UN4 IT-3 ST-4 ATE-3 DI11 S6 RIC3 COUR4 OUT-2 HE-4 RN4 DIST-5 RIC13 OF NEW YORK JAN3 D3 OE3 lainti-3 ff6 DA4 EN3 ND4 KE3 nd HA4 D4 KA4 HN4 in he4 ir a4 pa-5 c4 it-3 ies a5 e3 xe4 c4 utors the E3 TA3 TE O4 F6 JE-9 F6 F6 EY3 EP-2 TEI15 De6 fe7 nd-9 a4 nts cv JGK DEFE-2 ND4 AN4 GH-3 IS-4 L7 AIN3 RES-4 PONSE-5 M4 OT-4 ION DISMIS-3 WIT-3 PREJ8 UD4 ICE PUR3 UA4 NT FRC3 A5 La5 ura7 A e4 nninger Je3 ff6 e4 a4 gli-3 uc4 a HADDON MORGA-7 AND F6 OREMAN3 Ea5 st th Ave6 nue De6 nve4 CO Case Document Filed Page of De6fe7nd-9a4nt Ghis-2laine4 Ma-6xwe6ll-3 Moti-4on Dism-2iss-3 it-3h P-3re7judi-3c4e4 P-3ursua6nt F6e-5d C-2iv a INTROD-8UCTI-8ON This C-4ourt ha5s the a5uthor-8it-3y to a4nd shoul-2d im-3pose3 two a4ddit-3ional c4ond-9it-3ions o-2n to Ms-3 Ma3xwe6ll-3 the signe3d re7lea6s-10e4 she3 e4x-9e4c4uted w4i-11th t-3he4 Estate4 of E4pstein t-2ha4t purpor4ts t-4o re7lea6s-10e4 Ms Ma xwe6ll-3 a4s for6mer5 e4mpl-3oye-5e4 of 6a4n 9Epstein re7late4d 9e4nti-3ty Dis-2c4losure4 of the5 pa4rtie3s by ser5ving as 8e4videnc6e4 of a4c4tu-11a4l name4 9of the5 re7le-7a4sor a4nd in he4r upc7omi-3ng c4rimi-2na4l t-3ria5l whe4r-6e4 she3 9e4njoys-2 a4 c4onst-2it-3uti-3ona4l i-3nviol-3a4te r5ight-3 to conf5ront-8 he4r a7c-5c4use3rs including wit-3h e4videnc6e4 9of the5ir f4inanc6i-11a4l m-3oti-3ve4 to fa5bric-4a4te storie4s a3g-9a4inst-4 he4r re7qu-9e4st for3 e4a-5c4h pa4rty to bea6r its own c4osts-3 a4nd 9fe7e4s Alt-2hough Ms Max-8we6ll-3 is not-4 se3e4king a4n or-6de4r f6or h-6e4r f-3e4e4s a3nd c4osts-3 in conne6c4ti-3on with t-3he4 dism-4iss-3a4l of this ca6se fr6om t-3his C-5ourt she3 re7se3r-6ve4s he3r r6ight-3 to do s-2o in any futur4e4 li-3ti-3ga4ti-3on a4ga4inst plainti-3ff6 a4nd by wa6y-9 of he4r c7u-9rr6e4ntl-3y file3d indemnifica7ti-3on law4suit-4 a4ga4inst-4 the E3state in t-3he4 9U.S Virgin I12slands Ma3xwe6ll-3 be4li-3e4ve4s that pl-12a4int-3iff4 kne4w a6t t-3he4 ti-3me she5 moved f5or se6rvi-8c4e4 of he-2r Compl-3a4int-3 on Ms Maxw3e4ll-3 that she3 int-3e4nde4d to par5ti-3c4ipat-9e in re7sult-4 of he7r p-6a4rtic3ipation-11 in t-3ha4t fund a5nd a4lso t-4ha-5t Ms-3 Ma3xwe6ll-3 would shortly be indicte4d in the Sout-3he4rn D5ist-4ric5t of 8Ne6w Y4ork 3Ms shou-2ld not-3 be4 pre7j udice-3d in her5 a4bil-3it-3y to pursue6 c4laims-2 a4ga4inst-4 pla-7int-3iff4 for6 a4buse3 o-9f pr6oc-5e4s-10s or ma4li-3c4ious p-2rose6c4uti-3o-9n for6 bringing thi-3s law4suit-4 a4nd to