1068

PDF Document Uploaded Feb 2, 2026 by Unknown Updated by admin 1 views 1015.83 KB
Folders as described.
DOJ Epstein Release Interview Victim Statements Evidence Maxwell
← Back to Giuffre v. Maxwell, No. 1;15-cv-07433 (S.D.N.Y. 2015)
Extracted Text

UN4ITED S-3TA4T-2ES3 DI-3ST3RICT CO-4UR4T SOUT3HER-2N D4IST-2RI-3CT4 OF NEW YORK VIRG4INIA 4L G3IUFFRE Plai-3nt3iff4 Case No Civ LAP GH4ISLAIN-2E MAXW3E-3LL Def4endant-3 BR4IEF 2IN OPPOSITION TO Case Document Filed Page of ii TA4B-2LE4 OF-5 CONT4E-2NTS PR3ELIMI-2NA4RY4 S-3TA3T-3EMEN3T AR4GUMEN-3T I All Documen3ts-2 at I-2ssue 3are Judic-2ia3l 3Documents E4ntit-4led t-3o 5a Presumption of Public Access II Th3e Court Should U3ns-4eal Port3ions3 of Dock-4e4t 3En3tri-4es t-3he 5Second Circuit-3 Alread4y Release-3d I Th3e Court Should U3ns-4eal Por-2tions6 of Documents Ment-2io3ning Doe and D4oe IV Th3e Court Should U3ns-4eal Dock-5e4t 3En3try-2 and R4elat-4ed Docke-3t Ent4rie-3s A Continued-2 S6eal-3ing The Prote-3c4tive Order Does Not W6arr-4ant Cont-2inu3ed Seal-3ing Continued-2 S6eal-3ing A C4ri-8m8inal-4 Investi-2g5ati-4on5 Does Not W4arr-4ant Co4nti-3nued Sea3ling The Court Shoul-2d Unsea4l Docket-3 Ent4ry a-2nd 5Relat-3ed Doc5ket Ent-3ries VI The Court Shoul-2d Unsea4l Docket-3 Ent4ry a-2nd 5Cert-2ain Re3lated Docket-2 5Entri-4e4s A Docket Ent-2ry Docket Ent-2ry Docket Ent-2ries VII The Court Shoul-2d Unsea4l Docket-3 Ent4ry a-2nd 5Cert-2ain Re3lated Docket-2 5Entri-4e4s VI-3 The Court Shoul-2d Unsea4l Docket-3 Ent4ry a-2nd 5Relat-3ed Doc5ket Ent-3ries CO4NCLUS3I-6ON Case Document Filed Page of i TA4B-2LE4 OF-5 AU4THORI-5TIE3S Supp 3d S.D.N5.Y Brown Maxwell F.3d 2d Cir-2 passi-3m In r-2e Coordinated Pretri4al Proc-2eed3in3gs F.R3.D C.D C4al In r-2e Om3nicom4 Grp Inc Se-2c Litig No C4IV-4 RC4C/-4MHD3 4W4L S.D.N3 Oct-3 In r-2e Parmalat-2 Sec L4it-3ig3 F.R3.D passi-3m Lugosch Pyramid-2 Co of Onondaga F.3d 2d Cir-2 Lytl-3e 3JPM3organ Chase Supp 2d S.D.N5.Y passi-3m Tel Corp F.2d 2d Cir-2 U.S3 Presc-2ient Ac5quisi-4tion Gr7p Inc-2 MJ Public-2 Tru5st Supp 2d S.D.N5.Y S.E.C3 Th-4eStr-3ee3t.Com F.3d 2d Cir-2 Unite State5s Amodeo F.3d 2d Cir-2 United St-4a5tes Am3odeo F.3d 2d Cir-2 United St-4a5tes Huntle-2y Supp 2d E.D.N5.Y United St-4a5tes Massino Supp 2d E.D.N5.Y Case Document Filed Page of iv United St-4a5tes Sat tar Supp 2d S.D.N5.Y VR O4pti-3cs 3LLC4 Pel-2oton I-3nter-3ac4tive I-2nc No CV J-2PO3 6W9L S.D.N3.Y May Wol-3insky 4Scholas-3tic In3c Supp 2d S.D.N5.Y Case Document Filed Page of Object-3ion 3to3 Unseal-2ing 3Docket Ent-2ries and ECF Nos PR3EL4IMI-2NARY3 4ST3AT-5EME3NT objec-3tion is 290b5lat-4an4t 286att-4em7pt 284sta-3ll 283the 292un5sealing 291process cre6ati-4ng5 unjus-2ti-3fi6ed 24obst-2ac3les-3 25and induci-4ng th3is 27Court 23int-3o 24patt-4e4rn 23of 23dela-3y 25that 25will-3 25ensu3re 22th3e 24docum7ents-8 in 18thi-3s 19c4ase 25whi ch are-3 20c4learly-2 20sub4ject4 20to a 19pre-2sum7pti-3on 20of publi-3c 19ac3ces-2s n5ever-3 20see 22the 22li-3ght 18of 23day To 36be 40the 32two 35Does 35at 32iss-3ue 34ha4ve 34not 33rai-4sed3 35any 34objec-3ti-3o5n 35to 33the 32unsea-2li-3ng 35of 38these 30m8ate-3ri-3a4ls It-3 is only M4axwell-3 who objec-3ts In 33objecti-2ng 40to 33the 32unse3aling 35of any 34document rela4ted 32to ocke3t ntr-3ies and 65Maxwell 60has3 60illustrated 65th3e 60problem8 60that-4 60Pl4aintiff4 60point-3ed Apr5il-3 jo3int-3 24letter 24to 31th3e 25Court Se4e ECF4 29No ecause only Doe 4and Doe h-4ave r-3eceived4 noti-3ce of pot-3ential s-3ea3li-3n5g thus-2 far a-5nd becaus-3e the f4ir-3st five-2 m3oti-3ons 45con4tai-4n 39the 47n5ames 44of 41variou5s 45other 44Non Part-3ies Max3well 47con4tends 43in 46he4r 46ob5jection 42that the ourt-3 c4annot unseal any of 121the 127first-3 124five 124m3oti-3ons or 124rela4ted 127d5ocket-3 124entri3e4s unti-3l 126e4ach Non Part-3y 34is 32separ-4a4tely 29noti-3ced 31in 36th3e 35orde-2r 31that-4 29their 36nam7e appear-4s 35on 29th3e 35Non Part-3y5 34li-3st Id a4t the 47publi-3c 44wil3l 43not 43have 43access to th se docum7ents 45to 43which 44they have 19Fir-2st 22Am5end-5m8ent-7 20ri-3ght 18of 23acce-3ss for 21year-3s And m8eri-4tless obj3ections 18pre-2vail the public-2 will-3 n5ever-3 hav4e acc-3es3s to those document-2s port-3ions of 206docum7ents-3 219m8enti-4oning 216non par-2ties 210rat-4he4r 216than7 waiti-4ng 30to 23u5nseal-4 30the 22en4tire3ty 23of 24giv3en 24docum7ent 22unti-3l 28all 25non par-2ties 24h5ave No 44at em5phasi-3s 45in 46ori-3g5inal 44Yet 45Maxwell-4 now asks the 47Court 44keep 46eve3ry 41docum7ent-7 rel-4a4ted 97to 96m8oti-3ons 94and m8ore-2 94than tot-3al 97d5ocum7ents under-2 94seal in-6 Case Document Filed Page of thei-4r4 25entire3ty unt3il-3 30ever-3y5 25Non Part-3y5 25listed 27therei n5 30rec-3e4ives-3 25no5tice 24and 24h5as 25opport-3un5ity 26to 28req-2ues3t excer-4p5ts 7and4 10object Th6is 12is espite 13th3e 9fact 14that 15Doe 10and D7oe 10did3 10not3 15even 8req-2u5est 11excer-4p5ts 7of the 122docum7ents-3 121whic4h 119their 121names 119appear 119let 119alone 118file3 jec-3tions 121unsealing objec-3tion 10a4re instructions 72when 73it rem5and ed thi-3s 75m8att-4er 77ne4arl-4y 74ye4a4r ago Furt-2her-2 objec-3tions 44extraor-2d5inaril-3y 44gene3ral-4 44and 