039 01

PDF Document Uploaded Feb 1, 2026 by Unknown Updated by admin 1 views 249.27 KB
Court Records as described by folder names.
Epstein Release Interview Victim Statements Evidence Maxwell
← Back to Davies v. Indyke, No. 1;19-cv-10788 (S.D.N.Y. 2019)
Extracted Text

IT A IS RICT CO RT RN IS RICT RK A RY a i nt i a nd RICH A RD A as ut or of he at of ps i a nd A RA ICK RS nda nt Ci A IN IO RD A A A i ri udge bri ngs ort a i unde ork a a ga i ns i nt al i a a rre Indyke a nd Ri ha rd a hn he xe ut ors of he a of re ps i Indyke a nd a hn or he xe ut or de nda nt he xe ut or de nda nt now ove ork a uc da a ge a re a gori a una va i a bl i a pe rs ona i nj ury a i on a ga i ns he pe rs ona re pre nt a i ve of a a or he re a ons ha ol ow he Court gra nt ha ot i on I Bac gr ou A oe omp ai ps yc hol ogi a a bus a ps i n?s ha nds duri ng a nd um a ry a ount i de a i a ount It a ge ha oe a he ni a oe ha be gra nt a ve proc ps udonym ous kt oe a ue a ra i ke rs ho i a ge ha ve rve a ps i n?s he dul a nd a i a nt Se kt oe bi or puni i ve da a ge a ga i ns i ke rs i not i pl i a by hi ot i on Case Document Filed Page of Case Document Filed Page of pa re nt a a young re uge rom a a orn ount ry a nd a orki ng i purs ui of a prom i i ng car a a ode he i a a ge he ps i hrough a not he ode Id ps i a de a oe how i port a nt a nd pow rf ul he a a nd prom i he he i he ode i ng a re a nd ol ge a dm i i ons I oe i urn be i ve he oul rus hi a nd ha he oul ha nge he i Id ps i how ve us hi pow ove a ry xua a bus he vi i ous a nd re pe a dl Id A i de by de nda nt a ra i ke rs ps i n?s he dul a nd a i a nt ps i oul um on a ry hi a nha a ow nhous orde he gi ve hi a a ge a nd he ubj he xua a he ve ri of hi i nc re a ove i Id al i he Com pl a i nt gra phi a hroni ps i n?s a of xua a bus i he ow nhous hi i nc ude orc i ng oe pe rf orm ora on hi a nd a ra pi ng he Id In a he Com pl a i nt a ge oe a a re ul of a i nc i de nt a he ow nhous udde nl a he rut he a not ve a hum a be i ng ps i he a a obj a nd ps i a re a i ng he a a pros i ut one of a ny gi rl he re a a xua obj Id oe ha a bre a kdow a os i di a he re a ork Ci re urne he pa re nt hom a ros he ount ry a nd ne ve a ps i a ga i Id ps i n?s a bus a us Doe to abandon her modeling career and left her humiliated angry and suicidal with debilitating pa ni a a ks a nd dra a i ps yc hol ogi a a rs Id ps i n?s a rre i ul ga ve oe bri hope ha he i ght i na a ons que nc but hi de a i A ugus a a de ra a i i a nha a a ry i he de ol a ns ha he ha va de us i ye a ga i Id In hi a i on oe bri ngs a i unde ork a of ba ry i a a ul i a nd he i nt nt i ona i nf i i on of ot i ona di re i a ga i ns Indyke Case Document Filed Page of Case Document Filed Page of a nd a hn ol i he i a pa i i a xe ut ors of ps i n?s a i a nd a ga i ns i ke rs or he i nt gra rol i ope ra i ng ps i n?s ope ra i on of ra i ki ng a ry a nd ot he gi rl i A i ba i or pe rs ona uri di i on ove he xe ut ors i a ge ha ps i a ubj pe rs ona uri di i on a he i of hi de a i be a us he ort i ous a gi vi ng ri a i nt i a i ook pl a i ork a i he Com pl a i nt ks i a