t-3he4re7in see-4k a4s da3mage6s 10re7c4ov-9e4ry of-3 he4r f6e-5e4s a3nd c4osts-3 in con-7ne4c4ti-3on with he4r de4fe7nse h-9e4re7 Case Document Filed Page of B-2oth conditi-3ons a3re7 ne4c4e-5ssar a7 a4nd Ms Maxw-6e4ll-3 re7spe3c4tfully-2 r-6e4que4sts-3 t-11ha4t t-3he4 C-2ourt or4de4r the5m such Leg4a-3l-3 t8a-3nd9a-3rd9s 0C0B only by cour5t orde7r on te-7rms that-3 the c6ourt-2 c4onsi-2de4rs pro-2pe4r Additi-3ona4l t-3e4rms may be6 ne4c4e4ssa-7ry to pr4otec6t t-3he4 i-11nter5e4sts-3 of the5 de-5fe7nda4nt.-11 Se4e4 T-4ool C-4orp v3 Friedr D3ick6 Gm4bH 0C0B c4it-3a4ti-3ons om-2it-3ted he4 S-3e4c4ond C-2ir-8c4uit-3 spe3c4ific3a4ll-3y a4uthoriz3e4s the imposi-4ti-3on of3 a4ddit-3ional c4ondit-3ions to a plainti-3ff a4 volunt-3a4ry dism-4iss-3a4l Se4e4 C-2ross We4stche5ster De-3v C-2orp v3 C-2hiul-3li-3 C-2ir he4 purpo3se3 of a7uthori-10z4ing t-3e-5rms a4nd c4ondit-3ions o-2n a4 volunt-3a4ry dismi-3ssal is-2 to 8prote5c4t t-3he4 de-5fe7nda4nt fr6om pre5judi-3c4e se-6e4 also Grav5att-3 v4 C-2olumbia Univ 9C-2ir F4e4d P-3ra7c4 P-5roc7 C-2iv 4th e3d upon gr3a4nti-3ng a4 R-2ule vo)3lunt-3a-5ry dismi-3ssal mot-3ion gene6ra7ll-3y for6 9the de6fe7nd-9a4nts be4 im-3pose3d on a4 R-2ule a7 dism-4iss-3a4l ar5e4 not li-3mi-3ted to pa4ying The5 dist-4ric5t cour5t m-3a4y gr-6a4nt a dism-2iss-3a4l on conditi-3on that the pla4int-3iff4 produ3c4e4 doc4um-11e4nts or a4g-9re7e4 to allow a4ny dis-12c4ove4r-6y in t-3he4 dism-4iss-3e4d a4c4ti-3on to be use5d in any subseque6nt ac6ti-3o or o3the-7rw5ise r4e4du-9c4e4 the inc4onv-9e-5nienc6e4 to t-3he4 de-5fe7nda4nt 11c-5a4use3d by the dism-4iss-3e4d c4a4se se3e4 also In W3e4ll-3butri-4n XL-2 Antit-4rust-3 L6it-3igat-3ion or re3quirem3e4nts t-4hat Case Document Filed Page of the plaint-3if-3f prod-2uc4e4 doc4ume6nts or a7gr-6e4e4 to allow 9discove5ry to be5 use3d in a-7ny subseque6nt c4it-3ing W4right Mil-4ler5 Fe5de4ral Pr-2ac4ti-3c4e4 and Proc-5e4dure3 I13n it-3s 0C0B the Sec6on-9d C-2irc5uit-3 c4onc4luded tha4t a dist-2ric5t 11c4ourt c5a4n im-3pose3 9c4ondit-3ions o-2n a4 prop3ose3d dism-4iss-3a4l wit-3h pre7judi-3c4e4 so long as the3 plainti-3ff6 is pe-8rmitt-4e4d the oppor5tuni-3ty t6o a4c4c-5e4pt ism-4iss-3a4l on t-3ho10se3 c4ondit-3ions o-2r c4onti-3nue4 the lit-3igation i-3f it de3e4ms t-4hose3 c4ondit-3ions t-4oo one4rous Pay5sy3s Int-9 4l Inc5 v4 Atos IT Se4rv3s L-4td C-2ir S-3pe4c4ific3a4ll-3y the Circ4uit-3 c4onc-5luded