45vagu4e 44and 45cannot-3 44defeat 46the Fir-2st Am7end-5m8ent pr-4esumpti-2on of3 publi-3c a3cces-3s 4as t-3o any do4cum7ent AR4GUME-3NT favoring 8non United 12Stat-3es 9A6modeo 2d 23Cir Am3odeo4 Accord3ingl-3y 25Maxw5ell-4 25be4ars-3 30the docum7e pub5li-3c acce-3s4s See 96Lyt3le JPMorgan Chase 4F Supp see al-4so 4In r-2e Parmalat-2 Sec Litig S.D.N3.Y rty 21opposi-2ng 25disc-3losure 19m3ust 17m8ake 19p-4articul-4a4r 18and speci-4fic 45dem7onst-2ration 43of 48fact 44showing 44that-4 45disclo4sur-2e 44would 45result 47in 43an 44in3jur-3y 45suff5ici-4e4ntl-3y 45se3ri-3ous4 articul In 28re 33Parmalat 28Sec 28Lit-2ig at see 27also Tr 90of 86Jan 89Conf5 89at ve 20no5t 19file lengt-4h5y 19bri-3efs 18on 19e4ver-2y 19document4 thr-3oughout 51th3e 55cour-2se3 54of 51the 57unse3aling 54proc-2ess 54Tr 55of 51Jan 54Conf5 54at 54Plai-3n5ti-3ff6 has 216therefor5e 215attem7pted 216ke4ep he4r 216opposition 211conci-3s4e 214attached 216Exhib4it 212her-2e4to summ5ary-2 char-3t of her positi-3on 5as t-3o e4ach docum5e-5nt for eas-3e o4f ref3ere-3nce I-3n future oppositi-3on5s to objec-3tions 199unsea-2li-3ng,5 199Plai-3nt3iff4 199ref5er 202bac3k 201rel-4ev4a4nt 201portions 199inst-4ead brief3ing issues-2 m8ult-3ipl-3e ti-4m8es Fur-2ther-4 P6lai-4n5tif4f fil-2es t-3his brie-2f w5it-3h the sam8e under-3sta-3nding as6 Maxwell th3at 7the 7Orig3in3al 7Parties-2 10a4re 7aff5orde-2d 10six 7pages per 13document See Maxwell 10Mem6 il-3l subm5it-3 a corre3cte-3d s4ix pag4e br-2ief Case Document Filed Page of expla-3na4ti-3on of3 4why 2the 7d5ocum7ent 7shoul-2d 4rem5ain 7s4eal-3ed4 4or t-3he r-2edactions should 5con4ti-3n5ue 5specif3ic to t-3ha4t docum10ent I t-3hink t-3hat on speci-4fi6c 260a4rgum6ents-3 259certain 258docum7ents-3 259are 259for 258exa3m3ple woef4ull-3y 204in3adequat-4e to3 burde-2n 49of 46o-4ver-2com7ing 51the 52Fir-2st 52Am5endm7ent 52pre-2sum7pti-3on 49of 51publi-3c 50access espec-3ia v5olum6inous tr6aff5icki-4ng 89oper-2ation and 121and 125bri-3ng 124just-4ice his victim6s See United 57Sta3tes-3 60Massi4no 58S6upp E.D.N3.Y ecogni-3z4ing3 that-4 59he4lped 59ensur-3e 55that 59the 57rep-2ut3ed4 59boss 60notor-3ious 57organized 59wil3l 61spend s4ee 61a5lso pre-2sent-3 att-4em7pt 76at 77u5sing 77vague 71arg-2um8ents-3 74descr-4ib3ing 76h5ig3h level 75ca3tegories 73of 71counte-3rvail3in3g 74int-3e4rests keep 3the doc6ket in 5th3is ca5se 3under-2 5seal See Sealed 6Decem7ber-2 Letter pr-3ov5idi-3n5g 5the C4ourt with 25list 25broa-2d 30and 24v5ague 23ca3tegories-3 25of 28reason5s 24for 26m8aint-4aining 25nea3rl-3y5 30all 25of 28the 22m8oti-3on 25p5aper-3s4 in 58this 60m8att-4er 57under-2 60s4eal Brown 59M3axwell 60No 60Dkt 2d 58Ci5r li sting in 10cu4rs-2ory fashi-2on 9seve ral-4 4rea-3son4s 10th3at 12th3e 10summ10ary-2 9judg-6m3ent 12m8ate-3ri-3a4ls 7shoul-2d 4rem10ain 12under-2 9in3 Case Document Filed Page of specifi-3c 24reasons as 23to 23why speci-4fic 25documents shoul 25rem5ain7 shie-3ld3ed 15from4 14the 17publi-3c4 14de-5m8onst-2rates 16that-4 14sh4e 15c4annot 17articul5ate-3 14such 16spe3cific 17reasons4 14and 15cannot-3 m8eet-3 her-2 burde-2n Furt-2her-2 4t he cent-3ral a4ll-3eg4ati-4on nd5erlying th3is 12c4a4se that 9Ma3xwell 12recru4ited 9Plai-3n5ti-3ff6 9int-3o5 a 70sex traf3ficking 71network 67and 70par-2ti-3c4ipat ed 70in 66the rec-3ruitm7ent 72and 70abuse-2 69of 69other-4s are no secr-4e4t 41and 40h5ave 41been 41av4ail-4ab4le 42to 36th3e 40publi-3c 40for 33year-3s Se4e 39Co-2m8pl 34ECF4 39No Absent 146specif3ic 147com7pell-4ing 141rea-3sons 146se3al the 142first-3 144five5 139m3oti-3ons in 144en4ti-3r4ety objec-3tion are m8eri-4tless Accordi-3ngly3 as 29gener-3a4l appr-2oach th3e 29Court 28shoul-2d unsea-2l 28th3e 29first-3 30fiv6e4 m3oti-3ons 125with only the 132m8ini-8m8al 127red-2ac3ti-3ons 125th3at 127the 127Sec4ond 124Circ-2uit-3 119appli-4ed judgm6ent 27rec-3ord Brown 2d 26Cir Brow7n 0C if 108any 110are 108a4ppli-3cab3le a4nd 104red-2a4c4ti-3ons the 107nam7es of to be no5ti-3c4ed 110Non Parties if docum7ent 262rev-2eal 260non publi-3c 255inform7ati-4on 259about 262the 262Non Part-3ies 258that5 259could 262war4rant 259sealing Alter-4na4ti-3ve4ly3 74if 73the 72Court 76finds5 74up5on 74rev-2iew4 74th3at a4 74document 75con4tai-4n5s4 74no 74sensit3iv3e 75inform7ati-4on-4 about to be not3iced 3Non Party 3or 3th3e 335docum7ent 337conta-3in3s 335o5nly 336publicly 331avai-3lable inform7ati-4on 24about 25yet to be not3ice-3d5 24Non Part-3y the 27Court 26co4uld 26unsea-2l 26th3e 25docum7en-5t with 26only3 the Brown m8ini-8m8al 82red-2act-3ion3s 80if 78a4ny 79without 73engagi-3ng 74in 76the 82no5ti-3ce3 79p5roc-2ess 79Ei4th3er 82app4r oach3 For 231refere-3nc4e,4 speci-4fic posit5ion 46as 46to 46ea3c4h 44docum7ent 52at 47iss-3u5e 45is also incl-4uded 40in 46the 47cha3rt-3 39att-4a4ched thi-3s brief as 5Exhibi-2t A The Brown m8ini-8m8al 37red-2act-3ion3s nco4m3pass of 141all-4eged 144vict-4im11s m8att-4ers-3 139where 141the 142qu5estions 141were 136likely 141only 141p5erm5it-3ted a4nd 139the 142resp6onses-2 139only 136com7pell-4ed Case Document Filed Page of I All 46Documents 47at 46Issue 42are 46Judici-2a 46Document3s 45En3ti-3tl-3ed 44to 44Presum-2ption 46of 46Pub3li-3c Access Judi-2cial 20doc4u-4m8ents-3 