ddi i on om pe ns a ory da a ge a nd a orne ys a nd os puni i ve da a ge i a a ount be de rm i ne a ri a Id Th Ex tor ar ti al oti on to i mi a a ry he xe ut or de nda nt i a pa rt i a ot i on di i kt a nd a upport i ng ora ndum of a kt ef It ought di i a of he pra ye or puni i ve da a ge on he ground ha uc da a ge a nnot a a a of ork a be ought a ga i ns he pe rs ona re pre nt a i ve of a a a rc oe i a ora ndum of a i oppos i i on kt oe pp a nd a upport i ng de a ra i on by a ni ul kof kt ul kof hi a a he ps i n?s i a rc he xe ut or de nda nt i a re pl kt ef Re ly II A i ab Le gal tan ar urvi ve a ot i on di i unde Rul a om pl a i nt us pl a nough a a a a i re i ha i pl a us i bl on i a A Cor wom bl A a i i onl ha ve a i a pl a us i bi i he he pl a i nt i pl a ds a ua ont nt ha a ow he ourt dra he re a ona bl i nf re nc ha he de nda nt i i a bl or he i onduc a ge A hc of Iqbal A om pl a i nt i prope rl di i he re a a a of a he a ga i ons i a om pl a i nt how ve rue oul not ra i a a i of nt i nt re i wom bl a he re ol vi ng a ot i on di i he ourt us a pt a rue a pl a ua a ga i ons i he om pl a i nt Case Document Filed Page of Case Document Filed Page of a nd dra a re a ona bl i nf re nc i he pl a i nt i a vor St gi ns a Inc 3d 2d Ci ha ne how ve i i na ppl i a bl ga onc us i ons Iqbal a a di ngs ha of onl a be a nd onc us i ons or a orm ul a i re i a i on of he nt of a a us of a i on i not do wom bl a I i i on In ovi ng di i oe pra ye or pu ni i ve da a ge a ga i ns he he xe ut or de nda nt a rgue ha ork a a ppl i hi pe rs ona i nj ury a i on a nd a gori a prohi bi a a a rd of puni i ve da a ge a ga i ns he pe rs ona re pre nt a i ve of a a pe i i a he not a of ork?s a ow rs a nd rus a provi de a us of a i on or i nj ury pe rs on or prope rt i os be a us of he de a of he pe rs on i a bl or he i nj ury or a ny i nj ury a a i on a be brought or ont i nue a ga i ns he pe rs ona re pre nt a i ve of he de de nt but puni i dam age hal not be awar de nor pe nal i adj udge i any uc ac i on br ought ov dam age or pe onal i nj ur a pha i a dde A ppl yi ng hi a ut ourt ha ve he puni i ve da a ge una va i a bl i pe rs ona i nj ury a i ons a ga i ns xe ut ors or a dm i ni ra ors of a he i nc ude de ra ourt de rm i ni ng he da a ge a va i a bl or ons i ut i ona ort a i unde ork a aham nde on R.D pre udi ng ba on a puni i ve da a ge a i i a i on a ga i ns a a dm i ni ra ors a nd not i ng ha York law is very clear on this point Blissett Eisensmidt Supp N.D N.Y ove rt urni ng ba on a ury?s puni i ve da a ge a a rd i a a ga i ns a a nd not i ng rong pol i a ga i ns he a nt of puni i ve da a ge a ga i ns a a on a ount of rongf ul onduc of he de de nt a a ourt i pe rs ona i nj ury a i ons gove rne by ork a or don Nat han 2d Case Document Filed Page of Case Document Filed Page of 1st Dep af irming dismissal of punitive damages claim because under EPTL a def endant?s death precluded recovery of punitive damages rom personal representatives of a cf aum i nbaum 2d th Dep af irming denial of punitive damages in case against deceased executor cit ing EPTL a a nd he