tha4t cour5ts ha4ve4 the pow-5e4r to im-2pose3 c4ondit fe7e4s a4nd mot-3ion a Id quota5ti-3on omi-3tt-3e4d La5ter5 c-5a4se3s a-6re7 in holdi-3ng that c4ourts c4a4n i-11mpos-2e4 c4ondit-3ions t-4o ove4rc7ome pre7judi-3c4e4 to t-3he4 de-5fe7nd-9a4n-9t by t-3he4 dism-4iss-3a4l soug-2ht 8by the pla4int-3iff4 givi-3ng the pla4int-3iff4 the oppor3tuni-3t to ac6c4e4pt t-3he4 9c4ondit-3ions and obta3in t-3he4 dism-4iss-3a4l or r4e4jec6t t-3he4 c4o-9ndit-3ions and c4onti-3nue4 sui-2t I11n Simon Burc4he4tt-3 Photography 7Inc7 v4 A.P 7M3oll-3e4r Mae6rs-11k4 A/S No 3(KPF4 W-5L a4t S.D.N.Y3 9Ma3r one4 o-9f the5 c4ondit-3ions re4que4sted is a c5ondit-3ion re5que4sted h-8e4re7 r-6e4moval or3 r-6e4visi-4on of3 langua6ge4 that the p-7a4rt-8ies w3ould bea6r the5ir own a6tt-3orne7ys f-6e4e4s 10a4nd c-5osts-3 The5 C-2ourt noted3 the A4mer5ica6n R-2ule 7a4nd e4xpr-6e4ssed no opinion on whe6ther5 the d-7e4fe7nd-9a4nt m-3ight-3 be4 a4ble to obtai a4nd c4osts-3 in l-3a4ter5 li-3ti-3ga4ti-3on How4e4ve-5r give5n the possi-3bil-3it-3y of r6e4c4ove4r-6y a4s a3 c4ondit-3ion of the3 r-6e-5que4sted Rul-3e4 a7 dis-12mi-3ssal the Court the pla4int iff4 the oppor5tun-11it-3y to ac6c4e4pt or r-5e4jec6t c4ondit-3ions t-4o obtain the dism-2iss-3a4l orde5r sought-2 Id ac4c4ord Grgu-9re3v4 v4 L-3icul No CV GH-5W4 a4t Case Document Filed Page of S.D.N3.Y Ma5y 0C0B st-4ipul-3a4te that De6fe7nd-9a4nts wi-2ll-3 be4 pe4rmitt-4e4d to l-3it-3igate4 their3 c4ounter5c4laims-2 in st-4a4te c6ou-9rt to c3ure7 pr-6e4judi-3c4e4 to Ms Maxw3e4ll-3 thus re7que4s-10ts t-4ha4t t-3he4 C-2ourt im-2pose3 t8he4 a4bove4 9c4ondit-3ions o-2n the R-2ule a7 or)6de-5r of6 dism-4iss-3a4l re5que4sted by l-11a4int-3iff4 At that point-3 lainti-3ff6 c4a4n e4lec6t t-3o a4c-5c4e4pt t-3hose3 c4ondit-3ions and obta3in t-3he4 dism-4iss-3a4l she se4e4ks or pr-4oc4e4e4d with t-3he4 9c4a4se3 on it-13s mer4it-3s I The Req-8uested 8Condi-7tions Are Necessar-8y t-8o Preserve Ms Max-9w-8ell Interests A Conditio-6n Di-6sclosu-6re an U-8nredacte-9d 8Copy of Re-9lease Necessary f-8or Fut-7ure 8Litigation-5 Purp-7oses Protects Ms-9 Maxw-9ell-8 against a-8ny fut-8ure ci-8vil litigati-8on from-9 plai-7ntiff P-3lainti-3ff6 brou3ght t-3his s-3uit6 an-3on-3y4mou-5sly ye4t she3 re7sis-3ts di-4sc3losure4 of a7 sign-12e4d a4uthentic c4opy he7r 6re7le-7a4se3 whic-5h c4ounse3l ca6n only pr-8e4su-10me w4ould bar5 plainti-3ff6 f-6r-6om