19or 21those-3 19that-4 and 34useful 35the 37judicial 40proc-2ess are 36entit3led 37to 34pre-2sum7ption 36of 38publi-3c4 40acce-3ss Bro5wn at The 25fi6rs-2t 23five 25m8otions to 23be 24co4nside-3red 27und5er 22the Order 27and 24Prot-2oco4l 28for 26Unseal-2in3g 25Decided Moti-4ons 44a4re disc-3over-2y m8oti-3ons 44that 45were 43res-3o5lved 47by 45Judge 43Swee-3t ECF4 45No 45at There-2fore as 21the rem5aini-4n5g 19sealed 20m8ate-3ri-3a4ls 16iss-3u5e c4all ed upon5 the 17court 20to 23exer-3c4ise-3 20its 25Arti-3c4le 19p5owers access Brown at ll-3 docu-5m8ents-3 subm7it-3ted in conne-3ction with and rele-3van4t such 56judicial 54decision Id see 57a5lso VR 92Optics-3 94LLC4 95Pelot-3on 94Int-3e4racti4ve 94No CV J-2PO3 94at S.D.N3.Y 22May m6oti-3ons 24to 23com7pel 25ex hibi-3ts 22a4re 22judi-3c4ial 25docum7ents-3 25ECF4 20No at along 19docum7ents-3 19relevan3t are-3 169prope7rl-3y 169cons3idered 170judi-3c4ial 164docum7ents-3 which a pr-3es3u-4m8pti-3on of3 publi As 48to 51the 47weight 52of 46th3e 45pre-2sum7pti-3on 49of 46publi-3c 45ac3ces-2s 50app4li-3c4a4ble 49the 47fir4st 52five 49m8otions,-4 incor-4rect Maxwell-4 15at 14first-3 15five 15m3oti-3ons 14are 16all 15res-3olv3ed 14di3scove-2ry 13m8oti-3ons adjudi-4c4ati-4on5 54of 51the 52ultimate 56m8eri-4ts 52of 51the 52case 53a4rguably 49tr-3igg3ers-3 49the 57h5igh3est-3 54d5egr-2ee3 51prot-3ec3ti-3o5n5 agai-3ns4t 86seali3ng 84thi-3s 85doe4s 85not 86im6ply 86that-4 84m8oti-3on 84paper-3s 85add4ressed 85to 85d5isc-3over-2y 84d5isp ute 87do 84not tr-3igg3er 42the 42p5ubli-3c In 41re 41Om4nicom 39Sec 41Lit-2ig 39No 39CIV RC4C/MHD 359Oct rr-3oneous 361judi-3c4ial deci-3s4ion m8aking 157with 156respect 156su4ch 155evide-3n5ti-3a4ry 156and 155discovery ter-4s 155can 156cau3s4e 155subst-3an4ti-3a4l har-2m Bro-4wn Case Document Filed Page of Id All 46of 36th3e 45docum7en-5ts 47at 42iss-3u5e 45in3cludi-4ng 44m8oti-3ons b5ri-3efs,6 de clarations,3 109and 110exhibi-4ts 109therefore 110judi-3c4ial-4 104docum7ents-3 114entitl-3ed 109pre-2sum7pti-3on access that-4 5c4an only be-3 o5ver-2com7e by spe-2cific a-3nd 5subst-3antia4l reasons for seali-3ng II Th3e 155Court 154Shou3ld 155Un3s-5eal 157Port3ion4s 156Doc6k-3et 152En3tri-4es 151the 156Second 153Circuit 154Alre3ady Release-3d The 89List-3 89of 81Decided 92Mo4ti-3ons 85that-4 84th3e 90Origi-3na4l 91P6arties-3 89subm7it-3ted 87to 91the 87Court ECF 87No contai4ns 65colum5n 64indi-3ca3ti-3ng5 64th3at 67ce3rt-3a4in 66p5ort-3ions 62of 61th3e 65docum7ents-3 64at 67issue 64we6re 67already unsea-2led 17by 20the 12Second 19Circ-2ui3t 15The5 15Court 13should 17unsea-2l any4 port-3ion3 15of 18th3e 14first-3 15fiv6e 19m3oti-3ons 14that is a-3lready av3ail-4ab4le t-4o 5th3e publi-4c I Th3e Court Should U3ns-4eal Por-2tions6 of Documents Ment-2io3ning Doe and D5oe port-3ions o-4f docum7ents-3 64m8enti-4oning Doe 64and Doe 61rat-4h5er 67th3an 65wai4ting 64unseal 64the 62en4ti-3ret5y 64of 61the 64fir4st five 34m8oti-3ons 32unti-3l 31all 34no5n Nei4ther 34Doe 34nor Doe 44req-2ue4ste-3d 44excerpt3s 45of 41the 47sealed 45m8ate-3ri-3als 43that-4 44m8enti-4o5n 44thei-4r 45and 45Max3well as 46not3 identified 66an4y co-5m8pell-4in3g rea-3son to 66conti-4nue 65to 61keep 66their 66id3entiti-3es 66hid3den In 66fact 65Doe alr-4e4ady 169widely 167pu5bli-3c4ize-3d 169weighing 167against 171con4ti-3nu e4d 169sealing See United 167States4 Avenat-2ti consi-3dering 39whether-3 44se3aling 44is 47app4ropria3te 47an 45im6port-3an4t 46cons3ider-4a4ti-3on 39is 42of 41cour-2se 46whether-3 39the inform7ati-4on 144sought-2 145kept Ly5tle Supp are-3 134already 136the port-3ions of Doe deposi-3ti-3on 44tr-3ans3cri-4p5ts 52and 50statem6ents-3 49to 51law 50enforcem6ent 57were 49publi-3c when 43the 47Second 45Circ-2uit 43unsea-2led 47th3e 44judg-6m8ent record in 46thi-3s 44Inde-2ed 45quic-7k Case Document Filed Page of Google 24sear5ch 24of Doe 30or Doe of the inform7ati-4on about t-4hose Non Part-3ies tha3t is cur-2rently u3nder-2 seal The 30only 28a4rgum6ent 27that 35Maxwell-4 30m8akes 27concerning 33doc um8en-5ts 27spe3cifically 32relating 35Doe 74or 76Doe that-4 74Docket 76Entries 74and identic-2a4l excer-4p5ts Doe 0F any 15further-3 14in3volvem5ent 22in thi-3s 15m8att-4er 17and 15that-4 15Doe 14was 14u-4nable-3 14to 16accurately 15rec-3a4ll 13deta-3ils 14of Maxwell-4 34at W9he-5ther-4 34Doe wants t-3o be invol-4ved in this-2 m8att-4er 2has no be-2ari-4n5g on whether-3 the publ-4ic has a const-4it6u ti-3ona4l r-3ight-3 to 8acce-3ss 8ex4cer-3pts 7from9 5his 7depositi-2o5n 10that-4 10were 8e4xhibi-3ts 12to 8m3oti-3on 10papers5 And-2 10Maxwell-4 10cites pre-2cedent f3or t-3he pr-2opos4ition t-2ha4t suff5ici-4e4nt t-3o justify6 conti-4nued4 514s4eal-3ing m8ay 516been3 515proper 509subj-2ec3t cro-2ss exam6inat-4ion 118does 121not 116ju3sti-4fy 116keeping 118port-3ions 116his 122deposi-3ti-3on 119sh4ielde4d 119the publi-3c 45wh7ich 42can 41judge 42his 47c4red-2ib3ility 42for 43itsel-2f 39The 44Court 46s4hould 46unseal 44Docket3 44Entries and As 16to the 12fol6lo wing dock4et 12entries that 15m8enti-4on Doe 15or Doe 15Maxwell-4 20has 13identifie3d rea-3son4 94to 96k5e4ep 95the 92porti4ons 95of the 92d5ocum7ents-3 94that-4 94m8enti-4on 89th3e under-2 94seal-4 