U3 N3 I4 TED4 TAT3 ES-3 I4 TR-2 I4 CT COU4 O3 U3 THER-3 N3 DI4 I4 CT O3 NEW YO4 U3 N3 I4 TED4 TAT3 ES-3 AM I4 CA-2 PR-5 O3 PER-6 TY4 ELE10 AS-3 O3 D3 ER Cr-2 AT agai3 st TO VA N3 O3 EL e4 a p4 on the etter p4 p4 i5 c4 ti-5 on of J6 son4 Es5 ttorn3 ey for7 the d4 efen4 d4 nt OVA OEL for7 r4 d4 er-5 ma-4 nd5 ti-5 ng the r4 el-4 ea-3 se of the fir-7 ea r4 nd5 other14 p4 r4 op4 r4 ty-3 su4 r4 r4 en-8 d4 er4 the ew Y4 or4 i ty-3 ol-4 c4 De p4 r4 tment c4 ond5 ti-5 on c4 to the def5 end5 nt I4 I4 HER-5 EB-2 O3 D3 ER-5 ED th the ew Y4 or4 Ci-2 ty-3 ol-4 c4 Department sh4 mm ed4 i5 tel4 r4 etur4 the firearm d4 othe r4 p4 r4 op4 r4 ty-3 su4 r4 r4 nd5 er4 d4 c4 ond5 ti-5 on of i5 th10 a ov-2 ref5 er4 enc5 ed4 c4 r4 mi-5 na-2 c4 ti-5 on Da-5 ted3 nu12 r4 ew Y4 or4 ew Y4 or4 Case Document Filed Page of USDC SDNY DOC EN ECTRO NI CA LY FI LED DOC ii DATE I ILED ANALISA TORRES Uni ted States District Judge