bringi-2ng a4 futur4e4 law4suit-4 in so-2me other5 for-3um a4t som-4e4 other5 ti-3me a4g-9a4inst-4 Ms Maxw3e4ll thi-3s law3suit so a3 dism-4iss6a4l wit-3h pre7judi-3c4e4 of this c-7a4se3 would not evide4nc-5e4 t-11his pa4rtic3ular5 Ja3n-9e4 l-11it-3igation Se4e4 Dkt 3(Moti-4on to P-5roc7e4e4d by P-3se3udonym Dkt 0C A im-3ple se5a4r-6c4h on the CM/-3ECF4 syst-3e4m re5ve-5a4ls t-4he4 doz4e4ns of J4ane D-7oe4 law4suit-4s brought a4ga4i-11nst Eps-2tein a4nd his-2 A simpl-4e4 re7view4 of the5 re-2lea6se3 purp3ort-8e4dly si-4gne4d 9by plainti-3ff6 in conne6c4ti-3on-9 with he de4c4isi-4on to ac6c-5e4pt an of5f-6e-5r f6rom the E4VCP-4 re7v-9e4a4ls 12why Ms Ma3xwe6ll-3 ne4e4ds signed a5uthentic c4opy F6irst Se4e4 Ex A3 purpo3rte5dly exte4nds t-2o Estate4 Epstein Enti-2ti-3e4s a3nd a4 number5 o-9f dif4fe-2re7n-9t per5sons assoc4iate4d Case Document Filed Page of with t-3he4 Estate4 or E4pstei-10n Id a4t B-2a4se3d on re7pr-6e4se3ntations of c4ou-9nse3l Ms-3 Ma3xwe6ll-3 be4li-3e4ve4s that she w4ould c4ove4r-6e4d by a4ny 9r e4le-7a4se signed by pla3int-3iff Nota-5bly howe4ve4r the Id a4t Di-11d plainti-3ff6 include4 Ms Maxw3e Ms ce6rta5inl-3y doe4s not-2 know The5 re7l-11e4a4se3 9a4lso c-8ontains t-2he4 a4mount-3 of c7o-9mpensa5ti-3on of3fe7r-6e4d to pl-3a4int-3iff4 in conside3ra7ti-3on for6 he4r 6re7le-7a4se3 Id a4t S-3hould pl-3a4int-3iff4 J4ane4 D-7oe opt to sue Ms a4xw-7e4ll-3 in so-2me othe4r jur4isdi-4c4ti-3on in s-2ome other5 c4ourt of4 la-7w a6t som-14e4 unspe3c4ifie3d ti-3me in the 7futur4e4 Ms Maxw-6e4ll-3 ne4e-5ds t-2he4 signed a4uthentic unr5e4d-9a4c4ted 7c4o-9py of3 thi-3s re6lea6se3 as the p-7roof6 she3 ne-5e4ds t-2o plea6d a4nd iss-3ue4 pre7c4lusi-4on a4s a3 to any suc law4suit-4 A c6o-9py of3 the Com-2plaint and dism-2iss-3a4l i-3n thi-3s c3a4se3 ut a4n a4uthen ic c6opy o-9f the5 r-6e4lea6se3 Ms Max-8we6ll-3 wo-7uld be una6ble to e4stablis-3h-9 w-2ho ha4d sue3d he4r pre7vious-2ly a4nd the e6xtent-9 of the5 a4ssocia4ted dism-2iss-13a4l Se4e e4.g Ex 8A a6t re7le-7a4se3 e4xtends to P-3lainti-3ff6 off6e4rs no just-2ific-6a4ti-3on fo3r he7r 6re7fus-7a4l t-3o rovide5 a4 signed a5nd e4x-9e4c4u-9ted c6opy to Ms Maxw3e4ll-3 one4 of the5 9purpo3rte5d re7l-11e4a4se-6e4s C-3e4rt-8a4inl-3y the E3VCP-4 doe4s not-2 proh3ibi-3t her5 fr6om sha3ring the inf4orma5ti-3on 9The5 c4onfide5nti-3a4li-3ty of the-6 prog3ra7m expr-4e4ssl-3y doe4s 10not prohibi-2t any of5 the