94The 94C7ourt-3 89shoul-2d5 unsea-2l 3them5 4at t-4h5is tim6e Docke-3t Ent4ry Page 5Nu3mber-2 at a at at at at In 8referring 8to speci-4fic 10do5cum7ents-3 10Plai-3nti-3ff6 10refers-3 10them5 10by 9docket-3 10entry 10num8ber-2 10that-4 appear-4s 4on 10th3e 4docket-3 5an4d 5on 5the L3ist 5of 8Decided Moti-2ons 5Pl4aintiff4 5rec-3ognize-3s 4th3at th5is 7appr-2oach3 13belie4ves 13that-4 15he4r appr-2oach 3is the cl-3ea3rest 4way to conve-2y her-2 positi3on as t-3o ea3c4h docum7ent 7to t-3he Cour4t Case Document Filed Page of at at at Final-3ly 46Doc6ket 47Entry summ5ari-4ze publi-3c4ly 41avai-3lable s4tatem7ents Page 44summ5a-5ri-3ze3s4 th3at 67is 67already3 69en4ti-3rely 69pub5lic5 69and entire-2ly3 34publ3icl-4y5 34availab3le 32depos3it-3ion3 34testim5ony 34of 35deceased4 34Non Part-3y.5 34That 36p5age 31at 32the 37v5ery lea-3s4t 3shoul-2d unsea-2led 7Docket 3Entry 5which m7enti-4ons 4J 4Doe is a-3lr-3e4ady 4entir3ely publicly avai-3lable 35th 29docke3t Doe 29United 27Sta3tes cv S.D 31Fla 30a4nd 30ther-4efor5e 34shoul-2d 30also be unse-2aled IV Th3e Court Should U3ns-4eal Dock-5e4t 3En3try-2 and R4elat-4ed Docke-3t Ent4rie-3s In 181addition 181unsealing 176portions 179Docket 179relate-3d5 179doc4ket 182en4tries-2 th3at m8en ti-3on Doe 15or Doe 15the 12Court 13shoul-2d 15unsea-2l Docket 13Entries 14and b5ecaus-3e4 19Max3well 22has3 19fail3ed 20to 19h5er 22burden identifying speci-4fic competing 32and 34c4o-4m8pell-4ing 33in3ter-4es3ts 32in fav7or 33of seal-4ing3 and 34that-4 35th3ose 33int-3e4res-3ts outweigh 12th3e 14pre-2sum7ption 16of 18acce-3ss.3 See 13Ly5tle 16Supp 15at In 18re 13Parmala5t 18Sec 13Li4ti-3g 77at Ma3xwell 77contends 74that th3e 75above list3ed4 74docum7ents shoul-2d 74all 74rem10ain 77under-7 quotes-3 5su-5m3m8ar-7ies-3 5of 8or po3rtions 3of 8tran5scr-3ip3ts fro6m8 deposi-3tion 34that 34th3e s4ubjec-3t 31m8att-4e4r 36of the doc4u-4m8ents is 32e4xtr-3em7ely 37personal 36c4onfidenti-3a4l subj-2ec3t 14co4nside-3rable4 14a4buse 16by 9the 12m8edia-3 Her4 14argu-2m8ents-3 14are6 14unavaili-2ng and 110insuff3ici-4ent 1m8eet-3 109burde-2n5 of 106sho-5wing that-4 her-2 109de4posi-2ti-3on 104tr-3a4nscr-3ip 1or any docum7en-5t conta-3in3ing 49excer-4pt 49or 51disc-3ussi-3on of 49deposi-3tion m3ust 52rem5ain seal-4ed 50or 46redacte-2d in enti-4r4ety Case Document Filed Page of A in Does Not Warrant-2 Continued Seali-2ng broad7 29and 30vague cla-3im that-4 29th3e 30above list3e4d 29docket-3 29entrie-2s and 54ther-4efore 54sho4uld 53rem5ain enti-4rely seale4d is 52unavailing But 55even3 if 243Maxwell 244had 245p5rovi-3d5ed 245specif3ic 242rea-3son as3 244why cert4ain 247po5rt-3ion3s4 244d5ep4osit-4ion3 ost 205cas-2es 201which 205cour-2ts 202have 206conc3luded 207that 205pri-3va4cy 205int-3e4res-3ts indi-3vidu3als-3 129were 136suff5icient 136ove4rco-2m8e 135the 137presum9pti-3on 136acce-3ss 131invo3lve 137illness 136sens-2itiv4e-5 Lyt3le S6upp 2d And 89is 97gen4erally 87the 97p5ri-3vacy3 United 47Stat-3es3 50A6modeo 2d 51Cir Am3odeo 50II Finally 50in 51ca3ses 52with 51far 44rea-3ch4ing 51publi-3c 50ram10ificat-4ions 47li-3ke 45th3is 52one 50and h5is Un7it-3ed4 119States4 Huntle-2y i-3nter-4na4l 126quot3ati-4on 125and 125cit-4atio5ns o-4m8it-3ted se3e 5also 7Am3odeo 5II 3at m8ate-3ri-3als-3 132such 135fai5r 131opport-3uni3ty3 134for 133the 137subj-2ect-3 136res-3p5ond 136any 135accus-3a4ti-3ons inued Sealing Second M4axwell-3 419vag4uely 422states 415above adver-3se3 284pub5li-3c4it-3y 279concerning 284pu5bli-3c 285figu6re not4 a 285s4uff6ici-4entl-4y 279com7pell-4ing 281rea-3son 280that Pre4sci-3e4nt 51Acquisit3io3n 49Gr 49Inc 50Publ4ic 52Trus4t Supp r-3e4jecting 122opposi-2ti-3on5 unsea-2lin6g 124the 127basi-3s 125that 124the Case Document Filed Page of 69The 69fac-3t 71that 69the 72publi-3c 70and 70th3e 75m8edia-3 are-3 int-3ereste-2d 64in 71thi-3s 70case6 weighs i-3n favor of unseali-3ng Maxwe not a-2gains6t i-3t Th3e Prot-2ective O-3rder D5oes Not War-2rant Continu4ed Seali-3ng Third Max3well a 70rea-3son4 69to 66keep 71portion4s and 70summ5ari-4es of 64deposi-3tion 68tr6anscr-4ip3t 71se3ale Maxwell Mem6 69at But 60reasonabl-2e 59rel5iance 60on 59prot6ect-3iv3e 59order 65is 57not 59coun4ter-4va4iling 59intere-2st 62that 60alone 61justifies keepi-3ng 44do5cum7ent 42sealed Mar-2tind6ell 45the 47case 51on 45which 44M4axwell-3 45p5ri-3m8arily 43reli3es was 45not 48abo4ut the 52presum9p-4ti-3on 49of 46public 49acce-3s4s or 46s4eal-3ing 2d 33Cir Rather-3 the 32iss-3ue in 33th3at 32cas-2e 34was5 35the 27m8odificat-4ion 33of 34prot-3ective 33order I at Furt-2her-2 34in 36a4nother-4 34cas-2e 30that-4 34Maxwell 34cit-4es S.E.6C 35TheStr-7eet-3.Com 2d 36Cir Mar-2ti-3n5dell es3tablishes 144pre-2sum7pti-3on 144agai-3nst 147p5ubli-3c 144where est-3ab4li-3shed 274the 277pa4rty 273cla im6ing 276pri-3vacy 275rea-3sonab3ly3 m8phasi-3s 140added The5 139th3at 137Maxwell 139cit5es 139noth3in3g about 137ge4ner-2alized3 139rel5ianc-3e4 prot-3ec3ti-3ve4 106b5eing 102s4uff6ici-4ent 99shie-3ld3 judici3al 106document3s from9 104the 107publi-3c 106wh7ethe-3r 101such relia nce3 15can 18outweigh 12th8e 14pre-2em7pti-3o5n 15of 18publi-3c4 15a4cces-3s Abse5nt 13som7e 14other legit3im6ate-3 15and 14specif3ic