rong pol i a ga i ns he a nt of puni i ve da a ge a ga i ns a a on a ount of he rongf ul onduc of he de de nt he a of a a ori of a i i a ord i a a re i he Restatement Se cond of Torts See Restat ement Second of Torts cmt a Punitive da a ge a re not a a rde a ga i ns he re pre nt a i ve of a de a ort a or al oe pp a a know dgi ng ha a a ori of a do not pe rm i puni i ve a a ge a ga i ns a hi a ori rul a i gns i he ge ne ra rul unde de ra om on a ha a action survives the death of a party insof ar as it is remedial and not penal in nature See e.g i i al Com of ns ur Cr di or of ol di ngs al an Ci A WL a A ug ol i ng a por and om ndat i on adopt WL pt he us i i a i on om nl gi ve or pre udi ng puni i ve da a ge a a rds a ga i ns a i ha puni hm nt a nd de rre nc he re ogni ba or i pos i ng puni i ve da a ge on a ort a or a re not a dva nc by i pos i ng puni i ve da a ge on hi or he a A he xi upr Court xpl a i ne i a dopt i ng he a ori rul uni hm nt a nd de rre nc a re not a om pl i he by na bl i ng re ove ry of puni i ve da a ge rom he a of de a ort a ors he ort a or a nnot be puni he or hi ul pa bl be ha vi or pu ni i ve da a ge no onge ha ve he de i re a nd he re ore he vi i os he ga nt i nt Case Document Filed Page of Case Document Filed Page of re ove hos da a ge ar am i ov i de nc Was Ins Co 2d a nva i ng a of ot he a oe doe not di put ha EPTL a pre ude puni i ve da a ge i a pe rs ona i nj ury a i on unde ork a Ins a oe a ke hre a rgum nt ha de nda nt ot i on i pre a ure oe a ha de nda nt ot i on i i prope rl yl a a ot i on di i i at a nd ha he a of he ni a i rgi Is a nds I not ork a a ppl i a nd pe rm i puni i ve da a ge a ga i ns a a i a oe i rs a rgum nt i qui kl di pa he oe i a he re ourt ha ve de i ne re ol ve ot i ons di i a i a pra ye rs or re i i ndi ng uc ot i ons pre a ure Se i at i a i ons om i But a re vi of he a re ha he ot i ons i hos a re not ba on a gori a pre us i ons of puni i ve da a ge In ont ra he re puni i ve da a ge ha ve be una va i a bl a a a of a ourt ha ve not he i a di i pra ye rs or uc damages at the threshold See e.g Murtha N.Y State Gaming Comm?n No Civ WL a pt di i i ng de a nd or puni i ve da a ge unde he ork a um a Ri ght a RL be a us i doe ot provi de or puni i ve da a ge os N.Y of duc Ci A WL a A ug gra nt i ng ot i on di i de a nd or puni i ve da a ge unde he A ge i ri i na i on i pl oym nt A a nd he ork Ci um a Ri ght a CH RL he re ne i he a ut pe rm i a pl a i nt i re ove puni i ve damages Talarico Port Auth of N.Y N.J Supp 3d S.D.N.Y di i i ng de a nd or puni i ve da a ge a ga i ns ort A ut hori he re he hi rd Ci rc ui a nd he ove rw he i ng a ori of di ri ourt i hi hi Ci rc ui ha ve he ha puni i ve da a ge a re not a va i a bl a ga i ns ha de nda nt i nt rna quot a i on a rks a nd i a i on om i Cane Case Document Filed Page of Case Document Filed Page of Me ans A ut Ci A WL a pt di i i ng de a nd or puni i ve da a ge he re uc re i was pre ude a a a of a om an Cat hol i Diocese of Rockville Ctr Gen Reins Corp No Civ CM WL a pt In hi a he i rc um a nc urroundi ng he de ni a of he i ns ura nc i nde