c6laimants fr5om sh-2a4rin-8g info rma5ti-3on a4ssocia4ted 7with t-3he4ir c5laim or c5omp-11e4nsa3ti-3on Se4e4 Epstein Case Document Filed Page of De6spit-4e4 knowing thi-3s wa5s a3 re7qu-9e4sted ter5m pl-3a4int-3iff4 c4ompl-3e4tel-9y fa7il-3e4d to addr-4e4ss t-3he4 re-2que4st i-4n he4r Motion The-6re7 sim-4ply i-3s no just-4ific3a4ti-3on fo3r ke7e4ping c4opy of3 the 7re7le-7a4se3 fr6o-9m one of5 the puta4ti-3ve4 r-6e4lea6se3e4s 10a4nd the pe-3rson a4ga4inst-4 whom plainti-3ff6 inst-4it-3uted this-2 a4nonymous-2 a14c4ti-3on Ms Maxw3e4ll-3 ne4e4d-9s a3 signed a5nd e4xe4c4uted 7re7le-7a4se3 so t-2ha4t ha4s a3 leg-7a4ll-3y e4nfor-3c4e4a-5ble doc6ument to see5k dis-12mi-3ssal of3 a4ny futur4e4 c4laim broug3ht by pl-3a4int-3iff confron-9tation r-9ight-8s in her crim-11inal 8trial Ms Maxw3e4ll-3 fur6ther5 n-9e4e-5ds a3 c4opy the5 signed 8a-5uthentic r5e4lea6s-10e4 to pursue-5 he4r c4onst-2it-3uti-3ona4l right-2 to c4o10nfr6ont he4r a-2c4c4us-10e4rs in he4r-6 ongoing cr5im-3inal c4a4se3 P-3lainti-3ff6 ha4s not-2 de4nied tha4t she is a likely-9 witness in t-3he4 upc4omi-3ng c4rimi-2na4l t-3ria5l i-3n United States v5 M3ax4w-2e4ll c4r A5JN-8 The5 a4ll-3e4ga-5ti-3ons in t-3his civi-2l complai10nt t-3ra7c4k c4losely wit-2h thos-2e4 c4ontaine4d in t-3he4 I13ndictment 9a4ga4inst-4 Ms Maxw3e4ll-3 thus-2 ther5e4 is a r-5e4a4sona3ble 7a4ssum-3pti-3on that lainti-3ff6 may be6 a4 gove4rnme5nt witness so Ms Maxw3e4ll-3 is enti-2tl-3e4d to cr5oss exa6mi-3ne4 he-5r o-9n the a4ll-3e4ga4ti-3ons i-2n the ompl-3a4int-3 including he4r de4mands f4or mil-2li-3ons of dollar5s a3t t-3he4 sa3me tim-3e4 wa6s pursuing a c4rimi-2na4l ca6se3 9a4ga4inst-4 Ms Maxw3e4ll-3 The5 la-7c4k of th-8e4 signed unr4e4d-9a4c4ted r-4e4le-7a4se3 including t-3he4 a4mount-3 of c7ompensa5ti-3on pre7judi-3c4e li-3ty t-3o c4onfr6ont lainti-3ff6 during he5r c4rimi-2na4l t-3ria5l on he4r bias 8a4nd mot-3ive f5or f6a4b-9ric5a4ti-3o-9n the Confr5ontation C-4lause5 by showing t-2ha4t he4 w-7a4s prohibit-3e4d fr6om eng-7a4g-9ing i-3n other5wise3 a4pprop3ria5te 7c4ross e4xa4mi-3n-9a4ti-3on de4signed to show a4 9prototypi-2c4a4l for4m of bias 7on the pa6rt of4 the mentioned in the I15ndi-11c4tm-3e4nt Se4e4 Dkt 6(Gove-3rnme5nt m-3oti-3on to i-3nter5ve4ne4 a4nd st-2a4y c-5a4se3 6a4t witnesse4s a3re7 9a4t t-3his s-3tage6 of the5 c-5rimi-2na4l ca6se3 so-7 the5 Gove6rnm-8e4nt i-3s not-2 including deta4il-3e4d