counte-3rvail3in3g 104int-3erest ju3sti-4fying 103c4lo3sur-2e 105Max3well 107canno3t 100prot-3ec3ti-3ve 106a4lone defeat t-3he p4resum9pti-3on of3 publi-3c acc-3e4ss t-3o the judicia-2l do3cum7e-5nts at hand rea-3sonab3le pre-2sum7pti-3on 14of 11publi-3c 15ac3ces-2s 15Maxw5ell-4 14ha4s 15failed 12to 16dem7ons-5tr-3a4te 17that 14sh4e 15relied 17on 9th3e 15prot-3e4cti-4v5e4 orde-2r 63in 58ans3werin-2g ever6y 59single 59ques3ti-3on during 61h5er 57depos3it-3io3n In 58fact th3e 59Second 59Circuit squ4arely4 addr-2esse-3d5 154rejected 149the a4rgum6e-5nt Maxwe4ll 153currently akes Lugosch 154Pyramid Onondaga 2d 156Cir In Lugosch Case Document Filed Page of but th3e 24Second 24Circuit 23disagre3ed and 59held 57that 60the 57exis-3tenc6e 59of 59con-5fident iali3ty 58order 60did 58not 58de4feat 59the 57pre-2s4u-4m8pti-3on 60of 63p-4ubli-3c 59access to 61jud3ici-4a4l 61d5ocum7ents-3 59whe-3re 57the 62order 59was 59u5m3bre-2ll-3a 60o5rder 59and 55specif3ica-3ll-3y 54contem4plat-4ed 60th3a4t relief 125provisions 122could 125s4ought The 124Second 125Circ-2ui3t expla-3i Rule 156countenanced 149the 154law 151acce-3ss To 153reverse 155b5urde-2n 156th3is sit-4ua4ti-3on 84wo7uld 86be 80to 86im6pose 85s4ignif4ica-3nt 86and 85p5erh-2aps 86ove4rpow5eri-4ng 84im6pair-4m8e nt 86on 84the 87pub5lic Id at quoting In 31re 36Coordina4ted 37Pre4tri-4a5l 31Proceedi-4ngs C.D C4al In Lug-3osch the 207protective 205order is an 205um3bre-2lla 204prot-3e4cti-4ve 205order that Lugosch at ECF4 No Max3well c-3anno4t 3use s-2uch an 3u-4m8bre-2ll-3a o4rder to 3shield Maxw3ell-4 96can rea-3sonab3ly 101arg-2ue 95that she produc-2ed 100documents 96reliance 99on 99the 102fact 100th3at See Lugosch F.3d at nt Brown is 97of 94help 92to 96here 93and d5oes 96not3 94sup4port-3 keepi-3ng d5ep4osit-4ion3 unde4r 41seal 39in its entire-2ty 41due4 34to 41the m8ere exis-3tence 39of 40prot-3e4ctive orde-2r min5imal3ly 12reda3cte-3d5 ver-2sion 17of summ5ary-2 15judg-6m8ent 12rec-3o5rd pe4rs-2o5nall-4y 15identif6ying 13information th3e 14na-5m8es all-4eg4ed 29m8inor-3 30victim6s 29of 33sexua-2l 33abus3e and4 where 18the 17quest-3ions 17wer4e 19li-3kely 17only3 20per-2m8it-3ted and 19the 17res-3p5on ses 17only 18co-5m8pell-4ed becaus-3e 19of em5phasi-3s 4adde3d Maxwell5 has 121not 116explained 121what4 114red-2ac3ti-3ons to3 119depo4s4it-3ion3 119transc3ript a4re 122wa6rr ante-3d 119unde4r 116the 122Se5con-5d Case Document Filed Page of list3ed 125docu-5m8ents-3 124rem5aini-4ng seal-4ed in 3th3e4ir enti-2r4ety See 3Lugosch rem5and 4the de-3fendants 3shoul-2d 5have3 p5arti-4cu4lar 67cir6cumstance-3s sur-2roundi-3ng5 em5p-4hasi-3s 90added prot-3ec3ti-3ve o4rder does not jus ti-3fy th6e p4erm5anent-3 seal-4ing of her entire-2 depos3it-3ion 3tr-3an4scri4pt Seali-3ng Fourth Maxwell5 Mem6 at Each document at issue 5was subm7it-3ted t-4o as3sist the C3ourt-3 5in renderi-4ng5 a eci-3s4ion on disc-3over-2y5 124m3oti-3on 124Max3well 127has 126fai5led 126a4rticu3lat-4e 125wi5th 124speci-4fic5it-3y5 124whatsoe-2ver 122how 122each of 23m8ate-3ri-3a4ls 27that 25shoul-2d5 25n5ot 25subm7it-3ted 27to 23cou4rt-3s4 Id 25Filing5 excer-4p5ts 144deposi-3ti-3on 144tr-3ans3cri-4p5ts 146summ10ar-7ies-3 141depos3it-3ion 141testim5ony 146conn4ect-3ion 146wi5th counte-3rvail3in3g 144int-3erest 146ju3sti-4fying 143se3ali-4ng 141docu-5m8ents-3 0F the 82Second 75Circ-2ui3t in di3cta-3 pre3vent records3 fro-3m8 104being Brown 49at he 50Court 51did 51not 51hold3 that-4 is 5reason 9to 11k5eep3 9docum7ents-3 9shie-3ld3ed 10fro6m8 9the 12publi-8c after 57th3ey 59ha4ve 59already 58b5een 58filed 63and4 60rul-3ed 59upon5 65by 60the 57cou4rt In 58fact Bro5wn provi-3ded autionar-2y5 Case Document Filed Page of note 7that-4 15the 12publi-3c 9shou4ld 8rec-3ogni3ze3 10that-4 public cour-2t filings 11do 10not necessarily ref own f5indi-3ngs and shoul-2d5 Id at An3noyanc-3e Embarrass-3me-2nt 4Oppres-2sion an4d U3ndu3e Warrant-2 Continued Seali-2ng Fift-4h deposi-3tion 163m3ust 167rem5ai-7n 164under-2 Maxwell See Lytle Supp 2d r-3efusin4g 126red-2a4ct 122nam7es 121ta-7rge-2ts 121harassm7ent 127and see 37also 38Sup de-2ny5ing m3oti-3on 261seal em7bar-2ras-3sing 211the 212publi-3c 210ram5ificat-4i Wolinsky 210Scholas-3tic Supp S.D.N3.Y hol-3d5ing 365fear 365that 364disc-3losure4 364cause i6nter-4na4l 58quo5tation and 70cit ation5s 70om8it-3ted The 69fact 65th3at 72th3is 64invol-3ves3 the 67sens-2itive3 69su4bjec-3t 66of 66chil5d 69sex 71abus3e-5 does not-3 a4ll-3o5w an acc-3use3d abuse-2r t-3o 5s4hiel-4d he4r c-2o5nduct by cla6im6ing e-7m8bar-2ras-3sm7ent g5 thi-3s 75the 82s4tandard 80for 78se3a4li-3ng 74is 82di3ff6icul-4t 81to 76imagine-2 79any4 79law4suit-4 79in 81wh7ich 77any 80of 76th3e 80paper-3s sta-3rting4 25with3 25the 27com7plai-4nt 23and4 25ending 27with 28summ10ary judg-6m ent 22m8oti-3ons would 25not3 25be 24sub4ject In r-2e 4Om4nicom G-3rp I-2nc Sec L3it-3ig 4W9L at Case Document Filed Page of A C4rim-4inal-2 5Invest-3iga3ti-3o5n D3oes Not Warrant-2 Continued Seali-2ng Final-2ly conta-3in3ing 66port-3ions 67or 66s4u-4m3m8ari-4es 66of 64deposi-3ti6on 64tes-3ti-3m8ony 64Maxwell-4 64Me m8 64at 64She 64sta-3tes provi-3d5es3 he 45sealed 45testim5ony 44or 46summ5ari-4es m8ay 15inappr-4opri-3a4tel-4y5 