ni i a i on a i do not a rra nt he ra re xc pt i on provi de or puni i ve da a ge unde a bre a of ont ra a i or hi re a on the Court rants Def endant?s motion to dismiss the punitive damages claim SJB ex rel Berkhout N.Y p?t of duc Ci RB WL a ul di i i ng puni i ve da a ge a i be a us uc da a ge a re una va i a bl i a i ons a ga i ns uni i pa i i rovi de ha ork a a ppl i hi a i on hi a oo i nvol ve a a gori a pre us i on of uc da a ge unde a ha a be a dj udi a a he hre hol oe ond a rgum nt i ha he de nda nt xe ut ors ha nge i i prope rl brought a a ot i on di i oe a he re i di vi de a a ut hori on hi poi nt Court i nc udi ng i he a i a bove ha ve gra nt ot i ons di i pra ye rs or uc re i But ot he rs ha ve de i ne nt rt a i uc ot i ons a i ng ha a us puni i ve da a ge a re a orm of da a ge not a i nde pe nde nt a us of a i on a ot i on di i a pra ye or re i i he orm of puni i ve da a ge i proc dura pre a ur ar i na Me ans A ut upp 3d quot i ng unt al i ade A qui i i on I LLC Ci WL a ov al Wi de an Spar ne gy Inc Ci WL a S.D.N.Y Apr Jones City of New York No Civ VSB WL a A pr ange oadway Ci Case Document Filed Page of Case Document Filed Page of WL a ov al i ade Col i on upp 2d he Court ha no oc a i on re ol ve hi onc pt ua de ba be a us he xe ut ors ot i on di i unde Rul a rna i ve a be re a a a ot i on ri ke unde de ra Rul of Ci vi roc dure Se ri ght A i 5C Fed al ac i and oc dur 3d he hni a na gi ve a ot i on ha ngi ng a pl a di ng i of i i port a nc i na uc a pre udi he nonm ovi ng pa rt ha rdl a re ul rom re a i ng a ot i on ha ha be i na ura de nom i na a ot i on ri ke a a ot i on di i he om pl a i nt A nd unde Rul on a ot i on or ua pont a ourt a ri ke rom a pl a di ng a i ns uf i i nt de ns or a ny re dunda nt i a ri a i pe rt i ne nt or a nda ous a Ci A hough ot i ons ri ke unde Rul a re ge ne ra di a vore a nd gra nt onl i he re i a rong re a on do A nde on Ne ws A Me di a Inc Ci PAC WL a A pr i nt rna quot a i on a rks om i i i ng oe Ci of or upp 2d al i ps Com onwe al ni Cor 2d 2d Ci a pl a ut hori pe rm i ri ki ng pra ye rs or puni i ve da a ge he re uc re i i una va i a bl a a a of a Se In Me i nc A uc i on at Se i i up 2d gra nt i ng ot i on ri ke i ons of om pl a i nt a rt i ng puni i ve da a ge be a us pl a di ngs di not hi gh ba or puni i ve da a ge i non fr a a se a fi i a aff?d sub nom La Pac Corp Merrill Lynch Co A pp?x 2d Ci Ce i a Mode S.A de C.V SP A A or i Ci WL a A pr gra nt i ng ot i on ri ke pra ye or puni i ve da a ge or a i ure a ge ve of hi gh ora ul pa bi i Case Document Filed Page of Case Document Filed Page of ne a ry us a i puni i ve da a ge a a rd i a i nvol vi ng ra ud a nd de i ade nbur hal ann Co Im agi ng i agnos i Sy Inc upp 2d S.D.N.Y granting motion to strike punitive dama ges because complaint did not allege i nt al i a gre gi ous conduct suf icient to sustain such an award Brady Port Auth of N.Y N.J No Civ NG CLP WL at E.D.N.Y Oct gra nt i ng ot i on ri ke punitive damages claims on grounds that Port Authority was immune rom such damages Nash Coram Healthcare Corp No Civ LMM WL at S.D.N.Y June gra