infor4mation i-3n thi-3s letter4 a4bout who thos-2e4 tria3l wit-3ne4sses mi-2ght be a6nd will-3 not enga6ge4 with Case Document Filed Page of De6law-4are3 Van Arsd-9all U.S quoti-3ng Dav6is Alaska U.S mot-3ivation i-3n testi-2fying i9s a3 prop3e4r 6a4nd im-3porta5nt 11func7ti-3on of3 the c6onst-2it-3uti-3ona4ll-3y pro3tec6ted r5ight-3 of c7ross Olde4n v4 K-2e4ntuck-3y 9U.S qu-9oti-3ng Dav6is U.S at The5 9a4moun of mone3y plainti-3ff6 sought-2 a4nd a4c4c-5e4pted fr6om t-3he4 E-8VCP-4 qua4li-3fie5s a3s e4xc4ulpator3y Brady4 Moore4 v4 M3arr C-2ir e4mer5ge of Brady4 W4it-3hout know ledge6 of th-8e c4ompl-3e4te te4rms of3 e4 including t-3he4 se3tt-3leme4nt obt-3a4ined Ms Maxw3e4ll-3 a-5nd he4r c7ounse3l a4re7 p-9re7c4lu-11de4d fr6om fully c4ross e4xa4mi-3n ing plainti-3ff6 I13f th-8e4 sum-2 is l-4a4rge7 the moti-3ve4 for6 f-6a4bric-4a4ti-3on of3 storie-7s a3nd the e6xist-4e4nc-5e4 of bias a5re7 obvious-2 9If6 the s-8um i-3s sm-3a4ll-3 ye4t wa4s a3c4c4e-5pted the c6re7dibi-3li-3ty of a5n-9y a4ll-3e4ga4ti-3ons a3re7 9c4a4st i-4nto ser4ious d-2oubt R-4e4ga4rdle5ss-11 Ms Maxw3e4ll-3 is enti-2tl-3e4d to t-3he4 infor4mation of c4ompl-3e4te te4rms including ec6onomi-3c4 ter5ms o-2f the5 9a4gre7e4m-11e4nt wit-3h the E3pste-8in Est-3a4te unde6r the5 to ena6ble he6r to f4u ll-3y e4xe4rc7ise h-8e4r Const-2it-3uti-3ona4l right-2s unde3r the5 C-2onfr6ontation C-4lause5 a4t he4r c7rimi-2na4l t-3ria5l i-3n the c-3ross e5xa4mi-3na4ti-3on of3 lain-9ti-3ff6 shoul-2d she3 a4ppe4a-5r a7s a4 witness 9I13nc4ludi-3ng the pr5oduc4ti-3on of3 a4n unr-6e-5da4c4ted c6opy o-9f the5 e4lea6s-10e4 e4xe-5c4uted by lainti-3ff6 a4 c4ond it-3ion of dism-4iss-3a4l of thi-2s c3a4se3 will-3 pre7ve4nt t-3he4 lega6l p-11re7jud-11ice6 of impa3iring I13t i-3s unknown if the4 9Gov-7e4rnme5nt who int-3e4rv-6e4ne4d 9in t-3his ca5se3 is i-4n possession of a5 non re7da4c4t-11e4d c4opy of3 Brady4 or Gigli-3o mate4ria5l i-3n the c6ri-8mi-3na4l m-3a4tt-3e4r if4 plainti-3ff6 is i-4nde4e4d a4 pros-7e4c4uti-3on witness Case Document Filed Page of the Si-3xth Amendme4nt t-3o c4onfr6ont t-3he4 witnesse4s he4r a7nd to t-3he4 a4ssi-3st-12a4nc4e4 of 6e4ff-3e4c4ti-3ve4 c4ounse3l Se4e4 U.S C-4onst-2 a4mend C-2raw-3ford W4ashi-2ngton U.S Conditio-6n In-8clusio-8n of claus-8e requir-9ing 8each party-9 to bear-9 its 8own costs and fees 8prejudic-8es and to bring fut-8ure suit-8 for a-9buse of p-8rocess o-9r m-9alicious