14infl4uence 17po5tential 14wi tnesses3 14or 11alleged 16v5ictim6s Id 14Maxwe4ll-3 9p5rovi-3des3 suppor-2t 51for 49assertio5n 49that-4 49th3e 50crim8inal-4 49just-4ic7e 50sys tem5 49woul-4d 49be 50hindered by 49the 52d5isc-3losure 50of her-2 10deposi-3ti6on 10tes-3ti-3m8ony 10and 9she 8cannot-3 10dem7a-5nd 10blanke-3t 8s4eal-3ing 8bas3ed4 10on 10vague 8asse-3rtions a cr-3im inal-4 in3vest-3ig3ati-4on Maxwell-4 45failed 47to 45he4r 43burde7n 45of 48justifying 44the 47contin5ued 44sealing3 50of 48Docket 43Entries 60and The urt-3 60shoul-2d5 unsea-2l 11those 13docum7ents-3 14in 16their3 14entir3ety 17with onl3y any 15app4li-3c4able Brown m8ini-8m8al 17red-2act-3ion3s an4d5 red-2ac3ti-3on o5f 36yet to be n5oti-3ced3 39Non Part-3y 39nam7es if 38the 42s4eal-3e4d 39inform7ati-4on 39about 37the 37Non Part-3ies6 is s-3ens3it-3iv3e a3nd non publ3ic Th3e Court Should U3ns-4eal Docket 4En3try-2 and R4elat-4ed Docke-3t Ent4rie-3s Maxwell-4 134s4tated 135that 134does 136not 136o5bjec-3t 136uns4eal-3ing 136Dock6et 137Entry and 135rel5ate-3d docket-3 219entri3es a Non Part-3ies 26m8ay 19rai-4se 18counte-3rvail3in 20int-3e4res-3ts 22that 15m8ust 17be 19addr-2esse-3d 20by 20th3e 19Court 18pursuant 19to Maxwell-4 5als6o 5conte-3nds 4th3at the 4follo4wing 5docket 6entr-4ies 6shou4ld 3rem5ain under 4seal 99Maxwell-4 em7 99at 99the 97exception Docket 86Entry 84however 86which 85c4ontai-4ns 85on5ly3 84one 85red-2a4cti5on 84that-4 79can 81be 85rem5oved 85becaus-3e 80it poses-2 10no 15co4unter-4va4iling 14int-3e4res-3ts 12th3e4se docke3t 8en4tr-3ies a4re 7a4lre5ady 9publicly 13available 10the 7do5cket and ar-3e no4t 3on the-2 List o6f eci-3ded Mot-3ions Case Document Filed Page of thes-3e 105docu4m8ents seal-4ed 106red-2ac3ted 102Docket 106Entry 105related6 104docket-3 104entr5ies-3 104shoul-2d unsea-2led 157wi5th only any 155appli-4cab3le Brown m8ini-3m8al 157red-2act-3io3ns 155and red-2act-3ion3s 151the 157nam7es yet to be no5ti-3ced3 30Non Parties if 31the 32s4eal-3ed 34information 32about 32th3e 29Non Parti4es 28is 32sensit iv3e 29and 29non publi-3c VI Th3e Court Should U3ns-4eal Dock-5e4t 3En3try-2 and C4ert-3ain Relat-3ed Docket Entries In 81addition 79unsea-2ling 73port-3ions 82of 71Docket 81Entry 79and 80its 79rel-4a4ted 82do5cket-3 79en4tr-3ies 73that m8enti-4on Doe Doe 30the 32Court 33sh4ould 28unse3al 32Docket 28Ent4ries and b5ecaus-3e 10M4ax4well 12has 11fai5led 7to 9her-2 9burde-2n5 9of 6identifying speci-4fic5 19competing 17and 20c4o-4m8pell-4ing 16in3ter-4es3ts 17in 21fa7vor 21of 16sealin3g 19and 15that 19th3ose 21in3terests 19outweigh7 the 52pre-2sum7pti-3on 49of public access Se4e 50Lytl-3e 48Supp 54at In 49Parmalat 51Sec 51Lit-2ig Docket 181Ent4ri-3es3 179and addr-2esse-3d 5in3 Part-3 I sup4ra A Docke-3t Ent4ry As 151Docket 151Entry 149Maxwell-4 144conte-3nds 150th3at 152all 149redactions 149shoul-2d5 149rem5ain 151place5 osition 241testim5ony 239and 240Non deposi-3tion est-3im6ony 24and 25she 26cit-4es 21the 27sam6e 25counte-3rvail3ing 26int e4res-3ts 22discussed 26in I supra Maxwell-4 20at 18the 17sam6e 19rea-3sons 18explai4ned 19above 18she 18has 18failed 22to 18sta-3te 22with3 20speci-4fici3ty3 why 82the 87portions 86of h5is 82docum7ent 87that-4 84m8enti-4on 84no 84Non Party 83shoul-2d5 84rem10ain 87shie-3ld3ed 85from9 84the publi-3c 4alleg4ati-4ons4 in 3thi-3s4 m8att-4er 2or q8uest-3ions tha4t 3Maxwell fa3iled to answ4e4r duri-3ng5 her 7deposi-3tion.-3 149for 143exa3m3ple Docket Ent-2r ies-3 and are alre4ady publi-4c4ly3 avai-3lable on4 the doc-3ke4t 3of Doe United State-2s cv S4.D Fla Case Document Filed Page of inform7ati-4on 79were 81valid 74reasons 75to 81ke4ep 80docum7ent e4ale-3d,5 74Docket 81Entry 79canno3t 81be 80s4aid 77to 274Page4s4 274thr-3ough5 271Docket 276Ent4ry 274shoul-2d th3ere-3fore be unre-2dac3ted If 88the 92Court 91decl-3i nes 91to 86unsea-2l 91page3s 89thr-3ough 89in 91full 89the 92following 90it-3em7s 90in 91Doc-3ket-7 144th3at 147a4lr-3e4ady 145public 139and shoul-2d unsea-2led Specifically 42each 47bull-3e4t 46point-3 44listed-2 39below 45incl-4u5des 45cit-4a4ti-3o5n 44to 45page 46of 41Maxwe deposi-3tion t4hat i-4s 4a part 4of the summar-2y judgm6ent r-4eco3rd t-3ha4t 3the Se-2cond 4Circ-2ui3t unsealed Pub3li-3cly Av4ail-3able Ite4m Page Bullet Point-3 No Page Bullet Point-3 No Page Bullet Point-3 No Page Bullet Point-3 No Page Bullet Point-3 No Docke-3t Ent4ry Docket 241Entry is 240full 240tr-3ans3cri-4p5t dep4osit-4ion 239Again 240instea3d provi-3ding 53sp4eci-3fic 50reason5s 49to 48redact 53ce3rt-3a4in 48portion4s 49of 50depo4sit-4ion,3 50Max3well 47contend6s the en4ti-3r4e-5 document m3ust 67rem5ain 67u5nder-2 64seal be4cause th3e de4posi-2ti-3on5 64was Prot-2ec3ti-3ve 90Order Ma3xwell 94at or 91the 97reasons 90articul-4a4ted 94Part-3 94IV s4upra 94thi-3s 90is sim5ply 66not 61how 62the 67presum9pti-3on 64of 66publi-3c4 64acce6ss 66works T6he 65protectiv5e 65order 64th3at 62gover-2ns cas-2e 4is a 6blank conte-3nt3ion 81th3at 82Maxwell5 79relied 82on 79th3at 82protective4 79orde-2r 81in 76an4sweri-3ng 79ea3c4h 79and 80ever-3y5 79deposi-3tion quest-3ion3 14is 17n5ot 16reasonable 13or 16c4red-2ib3le See 16sup4ra Part-3 9IV.C Maxwell-4 15fail ed 10to 16a4rticu3lat-4e4 