nt i ng ot i on ri ke pra ye or puni i ve da a ge be a us om a i nt di not a ge a uf i i nt upport uc da a ge i bre a of ont ra a re he re i pra i a i dom i re a i ng de nda nt ot i on a one ri ke i doi ng i ne a ry na bl he Court re ol ve a he um he vi a bi i of oe pra ye or puni i ve da a ge i num rous pe rs ona i nj ury a i ons pe ndi ng a ga i ns he ps i a a a re ul of he re nt na nt of he ork Chi i i A he re i va ue i a ri yi ng or he pa rt i a nd ors he da a ge a va i a bl i a i ons he re he a pe rm i a ure a ns on hi poi nt oe i na a rgum nt i ha I not ork a gove rns he he puni i ve da a ge a re a va i a bl Be a us hi Court i i ork it a ppl i a ork hoi of a a na ys i ha que i on Se Kl ax on Co St nt or Mf Co Cas Co Cont Cas Co 3d 2d Ci A de ra ourt i i ng i di ve rs i a ppl i he hoi of a rul of he orum a he re a he re he a i ound i ort ork ourt a ppl a i nt re a na ys i de rm i ne hoi of law i ue ol de Wy Inc Ci WL a A ug nde ha a na ys i puni i ve da a ge a re ons i de re be onduc re gul a i ng Case Document Filed Page of Case Document Filed Page of a nd he a of he uri di i on he re he ort oc urre i ge ne ra a ppl Se St ar Inde i ab Co A Cl ai Mgm Inc Ci WL May quot i ng ui di Int Cont ot Cor Ci A WL at S.D.N.Y Apr Bauta Greyhound Lines Inc No Civ RE WL a a re he ort a ge oc urre nt i re i ork he pe rs ona i nj ury a i hi oe Com pl a i nt bri ngs ar ise rom xua a a ul a nd re a onduc ha a a ge oc urre xc us i ve i hi ork i ty i a nd a round ps i n?s a nha a ow nhous Doe counters by noting that while th is rule applies as a general matter it may be overcome i he re i good re a on not a ppl i oe a i i ng Nat wi oc at i Counc i A de on upp 3d In a rgui ng ha he re i re a on not apply New York law to the punitive damages question here Doe relies on the doctrine of pe age unde hi ourt a re a he hoi of a a na ys i or one or ore i ue i a a i hi i ns a nc he a a i a bi i of puni i ve da a ge a di i nc rom he re of i a na ys i he re he a ppl i a bi i of ork a oe ort a i or om pe ns a ory da a ge Id al awr nc uc hal A as a hi a i i A ur anc Co upp 3d ous i A ge nc A i Inc Ci WL a oe a rgue ha a hough ork a ha ve he gre a i nt re i re ol vi ng i ue re a i ng om pe ns a ory da a ge he I he re he xe ut ors a re dom i i a nd he re ps i n?s i i be proba ha he gre a i nt re a puni i ve da a ge hi unl i ke om pe ns a ory da a ge a re de nda nt oc us oe a oe doe not a rgue ha he xe ut or de nda nt he ve ri puni hm nt or a re i ne of de rre nc Ins a oe Case Document Filed Page of Case Document Filed Page of a rgue ha ps i n?s de i i on a hi i hort be ore hi ui i de provi de ha i oul be proba i he I a ra gi a ot i va he a rgue ha hi xe ut ors houl not be pe rm i i ve a va i he ve of rt a i be ne i of I a but a voi hos a pe of I a ha he do not i ke Id a he Court i unpe rs ua de ha ve be ne i ps i nvi i one or hi a by vi rt ue of proba i ng hi i i he I oe doe not a rt i ul a a ny re va nt hi i i ga i on he ha onc us ori oe doe not a rgue ha he de i i on proba ps i n?s i i he I i ha ve a ny a dve rs be a ri ng on a pe rs on a i nj ury a i on brought a