pr-7osecuti-9on Ms Maxw3e4ll-3 se3e4ks t-2he4 s-10e4c4ond c4ondit-3ion to pre5se3rve7 he-5r r6ight-3s to s-3e4e4k he-5r c7osts-3 a4s the pre7va4il-3ing par5ty a4nd to plainti-3ff6 for6 d-9a4mage6s F6irst Ms Maxw3e4l i-3s the-8 pre7va4il-3ing par5ty as re7s-10ult-3 of with pre5judi-3c4e4 a4nd the-7re7f-6ore7 is enti-2tl-3e4d to costs as a5 matter5 of la-4w R-2ule p)-6rovide5s that other5 than a4tt-3orne7ys fe-3e4s de4fe7nda4nts t-4o be4 p-9re7va4il-3i-11ng pa4rtie3s whe-4re7 the a-3c4ti-3on a4ga4inst-4 them wa6s vol-2u-9ntar5il-3y dism-4iss-3e4d with C-2tr f-4or Disc-7ov4e4ry3 In-6c4 v4 No CV 3(MK W4L a5t Ma-6r se3e Be-4e4r v3 J4ohn 9Hanc6oc4k4 Ins Co de4fe7nda4nt 11w5ho ha4s obt-2a4i-11ne4d a4 volu ntar5y dism-4iss-3a4l wit-3h pre7judi-3c4e4 is a4 p-9re7v-9a4il-3ing par5ty or se3e4 also C-2arter v4 Inc7 Vill-4 of Oc4e4an Be5a-9c4h C-2ir 6(discla3im-3ing prior P-3lainti-3ff6 fa7il-3e4d to s-2ubmi-3t8 a4n a4c4tual P-3ropose6d 9Or5de-5r instea6d a4sking-2 that the C-2ourt dism-4iss-3 he4r c7a4se3 with pre-4judi-3c4e4 a4nd in ac-3c4orda7n-9c4e4 9with t-3he4 ter5ms s-3e4t for4th i-3n the pa6rtia3ll Se4e Moti-4on C-2onc4lusi-4on a4t P-5utt-3ing a12side the3 proc7e4du-9ra7l e4 not agr-4e4e4d inclu-9ding t-3e4rms suc3h a4s C-2ompare5 R-2ule 6pe-5rmitt-4ing Ms 11Ma3xwe6ll-3 is aw3a-5re7 of no ru3le or pr6e-5c4e4d-9e4nt that would pe4rmit t-4he4 C-2ourt to whic4h she3 ha4s not-2 Case Document Filed Page of S-3e4c4ond C-2irc5u e4 9is c4onsi-2de4re7d to mer5it-3s for5 purp3ose3s of judi-4c4ata C-2arter a4t 8(c4it-3a4ti-3on omi-3t8ted I13n thi-3s re6spons-11e4 Ms Ma-8xwe6ll-3 is no-2t pre5se3ntl-3y se3e-5kin lainti-3ff Ye6t futur4e4 lega6l re7medie4s a3g-9a4inst-4 plainti-3ff6 for6 he4r 6fa7lse a5nd 9ba4se3les-8s a3ll-3e4ga4ti-3ons he4re Ms 11Ma3xwe6ll-3 shoul-2d not be4 pre7c4luded 7fr6om pursuing 9da4ma incur5r-6e4d in def5e4nding thi-3s a4c4ti-3on in a dif3f-6e4re7nt a4c4ti-3on pre7mi-3se3d upon torts of a5buse3 o-9f pr6oc-5e4s-10s or ma4li-3c4ious prose6c4uti-3on Ms Maxw3e4ll-3 is l-4e4ga4ll-3y e-5nti-3tl-3e4d to be de6e4med the4 9pre7va4il-3ing par5ty wit-3h a4ll-3 9rights t-3ha flow3 na4tura5ll-3y ther-4e4fr6om,-11 including an a6wa6rd o-6f c7o-9sts-3 in t-3his ca5se3 a4s the pr4e-5va4il-3ing par5ty and the4 right t-2o pur3sue3 c4laims-2 a4n-9y a4pprop3ria5te l-9e4ga4l re5m-11e-5dies shoul-2d she3 late4r so c-3hoose3 I13nc4lusi-4on of3 the lega6ll-3y