14any4 speci-4fic 29co4m3pell-4ing 31reason 34to 36k5eep 31thi-3s 30entire-2 34d5ocum7ent 34whi-4ch 35large4ly 31conta-3in3s 35que4sti-4ons4 34abou4t the 27publi-3c 25a4llegations 25un5der-2ly3ing 24cas-2e 25and 25refusal-3s 25to 26ans3wer 25those-3 24quest-3ions un5der-2 24seal-4 shie-3ld3ed 50from4 49the 52publi-3c4 In 51re 51Parmal at 51Sec 51Lit-2ig 49at Case Document Filed Page of har-2m8 139unsub-5sta-3nt3iated 139speci-4fic 139e4xam7ples-3 141articul-4a4ted 137reasoning 141fai5l 141sa3ti-3sfy 140test Furt-2her-2,5 9port6ion 10of 6th3is 7transcript 7are6 9already 9as 11no5ted 2on 9the 7Lis3t 6Decided m3oti-3ons Docket 256Entry 254shoul-2d 254ther-4efo7re 255unsealed 255with only the Brown m8ini-8m8al-7 red-2ac3ti-3ons 44any are-3 44ap4pli-3cab3le an4d 44of 41the 47nam7es o-4f 41yet to be not3ice-3d5 44Non Part-3ies if 43the 47seale4d inform7ati-4on about t-4he N6on Parties-2 5is sensi-2tive an4d non public Docke-3t Ent4r ies Maxwell-4 259co4ntends-3 259that5 259the 262red-2ac3tions 261Docket 261Entry 259conta-3in 256quotations-2 259from4 Non Part-3y d5eposi-3tions a4nd thus-2 that all-4 of the re-2d5act-3ion3s should rem5ain i-4n plac-3e Max3well M-3em7 at 50But 50at the 47following 49red-2action4s 49conta-3in 48no 55such 48quotations and do 50not 48im6pli-3cat-3e the 7p5ri-3vacy3 4in3ter-4es3ts of 4a4ny 4Non Party or m8ere-3ly3 4restate 4th3e 5p5ubli-3c4 4allega3tions 4th3at Pl-3a4int-3iff4 4m8ade-6 agai-3ns4t Ma-3x5well and can be unse-2ale6d Page Redacti-2on Page Page All Redactions re-2da4cte-3d 5inform7ati-4on reg-2arding Non Part-3y su4m3m3ari-4zes-2 p5ubli-3c port-3ions o-2f h8is de-3position3 Page Page Page All Redactions Page All Redactions Docket Ent-2ries and ar-2e co3rrecte-3d o5r a-2m8e-5nded ver-3sions of4 Docket Ent-2ry 3and shoul-3d be tr-3e4ate-3d s4im11il-3arl-4y Maxwell 39ob5jec-3ts 39unse3ali-4ng5 Docke5t 41En tries 34and axwell but t-3hose doc-2u-4m8ents are-3 not cur-4rently s-2ea3led and are t-4hus not-2 on the-2 List-3 of D5eci-3ded Mot-3ions The 25sam6e 24is 22tr-3ue 24of 28Docket 23Entries 25which 24Maxwell-4 30arg-2ues Maxwell 69at 69These3 69do5cket-3 64entrie-2s4 64already 66avai-3lable4 64the 72pub5li-3c4 69full 69the docket-3 Case Document Filed Page of VII Th3e Court Should U3ns-4eal Dock-5e4t 3En3try-2 and C4ert-3ain Relat-2ed Docket Entries In 38addition 40unsea-2li-3ng 45port-3ions 37of 43docket-3 40entries6 rel-4a4ted 37to 38Docket 38Entry that-4 Doe 19or Doe 19the 22Cou rt-3 19shou4ld 21un5seal-4 19Docke5t 16Entri-4e4s 24and bec3ause 22Maxwell 24ha4s 25failed m3eet-3 24h5er 27bu5rden 22of 21identif6ying spe3cifi3c 25com7peti-4ng and 20com7pell-4ing 21in3ter-4e4sts 18in 21favor 19of 11sealing 21and 15that-4 14those 18in3ter-4es3ts 22ou5tweigh 22th3e 20pre7sum7pti-3on 19of publi-3c acces5s See3 39Lyt3le 38Sup6p 39at In 40Parmalat 41Se4c 40Li4tig 37at As 11to 8thes-3e 9docum7ents-3 5Maxwell-4 10ha4s 9su-5m3m8ari-4ly 8sta-3ted 7that 10th3ese 7documents 8shoul-2d 10rem10ain 7seal-4ed becaus-3e 175they 177m8enti-4on 174Non Pa rt-3ies6 174have 176yet rec-3e4iv3e dete-3rm6ine 32th3at 32th3e 30Seale6d 29Mat-3e4ri-3a4ls 27rem5ain 32seal-4e4d 29by 29applica3ti-3on 29of 26coun4ter-4va4iling 30in3ter-4es3ts 32CI thr-3ough 60CI Yet 59agai-3n 60Maxwell-4 60has3 60failed 57to 58provide 60any 59spe3cific 57rea-3son4s to 11keep 11these 9docum7ents-8 enti-4rely under-2 9seal-4 9th3at 12o5utweigh 12the 7pre-2sum7pti-3on 9of 6publi-3c 10acce-3ss The Court 91should 87ther-4efore 85unsea-2l 91dock4et 92entries relate-3d 84to 91Doc6ket 92Entry in 91their 91e4nti-3rety 89wit m8ini-8m8al 42red-2act-3ion3s 40as 41a4rticu3lat-4ed 35in Brown 39if 38any 39app4li-3c4able-3 and 40of 31the 42nam7es 41of yet to be noti-3ced Non Parties if the s-2ealed inform7ati-4on about t-4he Non P6arties-3 i3s sensit-2iv3e and no3n public Plai-3nt3iff4 takes 104pos4it-3io3n 104tim9e 106the 102following 105d5ocket-3 104en4trie3s 5Pl4aint iff4 5however poin3ts 7o5ut 3th3at 7the L8ist 5of 8Decid3e4d 5Moti-4on5s 4n5otes-3 10that 5the-7 Second 35Circuit 36a4lr-3eady 36u5nseal-4ed 35v5arious 35port-3ion3s4 34of those docum7ents-3 34whi-4ch 35m8ay 35be 35unsea-2led thes-3e dock3et entries a-2s w6ell-4 Plai-3nt3iff4 20agr-2ees-2 20with 18Ma3xwell 17that 20e4ver-2yth3ing 18ex4cept-3 20for 21th 19redaction 21on 20page 20of 23Doc-3ket Entry 4shoul-2d 4be 5unsea-2led 4Max3well 7Mem6 4But 4be-5cause-3 4there 5are-3 4no 4other-4 Non Part-3ies m8enti-4oned 40in 41red-2act-3ed 40p5ort-3ions 42of 36th3e 40docum7ent,-7 39ther-4e 40is 42no 34need 41to 41wait 37for 38further-3 39Non Part-3ies to be noticed to do so Plai-3nt3if 106also 108agr-2e4es 1wi5th3 109Maxwell 109th3at 112Docke5t 106Entri-4e4s 104and 110un5sealed Maxwell 69at 64with 71th3e 70exc3epti-4on5 69of 66pa4ge 69of 69because 69th3at 67letter 69app4ear-3s 65to 71h5ave3 been 36include4d 34in 36th3e 35fil4in3g 34by 34m8ist-4ake 34Because 27ther-4e4 34are 33no 29other-4 34Non P6arties-3 34m8ent io3ned 35in 31the docum7ents-3 ther-4e is-3 no n5e4ed to wai-3t fo6r furt-2her-2 No7n Parties-2 5to 3be noti-4c4ed to do so Docket Ent-2ry is Non Part-3y d5eposi-3tion tra6nscr-3ip3t and Plai-3nt3iff4 take-3s no posi-3tio6n as-6 to t-3ha4t docum10ent a-3t t-3his tim6e