ga i ns he a i ork ha i nvol ve ort i ous onduc i ork oe doe not a rgue or xa pl ha he proba i ng of ps i n?s i i he I a nds i ns ul a hi a rom re ove ry rom uc a pl a i nt i or ot rw i i pe de he or ot he rs vi i i i ork rom re ove ri ng on ri ori ous a i oe poi nt ha he a a pros pe rom be i ng proba i he I i di onne rom he a i ore unda nt a oe doe not a rt i ul a a ny onc re i nt re ha he I ha i i he vi ndi a i ng he ri ght of a vi i xua a bus i a a nha a ow nhous i a nd or pe i a re va nt puni i ve da a ge i a uri ng ha he pe rpe ra or of ha a bus i a de qua puni he a nd de rre In ont ra he ond Ci rc ui ha not he rong i nt re ha ork ha i re pe onduc re gul a i ng rul i nc udi ng re ga rdi ng da a ge i re pe unl a ul be ha vi or i hi i borde rs If onf i i ng onduc re gul a i ng a a re a i ue he a of he uri di i on he re he ort oc urre i ge ne ra a ppl be a us ha uri di i on ha he gre a i nt re i re gul a i ng be ha vi or i hi i borde rs Coone good If a nyt hi ng he proba i ng of he a i he I a a nd be ne i he a re di ors a nd he re by pot nt i a oe he xt nt ha a a proba i he I a a voi he hi gh estate a ra i pos by ork a Case Document Filed Page of Case Document Filed Page of Mac Inc 2d In i i i i bane Can adi an ank SA obs rve ha unde ork a he he uri di i ons of he onduc a nd i nj ury a re di i nc i i he pl a of he a ge dl rongf ul onduc ha ge ne ra ha upe ri or i nt re i prot i ng he re a on a bl xpe a i ons of he pa rt i ho re i on he a of ha pl a gove rn he i pri a ry onduc a nd i he a dm oni ory ha a ppl yi ng i a i ha ve on i i a onduc i he ut ure 3d 2d Ci quot i ng Sc hul oy Sc out of A Inc 2d a ra i ons om i re he a ge dl rongf ul onduc ook pl a i ork he re ore onc ude ha ork?s rul on ra ud da a ge a nd ne gl i ge nt i re pre nt a i on a ppl AH Inv hi MF Ci i gr oup Inc A pp?x 2d Ci ork?s i nt re i a re i nf orc by he a ha oe ui i i onl by vi rt ue of he a re nt na nt of he ork Chi i i A hi pora ri re vi i ba rre ui Se Cm pl ha ork a gove rns he a va i a bi i of puni i ve da a ge i urt he re i nf orc by oe ha vi ng ue he xe ut or de nda nt unde a It i probl a i or he he rrypi i hi ha provi i on i nvoki ng he pa rt ha a ut hori a pe rs ona i nj ury ui a ga i ns a xe ut or hi di a i i ng he ba a nc hi de i i he re ove ry a va i a bl i uc a ui Se i upp a It oul be a a nom a ous i ua i on i nde i pl a i nt i re a ow proc i hi a i on a ga i ns he a of Ca be a us of a hi a he a i he a a ow re ove re i i he orm of puni i ve da a ge hi a rl i be yond he ope of re i hi ha a ut a ut hori uc a re ul i a i nc ons i nt i he doc ri ne of pe a ge he re one orum a i a ppl i re gul a rt a i i ue a ri i ng rom a gi ve ra ns a i on or oc urre nc hi hos of a not he ys re gul a he ot he iss ue Sc hwar wi Ci i Ins Co upp 2d oe a i undi put dl a qua i a pe rs ona i nj ury a i Se Cons a a de i ni ng pe rs ona i nj ury a i nc udi ng a a a ul ba ry a i pri onm nt or ot he a i ona bl i nj ury he pe rs on i he of he pl a i nt i or of a not he oe doe not a rgue ot he rw i Case Document Filed Page of Case Document Filed Page of pha i a dde af ub nom Sc hwar i