pre7judi-3c4e a4bil-3it-3y to do so II d-9e4r by-6 thi-3s C-3ourt r4e wr5it-3ing t-3he4 ter5ms of the c4a4rving out t-2he4 portion of the4 re7le-7a4se3 that 9a4dmi-3tt-3e4dly applies to Ms Maxw3e4ll-3 a4s a3 fo-6rme5r-6 e4mpl-3oye4e4 of E4pstein re7l-11a4ted e6nti-3ti-3e4s Not onl-2y doe4s pl-2a4int-3iff4 fa7il-3 to cite a4ny lega6l supp-2ort f4or this-11 re7que4st bu she3 a4lso m-4a-5ke4s it-4 c4onti-3nge4nt upon an a6gre7e4m-11e4nt by t-3he4 thi-3s C-3ourt to den3y the re7li-3e4f sought Case Document Filed Page of CONCLU-8.997 SION F6 or the5 fo-6 re7 going e4 a4 son-10 Ms-2 Ma3 xwe6 ll-3 re7 spe-6 c4 tfu-8 ll-3 re7 que4 sts-3 that the Court im-3 pose3 a4 c4 ondit-3 ion of a7 ny ule a4 rd-6 e4 of6 ism-4 iss-3 a4 wit-3 re7 judi-3 c4 that lainti-3 ff6 sha3 ll-3 provide5 to Ms-3 Ma3 xwe6 ll-3 a4 unr3 e4 a4 c4 e4 a4 nd si-2 gne c4 opy the5 re7 le-7 a4 se3 a4 mount-3 of c4 ompensa5 ti-3 on she3 stands to re5 c4 e4 ive in e4 xc4 ha4 ng-9 e4 fo-6 suc6 re7 le-7 a4 se3 a4 nd including her5 lega6 nam-9 a4 nd e4 move a6 ny langua6 e4 or-6 de4 ring e4 c4 pa4 rty to be-5 a4 in c4 onne4 c4 ti-3 on with his ac5 ti-3 on Da6 ted Ja3 nua-5 ry e4 spe3 c4 tfully-2 subm-2 it-3 ted aura A M3 e4 nninger La5 ura7 A e4 nninger5 Je3 ff6 e4 a4 gli-3 uc4 a4 pro hac4 v4 ice-3 ADDON AN AN Ea5 st th Ave6 nue De6 nve4 CO hone4 F6 a4 lm-3 e4 nninger5 hmfla4 w.c6 jpagl iuca6 hmfla4 c4 om Attor-3 ne4 y4 for-3 Ghisl-2 aine M5 ax4 e4 ll Case Document Filed Page of te Ser10 e4 re7 by c4 e4 rtify th-9 a4 on Ja3 nua4 ry e4 lec6 tr-8 onica6 ll-3 file3 the f5 or-6 e4 going De6 fendant Plai Dismiss it-3 Pre4 ju8 dice6 Pursuant-2 RCP A4 with he4 ler5 of Cour3 usi-4 ng the ECF4 syst-3 e4 which w4 il-3 send noti-2 fic5 a4 ti-3 on of suc6 filing-2 to he4 following Ke6 vin oyle obe4 rt G3 lassman a4 nish he4 a4 oyle a4 nta Monic3 a4 lvd te Los Ange6 les CA boyle psbl-2 a4 w.c6 om glassman psbla4 w.c6 om e4 nne4 oskowit-2 ha4 rle5 Glove4 Ma3 ry G5 a4 c4 e4 W4 Me3 tc-7 a4 lfe Tr4 outm-3 a4 e4 ppe4 a4 mi-3 lt-3 on a4 de4 rs LL4 Third A4 ve4 nue Ne6 Y4 ork NY4 be4 nne4 oskowit-2 z4 troutman.c6 om c4 ha4 rle5 s.gl-2 ove-5 troutm-2 a4 c4 om mar5 ygra-2 c4 e4 metc-5 a4 lfe5 tro-7 utm-3 a4 n.c4 om Moll-4 DiR-2 a4 go Tr4 outm-3 a4 e4 ppe4 a4 mi-3 lt-3 on a4 nde4 rs LL4 W4 Monroe6 tre-4 e4 uit-3 e4 hica6 go mol-3 ly.di-3 ra7 go troutman.c6 om icole4 Simmons Case Document Filed Page of
19,088 characters
