She needs to answer these MAGNA9 LEGAL SERVICES Page