be Mut Ins Co 3d 2d Ci re oe i i ve dra i ng upon a ks to i nvoke pe a ge a ppl di re nt of a to a i ngl i ue he doc ri ne doe not i nvi uc a re ul i na A de on on hi oe re i i a i i ng ha I a gove rns puni i ve da a ge i i na ppos i A de on ha brought a a rl i a i on i hi i ri or de a a i on i bre a of va da a a ga i ns he a i ona i oc ra i Counc i a nd i ha i oge he A de on upp 3d a ha a i on ha be di i purs ua nt va da a nt i A a ut he ue A de on ki ng puni i ve da a ge unde ha a va da a ut Id A de on?s ot i on di i he puni i ve da a ge pra ye udge ke he ha va da i nt re a ronge ha ork?s a puni i ve da a ge be a us A de on ha brought he i ni i a ui unde va da a a nd be a us i ha be di i unde he va da A a ut on hi he now purs ue puni i ve da a ge He re a one ha a us he i i ga nt ha a pt us va da de a a i on a hi Fi rs A ndm nt ri ght va da ha a orre pondi ng i nt re i puni hi ng he i i ga nt or a i i ous i nvoki ng va da a a nd i de rri ng ut ure i i ga nt rom doi ng he a A de on upp 3d a i i ng Sc hul 2d at ot i ng ha uni i ve da a ge a re de i gne puni he de nda nt not om pe ns a he pl a i nt i udge ke xpl a i ne ha he hoi of a i nqui ry or puni i ve da a ge provi i ons i ne a ri de nda nt oc us i hi a Id i nt rna uot a i on a rks om i i i ng ol de WL a By ont ra udge ke onc ude ha ork?s i nt re i he di put a re a i ve a nua a nd i ve i i he a ha he ui a i i de ra di ri ourt i a nha a he re not a bl he a i re brought unde va da Case Document Filed Page of Case Document Filed Page of de a a i on a A a ork a ks a pa rt i ul a ri i nt re i he i prot i ng de nda nt rom i a bi i unde va da de a a i on a or i ont rol i ng he be ha vi or of i i ga nt ho i i he de ra ourt A nd he re he oc us uri di i on ha a re ort ui ous re a i ons hi i he a ha uri di i on i nt re i he a i i ni a Id at i nt rna quot a i on a rks a nd a ra i ons om i oe a i hi i ri i ont ra A de on doe not bui on a pri or i i ga i on i or ba on he a of he I In a ny ve nt he hoi of a de ba he re a ppe a rs a a de i ha i be a us hi he I doe not ha ve a a ut on poi nt a nd I ourt a ve not qua re re ol ve he i ue i i i ke ha I om on a oul not pe rm i a a a rd of puni i ve da a ge a ga i ns a a In he I upre Court i ns ruc ourt a ppl ha i rm a ank a na ys i de rm i ne I om on a hi nt a i ons i de ra i on of hre non di pos i i ve a ors he he a ny I ourt ha pre vi ous a dopt a pa rt i ul a rul he pos i i on a ke by a a ori of ourt of ot he uri di i ons a nd os i port a nt ly hi rul re pre nt he ounde rul or he I Se ov of i gi Is ands Connor I Mat he an I ank Int nt al as i ng Cor I he pa rt i di a how he a ors a ppl but he xe ut ors a nt i he ore pe rs ua i ve A he i rs ank a or I ourt ha ve re pe a dl i he Re a nt ond of ort a vora bl i a be i i di a he ha ve xpre quot he a ngua ge i om nt a ha ba rs a a a rd of puni i ve da a ge a ga i ns he a of a de de nt ort a or Se am i on ows on ol di ng Co I I uni i ve da a ge a re not a a rde a ga i ns he re pre nt a i ve of a de a ort a or nor ordi na ri i a a i on unde a de a a ut quot i ng Re a nt ond of ort a Case Document Filed Page of