The portion of the appea pertaining to ane oes wa withdrawn pur suant to the oint Notice of Withdrawal a to ane oes DE rec onsideration bef ore the mag istrate judg UNI TED STATES DI STRI CT COURT SOUTHERN DI STRI CT OF ORI DA CASE NO RRA/J OHNSON ANE DO NO Plaintiff vs EFF REY EPSTEI Def endant Re la te a se ORDER AF IRMING MAG ISTRATE JUDG JOHNS ON?S DISCOVERY ORDERS Appea of Portions of the Mag istrate?s Or ders Da ted Fe bruar DE DE and April DE with I ncorpor ated Obje ctions and Memora ndum of aw DE iled Def endant iled a re ply on une The Court has conduc ted a eview of the motion response re ply the per tinent portions of the rec ord and is other wise fully advised in the pr mis Case Document Entered on FLSD Docket Page of Case Document Entered on FLSD Docket Page of As the Court previously stated it did not consider in Def endant appea any leg al arg uments which we re not pre viously provided to Judge Johnson in he discove ry motions and motion for rec onsideration being appea led See DE only modify or set aside the orde if it is found to be lear ly err oneous or ontrary to law See a lso S.C A oc a Ma ist ra te Judg Rul a A rd i le a rl err oneous if the revie wing court a fter a ssessing the evidenc in its entirety is left with a definite a nd firm conviction that a mistake has bee committed Kry ufthansa erma Ai rl ine 1th Cir Se a lso United States United States Gy psum Co U.S plaining ener ally a finding is?cle arly err oneous whe althoug there is evidence to support it the reviewing court on the ntire evide nce is lef with the definite a nd firm conviction that a mistake has bee committed The mere fac that a re viewing court mig ht have de cided the issue dif fer ently is not sufficient to overturn a decision whe there a re tw rm iss ibl vie ws of the iss ue or ia State Confere nce of Br anche of NAACP Geor ia F.2d 11th Cir After car eful re view of the Mag istrate?s Or ders De fenda nt?s appea the response and the reply the Court finds that the Mag istrate?s Or ders we re not lear ly err oneous or ontrary to law A i i i ORDERED AND AD JUDG ED that Def endant Consoli dated Rule Re vie a nd Ap pe a is DENIED a oll ow De fe nd a nt ha ll ro du the do ume nts omp lle Judg John so rd rs wi thi thr us ine ss a ro th da te of thi rd Se DE fo re tur nin the do ume nts a i i a a i i i a i a Case Document Entered on FLSD Docket Page of Case Document Entered on FLSD Docket Page of Pla int if a dis los thi in fo rm a tio to a xpe rt wi tne ss ta ine to te sti fy a tr ia but only on condition that the expert will ag ree to retain the onfidentiality of the infor mation and not disclose it to any third parties without the ag ree ment of De fenda nt or furthe orde of the Cou rt minor sexual assault victims Additionally Plaintiff shall not disclose Defe ndant?s tax returns or a a i a i i a i a this Order is without prejudice to any future motion by Def endant to exclude any of the information produc ed pursua nt to this order at trial DO NE AN RD ER ED in Chambers at West Palm Bea ch Palm Be ach County Florida this day of une th KE TD NN Un TD i ed at es Di ri ct ge Cop ie to all counsel of ecor Case Document Entered on FLSD Docket Page of Case Document Entered on FLSD Docket Page of
3,240 characters