Case Document Filed Page of VI Th3e Court Should U3ns-4eal Dock-5e4t 3En3try-2 and R4elat-4ed Docke-3t En3tries Maxwell-4 69do5es 71not 71object 70to 71unsea-2lin6g 69Docket 69and 70relate-3d5 69docket-3 69entrie-2s 70at lat-4e4r 6da4te but con4tends-3 th3at 7do5ing 6so4 4now 2would be 5pre-2m8ature Part-3ies rai-4se3 184counte6rva-2iling 180int-3e4res-3ts 182that 184m3ust 185add4ressed 185Cou Maxwell-4 docum7ents-3 4seal-4ed4 4or r-3ed4act-3ed,4 4Docket 6Ent4ry 4and it-4s4 4related 3docke3t 6en4tr-3ies 3shou4ld be 7unseale4d5 with 36only3 34th3e Brown m8ini-3m8al 37red-2ac3tion 30if 33appli5cabl-3e,4 and 30redactions 34the 32nam7es 36of 31yet to be noti-3ced3 69Non Parties if 68th3e 70sealed 65inform7ati-4on 69ab4out 71th3e 70Non Parties 67is 67s4ensi-3tive 64and4 69non publ3ic How4ever-3 Doc-3ket ntrie3s 29and contain Plai-3n hist-4o5ry and such 16infor-5m8ati-4on5 shoul-2d 30rem5a-5in 23se3ale-3d or 28redacte-2d S5e4e United 27Sta3tes-3 Sat3tar 26Supp6 S.D.N3.Y red-2ac3ti-3on or 3sealing CONC4L-2USIO-4N For 5the foregoi to3 keepi-3ng5 4Docket Entri-4e4s 79and 79sealed 80in th3eir-4 74entire-2ty at 82th3is 80and unseal 74or unre-2da4ct-7 them5 as di-3rected by t-3h5e 4Second Circuit-2 Docket 13Entries 20an4d are Non Part-3y 15d5eposi-3tion 16tra5nscr-3ip3t 15and Plai-3nt3iff4 take-3s 14no posi-2ti-3on 35as 30those-3 30dock4et 27entrie-2s 28th3is 29Second 29Circ-2uit-3 30has 28ho5wever 28alrea3dy 30unsea-2led cer-3tain page3s of the deposi-4ti-3on 5at D4ocket-3 Ent4ry as no3ted i-4n 5the List of D3eci-3de4d Mot-2ions Case Document Filed Page of Dated:-3 June3 Respect-3fully4 Sub-3m8it-3ted Sig4ri-3d 6McCawley Sigr-2id McC4awley Pr-2o Hac Vi5ce OIE-4S CHILL-4ER LE-5XNER LLP Las Olas Blvd Sui-2te Ft Lauder-3da4le FL Counsel f-3or 4Plai-2nt3if-3f V6irginia Giuffre Case Document Filed Page of m/y t0 I F/Z V/j 1a qC KS u?v vZ O5 a qr rCX qC 0V I I dc rM?M rM 10Cy n??m?n k?o?h I A I w?!ac qr MCX 10Cy ITy qr M3 Ґ??1rA5R h?H?T3P K?z X?K I v"x i X5 EO5 5a r?q CX 9r Cy rq rqC M3 ş?:c p/p0 5H V)V 6T Y2 G5 qrM?r?qr?r9 q?10Cy rCX qr l1 X?l 3K fm?Q Z2f CX CX gT L??T 2E Cy 3P EM3 J4T L?h??M q?ᡚ?Y r??O?rJt CTX i P!e i I CTX rC YY I 1e 2j CTX X0T1i k3v Jh/e0h1 H(K W/Q0 CTX j?!k 5B r2 CTX A A A 4v z"p A A A0A?A AK CTX A A?!k CX qCX YCX i!d A fi8 l8 yuZ 6L pH m?c sP;0 6ZR Ni P0 0Q X(P0s s(s p0 Pp CTX qq dR B/J Va A N?q qr NEeD K?i N?M?qr EeD k??O GH FT I CTX U3 U3 U3 U3 S6 E"L I I I5K7C:I 9O U3 Cn qrr qr q??r?q 9qr CTX G5 qr CX rC l0 WS zN pf1 ODV8L?m jC1DxV CTX CTX A qr 10Cy rYY Ң??P?V CTX C"C rqM?rq?q?qr qr CTX YY Jb?C.y CTX CTX GG4 A A G5 C.C M??r 10Cy rq YY C?J?yO c/XE?lgF GM??H p?ݡG Dp9Oh CTX CTX CJ4 I J6 CJ4 CK qrrM?q qq 9/CX?o CX qYqr rC dd?Z c6S ttcx A CTX CTX 10Cy rq rqYY X?qiX:4 3J Db ZH uD-8 1g?BH I vS 7Oo7u E?K?O J6 UJP U0 UT??ʴ UT UT UT O(p U(u UF1 iZ qr?r CX CX Yr zKW:E A K5M P-M UW VW L1J KJ56 N/Q SQ rC 6J ߵl ߵl 5TZ w8ĥDG oj?K _4 N)?Y Hp pRqc?W26 vz?WBrz?ZB??3X H4 CTX A CTX X4 U5 P8 5D qr qr 10Cy qr YY Mo?ANp D01jJ 9F bzEV 4O 8V CTX O!o CTX KK AA qr A C5 qr rYY 1A?CC V9 a c?F CTX A G5 qr EeD?M CTX 9?rY 10Cy rq qY ȠX1 a f??B CTX 9F I CTX 6D N?qr rrqq qC O?J RmA??b"0 M?.F q?D B?G CTX CTX F4 d6P A F4 qr rYY 4G AV8 CTX UY UL0 U0 U0 U0 UF UF UFAGA UA UA UAL UL UL UL UL UL UL U7 U7 U7 U7 U7 U7 U7 2EH GTU U/U OUoU UV G1 CTX TUV 1G 7A UA UAL X7 U7 U7 U77XL UL UL ULLYX KTX 8Y GJ A UMAT UD 7M GVW GF10 MWA LL MPM M?M 4M XY qr qr qr NEeD 10Cy qYY E2 GH l1 Pd h3V g?KIq V5kL O65S d_xKKU vV 5H p1 Z6 CTX U0 U1 CTX U0 U1 A0 1D qr qr 10Cy YY K??Kl 1B AMwv 1K F1 KV yW Gd T?H CTX CTX I CK M?qr K?SK?PQZ I IRZX 8YCX 10Cy qr CX kv zg S5kB??a iG wA CTX U2 6Y CTX U2 6Y I K,,j j,s 6Y P!p qr 10Cy qr YY G?O 9K mSd X0 9r?yal 1d bY0 XNf??qN D?J CTX P!Z b!o C,C qrM 10Cy qr8 I fX2 9R lO KV CTX Oo CTX A qr r?qr rq YY Lsy7H4 C,6E IL CTX U3 CTX J,O3_3xx qrM?r q?CX Y9/C 9CX CTX Y10Cy CX CX CX YC YY FV uTl bEWa ȓjJ-8 Gc G??Q9E 9Wq CTX CTX Up i I A 9_ qr qr YY D.X 7s F??Y bc3_c iH CTX CTX A qr 10Cy YY EMq 7H AY mK9Z BY A2 P6L N7 CTX CTX a I I i qr rC CTX CTX 7O I FMM qr qr i I I3 CTX Z6 I L(K4 P:u Z6P CTX y8 YY AKH 1U TH9?P Z??JQ hhc r?y1 CTX U2 CTX z2 KTX 8Y d6 i h,x N?rM?q?q?NEeD YY A n??D CTX r??r A N?qM??N rM a NiK 2J H?I??d U?nnF c7 GH I GH t?!TZ N?M?NEeD FXL J7Cl M8Bj k).d 0EtUd 1HrUi a N?M??NEeD CkY qTva YY h?b CTX BA BA Up/p4 h7 PB pB?B AB N?M 10Cy rq V?C 3e TK??v9Y R5H CTX P6 p6 p6 N?M 10Cy qrY l4 EG 9F T?Zfb H??lC XLɿrJJ?FZ7 t?!TZ N?M?r se M7Bk cWM J6Dl 0HrWi 0FuUd CTX A qr rY 1A?CC V9 a N?M CTX a chlPTT Xx pt LH NJvrrbfFB z62nj RV ZzjZZjz c?F qr NX a a?q 8l?hb?r Iy?WEoM GoNLoH Mi P??jd??YP??o Cm7i?aH?uIBq?W?h9 I j)A a1 nne P/Tv ab WJ 6Td.By??e I pJ?J a C?k i dJtJ JJ g1 JOV DD cOO H2 8W R2F 9K H1?I??GM KA gI/mldL DwF?i iccF??NF tF F/F/V NGs VPXYVVF50Y PM wcff EhF 9G m3WC CR RA gI 1NN DLE D0D TDTDdt fd gd nn dTE0g NVU B6 4B WwM3WC 9_ EP I?V I JA i?J RG gI7tl_G gOwO HAA r?f hH fu?s9 9iY Xe2 L9 RA TI 7A p0p 0SL j?cY vv91 m3WC EhF J??CR RA gI X9 fu?s9 9iY Xe2 qr A J7J7J TAR ROO BE A 2DF 8H_Br K:T7 9kY 1D A01G LK7 I A A AGJ Z2 9JPO CzMd??UR??iMe v?i_?eB EF J??oqÏR ܐF G6 xy K/Cu bhe Xh?t 0CM B9 R2TG DI PD D7 0E H2 C0 I A WtJe RY X?r?זQL?х6o3 5cL.T??TR?eI 0E 9BI 1B BA GDD 1D QfAz C?eN 8V t??DM HL VN hZ H6 7I X9 a A
41,269 characters