Case Document Filed Page of i i ng oy A as Mot or Inn Inc I I i nt rpre i ng he i rgi Is a nd?s rongf ul de a a ue I.C pre ude puni i ve da a ge oot owe Ci CV WL a I a a al Pappas Hotel on the Cay Time Sharing Ass?n V.I V.I Super Ct applying ank a na ys i hol ha I ourt oul a dopt Re a nt ond of ort a nd i i ng i ve I a i a ord owe Chi Co?s i i Inc ST TOR WL a I upe Ct A pr A ppl yi ng a ank a na ys i he Court i nds ha Re a nt ond of ort re he om on a of hi uri di i on ons i de ri ng he ongs a ndi ng a ppl i a i on of he Re a nt ond of ort i hi uri di i on a nd he a ppa re nt i de pre a a ppl i a i on of hi rul i a a ori of uri di i ons he Court i nds ha he Re a nt ond of ort re pre nt he ounde rul or he i rgi Is a nds a nd i i a ord i oc a publ i pol i oe ha not i a ny ont ra ry a ut hori A he ond ank a or he pa rt i a gre ha ons i nt i he Re a nt os uri di i ons do not pe rm i a a a rd of puni i ve da a ge a ga i ns a ort a or?s a Se Cr abt Ke at of Cr abt 2d Ind he maj ority view denies punitive damages fr a a se fe a so st a Jay Zitter Annotation Cl ai or puni i dam age i or ac i on as ur i i ng de at of or as or or pe on wr onge A 4t uni i ve a a ge a a nd ra 2d he pre va i i ng vi a ppe a rs be ha puni i ve da a ge a not be re ove re a ga i ns he a of a de a rongdoe oe not ha om uri di i ons i ke ork ha ve a dopt hi re ul by he de i i ons i am i on a nd oot re di a on hi poi nt be a us he xe ut or i a a a he pl a i nt i not he de nda nt Case Document Filed Page of Case Document Filed Page of a ut hi ot he ha ve done by ourt de i i on oe a hi di i nc i on how ve doe not a ppe a ge rm a ne he ank i nqui ry A he hi rd ank a or he pa rt i ha ve not i a ny vi de nc be yond I ourt ha vi ng re pe a ly i Re a nt i a vor i nc udi ng i he ours of a ank a na ys i a hi rul oul os oundl i he I?s i nt re Be yond re ogni i ng ha I ourt a ppe a om ort a bl i he a ori rul he Court he re ore a nnot a i gn i gni i a nt i nde pe nde nt i ght hi a or oe not ha he I?s a orne ge ne ra i a pa ra a ui i purs ui ng puni i ve da a ge a ga i ns he ps i a ba on a ge pre da i ons by ps i i he I Se ul kof oe urt he a rgue ha be a us he onl he i i i ps i n?s i hi brot he a rk ps i a ge dl kne or ha ons ruc i ve know dge of ps i n?s pa rn of xua a bus i i us de ny hi re ove ry rom he a by xpos i ng he a puni i ve da a ge a a rds i a uc a he rs oe a But he de i i on by a gove rnm nt a ye a pt obt a i uc da a ge i a hi gh prof i a i nvol vi ng a ga i ons of xt re onduc or he a ge gui know dge of a he i i hi a do not pe a he que i on ha he hi rd ank a or a a ys hi rul of a be dura bl rve he I?s i nt re he Court he re ore ha no ba i re a hi ank a or a ount rva i i ng a one out i ghi ng he i rs CONC LU I or he re a ons a bove he Court gra nt he de nda nt xe ut ors ot i on di i he pra ye or puni i ve da a ge a ga i ns he he Cl rk of Court i re pe ul di re rm i na he ot i on pe ndi ng a doc ke Case Document Filed Page of Case Document Filed Page of RD RE a ul A nge a ye ni a i ri udge a A pri ork ork Case Document Filed Page of Case Document Filed Page of
24,464 characters